Altglas wrote:
carstenw wrote
it has a fat band of in-focus compared to other lenses. Is it possible that the actual aperture was set the same but was different effectively?
With the long focus draw of a macro the effective aperture varies and it might be misleading in this distance range.
Yes, this sounds like what was happening. I don't know if the T-stops differ on the two lenses, but the optical formula of the 50MP yields more depth of field at the same aperture as the 50P.