I was thinking about upgrading my XTi body to a 40d but my boyfriend has convinced me to get some good glass first, and worry about the body later. I'm just a hobbyist, but I have a lot to learn. You guys intimidate me here, but I figure you're also a wealth of knowledge.
That being said, I'm looking to replace my kit lens with a better "everyday" lens. I was thinking of going for the Tamron 17-50 2.8 to replace my 18-55. I know the range is similar, but I'm linking the 2.8 factor of the tamron.
Do you think this is a worthwhile trade? Any other recommendation? Thoughts? Thanks!
Edited to add: I shoot a lot of outdoors scenery, I live a mile from the beach and love to shoot down there, if that influences your answer in any way
Although this is the "alternative gear and lenses" forum, we're a bit weirder than merely a 3rd party AF zoom lens question ;-)
You're likely to get a better answer on the Canon forum. That said, I have heard a great deal of good things about the Tammy 17-50 and think it would serve you very well as a general go-to lens. The one time I shot a copy I was pleased by the results.
Do you live near a major city? If you do then look for the major local camera store (where the pros shop etc.) Quite often these stores will have a good selection of lenses behind the counter. Bring your camera and memory card. Shoot a few shots with different lenses in the store and out the door if they will let you. Also check if they have a rental counter. For like $20 or more you might be bale to rent a nice lens or two that you are considering. Then check the files on your computer and see what the images will tell you.
An expensive "L" series lens favored by a pro that shoots indoors might be a heavy, expensive overkill lens for you if you are shooting outdoor scenery. I guess the point I am making is try out lenses yourself if you can. Asking a bunch of photographers "which lens is best" can be like asking a group of blind people to touch an elephant and describe what they are touching: not always an accurate survey.
But in general: buy the best lens you can afford. Quite often new shooters will keep upgrading through a rapid series of lenses before hitting on the quality lens they could have purchased in the first place.
thank you both for the feedback. I know buying lenses is such a personal thing, but I was juts wondering if my thought process was accurate. It seems like if I decide on this lens it's good glass. Thanks for advice about renting it, I live in Los Angeles and there is bound to be somewhere that will rent lenses
The Tamron is a very good choice. I'd suggest going to Canoga Park and stopping
by Canoga Camera (a very highly recommended dealer) and trying the lens out.
Also, I sent you a Personal Message. Check your PM.
I've been using this lens for about a year. For a standard zoom it's a good choice. It's plenty sharp, but the bokeh is not the nicest, so for portraits its not so great. The lens is also very contrasty; a bit too much for landscapes to my liking, actually.
