j4nu wrote:
ftllens wrote
Nifty Fifty wrote
ftllens wrote
The OP is asking which lens has the most 3D pop, not which electronic image processing produces the strongest 3D pop photos.😄 True, but I think like any 15 year old long conversation, the direction ebbs and flows over time. The OP also requested this thread to be closed 4 months ago but that never happened.
Processing and presentation is important, because it lets you understand how you can manipulate a flat lens to pop and a poppy lens to flatten and learn about which parameters increase or decrease the net effect.
Then you have to ask if the optical design characteristics are just specific magnifiers of the effect when 3dpop lighting conditions are already met and not the cause of the design itself.
I also agree that stereoscopic setups are overkill, but if you want to be precise about it, for an outdoor conditions with ever-changing lighting, it's more controlled if both comparison shots are taken at the identical time. Indoor controlled lighting of course (which is even better) doesn't matter.
Anyway here is a tree: This lens gets the Escher award, the pot feels simply wrong to my eyes.
To some extent, I think this is because the pot is disproportionately and unnaturally big - it almost dwarfs the bench to the right. Despite the size, the pot seems suspended, as if it levitates. Also the contrast is unnatural. I like the effect however - it is visually challenging and can make a viewer stop and try to make sense of the content. The picture doesn't look to be a photograph, yet it isn't a painting.