fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2009 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 20095DII failures on LL Antarctic trip

  
 
Mike V
Offline
Details
p.8 #15DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
If I ran the boat that takes the photographers to Antarctica, I'd have camera bodies for sale in the bar.


Feb 07, 2009 at 09:07 PM
stanj
Offline
Details
p.8 #25DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
I had a 1Ds and a 300d in Antarctica in 2004 and even though a wave swept over our zodiac, no ill effects. I don't baby my gear either.

I had my 1Ds2 fail in way less harsh conditions the next year, and my 1Ds3 died 3x so far INDOOR use only. Go figure.
Feb 07, 2009 at 09:25 PM
thw2
Offline
Details
p.8 #35DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
maverick666 wrote:
Yeah I'm actually amazed at Nikon...never had any problems in their equipments...no complaints from their customers...at all.....zero defects. Mind boggling.....

Maybe if they ask you to do the QC things will be better...


They don't need to. They only have to ask Nikon management/engineers how they do it.
Feb 07, 2009 at 09:26 PM
maverick666
Offline
Details
p.8 #45DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
I think you didn't get my joke here....nevermind...

thw2 wrote:
maverick666 wroteYeah I'm actually amazed at Nikon...never had any problems in their equipments...no complaints from their customers...at all.....zero defects. Mind boggling.....

Maybe if they ask you to do the QC things will be better...
They don't need to. They only have to ask Nikon management/engineers how they do it.

Feb 07, 2009 at 09:35 PM
Alan Kefauver
Offline
Details
p.8 #55DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
I took my D60 rafting in the rain in Alaska and it worked fine. Pulled it out from under the poncho when I wanted to take a shot. Drenched it once from a big splash.
Took the D60 and left the 5D in the hotel room figuring if it (D60) failed it was really only worth about $200. I keep trying to make it fail so I can buy a 40D or 50D
Tried a 5DII and returned it. Not as solid as a 5D.
I think the D60 and the 5D are the best non 1 series cameras Canon has made. I don't print larger than 13X19. Great IQ on both.
Just my $0.03
Feb 07, 2009 at 10:34 PM
90 5.0
Offline
Details
p.8 #65DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Mike V wrote:
If I ran the boat that takes the photographers to Antarctica, I'd have camera bodies for sale in the bar.




You could have sold at least 6 D700's that day lol.

And on the earlier comment about canon comparing the 5d2 to the D300, that's odd since they are different type cams one being ff and one crop but anyway it is irrelevant since the D300 has decent weather resistance as well. In the wildlife forum there was a pic of one on a tripod being rained on a while back,


This has been the reason I have always stuck to nikon from my first film slr to now, Over the years there have always been things that made me want to switch like for instance the 1dmk3 and 400 5.6 would be a great combo for me shooting wildlife, but my friends mk3 had problems with it constantly

It's sad because they have so many great products but there quality control and reliability is always in question.

.



Feb 07, 2009 at 10:59 PM
bobbytan
Offline
Details
p.8 #75DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
RDKirk wrote:
Earlier quoteCanon has to bite the bullet and admit that many of the features of the D700 are what their customers want and should produce a 5D2/5D to match instead of assuming that everyone can afford a 1D series.
In the 5D2 White Paper, Canon compares the 5D2 to the D300, not the D700.


That's probably because when the 5D II white paper was prepared the D700 was non-existent.
Feb 07, 2009 at 11:31 PM
miccullen
Offline
Details
p.8 #85DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
mmurph wrote:
But, 1/2 the failures were intermittent. Which means the camera started working again, so only a shorter down time.

Ah, so if it only dies for 30 minutes, that's cool? And you don't know when it's going to do it again, but just plow on? No way.

The figures are horrible. Whatever the reasons for them, they're horrible. (And it's clearly not 'extreme' weather conditions that can be blamed.)
Feb 07, 2009 at 11:42 PM
wtlloyd
Offline
Details
p.8 #95DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Eh. All the comments about how horrible it is....it really isn't too important in the long run. Everybody on the trip had 2 or three cameras, and most also had a pocket cam and /or some other format than 35mm. There was no shortage of cameras. And the reason there was no shortage is because both Nikon and Canon users brought multiple bodies due to the possibility of failure. You'd be a fool to bring a single Nikon, thinking that statistically they rarely fail.

The 5D2 isn't a serious contender for being out in the rain in my opinion (I've only owned a 5D in truth), better weather seal does not mean weather proof. I consider it no better than the 40D/50D bodies in weather resistance.

My Canon failure experience: last summer a brand new !ds3 failed - Error99 - after 15 minutes in a light rain, while shooting off the Quebec coast. Probably 60 degree F temperature, no rain cover. It came back after drying out that night.

On this trip, in Antarctica, I shot with my 1D3, exposed, using flash and making lens changes, in a very cold steady rain. No problems in over 2 hours of solid shooting. Halfway through the trip, I severly cracked the rear LCD cover. I put some "Scotch" tape over the crack, and continued to use it without problems. My 40D, used in somewhat less wet conditions, no problems. In the past, I shot with a 1D2 I used to own, in a light rain, fully exposed, with no problems.

Seems the 1-series bodies held up pretty well. That's about what I expected. 5D2, not so much.

Feb 08, 2009 at 01:33 AM
digimies
Offline
Details
p.8 #105DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
jerrykur wrote:
Outside of this trip has anyone killed a 5D or 5DMK2 due to rain?

Anyone? The sample of this forum should be 10,000 bigger than a couple of
hours and 26 cameras in Antarctica. Or are you guys shooting for real at all

jerrykur wrote:
Outside of this trip has anyone killed a 5D or 5DMK2 due to rain? I shot
with my 5D in the pouring rain with no issues. I usually threw a trash bag
over the top but not protection much beyond that.

What is it about this trip that kills Canon cameras?


I'm wondering the same. This weekend I have been shooting here in Finland
(1.7C, 97% air humidity and drizzle now), like so many other similar days.

During rain I'm not swapping lenses, not bringing my camera from cold to
indoors uncovered, avoiding button controls if they have got wet and using
small Arena swimming towel (better than plastic as it effectively dries the
camera and it is 'breathing' material) over camera when there is drizzle ->
no problems after 100's of hours shooting in wet conditions with 5D and now
5DMKII.
Feb 08, 2009 at 02:12 AM
jaclarkaus
Offline
Details
p.8 #115DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Put it in perspective ...

http://www.luminous-landscape.com/essays/aa-07-worked.shtml

Seems last time they had a few failures as well

Quote...
About 85% of the trip's members were shooting with Canon gear, mostly 1Ds MKII. There were a couple of 1D MKII and 5D's, with several people having Rebel XT and XTi bodies as backups.

There were quite a few camera failures, most of them occasioned by our shooting in rain on the first day ashore in The Falklands. The rain was not heavy – more a persistent drizzle than a heavy rain, but it took its toll. In all, 90 minutes of wet shooting produced six 1Ds MKII cameras which stopped working for one reason or another. Three of them recovered after a night of drying out. Three remained hors de combat for the rest of the trip.

Three Canon 5D's died that day, with one subsequent recovery. Two Rebel XTi's lost their rear LCD's, though otherwise continued to work (which is a real hassle, because though one can keep shooting, there's no way to change any settings, or at least to know what the changes are).

Feb 08, 2009 at 02:16 AM
OzPic
Offline
Details
p.8 #125DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
When you go to Antartica you must and I say again must have a back up plan which means you need to take a second camera even if it is a mechanical film camera and if your back up camera is a film camera you must keep the film warm ,with so many people here on all forum boards that shoot sport many talk about their "back up camera" now with Antartica being such an extreme environment a back up camera is a must because you just never know.

Dean.
Feb 08, 2009 at 04:55 AM
brainiac
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #135DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
digimies wrote:
>>Outside of this trip has anyone killed a 5D or 5DMK2 due to rain?

>Anyone? The sample of this forum should be 10,000 bigger than a couple of
hours and 26 cameras in Antarctica. Or are you guys shooting for real at all


My sister killed her 5D by leaving it on the deck in a boat and it got a sloshing of sea water. Otherwise I know of several 5D mk1's which have been used in light rain, carefully, without problems.
Feb 08, 2009 at 07:23 AM
Chrono1081
Offline
Details
p.8 #145DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
All I have to say, and I'm sure its been said...

You are so freaking stupid if you take your gear out in the rain without proper protection then cry when its destroyed.

Raincapes and hoods folks....


Feb 08, 2009 at 07:41 AM
DaveEP
Offline
Details
p.8 #155DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Chrono1081 wrote:
All I have to say, and I'm sure its been said...
You are so freaking stupid if you take your gear out in the rain without proper protection then cry when its destroyed.
Raincapes and hoods folks....


And if you used this 'proper protection' in very light rain (or no rain) and it STILL died? That's what happened....
Feb 08, 2009 at 07:50 AM
jerrykur
Offline
Details
p.8 #165DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
wtlloyd wrote:
Seems the 1-series bodies held up pretty well. That's about what I expected. 5D2, not so much.



But, on the same trip in 2007 6 1DSMK2's died. So the 5DMK2s performed about the same as the 1DSMK2s. The question is why?
Feb 08, 2009 at 08:03 AM
brainiac
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #175DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
jerrykur wrote:
wtlloyd wroteSeems the 1-series bodies held up pretty well. That's about what I expected. 5D2, not so much.
But, on the same trip in 2007 6 1DSMK2's died. So the 5DMK2s performed about the same as the 1DSMK2s. The question is why?


Could it be because the Nikon users were tending to use Nikon's superb zooms, the Canon users favouring primes, and lens changing was allowing damp air inside the Canons more than the Nikons? Either that or Canon 'weather sealing' sucks.
Feb 08, 2009 at 08:16 AM
Andi Dietrich
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #185DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Maybe these Canon shooters used adapted Nikon zooms, so its not Canon's weather sealing but Nikon's that sucks
Feb 08, 2009 at 08:28 AM
jerrykur
Offline
Details
p.8 #195DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
Chrono1081 wrote:
All I have to say, and I'm sure its been said...

You are so freaking stupid if you take your gear out in the rain without proper protection then cry when its destroyed.

Raincapes and hoods folks....




Please read the original article. Several cameras of the effect cameras were in Kata rain sleeves and died in 90 minutes
Feb 08, 2009 at 08:51 AM
wtlloyd
Offline
Details
p.8 #205DII failures on LL Antarctic trip
There simply is no correlation to what people did regarding lens changes, and how they may or may not have protected their cameras w/ covers.

It just ain't there.

To repeat: I changed, in the rain, lens and extenders multiple times on my 1D3. No failure. Using a 1Ds3 9 months ago, no lens change, and Error99 came up.

This inability to pinpoint a vulnerability, a weak spot in the camera construction, is the true damning quality for Canon. It means you simply can't anticipate and avoid problems.

Roll the dice, folks.
Feb 08, 2009 at 10:42 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister