Mark_L wrote:
I am very very leery of buying a sigma lens, when tested almost every sigma lens seems to perform below the nikon equivalent. Even the 50mm f1.4 people seem to love has some serious issues in the corners on full frame cameras (checkout the review on slrgear). Sample variation may also be an issue so I'd want to try 3 and keep the best one.
My Sigma 50mm is spot-on (I even checked with a LensAlign) yet the new Nikon 85mm AF-S that I rented from lensrentals was way-off, I had to set +20 in order to get reasonable things in focus.
As for soft-corners in full frame for the Sigma 50, it is by design, meaning that Sigma did trade-off corner for center sharpness + nice bokeh. If you want sharp corners maybe you need to look somewhere else.
But if you go for the Sigma please don't do the "try 3 and keep one" deal - why would I say it? Well, I received a used Nikon 24mm f/1.4 lens instead of a new one from a very big & legit online vendor (and now I have to wait for the exchange), so the more people abuse the policy, the harder it will be for legitimate returns to be processed.