Hey Martin, nice to see you here again!
I think there are at least two ideas of what 3D pop means:
1) the foreground is clearly separated from the background, thus there is 3D in the image. I would call this subject separation.
2) The image fools the eye/brain into thinking that it is looking at a 3D scene, not an image. I might call this 3D rendering.
I belong to the latter camp, the 50L user probably the former.
Do you still have your leather seat image, so you can show us? IIRC this was one of the images with the most 3d pop I have ever seen.