fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.150 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
And let me conclude

carstenw wrote:
Nonsense...


How dare you say that what I'm saying is nonsense?
Go tell that to your brother or your father.
Another idiotic keyboard bully...
This forum is turning into trash.
Aug 23, 2026 at 06:25 AM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.150 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?


sergun wrote:
Does it look like 3D?
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgG03do43qEdlcfFanTgI5m_7bJGFhdDGV7UUPaxQSn3997OtpCN-qTTDGb46XLdw3ei48pm-BB__NYKqmRGQFPXNnoQkZZYpIM6dgDV9XaC3S8vqDVHxx6GRzA1NIHElAEazV6hOiAzyjPJw-ejKTSyGiq3QW1BOONGGJI_y4aSR-l4sxDofRCZhKRWS1O/s4250/P1011404_1.jpg


It could be, but the busy blurry background is distracting (to me). When I am looking at the photo, my eye goes for the bright reddish-orange t-shirt of a boy who happens to be in the center of the frame. Then, I cannot help continue the visual "journey" into and around the somewhat mysterious blurry background. The composition is ambiguous: the intended subject (that should have "popped") is relatively uninteresting, and it doesn't compel me to keep looking at it, whereas I feel more intrigued by the life that happens behind the intended subject, in that blurry background. There's something interesting about this "inversion" - a blurry background is usually understood as relatively unimportant and separated to emphasize the subject. Apparently there might be creative ways of using a blurred background to contribute very significantly to (rather than subtract from) a composition, although this is probably not trivial.
Aug 23, 2026 at 06:29 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.150 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
sergun wrote:
Does it look like 3D?


What’s the story here? There’s a boy (on the left) holding what looks like a wrench, but he’s out of focus. Then there’s another boy with his back to the camera in the center of the image, and it’s unclear what his role is. The background shows a city park, which gives a sense of where the scene is taking place.
The photo doesn’t convey much, in my very humble opinion, and perhaps the real point of interest (the guy with the wrench) should have been highlighted better instead of focusing on the bicycle.
The shot with side lighting helps a little to give a sense of three-dimensionality, but the photo is fundamentally flawed, again in my very humble opinion.
I’ll say it again: it’s not enough to have one thing in focus and the rest out of focus to make an interesting photo, let alone one with a sense of three-dimensionality.

Aug 23, 2026 at 06:49 AM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.150 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?


Ripolini wrote:
And let me conclude

carstenw wroteNonsense...
How dare you say that what I'm saying is nonsense?
Go tell that to your brother or your father.
Another idiotic keyboard bully...
This forum is turning into trash.


"bullies and rude people should be treated the way they deserve" - I am not sure what "they deserve". If the idea is that bullying and rudeness should be reciprocated - I disagree because "violence begets violence" and then, yes, "forum is turning into trash" with the respondent sharing some of the responsibility.
In an unproductive exchange, it is best to avoid responding at some point, and often it is best to simply ignore a disagreeable post when the subject is not worth fighting about (as often is the case).
Aug 23, 2026 at 06:53 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.150 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
Ripolini wrote:
And let me conclude

carstenw wroteNonsense...
How dare you say that what I'm saying is nonsense?
Go tell that to your brother or your father.
Another idiotic keyboard bully...
This forum is turning into trash.


Like has occurred in this thread many times, it seems to me that you and Carsten are talking past each other and not recognizing that you are thinking about the thread in very different ways. The thread has been around for over a decade and has morphed and evolved to be many different things.

Ripolini, I agree with you if you want to make the case that a particular lens creates more 3D than other lenses it requires (or likely requires) comparing shots that control for all the non-lens determinants of 3D. I do think the thread was initially about that sort of question.

The thread has been about a lot more than that, however, for a very long time. We have spent a lot of time discussing what is 3D. We have talked about even whether a 3D effect exists. We have talked about what sort of 3D image is the best. There have been hundreds of pictures in which people have posted one shot and asked, "Is this pop?" or "Is this 3D?"

