fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.13 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
Mathieu18 wrote:
I’m not saying optics doe t play a role, but your comment about your wife, and certainly Derek’s weighty response echo my own thinking on it. Our brains take visual cues from the image, she. The fall off of the image closely matches what are brain expects, we see 3D in the image. When it doesn’t we see flat. I think that’s one reason that predominately we see the discussion around 35-50mm with some outliers. Also why brenzier shots or fast wide shots work, as out version is a narrow cone of focus with wide oof areas. The image is
...Show more →
DaveFP wrote
Mathieu18 wroteI’ve posted it before but since the discussion has gone there again it’s worth repeating.

ProfHank over on DPR, an actual professor from UK (Kentucky) tried to research what lens properties gave a 3D look. To do that, he tried to study which lenses gave a 3D appearance across a wide range of viewers. He found no concensus as to which images had or didn’t have a 3D look.

If people can’t agree on what is or isn’t 3D, than just like color and so many other things with optics it’s about personal perception and preference.

Doesn’t mean I don’t like it when I see it, but I also don’t think it’s an inherent quality in any lenses.
Hi Matt -

With all due respect to ProfHank:

The fact that he was unable to elucidate the characteristics in optics that contributes to "3D" doesn't mean that optics don't play a role.

Perhaps there are optical engineers at Leica, Zeiss, Nikon, etc., that would have no problem helping us come to terms with this topic.

Today there are thousands of first-tier researchers slaving away at Harvard, Princeton, MIT, Cal Tech, etc., in order to come to terms with as yet unexplained phenomena. Perhaps this knowledge lives in the future (IF, in fact, it is not available today).

With regard to 3D:

We don't really need people to "agree" or "disagree".

3D as an optical/visual phenomenon is best understood through facts rather than feelings.

That someone can't see it doesn't make it less real. My wife can't see 3D due to depth perception issues. Should we include her opinion in this topic?

One reality that can be hard to hear is that not everyone with expensive gear has the sense and sensibilities of artists.

Those with the best "eye" for such things make better mentors than those that don't.

I am, at best, a "capable" photographer but I have eyes that are very highly trained with regard to color and dimensionality.

As such I have no problem "reading" the relative presence or absence of dimensionality in an image.

The fact that "SonyBoy96" on DPR can't see it doesn't enter into the equation; at least not for me.

Wouldn't it be nice if Dr. Nasse could lend us a hand?


Well; that might be right. I really don't know. I think we can all agree on two things:

1. There is a lot of factors involved in this phenomenon. (assuming your are willing to accept its existence)

and -

2. This won't be the last we hear of it !




Apr 28, 2019 at 07:00 PM
darrellc
Offline
Details
p.13 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
Second this request from Mathieu... help us out, Sebboh.

My ten year old son and friends spent a couple of hours yesterday going through a card deck of optical illusions. There is likely something instructive for this discussion in deconstructing depth-related optical illusions. Understanding the cues of depth perception, could I intentionally use them in my photography to create images with more “pop”?

Similarly, it seems it might be more interesting to separate bokeh from “pop” and examine stopped down images that still exhibit “pop” to isolate other contributing factors.

I do feel certain lenses, like the Loxia 35, have a lot of depth stopped down vs. other lenses. I often was surprised at how much “dimensionality” the Loxia images had at f/3.2-f/4 compared to my other 35’s (including the RX1, FE 35/2.8, FE 35/1.4). Even my C/Y 35-70 sometimes exhibited this characteristic. Here’s a pic that felt somewhat “3D” to me despite being shot at least f/3.4 (I didn’t note the aperture setting).

Mathieu18 wrote:
Quite interested if you’d expand on this answer, specifically the 5 cues, or if you have some good literature to start with.

sebboh wrote
DaveFP wroteAre you sure it hasn't been explained? To know for sure we would have to do an extensive survey. More likely than not we would find that a substantial part of the answer lies in a physiology journal rather then an engineering one.
yes, i actually am a neurophysiologists that specializes in sensory perception and learning. there are a bunch of specific cues that the visual system uses to extract depth, texture, and to bind individual features into the perception of a single object. you can read a rich literature about it that goes back more than 50 years in animal studies and more than a century in psychophysical studies of humans. sadly, the link to properties of high performance lenses has not been well explored and there does not appear to be any real consistency in photo forum users perception of what photos produce 3D (though there is a strong placebo effect) nor is there amongst lay viewers.

the truth is that your brain uses lots of different cues to extract perception of volume and depth and it is easy to bias factors an individual pays attention to towards specific cues. people on photography forums are typically talking about any number of 5 different cues, but different ones are talking about different cues.







