fjablo wrote:
mudlake wrote
I'll throw an image out there for review. I took this in the Paris Pantheon last week with the 35GM and looking at it on my big screen, I see a lot of 3D. Anyone else see it in this image? The 35GM is a beauty of a lens. Some depth cues from the background being a bit oof, but mostly the way the subject is lit and especially the balance between light on the subject and a darker background.
This example is really all about the light and not the lens.
Another +1 for the contribution of the lighting is significant in this image.
The subject has high contrast lighting on it ... cross lighting in this instance, which affords the modeling intensity.
The background has a lower contrast lighting.
So, the transitional cues of near > far do transition from acute contrast > diffuse / low contrast. That is in context of a physiological depth cue.
That's not to say the lens isn't contributing a fast / slow transition rate ... but, when the lighting is this strong of a cue, the lens contribution is harder to discern its contribution. But, TBH ... I don't see much on this one that makes me think of this lens as something in the league of the VM 40/1.2 or other fav's that folks have. Likely the lighting contribution is "overshadowing" the lens contribution here.
Since there are a variety of potential cues (general to all) ... I think those lenses that have more rapid transition rates ... they "stand out" more when the strength of the lighting cues are absent / reduced. There, the credence to the lens contribution (vs. modest light modeling / depth cues) can be a bit more noticeable ... predicated on the optical attributes.
At the end of the day, the combination of the various elements work together to yield the total rendering ... that includes both optical / non-optical aspects. e.g. the brighter (forward projection) subject face vs. darker (receding) background is but ONE of such (rate of change) physiological response cues, regarding depth interpretation.