Ross Martin wrote:
grantgoodes wrote
Ross Martin wrote
The new old stock is s/n 998774.
I’m also looking at s/n 1048602 for almost $200 less, in minty condition. Looked at that 2nd one, and it's clearly an SIC (newest generation) coating version, and seems to be really nice condition.
When I got my Df, I realized I was really missing my old 105/2.5 (which I'd sold to purchase a Micro-Nikkor 105.2.8) and so picked up a minty copy for a good price. Sadly, I hadn't heard about the SIC vs. NIC coating change, and now I'm regretting that I didn't hold out for the "ultimate" 105/2.5 with a later serial number. I've seen some discussion threads where the two versions were carefully compared, and there IS an improvement in flare-resistance/contrast with the SIC coating, but it's not earth-shattering. Still, I have to resist buying yet ANOTHER Nikkor 105 (I have 4, including the 105/1,8 and 105/2 DC)! ---------------------------------------------
OffTrail wrote
Ross Martin wrote
grantgoodes wrote
Ross Martin wrote
Hey y’all, am I crazy for considering dropping $650 on a new in box (old stock) never used AI-S 105mm f/2.5?? Used copies in mint condition are going for $400-450. It’s tempting to me to go all in and have the new one. This focal length would fit nicely for me in a 28/55/105 AI-S trio. Personally I would seriously consider it. The only Nikkor I bought new was my AiS 24/2, and if there's another one I wish I'd had NIB it would be the 105/2.5: It would be totally worth it if it's a late-serial number SIC-coated version (higher than 1043xxx) as they go for a premium to begin with. Thanks for that info. I’m also looking at a mint copy for about $450 taxed/delivered, s/n 1048602. The new old stock is s/n 998774. The 1048xxx version should have the latest coatings, where 998xxx likely wouldn't. At least according to Roland Vink's site, SIC coatings started at 1043xxx. For the later S/N to be cheaper, have the latest coating, and still look mint, I think that makes a bit more sense.
That said, I can't tell you what difference SIC coatings really make for the 105's as both of mine are pre-Ai Sonnar versions. You guys are a great help, thanks! I went for the near-mint s/n 1048602 at $443 shipped/taxed, and zero interest 12 payments on my PayPal account so will be painless. Excited to have minimalist 28/55/105 kit! Hoping to head to the Southwest starting in late January where they’ll get a good workout but will try to make a few images in my area before that.
Ross, congratulations on the SIC 105/2.5 AIs.
I hunted down the SIC version a few years back and it was a total bear to find, in mint condition. If you decide to go after a second copy, the AI version is also a stellar performer and has more rounded blades. The AI version also feels a bit more solid which is the case with the majority of AI the variants.
Serge