Apr 28, 2019 at 07:30 PM
bushwacker
Offline
Details
p.13 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
smpetty wrote:
MIRANDA1 wroteI've seen the effect from a number of different lenses including the Zeiss 35 ZM 1.4, the Zeiss APO Sonnar 135, the Sigma 135 and also the Canon 200 F2. here is a shot from the APO 135. Sometimes it's a combination of super sharp subject with a distance separation to the background and sometimes it isn't.
https://live.staticflickr.com/7008/13478066025_adec15c49d_h.jpgZeiss APO 135 Sony A7R by Jose Raposo, on Flickr
Show me a picture where the background and subject aren't isolated from one another with 3D-ness.

For my eye and brain, 3D requires subject and background separation and a wide aperture.


This subject been discussed before... look from previous thread maybe 5 years back or more

There's one comparo between Zeiss 1.4/50P vs 2/50 Makro. One has blurry background and the other all sharp same scene.

There's this green Saab sample too.

and then Red Ferrari by Denoir

Those people who are in to this thing know what's 3D and what's not.

look for these names: Samuli, Denoir, Makten, Sebboh, Philip Reeve and many others.


Apr 28, 2019 at 07:35 PM
darrellc
Offline
Details
p.13 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
Samuli, Denoir, Makten, Sebboh, Reeve...

No, no, no, no. To bring this discussion to a definitive close, there is but one name: YANNICK KHONG.

I’m shocked his name and authoritative work on the subject hasn’t been brought into this discussion. Sneak preview... it is not at all complicated everyone, it is really very simple: there are only a “few elements” that determine if a lens renders flat images or with great depth perception. Read it and weep.
Apr 28, 2019 at 07:45 PM
JohnDizzo15
Offline
Details
p.13 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
smpetty wrote:
JohnDizzo15 wroteSome more snaps out of the Sigma 20 that exhibit what I think is it.

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/46801490255_6474818de3_b.jpgSigma Art 20/1.4 by John Dizzo, on Flickr
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/46801455015_ffabb0d57f_b.jpgSigma Art 20/1.4 by John Dizzo, on Flickr
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/47717828381_19ebcfd3f7_b.jpgSigma Art 20/1.4 by John Dizzo, on Flickr
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/40751497303_dbb41f3eeb_b.jpgSigma Art 20/1.4 by John Dizzo, on Flickr
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/32774594847_04c749f2e7_b.jpgSigma Art 20/1.4 by John Dizzo, on Flickr
Of all of the photos in this thread, even the interloping GFX images, your Sigma 20 shots have the most 3D-ness and pop, IMHO


Thank you, @smpetty. It honestly does do it the most regularly for me out of all my lenses (and I've also had the GFX with 63/45 along with faster adapted lenses). The lack of regular separation/differentiation of IQ from the then A7R2 and the GFX 50S for my uses was not readily evident or easily perceptible. The difference in usability however, was very noticeable which is why the 50S was ultimately shipped off to a new owner.

Under the right lighting conditions, the effect can be easily had with even APSC sensor bodies.

Also, it is easy for people to see what many consider to be pop or 3D with a fast telephoto lens (or close to the subject with a fast normal FL lens) since everything in the out of focus areas is obliterated. The look that gets me excited though, is when something is shot with a wide angle lens and has the pop. The ability to shoot an environment, be able to see plenty of the out of focus plane detail, and still have the pop as it were.

Found a few more Sigma 20 shots. Slightly less so than some of the others I posted earlier in the thread, but still there (at least to my eye).

Sigma 20/1.4 Art by John Dizzo, on Flickr
Sigma 20/1.4 Art by John Dizzo, on Flickr
Sigma 20/1.4 Art by John Dizzo, on Flickr
Sigma 20/1.4 Art by John Dizzo, on Flickr

Some samples with telephoto lenses. Again though, much less impressive (to me at least) when compared to a wide lens that gives its own brand of 3d pop.

Canon 200/2.0
A7R2 + Canon 200/2.0 IS by John Dizzo, on Flickr
A7R2 + Canon 200/2.0 IS by John Dizzo, on Flickr

Canon 300/2.8
A9 + Canon 300/2.8 by John Dizzo, on Flickr
Apr 28, 2019 at 08:07 PM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.13 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
bushwacker wrote:
smpetty wrote
MIRANDA1 wroteI've seen the effect from a number of different lenses including the Zeiss 35 ZM 1.4, the Zeiss APO Sonnar 135, the Sigma 135 and also the Canon 200 F2. here is a shot from the APO 135. Sometimes it's a combination of super sharp subject with a distance separation to the background and sometimes it isn't.
https://live.staticflickr.com/7008/13478066025_adec15c49d_h.jpgZeiss APO 135 Sony A7R by Jose Raposo, on Flickr
Show me a picture where the background and subject aren't isolated from one another with 3D-ness.

For my eye and brain, 3D requires subject and background separation and a wide aperture.
This subject been discussed before... look from previous thread maybe 5 years back or more

There's one comparo between Zeiss 1.4/50P vs 2/50 Makro. One has blurry background and the other all sharp same scene.

There's this green Saab sample too.

and then Red Ferrari by Denoir

Those people who are in to this thing know what's 3D and what's not.

look for these names: Samuli, Denoir, Makten, Sebboh, Philip Reeve and many others.



The ability to discern depth (or the illusion of depth) is a basic component of human vision.

I'm not sure that it is necessary to have "what's 3D and what's not" explained.

On the other hand an expert explanation of how optics play a role in this phenomenon (assuming they do play a role) would be very enjoyable to read as would any insights into the physiology of the phenomenon.

I'm sure Sebboh can help us understand the latter component so if any of the above can school us on the former that would be wonderful.









Apr 28, 2019 at 09:22 PM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.13 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
rsrsrs wrote:
which lens has the most 3D POP?




This one...

https://www.panasonic.com/ca/support/discontinued/cameras-camcorders/h-ft012.html
Apr 28, 2019 at 09:29 PM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.13 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
darrellc wrote:
Samuli, Denoir, Makten, Sebboh, Reeve...

No, no, no, no. To bring this discussion to a definitive close, there is but one name: YANNICK KHONG.

I’m shocked his name and authoritative work on the subject hasn’t been brought into this discussion. Sneak preview... it is not at all complicated everyone, it is really very simple: there are only a “few elements” that determine if a lens renders flat images or with great depth perception. Read it and weep.


I was going to bring him up.

https://yannickkhong.com/blog/2018/5/27/depth-life

I know that he and "the angry photographer" claim that 3D is a function of element count.

I have no reason to think that's wrong but I have never seen any research that backs it up.

What, in your opinion, makes it authoritative?

In any case he and Lloyd are preaching to the choir as far as I am concerned.

I love Zeiss optics (and similar lenses).



Apr 28, 2019 at 09:31 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.13 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
darrellc wrote:
Second this request from Mathieu... help us out, Sebboh.


i'll see if i can find some nice reviews that aren't behind a paywall. the short answer is that nothing from neuroscience research is going be terribly helpful in choosing lenses which have relatively tiny differences between them, but has a lot to say about how composition and even post processing can give things more of a 3D feel.

i don't know much about optics research, but i expect most of the work focuses on minimizing aberrations and materials. if anybody has done serious studies examining how subtle differences between lenses impact 3D feel or just viewer preferences, i'd bet it was marketing firms or lens producers and that it would not be generally available.

darrellc wrote:
Samuli, Denoir, Makten, Sebboh, Reeve...

No, no, no, no. To bring this discussion to a definitive close, there is but one name: YANNICK KHONG.

I’m shocked his name and authoritative work on the subject hasn’t been brought into this discussion. Sneak preview... it is not at all complicated everyone, it is really very simple: there are only a “few elements” that determine if a lens renders flat images or with great depth perception. Read it and weep.


his graphs make the scientist in me twitch uncontrollably.

Apr 28, 2019 at 10:22 PM
Dave Sanders
Offline
Details
p.13 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
DaveFP wrote:
darrellc wroteSamuli, Denoir, Makten, Sebboh, Reeve...

No, no, no, no. To bring this discussion to a definitive close, there is but one name: YANNICK KHONG.

I’m shocked his name and authoritative work on the subject hasn’t been brought into this discussion. Sneak preview... it is not at all complicated everyone, it is really very simple: there are only a “few elements” that determine if a lens renders flat images or with great depth perception. Read it and weep.
I was going to bring him up.

https://yannickkhong.com/blog/2018/5/27/depth-life

I know that he and "the angry photographer" claim that 3D is a function of element count.

I have no reason to think that's wrong but I have never seen any research that backs it up.

What, in your opinion, makes it authoritative?

In any case he and Lloyd are preaching to the choir as far as I am concerned.

I love Zeiss optics (and similar lenses).



I'm quite sure he was being sarcastic. Yannick is a fool and dead wrong, even in his most basic assertions. He was put properly in his place by Brian Caldwell, designer of the majestic Coastal Optics 60/4.
Apr 28, 2019 at 10:29 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Makten
Offline
Details
p.13 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
smpetty wrote:
I agree that it's 3D-ish, but there is plenty of background blur, especially considering the depth of the scene. The rock right behind the bike parts is blurred.


The point is that it would probably look less "3D" if there was more background blur. I think most of the images in this thread shot wide open with fast tele lenses don't at all look "3D" because it's something that my eyes can't relate to. It would never look like that IRL. Edit: A totally blurred background also eliminates the context of the surroundings of the subject. Which, in many ways, isn't beneficial.
Apr 29, 2019 at 03:15 AM
DaveFP
Offline
Details
p.13 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
Dave Sanders wrote:
DaveFP wrote
darrellc wroteSamuli, Denoir, Makten, Sebboh, Reeve...

No, no, no, no. To bring this discussion to a definitive close, there is but one name: YANNICK KHONG.

I’m shocked his name and authoritative work on the subject hasn’t been brought into this discussion. Sneak preview... it is not at all complicated everyone, it is really very simple: there are only a “few elements” that determine if a lens renders flat images or with great depth perception. Read it and weep.
I was going to bring him up.

https://yannickkhong.com/blog/2018/5/27/depth-life

I know that he and "the angry photographer" claim that 3D is a function of element count.

I have no reason to think that's wrong but I have never seen any research that backs it up.

What, in your opinion, makes it authoritative?

In any case he and Lloyd are preaching to the choir as far as I am concerned.

I love Zeiss optics (and similar lenses).
I'm quite sure he was being sarcastic. Yannick is a fool and dead wrong, even in his most basic assertions. He was put properly in his place by Brian Caldwell, designer of the majestic Coastal Optics 60/4.


Not surprised. It seemed to be a very simplistic assessment and I never heard anyone else of substance back his claim.

That's why I didn't mention him.

Apr 29, 2019 at 05:57 AM
rsrsrs
Offline
Details
p.13 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
Well,
Since i switched from the Canon 5D and Contax Zeiss (C/Y and N) to Sony E System i was looking for a Compact (AF) Lens who give me this effect and could not find any for an affordable price.
I have the Batis 85mm and the Zony 55mm but they are just sharp and nice blur but no 3D POP, i would not wonder if they are just Zeiss marked.
The only Lens i have which is very nice in all ways is the converted Contax G 45.
And it pops all the time in 3D.
Apr 29, 2019 at 06:47 AM
Sauseschritt
Offline
Details
p.13 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
You can simply adapt DSLR lenses to mirrorless if your new mirrorless system has no satisfying options.

Thats one of the spoils of mirrorless, you can adapt pretty much anything and its relatively easy to focus manually on mirrorless.



Btw, would I be correct in summarizing this thread as "what are you waiting for, get medium format already" ?
Apr 29, 2019 at 07:01 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.13 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?

I think the Batis 40 has a bit of it, but it's not really small. Being a Batis, it's kind of fat....and the hood makes it fairly long as well.

Compared to the G 45 it's huge.

-Tim

rsrsrs wrote:
Well,
Since i switched from the Canon 5D and Contax Zeiss (C/Y and N) to Sony E System i was looking for a Compact (AF) Lens who give me this effect and could not find any for an affordable price.
I have the Batis 85mm and the Zony 55mm but they are just sharp and nice blur but no 3D POP, i would not wonder if they are just Zeiss marked.
The only Lens i have which is very nice in all ways is the converted Contax G 45.
And it pops all the time in 3D.


Apr 29, 2019 at 07:15 AM
AdaptedLenses
Offline
Details
p.13 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
Appreciate it, and to be fair, I think the composition and post are probably more important than as you say the small differences between optics. I was more looking to shoot more 3D shots than pick "the best" lens. I know Chromostereopsis can play a role but imagine there are other cues as you mentioned that can help convey depth.

sebboh wrote:
darrellc wroteSecond this request from Mathieu... help us out, Sebboh.
i'll see if i can find some nice reviews that aren't behind a paywall. the short answer is that nothing from neuroscience research is going be terribly helpful in choosing lenses which have relatively tiny differences between them, but has a lot to say about how composition and even post processing can give things more of a 3D feel.

i don't know much about optics research, but i expect most of the work focuses on minimizing aberrations and materials. if anybody has done serious studies examining how subtle differences between lenses impact 3D feel or just viewer preferences, i'd bet it
...Show more →
darrellc wroteSamuli, Denoir, Makten, Sebboh, Reeve...

No, no, no, no. To bring this discussion to a definitive close, there is but one name: YANNICK KHONG.

I’m shocked his name and authoritative work on the subject hasn’t been brought into this discussion. Sneak preview... it is not at all complicated everyone, it is really very simple: there are only a “few elements” that determine if a lens renders flat images or with great depth perception. Read it and weep.


Apr 29, 2019 at 07:26 AM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.13 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
I find the word “pop” to be too vague and also rather vulgar. Are there any clearer, more precise terms that could help describe what exactly we’re discussing here?
Apr 29, 2019 at 07:56 AM
jeffersoncasey
Offline
Details
p.13 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
I have a different take here. Like those Renaissance paintings that has the 3D-ness to them, there are 2 important elements that contribute to the perception of depth - shadow, and gradation (which strongly related between both).

We perceive a photo without dark regions or shadows as flat, no matter how sharp they are. And on pictures that does have shadows, but without smooth gradients, will often look flat too.

So the biggest factor here, as some already mentioned, is the composition (particularly lighting). Then, it's whether the camera will be able to capture the gradation of the transitions between dark and bright regions, to give it more refined look.

In other words, having the best camera in the world, shooting in a bad and flat lighting, nothing will look 3D. However, when the lighting is right, and the framing and angle is right, even mobile photo can take pretty 3D looking photos.

Below were taken with Huawei Mate 9 SOOC jpeg.


And this is with aperture mode with blur amount set to taste to avoid unnatural look.


Not to impress everyone with the above and I took the same scene with RX1R and they looked even better. Took these for quick sharing with my friend and surprised they turned out very nice too. Just sharing my opinions here and perhaps some of you might not find my above shots interesting or even look flat.
Apr 29, 2019 at 08:40 AM
tsdevine
Offline
Details
p.13 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
Still think the Batis 40mm has a little magic going on, even stopped down.


Kilgore Falls by Tim Devine, on Flickr

-Tim

Edited on Apr 29, 2019 at 07:52 PM · View previous versions
Apr 29, 2019 at 04:53 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.13 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
Mathieu18 wrote:
Quite interested if you’d expand on this answer, specifically the 5 cues, or if you have some good literature to start with.

sebboh wrote
DaveFP wroteAre you sure it hasn't been explained? To know for sure we would have to do an extensive survey. More likely than not we would find that a substantial part of the answer lies in a physiology journal rather then an engineering one.
yes, i actually am a neurophysiologists that specializes in sensory perception and learning. there are a bunch of specific cues that the visual system uses to extract depth, texture, and to bind individual features into the perception of a single object. you can read a rich literature about it that goes back more than 50 years in animal studies and more than a century in psychophysical studies of humans. sadly, the link to properties of high performance lenses has not been well explored and there does not appear to be any real consistency in photo forum users perception of what photos produce 3D (though there is a strong placebo effect) nor is there amongst lay viewers.

the truth is that your brain uses lots of different cues to extract perception of volume and depth and it is easy to bias factors an individual pays attention to towards specific cues. people on photography forums are typically talking about any number of 5 different cues, but different ones are talking about different cues.


here's a cute little cartoon of the major cues we use to extract 3D information from images (can people see this image or does it require a journal subscription?):





obviously disparity and motion don't really work for photographs. only blur and texture are really subject to lens differences. there are, of course, other less important cues that are not shown.

there is a lot of interesting neuroscience work that might be relevant trying to figure out how responses of individual neurons across different visual brain regions are bound together to create a coherent percept of an object. the short answer to that though is that we are a long way from figuring it out and a large part of it may come from top down processing...

Apr 29, 2019 at 05:38 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister