Awesome shots though! I'm currently in the market for a new 85mm (since I recently let go of my f/1.4D). I may have to give this lens a closer look, considering how much I liked my Sigma 50mm f/1.4 in the past.
Bruce Sawle wrote: Gregg Heckler wroteNice images. If more people buy the Sigma it may just drive the price of the Nikkor down a little. I hope so. If it does for this kind of money I'd rather buy the Nikkor for its quality, reliability, and warranty.Sig is built at as good if not better then the Nikon 85 G it comes with a 5 year warranty and out of the box was more reliable then the Nikon 85 G lemon I received.
Firstly, these samples look impressive. The Sigma looks like a winner!
That said, I own the G and have handled the Sigma, side by side in fact. To say the Sigma is built as good or better than the G is a bit misleading.
Also, sorry you ended up with a lemon G. It happens. But it was exactly that. A lemon copy. I, along with many others are quite happy with the G.
Anyways, just want to repeat these look great . It certainly is great to have these options ain't it?
Thank you so much, Brucke. I'm in the market for a 85mm 1.4 and debating between a used Nikon and new Sigma. Your photos make me lean to the Sigma. Please post some more for us if you have a chance.
Honestly unless someone is willing to drop them both on pavement to test it this will always be a big argument. But in my opinion the 85 G is a well built lens and the Sigma is equally as well built. Price has nothing to do with this. The look and feel of the Sigma 85 1.4 is much nicer then the Sigma 50 1.4.
The Sigma 85 is almost like the Sigma 50 with a smoother rubber finish to it. Perhaps a little bit more solid. The switch is just as cheap feeling as the 50 and it's not sealed like the G IIRC. I'm not trying to justify the G. Not at all. But it is the better built lens. You've even got a Sigma owner in BenV stating as such.
Anyways, I can understand for lots of folks this doesn't matter. What's most important is the Sigma seems like it's got the IQ to compete. Glad to hear the AF is nice too.
Bruce Sawle wrote:
Honestly unless someone is willing to drop them both on pavement to test it this will always be a big argument. But in my opinion the 85 G is a well built lens and the Sigma is equally as well built. Price has nothing to do with this. The look and feel of the Sigma 85 1.4 is much nicer then the Sigma 50 1.4.
I agree both are very well built; I have both in my possession right now. I think the Nikon 85G feels more "solid" like it's one solid piece. The Sigma 85 feels solid as well, but not the same as the 85G, but you're right, it does feel nicer than the Sigma 50; the new coating is a huge improvement
as you got a lemon with the 85G, i got a lemon with the Sigma 85... 85G is spot on for me though
Have you noticed any focus accuracy issues with outer focus points?
There is a thread below that suggests the outer focus points with the Sig 85 and D700 are not very accurate. I've also seen a few of the same complaints on POTN.
I have not noticed any focus issues with the sig on any of the focus points. The pictures in this thread were taken using the center and outer non cross type sensors. My other thread all photos were taken using the non cross type sensors in contnoius tracking mode only. The focus consistency has be great. It's not perfect but very close. See the thread below.