Beautiful pictures and as usual an excellent review. I would like to offer a correction, however. I am pretty sure this lens does not have floating elements. I did my best to investigate this issue at one time and although I found one source that claimed that it had floating elements. I found several that suggested it did not. In the end I was persuaded by the argument that the Minolta MC lenses with floating elements (e.g., the 24 f/2.,8, the 28 f/2) had both floating elements and a rotating front filter threads, whereas those that did not (e.g., 35 f/2.8, 28 f/2.8) did not have rotating front filter threads.
https://farm2.staticflickr.com/1550/25800792370_057d123fb6_o.jpgBeautiful pictures and as usual an excellent review. I would like to offer a correction, however. I am pretty sure this lens does not have floating elements. I did my best to investigate this issue at one time and although I found one source that claimed that it had floating elements. I found several that suggested it did not. In the end I was persuaded by the argument that the Minolta MC lenses with floating elements (e.g., the 24 f/2.,8, the 28 f/2) had both floating elements and a rotating front filter threads, whereas those that did not (e.g., 35 f/2.8, 28 f/2.8) did not have rotating front filter threads....Show more →
Thanks for the correction
Two shots with my favorite Rokkor, the lower 75/3.5 in my Minolta Autocord CdS TLR ;-)
Mecklenburg, Heimat by Georg, auf Flickr
Autocord CdS, exposure unrecorded, Trix-X in Diafine, printed (not so well) on Foma-RC-paper
ouch! messed up the tones by Georg, auf Flickr
Autocord CdS, red-filter, Fuji Acros in Diafine, got unfortunately matching tones between boom/outrigger and the surrounding sky
Btw, I have a MD 24-35/3.5 without a camera. Is this one an "okay" performer on a matching film-body?
sebboh wrote: Phillip Reeve wroteWow, the last post is three weeks old, it seems that Minolta is less popular today.i think most people shooting minoltas have embraced the sony a7s and just post on that thread.
here's a few with the rokkor MC PF 58/1.4, a lens i never really liked on aps-c but liked on film and FF as more of a "character lens".
Which version of the MC 1.4/58 do you have? the older one or the newer one? The newer one is supposed to be quite a bit sharper but while I have both versions I never found the time to really use them, still have far too many lenses (OM 2/28, 1.8/50 and 4/75-150 along with Zeiss MP 2/100 beeing the newest)
Personally I think it's better to post in the various lens threads than in the FE pool, but that's just me. IMO what's interesting is how a lens / lens family draws, not how the FE cameras draw, so to say.
Anyways, took the A7s an the Rokkor 58/1.2 to the forests. All shot at around 2-2.8.
Phillip Reeve wrote: sebboh wrotePhillip Reeve wroteWow, the last post is three weeks old, it seems that Minolta is less popular today.i think most people shooting minoltas have embraced the sony a7s and just post on that thread.
here's a few with the rokkor MC PF 58/1.4, a lens i never really liked on aps-c but liked on film and FF as more of a "character lens".
Which version of the MC 1.4/58 do you have? the older one or the newer one? The newer one is supposed to be quite a bit sharper but while I have both versions I never found the time to really use them, still have far too many lenses (OM 2/28, 1.8/50 and 4/75-150 along with Zeiss MP 2/100 beeing the newest)
not a new trend, but this thread has been deadish for a long time. I also like the lens type specific threads better, they seem to be on the decline though since the a7 came out.
I have both versions of the 58/1.4, I tested them a while ago and haven't noticed any difference except in coatings and aperture blades (the older version has 8). I think the talk of the new one being sharper is wishful thinking, the MC PG 50/1.4 is a much better performer across the board.
sebboh wrote:
I have both versions of the 58/1.4, I tested them a while ago and haven't noticed any difference except in coatings and aperture blades (the older version has 8). I think the talk of the new one being sharper is wishful thinking, the MC PG 50/1.4 is a much better performer across the board.
I wasn't precise enough. Stephan from Artaphot.ch writes that the MC-II version is improved a lot and not quite close in performance to the 1.4/50's while the older MC-I is quite a bit softer. I think you talk about Auto vs MC.
I just ran a quick comparison at a distance of about 1.5m and was surprised how good resolution and little astigmatism my MC-I has in the corners. Contrast is very low but only my MD 2/50 comes close to the resolution at f/2 and even f/1.4. MC 1.4/50, 1.2/58, 1.7/55, C/Y 1.4/50, nFD 1.4/50, OM 1.8/50 all have less resolution in the corners (and they are all sharper in the center )
But I can confirm that the MC-II has noticeably improved contrast over the MC-I but the MC 1.4/50 has still more contrast at f/1.4
Phillip Reeve wrote: sebboh wroteI have both versions of the 58/1.4, I tested them a while ago and haven't noticed any difference except in coatings and aperture blades (the older version has 8). I think the talk of the new one being sharper is wishful thinking, the MC PG 50/1.4 is a much better performer across the board.I wasn't precise enough. Stephan from Artaphot.ch writes that the MC-II version is improved a lot and not quite close in performance to the 1.4/50's while the older MC-I is quite a bit softer. I think you talk about Auto vs MC.
I just ran a quick comparison at a distance of about 1.5m and was surprised how good resolution and little astigmatism my MC-I has in the corners. Contrast is very low but only my MD 2/50 comes close to the resolution at f/2 and even f/1.4. MC 1.4/50, 1.2/58, 1.7/55, C/Y 1.4/50, nFD 1.4/50, OM 1.8/50 all have less resolution in the corners (and they are all sharper in the center )
But I can confirm that the MC-II has noticeably improved contrast over the MC-I but the MC 1.4/50 has still more contrast at f/1.4...Show more →
ah, you are right. i was thinking the auto vs MC. how do i tell what version of the MC i have? the serial number is 588****.
sebboh wrote: Phillip Reeve wrotesebboh wroteI have both versions of the 58/1.4, I tested them a while ago and haven't noticed any difference except in coatings and aperture blades (the older version has 8). I think the talk of the new one being sharper is wishful thinking, the MC PG 50/1.4 is a much better performer across the board.I wasn't precise enough. Stephan from Artaphot.ch writes that the MC-II version is improved a lot and not quite close in performance to the 1.4/50's while the older MC-I is quite a bit softer. I think you talk about Auto vs MC.
I just ran a quick comparison at a distance of about 1.5m and was surprised how good resolution and little astigmatism my MC-I has in the corners. Contrast is very low but only my MD 2/50 comes close to the resolution at f/2 and even f/1.4. MC 1.4/50, 1.2/58, 1.7/55, C/Y 1.4/50, nFD 1.4/50, OM 1.8/50 all have less resolution in the corners (and they are all sharper in the center )
But I can confirm that the MC-II has noticeably improved contrast over the MC-I but the MC 1.4/50 has still more contrast at f/1.4ah, you are right. i was thinking the auto vs MC. how do i tell what version of the MC i have? the serial number is 588****.
Steve Spencer wrote: sebboh wrotePhillip Reeve wrotesebboh wroteI have both versions of the 58/1.4, I tested them a while ago and haven't noticed any difference except in coatings and aperture blades (the older version has 8). I think the talk of the new one being sharper is wishful thinking, the MC PG 50/1.4 is a much better performer across the board.I wasn't precise enough. Stephan from Artaphot.ch writes that the MC-II version is improved a lot and not quite close in performance to the 1.4/50's while the older MC-I is quite a bit softer. I think you talk about Auto vs MC.
I just ran a quick comparison at a distance of about 1.5m and was surprised how good resolution and little astigmatism my MC-I has in the corners. Contrast is very low but only my MD 2/50 comes close to the resolution at f/2 and even f/1.4. MC 1.4/50, 1.2/58, 1.7/55, C/Y 1.4/50, nFD 1.4/50, OM 1.8/50 all have less resolution in the corners (and they are all sharper in the center )
But I can confirm that the MC-II has noticeably improved contrast over the MC-I but the MC 1.4/50 has still more contrast at f/1.4ah, you are right. i was thinking the auto vs MC. how do i tell what version of the MC i have? the serial number is 588****.