Personally, I don't think we can put the genie back in the bottle and go back to the narrower question that started the thread. It is clear to me very few people want to do the controlled testing you outline--I know I don't want to. At the same time lots of people want to post single images and discuss the 3D nature of those images. People also want to discuss the nature of 3D and often recycle the same arguments many times--I know I have done that. That is what the thread has become. Many find it frustrating, but it keeps going because enough people don't and new people find the question interesting.

So, although I think you are right about what it would take to isolate the 3D contribution of a lens, I don't think that is what the thread is about any more.
Aug 23, 2026 at 06:55 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.150 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
Guys ... seriously.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1719880/2/

Got to page 3, post #3. It is from a photographer we ALL respect. It includes 4 different lenses of same subject, same lighting, same distance.

Yes, the human physiological response of depth and dimensionality is impacted by a variety of factors. Those factors include (no exhaustive), lighting (specularity / diffuse), contrast (tonal / hue / saturation), contour, shape, distance, and a host of factors that all share one common aspect to them ... the rate of change among attributes (we often call it falloff). Those rates of change occur across the hybrid matrix of the various contributing factors. In the matter of lenses (which is supposed to the focus of topic of this thread), the lens designers make decisions that affect the rates of change ... the rate of change for sharpness or resolving capability or acuteness can vary across zones A / B / C.

Philip has presented that in his statement of Thypoch taking a "slower / gentler" approach vs. something like a Voigtlander design that make take a very rapid approach. The matters of field curvature, vignetting, ... as well as other factors and aberrations that occur "differently" across the zones are other contributing aspects of the rates of change that are in play, from an optical perspective. Whether or not you prefer the style / look / render of the Thypoch vs. Zeiss, as it pertains to your individual assessment may vary. But, the point that they design differently and it induces different rates, is salient ... some folks tend to think more "natural", while other lean toward more "aggressive".

Separating and isolating the non-optical factors from consideration (valid as they are, history is well noted for human physiological response, not the least of which in art, et al) ... requires a controlled set. For all the folks decrying this (valid as it is), the link above is one of the best "controlled set" of images that we have readily available to us. Please review it.

Pause here, do not read any more until after you have viewed the four images. My next comments will be my assessment of the images, so I do not want to pre-maturely influence your review of the images.



Pause.

Pause.

Pause.



Resuming ...



In review of the images, I take note ... not to suggest that we have found the holy grail of the MOST 3-D lens. Rather, to note that of the four images ... there IS a DIFFERENCE in the rendering / falloff rates.

To my eye, ONE of the lenses is significantly different from the other THREE. That, and then, the other three ARE indeed, more tightly grouped, in the rates of change they are designed to induce / render.

Those two aspects are (imo) sufficient for logical deduction that the LENS DOES influence the perception. Peter Karbe (I've linked numerous times to his discussion) designed the SL APO lenses to induce a faster rate of falloff in that line of lenses. He specifically notes the difference in rate of falloff from that line of lenses vs. ... (my words, not his) let's go back to Mandler era. Zeiss designs different, Canon designs different, Voigtlander designs different, Thypoch designs different.

By this time, the matrix of designs is extensive, and with that comes also the point that, yes a degree of separation can sometimes be challenging to differentiate ... particularly in "one off" comparisons that incur a host of vairable outside the scope of the optical differences ... almost like pouring ketchup on a Wagyu steak and saying it tastes like the steak at a truck stop cafe. The difference are now masked.

Fred has established a wonderful site, and has long expected us to conduct ourselves as the "Gold Standard" of internet forum conduct among our members. Before you write your next post in this (or others) thread, please consider Fred's desire for our community to be the model for the world to see ... particularly as it pertains to inter-member conduct.

I've said it before, and it isn't going to change. Human physiological response to depth and modeling cues are predicated on rates of change (noted elsewhere). Plenty of attributes involved ... some are non-optically induced, some are optically induced. Some designers seek to harness this, others not so much. The soup mix of possibilities is exhaustive, and yes ... there will be NO CONCENSUS as to WHICH ONE LENS is the MOST. Smart and secure people already know this and don't bother to decry it and mock others about their contributions to the subject matter.

