fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
j4nu
Online
Details
p.145 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
I personally think @jojib@'s recent shots, the ones on the boat and in the forest actually show some 3d pop compared to shots posted previously, especially those with flash, which IMHO makes pictures rather flat.
But I think the whole discussion about those pictures sums up the difficulty of this topic in general:
there is no one definition of 3d pop, one which would be naturally understood by everyone ...
And that's where the confusion (and near-outrage presented by some in this thread ) comes from I think...
Aug 02, 2026 at 08:19 AM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.145 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
j4nu wrote:
I personally think @jojib@@'s recent shots, the ones on the boat and in the forest actually show some 3d pop compared to shots posted previously, especially those with flash, which IMHO makes pictures rather flat.
But I think the whole discussion about those pictures sums up the difficulty of this topic in general:
there is no one definition of 3d pop, one which would be naturally understood by everyone ...
And that's where the confusion (and near-outrage presented by some in this thread ) comes from I think...


"near-outrage" is an exaggeration. It was more like a mild disagreement.

If I am not mistaken, I haven't seen your posts on FM in a long while - for a year, or may be longer.
Have you been well?
Aug 02, 2026 at 10:24 AM
j4nu
Online
Details
p.145 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
ruthenium wrote:
j4nu wroteI personally think @jojib@@@'s recent shots, the ones on the boat and in the forest actually show some 3d pop compared to shots posted previously, especially those with flash, which IMHO makes pictures rather flat.
But I think the whole discussion about those pictures sums up the difficulty of this topic in general:
there is no one definition of 3d pop, one which would be naturally understood by everyone ...
And that's where the confusion (and near-outrage presented by some in this thread ) comes from I think...
"near-outrage" is an exaggeration. It was more like a mild disagreement.

If I am not mistaken, I haven't seen your posts on FM in a long while - for a year, or may be longer.
Have you been well?


Yes, you're right - I exaggerated a bit. And I agree with some of your points.

Thank you for the memory - I'm well, it's just that I don't shoot as much as I used to.
Aug 02, 2026 at 11:00 AM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.145 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
I have not read all 145 pages, but in there I assume there are multiple discussions (perhaps disagreements?) about what "pop" means?

Why I prefer separate optical terms like sharpness, bokeh, contrast, micro-contrast, vignette; plus even including coma, stigmatism and chromatic aberration.

To me, the best artistic version of these combines in a balanced fashion that does give certain lenses what I refer to as "the juice." That said, it's usually lenses with some vignette, good sharpness, smoother bokeh and at least medium to moderate contrast end up the clear winners.

The newer lens trend to sharp and contrasty above all else so they test out on a resolution chart as technically excellent, many times look so clean as to render too sterile for my liking. And that's great for those that like that look. But most lenses that had this older "juice" look to my eyes were older designs. Good examples for me to share are almost any of the older, pre-asph primes from any of the major manufacturers -- almost all had at least some if it.

Probably the best recent example I can share is Nikon's 58/1.4 G lens -- it was (still is actually) a gem in this regard, very reminiscent of Leica Mandler designs. Unfortunately it has pretty horrible CA which regularly rears its head on todays digital sensors. Ironically though, some new releases from Viltrox and Samyang have at least a significant amount of "juice" in many situations. The caveat is they also tend to lean toward great sharpness, contrast, micro-contrast and low CA for a slight tradeoff to busier bokeh. With that said, in Viltrox 2 standouts for me are the Viltrox 50/2 air and 26/2.8 EVO pancake; and in Samyang, the 18/2.8 (yes, big surprise for a wide!) and 75/1.8. All 4 of these are wonderful street/environmental run-and-gun prime options, all are small and lightweight, and all 4 of them can be had for about the same money as a typical f4 doitall zoom or even a little less... FWIW and my .02 only.
Aug 02, 2026 at 11:10 AM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.145 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
Hey Jack! When I stumbled upon this thread my eyes opened wide. I said to myself man this is like a walk in the park for my Canon 85/1.2 LII. This is akin in getting a 'sitter'---that's a tennis term for a ball to be smacked hard. I said to myself I will hit this tennis ball so hard you have to retrieve it in the parking lot. So after a long hiatus of the thread I bumped it and showed my 85L pics shot wide open. Right away a couple of people said---that is not 3D! Dang so I said what---it's as if my overhead smash wasn't a winner after all because they are claiming I hit the top of the tennis net !

Anyway I agree that 3D is more than silky smooth bokeh/background blur and it's more about getting the composition right. I still say that my Viltrox 35/1.2 LAB N has the most 3D pop!
Aug 02, 2026 at 11:28 AM
old-gregg
Offline
Details
p.145 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
Jack Flesher wrote:
I have not read all 145 pages, but in there I assume there are multiple discussions (perhaps disagreements?) about what "pop" means?


I only contributed jokes and puns into this forum, until now. Jokes aside, I believe there used to be a very real phenomenon which gave birth to the 3D pop folklore.

Back in the uncoated lens days, shooting into the sun (or with the light source anywhere close to the frame) resulted in a massive loss of contrast. Early coatings started to improve the situation. The introduction of T* by Zeiss, along with their optical designs optimizing for low-mid MTF contrast, allowed photographers to shoot into the light with the resulting contrast they couldn't achieve before.

I believe that was the origin of "pop".

These days, of course, all coatings are excellent.
Aug 02, 2026 at 12:14 PM
SteveCl55
Offline
Details
p.145 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
Aren't the ancient lenses described as 'character' ?
Oh dear here we go again. 😉
Aug 02, 2026 at 12:23 PM
Schwarzlicht
Offline
Details
p.145 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
This young man also has strong 3D POP genes!

DSC03349-1 by stm geist, auf Flickr

Edited on Aug 11, 2026 at 03:46 PM · View previous versions
Aug 02, 2026 at 12:25 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.145 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
Indeed! It POP so much I feel like getting an ice cold Coke Zero with ice!!! Love it!
Aug 02, 2026 at 12:29 PM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.145 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
jojib wrote:
Hey Jack! When I stumbled upon this thread my eyes opened wide. I said to myself man this is like a walk in the park for my Canon 85/1.2 LII. This is akin in getting a 'sitter'---that's a tennis term for a ball to be smacked hard. I said to myself I will hit this tennis ball so hard you have to retrieve it in the parking lot. So after a long hiatus of the thread I bumped it and showed my 85L pics shot wide open. Right away a couple of people said---that is not 3D! Dang so I
...Show more →

I agree that the Viltrox 35 LAB has it in spades — I just wish it wasn’t so darn humongous 🤣
Aug 02, 2026 at 12:56 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.145 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
I want to put in text some of the responses to Zeiss’s recent CY-inspired Aatma cine range. These illustrate how prepared cine lens design innovators are now, in using lens performance characteristics – virtually universally frowned upon as ‘aberrations’ and ‘faults’ - to achieve the kind of image depth we had in the better lenses of 30-50 years ago.

It’s wonderful to see a giant of optics like Zeiss coming to these conclusions, given it is also something of a mea culpa for the technical overreach seen in their much-vaunted technical ranges.

‘some under- or over-correction of spherical aberration can produce smoother plane transitions, not so abrupt’

‘some gentle and predictable field curvature is used to separate subject and background’

‘mid-tone tonal separation creates clean transitions’

‘lenses should transition to blur smoothly but decisively, avoiding nervous or double-lining near the focus boundary – this creates a depth gradient we see as three-dimensional structure’

‘this means that these lenses have a really unique look of soft rolls to more defined out-of-focus elements than you may expect from a lens that rolls off this nicely’

‘they have field curvature to them which for a modern Zeiss lens is pretty surprising, and a welcome addition in a lens series like this’

You will notice that all these characteristics flow from image analysis, not the correction of ‘aberrations’. It is time we looked askance at this term in its narrow technical usage. To me, design behaviors that impede or ignore image appeal are the real aberrations. You can’t just buy the best corrected lens and expect it to make the best images! Unless you are in the surveillance business.

I think many of these attributes have been adopted by the more successful and astute Chinese lens makers in the last two to three years. Their images are undoubtedly appealing but you can almost feel the surprise in the reviewer’s (or viewer’s) mind, because the visual effects are still rather niche among the major players that dominate the stills world.

The Chinese have way less accumulated baggage and many of them began in the cine world. They are nimble and agile in the marketplace, and they are very fast learners. What is most intriguing is the very different visual styles they build into their lens output, even as they use older lenses as source designs.

The appeal of their images stem from judicious optical balancing and close evaluations of the appearance of final images. That is a very different path to that of a pell-mell rush to secure the highest MTF and corner performance possible, using reviewer-friendly designs with a whole lot of asph and ED glass.

It will take the ponderous stills world much longer to ‘get with the program’, given the inertia of the established base of millions of lenses, boosterism by the press, YT, etc. By contrast, cine lenses are manufactured in small batches for rental by sharp-eyed, visually savvy cinematographers and directors. cheers.
Aug 02, 2026 at 08:19 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.145 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?


philip_pj wrote:
I want to put in text some of the responses to Zeiss’s recent CY-inspired Aatma cine range. These illustrate how prepared cine lens design innovators are now, in using lens performance characteristics – virtually universally frowned upon as ‘aberrations’ and ‘faults’ - to achieve the kind of image depth we had in the better lenses of 30-50 years ago.

It’s wonderful to see a giant of optics like Zeiss coming to these conclusions, given it is also something of a mea culpa for the technical overreach seen in their much-vaunted technical ranges.

‘some under- or over-correction of spherical aberration can
...Show more →

You of course are considering that the term abberation is a negative. It is actually a valid descriptor that may be either desired or not based on use case.
Aug 02, 2026 at 10:25 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.145 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
Delete duplicate

Edited on Aug 03, 2026 at 10:52 PM · View previous versions
Aug 02, 2026 at 10:25 PM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.145 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
Jack Flesher wrote:
I have not read all 145 pages, but in there I assume there are multiple discussions (perhaps disagreements?) about what "pop" means?

Why I prefer separate optical terms like sharpness, bokeh, contrast, micro-contrast, vignette; plus even including coma, stigmatism and chromatic aberration.


Hi Jack!

Still the best name for getting arrested on a plane. How are you? What are you shooting these days?

I still prefer the term "3D pop" I just enjoy that ambiguity. I guess there are two main opinions:

- 3D is when the foreground is separated from the background.
- 3D is when things in the scene look so real that if you didn't know you were looking at a photograph, you could be looking through a window.

I guess that says which group I belong to.


To me, the best artistic version of these combines in a balanced fashion that does give certain lenses what I refer to as "the juice." That said, it's usually lenses with some vignette, good sharpness, smoother bokeh and at least medium to moderate contrast end up the clear winners.

The newer lens trend to sharp and contrasty above all else so they test out on a resolution chart as technically excellent, many times look so clean as to render too sterile for my liking. And that's great for those that like that look. But most lenses that had this older
...Show more →

I can't speak to the Viltrox or Nikkor lenses, but many of the old Contax lenses have it. I recently picked up a few of them, and am trying to motivate myself to go out and photograph. Berlin somehow isn't really doing it for me any more. I need to go further...
Aug 03, 2026 at 11:43 AM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.145 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
carstenw wrote:
Jack Flesher wroteI have not read all 145 pages, but in there I assume there are multiple discussions (perhaps disagreements?) about what "pop" means?

Why I prefer separate optical terms like sharpness, bokeh, contrast, micro-contrast, vignette; plus even including coma, stigmatism and chromatic aberration.
Hi Jack!

Still the best name for getting arrested on a plane. How are you? What are you shooting these days?

I still prefer the term "3D pop" I just enjoy that ambiguity. I guess there are two main opinions:

- 3D is when the foreground is separated from the background.
- 3D is when things in the scene look so real that if you didn't know you were looking at a photograph, you could be looking through a window.

I guess that says which group I belong to.

Earlier quoteTo me, the best artistic version of these combines in a balanced fashion that does give certain lenses what I refer to as "the juice." That said, it's usually lenses with some vignette, good sharpness, smoother bokeh and at least medium to moderate contrast end up the clear winners.

The newer lens trend to sharp and contrasty above all else so they test out on a resolution chart as technically excellent, many times look so clean as to render too sterile for my liking. And that's great for those that like that look. But most lenses that had this older "juice" look to my eyes were older designs. Good examples for me to share are almost any of the older, pre-asph primes from any of the major manufacturers -- almost all had at least some if it.

Probably the best recent example I can share is Nikon's 58/1.4 G lens -- it was (still is actually) a gem in this regard, very reminiscent of Leica Mandler designs. Unfortunately it has pretty horrible CA which regularly rears its head on todays digital sensors. Ironically though, some new releases from Viltrox and Samyang have at least a significant amount of "juice" in many situations. The caveat is they also tend to lean toward great sharpness, contrast, micro-contrast and low CA for a slight tradeoff to busier bokeh. With that said, in Viltrox 2 standouts for me are the Viltrox 50/2 air and 26/2.8 EVO pancake; and in Samyang, the 18/2.8 (yes, big surprise for a wide!) and 75/1.8. All 4 of these are wonderful street/environmental run-and-gun prime options, all are small and lightweight, and all 4 of them can be had for about the same money as a typical f4 doitall zoom or even a little less... FWIW and my .02 only.
I can't speak to the Viltrox or Nikkor lenses, but many of the old Contax lenses
...Show more →

Hi Carsten, long time!

I’m now shooting Sony. I got into them mainly due to small body size options for full frame travel options, as well as SOTA AF and resolution in the larger bodies.
Aug 03, 2026 at 12:42 PM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.145 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
Ah right. I had the initial, obligatory, A7, but it did not sit well with me how many zooms and how few primes they were making, and their prices went sky-high very fast, so I left again. Meanwhile things have probably swung around the other way again, and they have some good lenses.

I ended up with Fuji GFX bodies. I started with a 50S, which I adored, and then recently I went for a 100S, which leaves me surprisingly cold. I am trying to figure out what to do about it, but honestly, I haven't invested a lot of time in it yet, so I am taking it slowly.
Aug 03, 2026 at 02:57 PM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.145 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
"3D is when things in the scene look so real that if you didn't know you were looking at a photograph, you could be looking through a window" that is a surprisingly good way of thinking about the perception.
However, this means no bokeh, isn't it? Perhaps only a gentle blur of things in the distance. I like this, as I never liked blurring everything around a subject as a way of subject isolation.
Aug 03, 2026 at 04:23 PM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.145 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
Well, that is the question. Are you able to hold your eyes on a subject, while you check everything in the background? I am not sure what the effective aperture of the eye is, but I know that the autofocus is very fast
Aug 04, 2026 at 11:06 AM
Schwarzlicht
Offline
Details
p.145 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
Back in the day, the designers of the T1 Bulli made sure to throw a little bit of 3D POP into the mix.

DSC05915 by stm geist, auf Flickr
Aug 11, 2026 at 03:35 PM
tuxounet
Offline
Details
p.145 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
ruthenium wrote:
"3D is when things in the scene look so real that if you didn't know you were looking at a photograph, you could be looking through a window" that is a surprisingly good way of thinking about the perception.
However, this means no bokeh, isn't it? Perhaps only a gentle blur of things in the distance. I like this, as I never liked blurring everything around a subject as a way of subject isolation.


This is completely correct. Zeiss, in all communications, differentiates "Pop" and bokeh. "Pop" is related to micro contrast.
https://lenspire.zeiss.com/photo/en/article/micro-contrast-and-the-zeiss-pop-by-lloyd-chambers/

"The ZEISS micro contrast “pop” is evident at every aperture until diffraction flattens performance with a heavy hand […]"
"The key thing to notice here is that there is no difference in the 3D “pop” of the image at f/1.4 versus f/4. That makes the lens exceptionally versatile, with aperture not the determining factor for image quality."
"The “pop” or “3D rendering” or “brilliance” or “bite” of fine details that results from high micro contrast lends a feel to an image that many lenses lack."
Aug 13, 2026 at 03:02 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister