#1 is superb. I used to do allot of spinning from similar rocky coast lines catching sea bass and this image took me right back and wished to climb into the picture. The colour is spot on the mood and the capture of the water movement cannot be faulted. It is all well having blur as water but it does not for me convey water at all. #1 does in this respect . Love it. I can even hear the waves roll on and off the rocks.
#2 yes blur as water that does end up looking like mist and not water . I understand why but too fanciful for myself. A bit like planet zog : )
Thanks for the comment. Number 1 is my favorite of the two for sure, number 2 was my first real attempt at a long exposure on the beach, and moving water. I thought I came out ok, but I can see why blurred water wouldn't be your thing. Thanks again for the comments.