The point of the thread was to promote a discussion about the optics involved with inducing the physiological response of dimensionality and depth. Those individuals who remain intent to derail the thread AWAY from the discussion of the optical influences ... really, you should ask Fred to HIDE this entire thread from your view, since it causes you so much angst and grief. Just walk away, for your own personal well being, as well as the betterment of joy for your fellow members.

I've made a variety of links, posts and contributions of discussion on this topic for well over a decade. It has included the objective discussion from Karbe, as well as others. Yet, all the naysayers continue to clamor for an A:B that is decidedly conclusive that the lens contribution has impact / influence on the subject.

I don't have a host of significantly different lens designs to conduct such an A:B that is clearly evident that the LENS contributed. For that reason, I defer to the post linked above. Human condition being such as it is ... I expect this to NOT sway any of the ardent objectionists. BUT, if you are a person who is genuinely interested in seeing the lens contribution ... is it real, or is it bogus ... the provided link is about the best I can offer, at this point in time.

Now, look in the mirror ... grow up and quit bickering like you're a bunch of middle school playground hooligans.

Seriously, take a pause with your conduct toward your fellow members.

Play nice.

Aug 23, 2026 at 07:13 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.150 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
Daran wrote:
carstenw wroteNonsense, to determine if a lens has 3D you just look at a photo which demonstrates the 3D, and decide if you agree or disagree.
Using that logic pretty much all modern lenses have 3D.


“3D” (whatever that is in a two dimensional photographic idiom) is not something that “lenses have.” Whatever it is, it is something that photographs have. Or not.
Aug 23, 2026 at 07:29 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.150 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
RustyBug wrote:
Guys ... seriously.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1719880/2/

Got to page 3, post #3. It is from a photographer we ALL respect. It includes 4 different lenses of same subject, same lighting, same distance.

Yes, the human physiological response of depth and dimensionality is impacted by a variety of factors. Those factors include (no exhaustive), lighting (specularity / diffuse), contrast (tonal / hue / saturation), contour, shape, distance, and a host of factors that all share one common aspect to them ... the rate of change among attributes (we often call it falloff). Those rates of change occur across the hybrid matrix of the various contributing factors.
...Show more →

Kent,

When I look at those images the Helier looks different from the other three, but I don't think it has more 3D effect--at least to my eyes. If anything a little less. The speed of focus fade may be related to 3D, but I am not sure how and because focus fade is so dependent and aperture and focus distance whatever role it plays I would think would be swamped not by differences in lenses at the same aperture and focus distance, but would be affected more by what aperture is used and the focus distance. Lenses do differ on focus fade, and I think that is interesting, but to me the relation of that to 3D is not at all clear and I don't find Fred's images in that thread at all helpful in understanding that relation, but perhaps that is just me being dense.
Aug 23, 2026 at 08:06 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.150 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
Steve Spencer wrote:
the Helier looks different from the other three, but I don't think it has more 3D effect--at least to my eyes. If anything a little less.


Agreed ... "less"

(lens = different)
Aug 23, 2026 at 08:17 AM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.150 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
philip_pj wrote:
All the Chinese lenses have above average to very good 3D. They choose one of the two 'models' of 3D, either the supersharp subject/fast fade to high blur background; or the smoother graduated content, with a real world vision level rendering of the subject, fading off smoothly and gradually to a still content-rich background. A slight simplification, but not by much.

Viltrox are big into the commercial lens business (pros, event, etc.) so they do the accepted 3D standard of the cutout subject/big blur approach, and they are doing a damn fine job of it. They seem primed to bite
...Show more →

yeah the 50L is 20 years old. Even Gordon Laing still likes it



Looking at my old 50L images I'll just save my money instead of getting a new Sigma 50/1.2 ART or the upcoming Viltrox 50. If I want the 50L on my A7V I will just get an adapter.

I like the 'dreamy' look.










Aug 23, 2026 at 09:11 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.150 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
This one has the most pop.
But also it has all other parameters to create it : red color, angled and lighten subject,slightly wide qnd distorted.

2 Questions for those how deny it :
1.Do you see the dimensionality in this one?
2.Do you think any sharp lens will deliver the same pop here?


Schwarzlicht wrote:
gregfountain wroteOverall, I really like this image - very cool minibus -- great color and detail, but the OOF areas aren't quite as pleasing to the eye. It's a minor nit for most.

Schwarzlicht wroteHere’s another shot from the same series with the classic minibus – this time freshly processed in Lightroom.
This is the legendary Kässbohrer Setra S6 with a special paint job, built around 1960. It comes factory-equipped with a lot of analogue-era technology – and, as you can clearly see, a generous amount of 3D POP was also part of the original construction spec.

The lens is the 50mm Planar 1.4 ZA – certainly not the newest or most clinically sharp design out there. It’s no CA monster, but wide open it can show some chromatic aberration or colour fringing. Modern lenses might handle that better. Still, I keep coming back to this lens because I genuinely enjoy its rendering and character.

Since some have seriously claimed that I 'manipulated' sharpness or other aspects in this series, here’s a quick breakdown of my Lightroom processing:

Exposure and white balance adjusted

Contrast boosted (the scene was quite flat with little light/shade contrast)

The overexposed sky was toned down

A subtle vignette was added for mood

And of course: sharpening and noise reduction applied as usual

That’s it – just basic raw development to bring out what was already there.

f1.4
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/26117200727_33c3ee9f4b_k.jpgDSC08211 by stm geist, auf Flickr
Thank you very much! Yes, the bus is really great. You don't see models from that era very often these days. Since the town hall was right nearby, I suspect it was used to take a wedding party to the registry office.

I have to agree with you about the bokeh – it is a bit busy. Depending on the situation, the bokeh can be absolutely beautiful. But there are also scenarios where the Planar gets a little restless, and sometimes it can even be too soft (mushy).

Back then, I took about 10 shots with almost the same framing but different
...Show more →
Aug 23, 2026 at 11:11 AM
Makten
Offline
Details
p.150 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
Ripolini wrote:
This forum is turning into trash.


Yeah, too many people like you, who add nothing of value.

"Hide me" on. Bye.
Aug 23, 2026 at 11:13 AM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.150 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
Makten,

Gamla Stan is just begging for a 3D-pop there with my Viltrox 35 :-) Definitely on my bucket list!
Aug 23, 2026 at 11:44 AM
j4nu
Offline
Details
p.150 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
RustyBug wrote:
Guys ... seriously.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1719880/2/

Got to page 3, post #3. It is from a photographer we ALL respect. It includes 4 different lenses of same subject, same lighting, same distance.


This is a great comparison by Fred, showing differences in rendering between lenses, but I wouldn't pick that shot as a standout example of "3D pop" ...


And regarding the bickering that happens in this thread regularly, I think people saying that this thread is "worthless" / "pointless" forget that people who enjoy following and posting in this thread might find that at least a bit offensive...

Even though I agree that the best way to validate a selected lens as "3D pop king" would be in a direct comparison under the same shooting conditions . But then I also enjoy some pictures and discussion in this thread on their own...
Aug 23, 2026 at 11:56 AM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.150 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
Daran wrote:
carstenw wroteNonsense, to determine if a lens has 3D you just look at a photo which demonstrates the 3D, and decide if you agree or disagree.
Using that logic pretty much all modern lenses have 3D.


Well, no, not at all. I did write agree or disagree,
Aug 23, 2026 at 03:39 PM
Trisha
Offline
Details
p.150 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
My all-time favorite 3D pop lens clearly is the Zeiss Batis 2/40 CF, which I use very often on my Sony A7III. An example with aperture 2.8, taken at the Oldtimer BBQ at Steigenberger Treudelberg Resort, a golf resort in the northern part of Hamburg, in Germany.



https://flic.kr/p/2swNML2
Aug 23, 2026 at 04:13 PM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.150 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
Hi @Trisha@, I’ve seen your photos on Flickr: there aren’t many, but they look very promising! I can see you’re a fan of Zeiss and Voigtländer lenses.
The photo of the Vespa clearly shows the LoCA at full aperture on the 50/1. I prefer the Apo-Lanthars to the Noktons
Keep up the good work.
Aug 24, 2026 at 02:40 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.150 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
j4nu wrote:
This is a great comparison by Fred, showing differences in rendering between lenses, but I wouldn't pick that shot as a standout example of "3D pop"


I hear ya that it might not be THE STANDOUT example ... mostly for the purpose of presenting an A:B that the lens does influence the difference. From that, yes ... there are plenty of "more pop" images to be viewed with other lenses. Just that this is such a nice A:B, and I can clearly see a difference.

What others are able to deduce from this ... i.e. lens contributes vs. lens does not contribute ... YMMV

Aug 24, 2026 at 05:42 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.150 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
RustyBug wrote:
j4nu wroteThis is a great comparison by Fred, showing differences in rendering between lenses, but I wouldn't pick that shot as a standout example of "3D pop"
I hear ya that it might not be THE STANDOUT example ... mostly for the purpose of presenting an A:B that the lens does influence the difference. From that, yes ... there are plenty of "more pop" images to be viewed with other lenses. Just that this is such a nice A:B, and I can clearly see a difference.

What others are able to deduce from this ... i.e. lens contributes vs. lens does not contribute ... YMMV



I think depth of field transition from in focus to out of focus can affect the 3D effect and be a factor that varies with the lens, but I don't think it is as simple as a faster transition creates more 3D or some lenses create more 3D than other lenses.

In my own experience the key is mostly composition that is tuned to the specific lens I am using and knowing the lens well. If the transition from in focus to out of focus is too fast, then you get the cut out look of a target that is too distinct from the background and that doesn't look like 3D to me. If the transition is too slow then there isn't a 3D effect either (or at least a 3D effect based on focus transition) and the target does not stand out in a 3D look. The heliar in Fred's example seems to have too slow of a focus transition and ruins the very marginal 3D effect you see with the other lenses in the example you linked.

So with focus transition, IMO, the lens can contribute to the 3D effect but it is a goldilocks effect where the focus transition needs to be not too fast nor too slow and although lenses can vary (even with the same focal length and aperture) in how fast the focus transition is, it really is much more a matter of composition and getting that focus transition just right if you want it to contribute and knowing the focus transition of your lens to do that.

Said another way, I suspect you could get the 3D effect just as much with the heliar in this example if you changed the composition by moving a bit closer and making the focus transition more abrupt. So, in my book this example is still mostly if not totally about composing the image properly to get a 3D effect if you want it. I almost always don't care, so I don't compose for that, but I think in this example you could get all the lenses to look pretty similar with just a slight change in composition.
Aug 24, 2026 at 06:11 AM
Daran
Offline
Details
p.150 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
carstenw wrote:
Daran wrote
carstenw wroteNonsense, to determine if a lens has 3D you just look at a photo which demonstrates the 3D, and decide if you agree or disagree.
Using that logic pretty much all modern lenses have 3D.
Well, no, not at all. I did write agree or disagree,

Doesn't matter. If you do not see the effect in an image, that does not mean that the lens used can not produce it. I have seen the effect, but I can't see it in most images presented here. Meanwhile I do not doubt that the proud presenters of those image did in fact see it and are not all just trolling. Hence all those lenses can probably produce it, whether I can see it or no.

Besides, due to understanding how the effect comes to be, it is obvious that the lens used plays only a small role. This is confirmed by no one here on 150 pages even trying to show a significant difference in a back to back comparison using different lenses on the same scene. All you get is loads of single lens examples that may or may not be significant and of course a ton of slop from Phillip.
Aug 24, 2026 at 08:01 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister