fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
Kalainen
Offline
Details
p.14 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
jeffersoncasey wrote:
I have a different take here. Like those Renaissance paintings that has the 3D-ness to them, there are 2 important elements that contribute to the perception of depth - shadow, and gradation (which strongly related between both).

We perceive a photo without dark regions or shadows as flat, no matter how sharp they are. And on pictures that does have shadows, but without smooth gradients, will often look flat too.

So the biggest factor here, as some already mentioned, is the composition (particularly lighting). Then, it's whether the camera will be able to capture the gradation of the transitions between dark and
...Show more →

This is, by far, the most sensible post I've read about the 3D-pop in ages. Far more intelligent than the usual pseudo-scientific stuff people like to hang into. And it makes perfect sense: gradations gives clues about the shape and the contrasty shadows emphasize the effect. Kind of explains why 3D is often associated with Zeiss, they strive for contrast in their lens design, but of course it's entirely possible with other brands also. It would also be more beneficial to understand the good/bad 3D-pop as an attribute of a some particular image and not a lens (just like bokeh). When mixed up with the theory of optical design (or other sciences) the whole concept of 3D-pop just adds more confusion than really explains anything. Therefore, it belongs to field of aesthetics. In my humble opinion - though I'm sure many will disagree with this kind of herecy..

Apr 29, 2019 at 11:29 PM
Sauseschritt
Offline
Details
p.14 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
If the term "pop" has to have any meaning, it would have to be a lens property, not a property of the images we're taking.
Apr 30, 2019 at 03:19 AM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.14 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
No it isn’t.

Not an exclusive attribute of a lens.
Apr 30, 2019 at 03:49 AM
Sauseschritt
Offline
Details
p.14 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
Then, according to you, this thread is superflous.
Apr 30, 2019 at 04:09 AM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.14 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
I am not alone if you do not ignore the many others who posted here.
Apr 30, 2019 at 04:16 AM
bushwacker
Offline
Details
p.14 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?


Makten wrote:
smpetty wroteI agree that it's 3D-ish, but there is plenty of background blur, especially considering the depth of the scene. The rock right behind the bike parts is blurred.
The point is that it would probably look less "3D" if there was more background blur. I think most of the images in this thread shot wide open with fast tele lenses don't at all look "3D" because it's something that my eyes can't relate to. It would never look like that IRL. Edit: A totally blurred background also eliminates the context of the surroundings of the subject. Which, in many ways, isn't beneficial.



Bro it’s going to start all over again.... others get it and some don’t. And watch.. it will become heated argument like year 2007.

He he he
Apr 30, 2019 at 05:59 AM
bushwacker
Offline
Details
p.14 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?


darrellc wrote:
Samuli, Denoir, Makten, Sebboh, Reeve...

No, no, no, no. To bring this discussion to a definitive close, there is but one name: YANNICK KHONG.

I’m shocked his name and authoritative work on the subject hasn’t been brought into this discussion. Sneak preview... it is not at all complicated everyone, it is really very simple: there are only a “few elements” that determine if a lens renders flat images or with great depth perception. Read it and weep.


I am interested... I might learn something from his style. You have alink?
Apr 30, 2019 at 06:00 AM
bushwacker
Offline
Details
p.14 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
Okay Ladies and Gents,

This is how Disney make 3D from 2D flat transparencies. Hear what the guy says... the feeling of volume and roundness... or something.

Watch this video. You might learn something from it. Check it out. From Makten’s diagram motion adds 3D too.. Disney says the same.



And this.





Apr 30, 2019 at 06:13 AM
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.14 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
Thanks, nothing shocking here, but still good food for though when looking at compositional elements.

Appreciate it.

sebboh wrote:
Mathieu18 wroteQuite interested if you’d expand on this answer, specifically the 5 cues, or if you have some good literature to start with.

sebboh wrote
DaveFP wroteAre you sure it hasn't been explained? To know for sure we would have to do an extensive survey. More likely than not we would find that a substantial part of the answer lies in a physiology journal rather then an engineering one.
yes, i actually am a neurophysiologists that specializes in sensory perception and learning. there are a bunch of specific cues that the visual system uses to extract depth, texture, and to bind individual features into the perception of a single object. you can read a rich literature about it that goes back more than 50 years in animal studies and more than a century in psychophysical studies of humans. sadly, the link to properties of high performance lenses has not been well explored and there does not appear to be any real consistency in photo forum users perception of what photos produce 3D (though there is a strong placebo effect) nor is there amongst lay viewers.

the truth is that your brain uses lots of different cues to extract perception of volume and depth and it is easy to bias factors an individual pays attention to towards specific cues. people on photography forums are typically talking about any number of 5 different cues, but different ones are talking about different cues.
here's a cute little cartoon of the major cues we use to extract 3D information from images (can people see this image or does it require a journal subscription?):
https://www.annualreviews.org/na101/home/literatum/publisher/ar/journals/content/vision/2016/vision.2016.2.issue-1/annurev-vision-111815-114605/20161010/images/large/vs20345.f1.jpg
obviously disparity and motion don't really work for photographs. only blur and texture are really subject to lens differences. there are, of course, other less important cues that are not shown.

there is a lot of interesting neuroscience work that might be relevant trying to figure out how responses of individual neurons across different visual brain regions are bound together to create a coherent percept of an object. the short answer to that
...Show more →

Apr 30, 2019 at 06:58 AM
echelonphoto
Offline
Details
p.14 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
JohnDizzo15 wrote:
For me, it varies depending on what focal length range and look we are talking about.

On the wide end, the Sigma 20 Art does a really good job of it. For normal-ish FL, the Voigt 40/1.2 is the one that yields the most for me. Lastly, the Sigma 105 Art on the longer end also does a pretty good job of creating that look in certain scenarios.

More often that not, the lens is only a part of the equation. I think it is equal parts lighting and post processing as well.


Agree with this opinion....3d pop, or "subject isolation" is a function more of distance and focal length. For instance...I can shoot my 85 1.8 wide open, but I can get more pop from my 70-200 at F4 if I shoot the subject at 200mm vs 85 mm, even though the f stop is quite a bit smaller
Apr 30, 2019 at 08:09 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.14 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
echelonphoto wrote:
JohnDizzo15 wroteFor me, it varies depending on what focal length range and look we are talking about.

On the wide end, the Sigma 20 Art does a really good job of it. For normal-ish FL, the Voigt 40/1.2 is the one that yields the most for me. Lastly, the Sigma 105 Art on the longer end also does a pretty good job of creating that look in certain scenarios.

More often that not, the lens is only a part of the equation. I think it is equal parts lighting and post processing as well.
Agree with this opinion....3d pop, or "subject isolation" is a function more of distance and focal length. For instance...I can shoot my 85 1.8 wide open, but I can get more pop from my 70-200 at F4 if I shoot the subject at 200mm vs 85 mm, even though the f stop is quite a bit smaller


Personally - I don't see subject isolation and 3D pop as interchangeable.

I've seen tons of shallow dof images with no pop and "poppy" images in which the background is in relatively sharp focus.

Apr 30, 2019 at 08:18 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.14 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?

Hmm, I guess "3D pop"? Even Zeiss uses that terminology in their international marketing.

https://www.zeiss.com/camera-lenses/int/photography/website/zeiss-batis-lenses.html

-Tim

vdo1 wrote:
I find the word “pop” to be too vague and also rather vulgar. Are there any clearer, more precise terms that could help describe what exactly we’re discussing here?


Apr 30, 2019 at 08:53 AM
realVivek
Offline
Details
p.14 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
That is truly scientifique, indeed.

tsdevine wrote:
Hmm, I guess "3D pop"? Even Zeiss uses that terminology in their international marketing.

https://www.zeiss.com/camera-lenses/int/photography/website/zeiss-batis-lenses.html

-Tim

vdo1 wroteI find the word “pop” to be too vague and also rather vulgar. Are there any clearer, more precise terms that could help describe what exactly we’re discussing here?


Apr 30, 2019 at 09:03 AM
seanj
Offline
Details
p.14 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
In looking at the Zeiss marketing page tsdevine posted, I tried to visually see what Zeiss was talking about. Zeiss seems to point to what can be accomplished in LR by bumping the saturation and increasing contrast (or probably dehaze a bit) while moving the clarity slider to the right and then labeling it 3D pop.
Apr 30, 2019 at 09:24 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.14 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?

I did say Zeiss's marketing...

-Tim

seanj wrote:
In looking at the Zeiss marketing page tsdevine posted, I tried to visually see what Zeiss was talking about. Zeiss seems to point to what can be accomplished in LR by bumping the saturation and increasing contrast (or probably dehaze a bit) while moving the clarity slider to the right and then labeling it 3D pop.


Apr 30, 2019 at 09:27 AM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.14 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
tsdevine wrote:
I did say Zeiss's marketing...

-Tim

seanj wroteIn looking at the Zeiss marketing page tsdevine posted, I tried to visually see what Zeiss was talking about. Zeiss seems to point to what can be accomplished in LR by bumping the saturation and increasing contrast (or probably dehaze a bit) while moving the clarity slider to the right and then labeling it 3D pop.


It is certainly Zeiss marketing but if you review this thread, or any other similar thread on the net, you will see Zeiss come up over and over and over again.

I might sound like a fanboy (and perhaps I am) but I would have to say that none of my lenses from the majors (including Canon, Sony, Nikon) have quite the colors, pop, and punch that Zeiss does.

It's not the only "look" and it may not be one's favorite "look" but if it appeals to you you'd be hard pressed to name a company that does it better.

Apr 30, 2019 at 09:38 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.14 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?

Don't take my comment the wrong way, if you look at my Batis 40 posts in this thread, I do believe in Zeiss having some of the best 3D pop producing lenses. (I also have quite a few Zeiss lenses....ZE 15, ZE 21, Loxia 21, Loxia 25, Batis 25, Batis 40...even some older C/Y Zeiss.)

But even in their marketing, they mention smooth bokeh and the transitions from focus to out of focus. I see some 3D pop even in my stopped down shooting with the Batis 40. Given the discussion over what exactly produces "3D pop" it's hard to ignore that there is some marketing occurring here. Doesn't mean it isn't grounded in some truth.

-Tim

DaveFP wrote:
tsdevine wroteI did say Zeiss's marketing...

-Tim

seanj wroteIn looking at the Zeiss marketing page tsdevine posted, I tried to visually see what Zeiss was talking about. Zeiss seems to point to what can be accomplished in LR by bumping the saturation and increasing contrast (or probably dehaze a bit) while moving the clarity slider to the right and then labeling it 3D pop.
It is certainly Zeiss marketing but if you review this thread, or any other similar thread on the net, you will see Zeiss come up over and over and over again.

I might sound like a fanboy (and perhaps I am) but I would have to say that none of my lenses from the majors (including Canon, Sony, Nikon) have quite the colors, pop, and punch that Zeiss does.

It's not the only "look" and it may not be one's favorite "look" but if it appeals to you you'd be hard pressed to name a company that does it better.



Apr 30, 2019 at 10:10 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.14 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
tsdevine wrote:
Don't take my comment the wrong way, if you look at my Batis 40 posts in this thread, I do believe in Zeiss having some of the best 3D pop producing lenses. (I also have quite a few Zeiss lenses....ZE 15, ZE 21, Loxia 21, Loxia 25, Batis 25, Batis 40...even some older C/Y Zeiss.)

But even in their marketing, they mention smooth bokeh and the transitions from focus to out of focus. I see some 3D pop even in my stopped down shooting with the Batis 40. Given the discussion over what exactly produces "3D pop" it's hard to
...Show more →
DaveFP wrote
tsdevine wroteI did say Zeiss's marketing...

-Tim

seanj wroteIn looking at the Zeiss marketing page tsdevine posted, I tried to visually see what Zeiss was talking about. Zeiss seems to point to what can be accomplished in LR by bumping the saturation and increasing contrast (or probably dehaze a bit) while moving the clarity slider to the right and then labeling it 3D pop.
It is certainly Zeiss marketing but if you review this thread, or any other similar thread on the net, you will see Zeiss come up over and over and over again.

I might sound like a fanboy (and perhaps I am) but I would have to say that none of my lenses from the majors (including Canon, Sony, Nikon) have quite the colors, pop, and punch that Zeiss does.

It's not the only "look" and it may not be one's favorite "look" but if it appeals to you you'd be hard pressed to name a company that does it better.


They like to brag about the "Zeiss Look" and their marketing says it's a combination of "True colors", "Sharpness" and "3D Pop":
https://www.zeiss.com/camera-lenses/us/photography/website/zeiss-batis-lenses.html
Apr 30, 2019 at 10:14 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.14 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?

Earlier in the thread had posted the international version of the link you posted. I definitely think that Zeiss has a "look" in most lenses...and it's a good one. This detour started when someone suggested we shouldn't use the term "pop" and I posted that Batis link to show that even Zeiss is using that terminology.

But any page like this is a marketing page, doesn't mean it isn't true..... Just that you have to take it with at least the knowledge that it is marketing.

And I very much like Zeiss lenses, and agree with much of what they tout as Zeiss advantages.

-Tim

Fred Miranda wrote:
tsdevine wroteDon't take my comment the wrong way, if you look at my Batis 40 posts in this thread, I do believe in Zeiss having some of the best 3D pop producing lenses. (I also have quite a few Zeiss lenses....ZE 15, ZE 21, Loxia 21, Loxia 25, Batis 25, Batis 40...even some older C/Y Zeiss.)

But even in their marketing, they mention smooth bokeh and the transitions from focus to out of focus. I see some 3D pop even in my stopped down shooting with the Batis 40. Given the discussion over what exactly produces "3D pop" it's hard to ignore that there is some marketing occurring here. Doesn't mean it isn't grounded in some truth.

-Tim

DaveFP wrote
tsdevine wroteI did say Zeiss's marketing...

-Tim

seanj wroteIn looking at the Zeiss marketing page tsdevine posted, I tried to visually see what Zeiss was talking about. Zeiss seems to point to what can be accomplished in LR by bumping the saturation and increasing contrast (or probably dehaze a bit) while moving the clarity slider to the right and then labeling it 3D pop.
It is certainly Zeiss marketing but if you review this thread, or any other similar thread on the net, you will see Zeiss come up over and over and over again.

I might sound like a fanboy (and perhaps I am) but I would have to say that none of my lenses from the majors (including Canon, Sony, Nikon) have quite the colors, pop, and punch that Zeiss does.

It's not the only "look" and it may not be one's favorite "look" but if it appeals to you you'd be hard pressed to name a company that does it better.
They like to brag about the "Zeiss Look" and their marketing says it's a combination of "True colors", "Sharpness" and "3D Pop":
https://www.zeiss.com/camera-lenses/us/photography/website/zeiss-batis-lenses.html


Apr 30, 2019 at 10:20 AM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.14 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
tsdevine wrote:
Earlier in the thread had posted the international version of the link you posted. I definitely think that Zeiss has a "look" in most lenses...and it's a good one. This detour started when someone suggested we shouldn't use the term "pop" and I posted that Batis link to show that even Zeiss is using that terminology.

But any page like this is a marketing page, doesn't mean it isn't true..... Just that you have to take it with at least the knowledge that it is marketing.

And I very much like Zeiss lenses, and agree with much of what they tout as
...Show more →
Fred Miranda wrote
tsdevine wroteDon't take my comment the wrong way, if you look at my Batis 40 posts in this thread, I do believe in Zeiss having some of the best 3D pop producing lenses. (I also have quite a few Zeiss lenses....ZE 15, ZE 21, Loxia 21, Loxia 25, Batis 25, Batis 40...even some older C/Y Zeiss.)

But even in their marketing, they mention smooth bokeh and the transitions from focus to out of focus. I see some 3D pop even in my stopped down shooting with the Batis 40. Given the discussion over what exactly produces "3D pop" it's hard to ignore that there is some marketing occurring here. Doesn't mean it isn't grounded in some truth.

-Tim

DaveFP wrote
tsdevine wroteI did say Zeiss's marketing...

-Tim

seanj wroteIn looking at the Zeiss marketing page tsdevine posted, I tried to visually see what Zeiss was talking about. Zeiss seems to point to what can be accomplished in LR by bumping the saturation and increasing contrast (or probably dehaze a bit) while moving the clarity slider to the right and then labeling it 3D pop.
It is certainly Zeiss marketing but if you review this thread, or any other similar thread on the net, you will see Zeiss come up over and over and over again.

I might sound like a fanboy (and perhaps I am) but I would have to say that none of my lenses from the majors (including Canon, Sony, Nikon) have quite the colors, pop, and punch that Zeiss does.

It's not the only "look" and it may not be one's favorite "look" but if it appeals to you you'd be hard pressed to name a company that does it better.
They like to brag about the "Zeiss Look" and their marketing says it's a combination of "True colors", "Sharpness" and "3D Pop":
https://www.zeiss.com/camera-lenses/us/photography/website/zeiss-batis-lenses.html


Tim - could you repost the link - can't seem to find it.

Apr 30, 2019 at 10:28 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister