fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2004 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2004Ultimate Bags Compilation

  
 
mt-m
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Ultimate Bags Compilation
I bought Domke F1X and exchanged it for the Tenba. Just didn't like the Domke at all. J1 and F2 were too small for my setup, F1x was too long.

Also, the top flap on Domke bag will keep you constantly wondering if your gear is exposed to the elements.

Tenba is more bulky, but I prefer it to Domke
Apr 29, 2004 at 10:20 AM
pierrot
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Ultimate Bags Compilation
Minh,
I just got got my Domke F3-X from Adorama last week. It is a really nice bag and I will try to put some pictures on this thread soon. Actually this bag is way bigger than it looks: I have stuffed my EOS 10D with 50mm 1,4 mounted, 85mm 1.2 + hood, 24mm 2.8 + hood, my old EOS 600 + 4-5 rolls of B&W film, Metz 54 MZ 3, Sekonic flashmeter, extra compactflash cards and spare batteries for everyone... And I could still fit some stuff in it. This bag looks like it has no bottom.

P.S. Do I have to register or do something special to be able to put pictures on a thread? I've never done it before...
Apr 29, 2004 at 10:23 AM
Minh Nguyen
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Ultimate Bags Compilation
Sounds great. I really want to get that bag but just not sure if it will fit my 10D and 28-135 attached and a few lenses.

You can register for image upload on FM (costs a bit) or upload them to another site (pbase) or your own server. PM me if you run into problems, I can host the image on my site for you.

Regards
Apr 29, 2004 at 10:37 AM
mt-m
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Ultimate Bags Compilation
One thing to keep in mind when shopping for a bag is intended use. If you plan to "shoot out of the bag" - open the bag, grab the camera, shoot - open again, change the lens, shoot, and so on, then manufacturer's descriptions of bag's capacity are next to useless.

According to Domke, you should be able to stuff three cameras with motordrives and quite a few lenses, flashes, etc in the F1X. It is true - as long as you only use it for storage during transport. I don't see how it would be possible to work out of this bag loaded to the gills.

I personally cannot work out of the bag with equipment stored at several layers.

Tenba says that P859 is supposed to take two bodies with motordrives AND lenses attached and FOUR extra lenses. Well - maybe they mean small lenses. Certainly not L lenses. And certainly not two Canon 1D bodies WITH lenses attached - just look at my pictures above. Now if I take the lenses off and pack everything very tight - it will probably take all the items specified, but it will not be a "open bag - grab the camera - shoot" setup.

Just my $.02
Apr 29, 2004 at 10:53 AM
Minh Nguyen
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Ultimate Bags Compilation
I totally agree with you. That's why I like Domke type bags as you can comfortably store one body and lens attached and perhaps, 2 to 5 other lens depending on model.

Besides, with shoulder type bags, if you pack it full, it will certainly be very heavy and hard to carry round all day.
Apr 29, 2004 at 12:19 PM
chris78cpr
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Ultimate Bags Compilation
Has any of you got a pic of how you stuff your nova 5 I just got one and am stumped on how to best set out the dividers!!!

Equipment needed to fit indide would be 10D with bged3/eos3/100-400/70-200F4L/1.4x/17-40/50 and either a 28-135 or a 20mm.

Chris
Apr 30, 2004 at 12:04 PM
bitweever
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Ultimate Bags Compilation
Does anyone else use Tamrac bags? I bought this one for my iBook a while back, and really liked it, so when I got my 300D, I bought a Velocity 7 bag from them.

I'll have to get some pictures of it over the weekend.
Apr 30, 2004 at 03:51 PM
unoriginalnick
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Ultimate Bags Compilation
Here's pictures of the Domke F2

I wrote a fairly comprehensive review on the bag here: http://www.jimadsonphotography.com/info/about_domke-f2.html

http://www.jimadsonphotography.com/info/domke_f2.jpg

http://www.jimadsonphotography.com/info/domke_f2-2.jpg

The short conclusion for those that don't want to read the review is that I think it's one of the best on-the-go bags you can get, it's wonderful to work out of, light, holds a fair amount of gear, ect. I had never seen the Tenba P859 before, but it looks to be about the same thing.
Apr 30, 2004 at 04:09 PM
Ed W
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Ultimate Bags Compilation
chris78cpr wrote:
Has any of you got a pic of how you stuff your nova 5 I just got one and am stumped on how to best set out the dividers!!!

Equipment needed to fit indide would be 10D with bged3/eos3/100-400/70-200F4L/1.4x/17-40/50 and either a 28-135 or a 20mm.

Chris


Chris,

I was using a Nova 5 before I bought a Mini Trekker. I managed to squeeze in a 10D & BG-ED3, EOS 30 & grip, 100-400, 20-35, 28-135, 550ex and a 50 f/1.8.

With the bag's cover opening away from me, I had the 10D on the far left. Bottom row, left to right - 100-400, 20-35 (50 on top), 550ex. Top Row, left to right, EOS 30, 28-135.

There was a noticeable bulge in the back from where the EOS 30 was sticking out (pushed out by the 100-400, I think).

Have fun stuffing all your gear into the bag!
Apr 30, 2004 at 04:13 PM
mt-m
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Ultimate Bags Compilation
Tenba P859 is larger and sturdier. There's more padding. F2 has really no padding at all where your A2 is. Tenba has padding all around, providing extra protection at the expense of comfort.

You'd feel MUCH more comfortable in a crowded street with the Domke than you would with Tenba. However, you can unzip the 4 sides and remove the padding, effectively turning the Tenba into a larger version of the Domke F2 with better weather seal.

One serious gripe I had with F2, F1X and J1 is the way the top lid closes - it is VERY easy to leave gaps at both ends of the bag, so in the rain you'd risk getting water in the main compartment. Tenba is much better in that regard. Otherwise Domke bags are excellent and quickly get that weathered look that makes you want pick up a pair of beat-up Nikon F2s on ebay and pretend to be a war journalist of the eighties

unoriginalnick wrote:
The short conclusion for those that don't want to read the review is that I think it's one of the best on-the-go bags you can get, it's wonderful to work out of, light, holds a fair amount of gear, ect. I had never seen the Tenba P859 before, but it looks to be about the same thing.

Apr 30, 2004 at 06:25 PM
unoriginalnick
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Ultimate Bags Compilation
Thanks for the comparison between the two. One of my favorite things about the F2 is the lack of padding, but the different top flap would be nice for weather issues. Of course it hardly ever rains where I live, so it's not so much an issue for me.
Apr 30, 2004 at 06:33 PM
dandill
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Ultimate Bags Compilation
I used the Orion AW for some fairly extensive treks over several weeks in the Swiss Alps. The bag itself worked very well, even preventing damage to my 10D kit when it got away from me on a very steep meadow.

I did find that in order for the lower part to be comfortable over long distances, the upper part was needed, to distribute the weight of the lower part from the hips to the shoulders. I found the lower part alone as a fanny pack workable but not so comfortable. However, around town, the lower part slung over the shoulder is turning out to be pretty convenient.

I hope this helps.

Dan
Apr 30, 2004 at 07:30 PM
grega
Offline
Details
p.3 #13Ultimate Bags Compilation
Currently I have black Tamrac expedition 5. I'm very surprised that it didn't get dirty and it looks like new after 2 years of daily use. It take it with me everywhere... to the mountains, when traveling...

There is just enough room in it for my gear, 1L of water and a sweater.

What I DON'T like about it is that
- I have to have my biggest lens attached to the Drebel all the time
- I have to put it of if I want to change lenses.

And that is why I want to get LOWEPRO TRIM TREKKER. That looks GREAT for my needs. Does anybody have it? Link to trim trekker

http://www.chondroworld.com/razno/torba2.jpg

http://www.chondroworld.com/razno/torba.jpg


May 02, 2004 at 03:28 AM
pierrot
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Ultimate Bags Compilation
Here are a few pics of my new Domke F3-X. I use this bag for indoor and street shooting. I think it is a very convienient bag and it does not scream "expensive photo gear". I really lik the tough build and the touch of the heavy duty canvas it is made of.
May 03, 2004 at 02:41 AM
Minh Nguyen
Offline
Details
p.3 #15Ultimate Bags Compilation
Thanks for the photo Pierre,

Do you think the F3X has enough padding at the bottom and on the sides? I'm just thinking if I should get the J3 because it has more protections.

Thanks
May 03, 2004 at 05:10 AM
pierrot
Offline
Details
p.3 #16Ultimate Bags Compilation
The padding on the bottom looks ok to me, but it is true that on the sides there is just the canvas... No problem as long as you don't bump you bag intor things. It might get annoying when you carry your stuff for a long time as you your equipment will start to "bite" your flesh after a while. There might be a solution with the removable inserts that you can buy separately. I have put a piece of a camping mattress along the side that rubs against my hip and it is ok so.
May 04, 2004 at 08:19 AM
KIDERAL
Offline
Details
p.3 #17Ultimate Bags Compilation
Ok, here;s the test.... I need to transport a 1d with a 400mm f2.8 usm is lens...
right now I have the Tenba P262... It holds the lens, but there is not much room for other stuff...


Any suggestions?
May 04, 2004 at 08:54 AM
picnic
Offline
Details
p.3 #18Ultimate Bags Compilation
I've gone through the whole bag thing--I have quite a few, none perfect, but some work better than others for various purposes. The ones I DO NOT use are the Lowepro Orion AW, the 75AW and an old Tamrac System 3 (smallish--bought, I believe, for the Oly E10). I also have the large Lowepro S & F belt with several lens cases--and there are times I do use that system--and its reasonably comfortable with the camera on an Optech strap slung over my back/chest with my hand in the wrist strap and hand on the grip. I use a Lowepro Magnum AW for commercial shooting, have a Delsey Gopix 90 backpack (doesn't have sternum strap or waist strap) for 'urban' shooting if I'm carrying several large zooms. I bought a discontinued Minitrekker (the same as the current Minitrekker AW without the allweather) that I use for hiking or carrying a good bit of equipment. I find that I can more easily carry the weight on my back, though less convenient than a shoulder bag. I was going to buy a Domke, etc. for an 'everyday' bag--but ended up buying a discontinued Nova 4 (cheap at $32)--very lightweight and I just wanted to carry the 10D/grip with a lens and perhaps 2 other lenses at times. This smallish light bag works well and is easier to get into than backpacks.

My question, however, is how others carry tripods. I would carry my big Bogen with a strap over my shoulder, but would not carry it hiking or otherwise long walking trips. I bought a lighter Bogen 3001 which I use with a 486 ballhead--not as light as a carbide, but nonetheless lighter and shorter than my normal one. I have just bought it and not hiked with it yet--but am wondering whether to add it to the back of my backpack (there are 'quick release' holders on the Minitrekker)--or to carry it slung over my shoulder with a strap--or does someone have a better method. (BTW, when I carry the big one for commercial work, its usually in my light bag--with 3 light stands, a number of umbrellas, etc. and the Magnum and a laptop are on a folding luggage carrier).

As far as I'm concerned, there is no easy answer for carrying a lot of equipment, so I have lightened up as much as possible--keep my lenses in bags on shelves and choose according to the day ahead--altho' I often keep that little Nova 4 with one of my bodies with the 28-135, a Sigma 20mm f/1.8 and the Sigma 15Mm FE all ready to go. For non-hiking, I just carry a tripod in hand.

Diane
May 04, 2004 at 11:07 AM
zepart949
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Ultimate Bags Compilation
Tubby wrote:
Here's my big ultimate honker (Lowepro Stealth Reporter 650 AW):

http://nvartech.smugmug.com/photos/2931594-L.jpg
http://nvartech.smugmug.com/photos/2931598-L.jpg
http://nvartech.smugmug.com/photos/2931596-L.jpg


Hey question...on your reporter 650, is it possable to remove the computer insert?
May 07, 2004 at 11:26 AM
askomiko
Offline
Details
p.3 #20Ultimate Bags Compilation
http://koti.mbnet.fi/~fisq/Kuvat/IMG_0234.jpg

Lowepro mini trekker. The tripod holder is great, as is the AW cover. (Which took a while to notice... It's well hidden. Feels good on the back, nice straps and padding. And enough small pockets.

Not enough lenses to fill it yet. :I

May 10, 2004 at 05:05 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister