fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2010 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2010Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread

  
 
Anden
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
Nice 3D!
Aug 12, 2010 at 05:25 AM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
wayne seltzer wrote:
More tacky!


Aw. Now I was only talking about the town, not your photography.
Aug 12, 2010 at 06:03 PM
wayne seltzer
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
freaklikeme wrote:
wayne seltzer wroteMore tacky!
Aw. Now I was only talking about the town, not your photography.


Yes, I was just playing along with the tacky idea, as there is a lot of tacky or gawdy stuff going on in Camp Vegas.

Aug 12, 2010 at 06:29 PM
wayne seltzer
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
Anden wrote:
Nice 3D!


Thanks Andreas!
Aug 12, 2010 at 06:31 PM
systemlayers
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
I'm considering selling my canon 35 1.4 for the Zeiss 35/2 and then eventually getting a 24 1.4 this thread has greatly pushed me towards the nikon rather than canon.
Especially if the canon 24 has similiar CA as my 35 1.4 has wide open.
Aug 12, 2010 at 06:45 PM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
wayne seltzer wrote:
Bifurcator,
Here is the 100% middle crop from the picture with the Paris balloon with only default sharpening in LR 2.6, 25/1.0/0, no other sharpening.
Crop shows the white car with advertisement for place where you can shoot AK47 assault rifles. Only in America.

https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/ufiles/93/454993.jpg
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/ufiles/28/458228.jpg

Remember this is at 1.4 hand-held with focus at infinity mark.



Outstanding! Thanks! I'm going to try and reproduce this shot around here. I need to find a street about that wide here and then wait for a car with writing on it. I'm going to compare it with an image from my Sigma 18-35mm f/3.5 Aspherical AF that I picked up for $10 off the Japanese auction site. I only have the M43 GH1 from panasonic tho so it'll be the equiv of 36mm. I think it'll interesting at least. I guess it's not a very fair comparison but it's the closest I can get.
Aug 12, 2010 at 09:15 PM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
Well, I took 245 test images (totally) at 7 intersections and I got many shots that were a pretty close compare. Text, same sized car and people, lighting similar (time of evening), etc.

The EXIF on your sample says:

    EXIF Summary: 1/400s f/2.0 ISO200 35mm
      Camera-Specific Properties:
      Equipment Make: Canon
      Camera Model: Canon EOS-1Ds Mark III
      Camera Software: Adobe Photoshop CS3 Windows
      Maximum Lens Aperture: f/2.0
      Image Generated: 2010:05:14 19:25:07
      Image Digitized: 2010:05:14 19:25:07


The results by my judgment (Sigma zoom at f/3.5 compared to Nikkor at f/2.0) :

  1. Sharpness: Extremely close! 0.5
    Depending on which of the 245 shots I looked at it ranged from slightly sharper to a tad less sharp.
    I didn't focus mine at infinite though. I went to past infinite (on the adaptor) and then pulled it back
    just a little from where infinite would be if the adaptor was spot on. So considering all things the Nikkor
    is probably a touch sharper with both lenses at their widest. For sure there was MUCH less difference
    than your comparison images above.
  2. Micro contrast: Very close. 0.7
    The Nikkor shows clear signs of snuffing the Sigma if the apertures were equal but at 3.5 vs. 2.0 they
    are very close. And that's assuming that the exif is correct and that it's not actually 1.4 like you thought.
    If the Nikkor was at 1.4 then it just wipes the floor with the Sigma probably all the way to f/8. And again
    less difference than shown in your comparison images above.
  3. Color contrast: Nikkor wins! 2.0
    Color isolation and contrast were much better in you image than almost all of my images. There were a
    couple of places in a few of my images that held their own but only if tweaked the ACR sliders just for
    that purpose.
  4. Color accuracy: Nikkor wins. 1.0
    Of course I have to guess but I have almost perfect "color IQ" and memory. The colors in the Nikkor image
    looked like what I think they're supposed to look like while the Sigma seemed a tad off and if I corrected for
    one channel then a different channel seemed off. These are low-light images so I'm asking a lot from a $10
    Sigma and there wasn't a HUGE difference but it was noticeable. I was shooting RAW though and I forget
    if you mentioned RAW or JPG. Also the sensor plays a significant roll here as well and I dunno the differences
    between 1Ds M3 and the little GH1.
  5. Bloom and Halo: Nikkor wins! 4.0
    This probably affects color contrast to some degree as well but all of the light and specular points were much
    better defined in the Nikkor image. If I had only looked at the Sigma without a comparison I would not have
    thought it was bad - no one likely would. But here is probably the biggest difference between the images.
    The Sigma on it's own is good in this department but the Nikkor is just exceptional! I guess a lot of the
    differences here can be attributed to the different coating types? I assume so anyway.
  6. Falloff: Sigma wins 5.0
    But this isn't fair at all because my crop factor is so high at 2 to 1 while you're shooting 1:1. None of my
    test images showed any falloff (vignetting) at all - zero. I'm not 100% sure but I don't think any of the
    10 or so wide and ultra-wide angle lenses I've tried on the GH1 show any falloff at all - probably due to the
    crop factor of the GH1.


This of course is nowhere near a scientific test nor conclusive in any way. Just something fun for me to spend my Friday evening on. I'm WAY too cheap to ever spend $2K on a lens unless maybe it was a 24" APO f/4 refractor telescope with a tracking mount or came with a laboratory grade microscope attached to it - so I'm not the person who can say if it's a good buy or worth the money. Considering that I'm shooting a $10 Sigma on a $350 camera body I guess that's just naturally to be understood. On the other hand that ultra-cheap rig held up rather well - at least in this one test. If the Nikkor's max aperture was 3.0 or 3.5 (closer to the Sigma) I'd say there was less than a-hundred-or-two dollars difference between the two. But given the fact that the Nikkor opens up to f/1.4 I suppose is a multiplier by most people's standards. It sure is a wonderful thing to have fast lenses when needed!

Aug 13, 2010 at 12:56 PM
wiseguy010
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
wayne seltzer wrote:
Yes, if Zeiss made a ZE 24/1.4 with aspherical elements and FLE design I would be all over it but they don't.


I am not so sure about that. According to the rumors a new 35/1.4 ZF/ZE is coming in near future. I wouldn't be surprised when a 24/1.4 ZF/ZE will follow.
Aug 13, 2010 at 03:23 PM
wayne seltzer
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
Who knows, that would be great but they first have the 35/1.4 and redesigned 25/2.8 to get out first.
If I was Zeiss I would be working on a 24/1.4 for the NEX 1.5 crop system which would sell like crazy since their isn't a cheap high quality fast prime 35mm effective solution for that system and the only 1.4 lens at 24 is the leica 24 'Lux at ~$6400.
Aug 13, 2010 at 03:54 PM
wayne seltzer
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
Bifurcator wrote:
Well, I took 245 test images (totally) at 7 intersections and I got many shots that were a pretty close compare. Text, same sized car and people, lighting similar (time of evening), etc.

The EXIF on your sample says:

    EXIF Summary: 1/400s f/2.0 ISO200 35mm
      Camera-Specific Properties:
      Equipment Make: Canon
      Camera Model: Canon EOS-1Ds Mark III
      Camera Software: Adobe Photoshop CS3 Windows
      Maximum Lens Aperture: f/2.0
      Image Generated: 2010:05:14 19:25:07
      Image Digitized: 2010:05:14 19:25:07


The results by my judgment (Sigma zoom at f/3.5 compared to Nikkor at f/2.0) :

  1. Sharpness: Extremely close! 0.5
    Depending on which of the 245 shots I looked at it ranged from slightly sharper to a tad less sharp.
    I didn't focus mine at
  2. Micro contrast: Very close. 0.7
    The Nikkor shows clear signs of snuffing the Sigma if the apertures were equal but at 3.5 vs. 2.0 they
    are very close. And that's assuming that the exif is correct and that it's not actually 1.4 like you thought.
    If the Nikkor was at 1.4 then it just wipes the floor with the Sigma probably all the way to f/8. And again
    less difference than shown in your comparison images above.
  3. Color contrast: Nikkor wins! 2.0
    Color isolation and contrast were much better in you image than almost all of my images. There were a
    couple of places in a few of my images that held their own but only if tweaked the ACR sliders just for
    that purpose.
  4. Color accuracy: Nikkor wins. 1.0
    Of course I have to guess but I have almost perfect "color IQ" and memory. The colors in the Nikkor image
    looked like what I think they're supposed to look like while the Sigma seemed a tad off and if I corrected for
    one channel then a different channel seemed off. These are low-light images so I'm asking a lot from a $10
    Sigma and there wasn't a HUGE difference but it was noticeable. I was shooting RAW though and I forget
    if you mentioned RAW or JPG. Also the sensor plays a significant roll here as well and I dunno the differences
    between 1Ds M3 and the little GH1.
  5. Bloom and Halo: Nikkor wins! 4.0
    This probably affects color contrast to some degree as well but all of the light and specular points were much
    better defined in the Nikkor image. If I had only looked at the Sigma without a comparison I would not have
    thought it was bad - no one likely would. But here is probably the biggest difference between the images.
    The Sigma on it's own is good in this department but the Nikkor is just exceptional! I guess a lot of the
    differences here can be attributed to the different coating types? I assume so anyway.
  6. Falloff: Sigma wins 5.0
    But this isn't fair at all because my crop factor is so high at 2 to 1 while you're shooting 1:1. None of my
    test images showed any falloff (vignetting) at all - zero. I'm not 100% sure but I don't think any of the
    10 or so wide and ultra-wide angle lenses I've tried on the GH1 show any falloff at all - probably due to the
    crop factor of the GH1.


This of course is nowhere near a scientific test nor conclusive in any way. Just something fun for me to spend my Friday evening on. I'm WAY too cheap to ever spend $2K on a lens unless maybe it was a 24" APO f/4 refractor telescope with a tracking mount or came with a laboratory grade microscope attached to it - so I'm not the person who can say if it's a good buy or worth the money. Considering that I'm shooting a $10 Sigma on a $350 camera body I guess that's just naturally to be understood. On the other hand that ultra-cheap rig held up rather well - at least in this one test. If the Nikkor's max aperture was 3.0 or 3.5 (closer to the Sigma) I'd say there was less than a-hundred-or-two dollars difference between the two. But given the fact that the Nikkor opens up to f/1.4 I suppose is a multiplier by most people's standards. It sure is a wonderful thing to have fast lenses when needed!

...Show more →

I was shooting RAW and the exif says 35mm at f2 because I was using my chipped Nikon-to-EOS adapter which is programmed for my ZF 35/2 lens. These shots were all shot a f1.4 as I had a piece of cardboard wedged against the aperture lever so the lens was wide open. This lens sharpens up quite a bit at f2 and beyond so I would have to post another shot at that aperture to have a meaningful comparison.
Also, my shot was handheld which I wouldn't do if doing a proper lens comparison.
Aug 13, 2010 at 04:03 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
wayne seltzer wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
wayne seltzer wroteMore tacky!
Aw. Now I was only talking about the town, not your photography.
Yes, I was just playing along with the tacky idea, as there is a lot of tacky or gawdy stuff going on in Camp Vegas.



Camp Vegas. There should be uniforms.
Aug 13, 2010 at 05:26 PM
philber
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
wayne seltzer wrote:
Who knows, that would be great but they first have the 35/1.4 and redesigned 25/2.8 to get out first.
If I was Zeiss I would be working on a 24/1.4 for the NEX 1.5 crop system which would sell like crazy since their isn't a cheap high quality fast prime 35mm effective solution for that system and the only 1.4 lens at 24 is the leica 24 'Lux at ~$6400.



Wayne, AFAIK, Zeiss can only work on whatever lenses for Sony that Sony agree to, unlike for Canon and Nikon where the absence of any contract let them do what they want. And, if the present trend is to be believed, Sony are moving away from Zeiss and promoting instead their own "G" lenses. This is the logo that now appears on the lenses of the better Sony compacts, whereas before it would have been Zeiss, just as Leica appear on the better Panasonic lenses.
So the best one can hope for IMHO is an adapter for the 24 f:2.0 for the NEX. And that is already not half bad...
Symetrically, Zeiss are so busy developping lenses for Canon and Nikon that the availability of Zeiss lenses is no longer enough to push people to buy into the Sony system, except if they want AF and zooms....
Just my $0.02
Aug 14, 2010 at 12:12 AM
phidong
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
Well, they didn't have the G line to brand their P&S cameras before and now that it is established it might not make sense to license the Zeiss name on point and shoots. I don't really see them shying away from Zeiss development, although they seem to be only filling the gaps on their alpha mount line. They just announced the 24/2 and there is a rumored 28 and 200 on the horizon possibly? For NEX there are a lot of gaps to fill and no "quality" lenses specifically for that mount now. If the market for NEX is as big as Sony hopes and people are predicting I think it might be an avenue that they will pursue especially if some higher end NEX-7 comes out but we'll see. I am specifically holding off on buying a NEX for this reason and to see what happens at photokina with the platform.
Aug 14, 2010 at 01:03 AM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread

Bifurcator wrote:
Well, I took 245 test images... ----snip -- snip---- ...It sure is a wonderful thing to have fast lenses when needed!


wayne seltzer wrote:
I was shooting RAW and the exif says 35mm at f2 because I was using my chipped Nikon-to-EOS adapter which is programmed for my ZF 35/2 lens. These shots were all shot a f1.4 as I had a piece of cardboard wedged against the aperture lever so the lens was wide open. This lens sharpens up quite a bit at f2 and beyond so I would have to post another shot at that aperture to have a meaningful comparison.


OK I see. And I agree about the proper lens test thing of course.



Also, my shot was handheld which I wouldn't do if doing a proper lens comparison.


Yeah, also I noticed that when the sigma was actually right at infinite (I have it marked on the lens) all those 15 to 30 meter distant objects (and that's the taxi and the people for sure) were noticeably softer than when I pulled it back just slightly off infinite - which is what I compared to.

Aug 14, 2010 at 11:31 AM
lamonica66
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
I am totally digging the vibe here....
Aug 14, 2010 at 06:23 PM
charles.K
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
These last series of shots still amaze me Wayne. Love the colors and the presence of the shots.
Sep 07, 2010 at 03:24 AM
wayne seltzer
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
charles.K wrote:
These last series of shots still amaze me Wayne. Love the colors and the presence of the shots.


Thanks Charles! It is a great lens for low-light street shooting, plus cheaper than a M9 and M 24/1.4.
Sep 07, 2010 at 03:51 AM
s23chang
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Nikon 24/1.4G Love Thread
the 24mm 1.4 L II is far superior than the old 35 1.4 L
Almost no CA just like th Nikon.


systemlayers wrote:
I'm considering selling my canon 35 1.4 for the Zeiss 35/2 and then eventually getting a 24 1.4 this thread has greatly pushed me towards the nikon rather than canon.
Especially if the canon 24 has similiar CA as my 35 1.4 has wide open.

Sep 07, 2010 at 06:12 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister