fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2010 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2010Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101

  
 
E-Vener
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
Lightroom 3 does a wicked good job at sharpening and noise reduction fro many camera. It is much improved over Lightroom 2.6
Feb 02, 2010 at 09:33 PM
rprouty
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
Here's a pic from a few years ago at 3200 ISO from a 20D.:-)

http://www.pbase.com/rprouty/image/67664915.jpg

Feb 02, 2010 at 09:36 PM
David Manning
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
Okay, downsized 1DIV file to 5D size. Here are the 100% crops.

http://www.davidmanningphotography.com/Mark-IV/Noise_Compare.jpg
Feb 02, 2010 at 09:40 PM
David Manning
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
brainiac wrote:
32067dlm wroteOkay, look at the width of the black between the patches. There's not much difference in size.
The width of the black is irrelevant. That depends on lens focal length and whether it is adjusted for the crop angle of view. But here we are trying to look at the sensor's performance, so the width of the black stripe doesn't matter, UNLESS you ensured that the angles of view were identical. IFF you ensured that the angles of view and distance to subject were identical, then the width of the strap would count as a guide to magnification. But all this is irrelevant. Just uprez the 5D file to 1D4 dimensions and show at 100%. Job done.


1D4 - 35L (35mm * 1.3 = 45.5)
5D - Sigma 50 1.4 (Often considered just a little shy of 50mm)
Tripod in same location. Shot about 5 minutes apart.
Feb 02, 2010 at 09:44 PM
BigBlueDodge
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
I think one obvious point we are all missing here is to appreciate what a damn fine camera the 5D classic was and still is. It's impressive that almost 5 yr old technology is still hanging in there with the new kids on the block.
Feb 02, 2010 at 10:17 PM
Ariel Bravy
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
brainiac wrote:
NO! DO NOT COMPARE NOISE PER UNIT AREA! Compare noise per image.


It depends on what you're looking for and how you shoot.

IMHO, both are valid comparisons.

The other day I compared my 4MP 1D vs. a friend's 21MP 5DII. I wanted to see how the high ISO compared. Did I uprez the 4MP to 21MP to do a fair comparison? No. Why not? Because it has nothing to do with my reality and the way I like to take pictures and look at images. I never do that in real life so at that point we're talking technicalities and not practical shooting. It's really helpful to know as part of the total package, yes, but it has little to do with my end results.

In my mind, 100% is 100% is 100% and if an image looks "closer" at 100% due to higher pixel densities, well then that's a nice bonus. I understand that the whole uprez thing may be more technically accurate and has its place in the grand scheme of things, but for me the more accurate comparison is virtually meaningless. It reminds me to a limited extent of the joke about Microsoft helping out a helicopter pilot. (If you're not familiar with it, google Microsoft helicopter.)

We each have our own shooting styles and different things make different people happy. I like looking at images at 100% (whatever that happens to be), as well as reduced to about 800px wide on the longest dimensions for webposting since that's how I post things on my photoblog. How images look under those two conditions is what matters to me and thus how I compare them.

So with all due respect, thank you (truly, brainiac, I mean it) for teaching us about the technicalities of image comparison. I can see you're really passionate about it and really enjoy it, plus you're very good at it. What's most important to you in photography may not be what's important to me in photography, but that doesn't mean either one of us is wrong.

Edited on Feb 02, 2010 at 10:47 PM · View previous versions
Feb 02, 2010 at 10:44 PM
David Manning
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
Okay, I did another test with a little more control. This time I ensured closer exposure. I upsized the 5D file to match the 1DIV file using Bicubic Smoother. How many more ways shall I do this?

http://www.davidmanningphotography.com/Mark-IV/Noise_Compare_2.jpg
Feb 02, 2010 at 10:45 PM
seraphkz
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
This is why I still have my 5D even though I own a 5Dmark2
Feb 02, 2010 at 10:53 PM
timpdx
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
This is why I still have my 5D even though I own a 7D

thx for posting.
Feb 02, 2010 at 11:00 PM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
sivrajbm wrote:
Canon ISO yes, Nikon D3s is the KING of camera ISO...
As my grandson says Sorry bout that...


I take old canon file w/ 3rd party NR to compare any canon/nikon new file anyday
Feb 02, 2010 at 11:07 PM
dragonfly5
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
You guys are making me feel better about my 5D all the time. I've been tempted by the new feature set in the 7D and have been waiting for the "mythical" 3D for years. seeing results like these makes it easier for me to wait. Seems like in terms of image quality the 5D is holding it's own for a long time.
Feb 02, 2010 at 11:11 PM
stanj
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
32067dlm wrote:
Okay, I did another test with a little more control. This time I ensured closer exposure. I upsized the 5D file to match the 1DIV file using Bicubic Smoother. How many more ways shall I do this?


Don't. You'll never achieve consensus. What I think, or what others think doesn't really matter, it will always be a mud bath because people will always measure differently and stubbornly believe their approach is the only correct one. I know which approach is correct for me, but that doesn't matter. Nor do I personally think that this comparison matters, because few people will be deciding between the 1D4 and the 5D1 based on high ISO noise alone, or even predominantly. YMMV of course.
Feb 02, 2010 at 11:12 PM
hnordberg
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
32067dlm wrote:
1DIV (ISO 3200, 1/2500s, f/6.3)
5D (ISO 3200, 1/3200s, f/5.6)

Well, I guess there are times when you would use these numbers in real life, but I think there may be a bigger difference between the two cameras if you reduce the amount of light. I think it would be interesting to see this comparison at ISO 3200, 1/60, f/1.8 or darker. There would then be much less signal and the noise would stand out more.
Feb 02, 2010 at 11:30 PM
Alan321
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
E-Vener wrote:
Lightroom 3 does a wicked good job at sharpening and noise reduction fro many camera. It is much improved over Lightroom 2.6


Correct me if I'm wrong, but the Lr 3 beta does not handle 1D4 raw files I'm guessing that support for new cameras will wait until the non-beta version is released.

- Alan
Feb 02, 2010 at 11:51 PM
jxsq
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
Couldn't agreed more. 1d user think alike.

For me, if a camera can't deliver sharp, low noise pictures at pixel level, something is wrong. I still buy them and use them, but i do that for other reasons.




Ariel Bravy wrote:
brainiac wroteNO! DO NOT COMPARE NOISE PER UNIT AREA! Compare noise per image.
It depends on what you're looking for and how you shoot.

IMHO, both are valid comparisons.

The other day I compared my 4MP 1D vs. a friend's 21MP 5DII. I wanted to see how the high ISO compared. Did I uprez the 4MP to 21MP to do a fair comparison? No. Why not? Because it has nothing to do with my reality and the way I like to take pictures and look at images. I never do that in real life so at that point we're talking technicalities and not practical shooting. It's really helpful to know as part of the
...Show more →
Feb 02, 2010 at 11:58 PM
dvarnav
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
Thats why I have my 5DII as Alternative to my 1DMarkIII it gives you FF-HDvideo +Low noise 21Mpix and the when you need lightning speed for action you have it through 1DMarkIII and all of them in 5000EUR while 4500 has only one body MarkIV
Feb 03, 2010 at 12:21 AM
David Manning
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
Alan321 wrote:
E-Vener wroteLightroom 3 does a wicked good job at sharpening and noise reduction fro many camera. It is much improved over Lightroom 2.6
Correct me if I'm wrong, but the Lr 3 beta does not handle 1D4 raw files I'm guessing that support for new cameras will wait until the non-beta version is released.

- Alan


You're not exactly wrong. LR3 beta will accept any camera's file that's been converted to DNG. The latest release of Adobe DNG Converter supports the 1D4 files. They are noticeably better than in LR 2.6.

David
Feb 03, 2010 at 12:31 AM
David Manning
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
I'm no scientist, but I have a master's in a research rich field (Psychology). Given the three tests I've run, on two sets of files. I conclude that a) the Mark IV files are Noisier than the 5D's at ISO 3200 or b) LR3b likes the 5D files better or c) the profiles in LR3b are fully baked for the 5D. I have little to no desire to do further testing. Like I said earlier, for me, the images at ISO 8000 are easily usable, and under certain circumstances (B&W), I'd go MUCH higher. The luminance noise looks very film like.

David
Feb 03, 2010 at 12:38 AM
Tad Killian
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
I think one obvious point we are all missing here is to appreciate what a damn fine camera the 5D classic was and still is. It's impressive that almost 5 yr old technology is still hanging in there with the new kids on the block.

Diggity-biggity-bang +1
Feb 03, 2010 at 12:42 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Noise, Interpolation, and Comparison 101
32067dlm wrote:
I'm no scientist, but I have a master's in a research rich field (Psychology). Given the three tests I've run, on two sets of files. I conclude that a) the Mark IV files are Noisier than the 5D's at ISO 3200 or b) LR3b likes the 5D files better or c) the profiles in LR3b are fully baked for the 5D. I have little to no desire to do further testing. Like I said earlier, for me, the images at ISO 8000 are easily usable, and under certain circumstances (B&W), I'd go MUCH higher. The luminance noise looks very film
...Show more →

Thank you for sharing your samples David. Actualy, 1d4 noise profile is not bad at all while comparing its sensor density to 5D.
Feb 03, 2010 at 03:52 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister