First off, I am a longtime Canon shooter and I am very happy with my Canon gear. I didn’t have any issues with any of my gear, including the infamous 1D MarkIII. However, I just ventured into the Nikon world. Why? Well, I have been using the Nikkor 14-24mm since January with an adapter on my 1Ds MarkIII. It is a great lens but I am not happy with the adapter situation. I am using a borrowed adapter with AF confirming but the G lens doesn’t let me change the aperture that easily. I had to shim the lever at approximately f/11.0 and shot it like that. Plus the lens didn’t really sit rock solid because of the adapter. I placed an order for an adapter in January that would let me change the aperture by loosening the lens position on the mount to get it to stop down but I didn’t get that adapter even when the D700 became available in late July. I recently cancelled my order. In addition, to that 14-24mm I also own a 200mm f/2.0 VR that I traded for my 1Ds MarkII body with another FMer plus some cash from him; this happened in March. So, “getting stuck” with these two great Nikkor lenses and knowing how well they perform on my 1Ds MarkIII, I got the itch to use them on a native body and when the D700 became available, I pulled the trigger. I considered getting a D300 in April/June but I am glad I waited .
After familiarizing myself with a different user interface and feature setting, finally, I set out to take some real shots with the D700 and 200mm f/2.0 VR. Here are the first real images using a Nikon system. The lens is awesome, it is at least as good as the famed Canon 200mm f/1.8 but with a VR. I had a blast using this lens.
I really like and enjoy this camera; I am impressed with the build, the wealth of features and I just started discovering them. Yup, the virtual horizon is cool and the option of putting a grid on the viewfinder can come in handy. There is almost nothing not to like about the camera, well, here are my first and honest less “favorable” impressions:
1) The position of the multi selector to change AF points is a tad too low for may taste. I am waiting for the L-bracket (RRS or Kirk) to become available then I can use a hand strap for a better handling in this respect. On the other hand, the lower position of this will enable people that use the grip to use the multi selector to change AF points without difficulties. I am not planning to buy a grip for this camera to keep the weight and bulk down.
2) The mere fact that I have to push the selector up or down or side-way to change the AF point (I used a single AF point for this session), made it also a bit cumbersome to do the AF selection. Yes, a raised joystick is better and is more intuitive for this purpose. Especially, if you are trying to do it fast.
3) Maybe I am old-fashioned, but I would mind using manual focus lenses with AF confirmation. The wealth of MF lenses, Nikon’s own and Zeiss lenses is there for the picking. A friend of mine loaned me an AIs lens. If you are using this or other non-CPU lens for manual focus, you have to keep an eye on the in-focus indicator, which is located outside the frame and not at the actual point that you want to focus. The arrow to indicate the direction you need to turn the focus ring is nice. However, in addition to the lit in-focus indicator, it would be great to have the AF point lit when the focus is achieved. I am going over the manual again and again but have not found a possible setting for this. If somebody can point out to me, how to change that. I certainly appreciate that.
I am not a professional photographer. So, photography is only my hobby, well, more an obssesion for me actually. Yes, I am a gearhead . Whew, this is probably the longest post I have ever made on FM.
Nice images, well-done and executed. Interesting shape of her eyes, too, which you highlighted. How did you get the EXIF data formatted so nicely and neatly under the image?
Rodolfo, thank you! The good thing about the files, it took me about 45 minutes, less than hour to view about 90 images I took of her today, to select about 20 of them, process them, and make them ready for the web. The files are very easy to work on, very consistent in a lot of respects.
The EXIF information display is a new feature of FM. If you subscribe to the Image Upload, I see that you are subscriber as well, you can post up to 3 pictures with frame and you also can include the EXIF data displayed like that.
Great images Joshua! Too bad that they are all out of focus and too soft
Boy, those pictures are razor sharp!
You are right, it takes a little while to get used to the different user interface and control layout and can be a bit frustrating using two different camera systems. However after a while it became second nature to me and I like a lot of things better than on my previous Canon cameras. The 14-24 is another lens you will enjoy using on this camera.
Julius wrote:
Great images Joshua! Too bad that they are all out of focus and too soft
Boy, those pictures are razor sharp!
You are right, it takes a little while to get used to the different user interface and control layout and can be a bit frustrating using two different camera systems. However after a while it became second nature to me and I like a lot of things better than on my previous Canon cameras. The 14-24 is another lens you will enjoy using on this camera.
Julius
Thank you very much, Julius! Yup, it is a matter of getting used to and a matter of preference. I will be using both platforms BTW as I would like to take advantage of the strength of each. Yes, the 14-24 is the main reason for this.
dminh01 wrote:
beautiful color
Thank you!
bobbytan wrote:
Hey Joshua - it was fun shooting with you yesterday.
Yup, that was fun. Let's do some more before too long then.
I prefer the 5D shots, but what's going on with the differences between skin and chest tones on the Nikon shots? Looks like a gold reflector or something.
I think I envy your shooting opportunities as much as your gear.
There is nothing wrong with having a foot on each side of the fence. Heck, there are more than just a Canon and a Nikon side. If you can afford good glass, the camera bodies will come and go in the digital age.
People are always going to compare stuff, it's our nature. I enjoyed your story about getting a Nikon 12-24 on your Canon mounts too.
AGeoJO wrote:
3) Maybe I am old-fashioned, but I would mind using manual focus lenses with AF confirmation. The wealth of MF lenses, Nikon’s own and Zeiss lenses is there for the picking. A friend of mine loaned me an AIs lens. If you are using this or other non-CPU lens for manual focus, you have to keep an eye on the in-focus indicator, which is located outside the frame and not at the actual point that you want to focus. The arrow to indicate the direction you need to turn the focus ring is nice. However, in addition to the lit in-focus indicator, it would be great to have the AF point lit when the focus is achieved. I am going over the manual again and again but have not found a possible setting for this. If somebody can point out to me, how to change that. I certainly appreciate that....Show more →
Thanks for sharing your thoughts and explaining how MF lenses work on the D700!
How did you find the screen for manual focus? Is it contrasty enough, and are the tolerances tight enough, to allow for accurate manual focus? One other question, the D700 screen isn't interchangeable, is it?
Do CPU'd MF lenses (Voigtlander comes to mind) blink up the AF points?
Excellent images from both cameras. We can blame the 5D in some areas but not in sharpness. It performs very nicely and the 24-70 Canon is a great lens although in my humble opinion the Nikon counterpart is even better. I would be very happy with either one.
The 200mm VR Nikkor is also a great lens. I have seen several images from the D700 with 24-70 f2.8 combo and I tell you that both are a killer.
I found all pictures excellent although I now understand why that hard spot on her face.
No matter how you cut it, the larger sensor offers better all around quality.
William Rodriguez
Miami, Florida.
Thank you for your thoughts, feedback and inputs, guys.
Steven, the screen of the D700 is fine but it is not designed to be used for manual focusing. At my age, I would trust my ability to manually focus without any assist , especially on a session like this. For landscap, camera on a tripod, that's a different story and yes, there is that Liveview feature. The focusing screen is not user-interchangeable. Brightscreen offers to install their screen that has splitt image or microsprisms. I heard/read a lot of positive vibes but I am not familiar how that exchange works. In addition, I am not sure whether this might void the warranty or not. If the aperture of the lens is larger than f/5.6, yes, the in-focus indicator will lit.
Well Joshua, you certainly started into the nikon system with some nice gear.I wonder how you'll transition between the Canon and Nikon as you go. Don't forget to download the latest picture controls from Nikon (landscape and portrait). Nothing you probably couldn't already do, but it's very convenient.
AGeoJO wrote:
Steven, the screen of the D700 is fine but it is not designed to be used for manual focusing. At my age, I would trust my ability to manually focus without any assist , especially on a session like this. For landscap, camera on a tripod, that's a different story and yes, there is that Liveview feature. The focusing screen is not user-interchangeable. Brightscreen offers to install their screen that has splitt image or microsprisms. I heard/read a lot of positive vibes but I am not familiar how that exchange works. In addition, I am not sure whether this might void the warranty or not. If the aperture of the lens is larger than f/5.6, yes, the in-focus indicator will lit. ...Show more →
Thanks, Joshua. I use mainly alternative lenses on my 5D, and if I move to the D700, then I'll want to use all those older non-CPU'd Nikkors and of course ZF lenses, in which case the quality of the matte screen will be of crucial importance.
If you have experience with the 5D, would you say the D700 stock screen is about the same in terms of isolating focus? The Ee-S is certainly better than the stock 5D screen, but if the D700 is somewhere in between the 5D stock screen and the Ee-S, then I'm sure I'll be satisfied.
Steven,
Twice, first in my original post and second in my response to you, I left out the word "not". To clarify, what I meant to say in the second one is "At my age, I would not trust..... ". I had the 5D for a short while and based on my recollection, the screen on the D700 might be a tad brighter and therefore better in isolating focus. I played with two manual lenses yesterday, Zeiss ZF 100mm f/2.0 macro and Nikkor AIS 35mm f/1.4. Using the Zeiss, due to the inherent shallow DOF, manual focusing works just fine. Contrasty objects snap into focus clearly. Again, the in-focus indicator, which is located on the bottom panel about 1/3 way from the left edge, BTW, works great and in a assuring way. My gripe is, Nikon should also enable the actual AF point to light up as an additional in-focus indicator for a more logical operation. The way it is right now, your eye has to go back and forth, to check the focus accuracy using the in-focus indicator outside the frame and back to the viewfinder itself for composition. Not a deal breaker, just less convenient.
BTW, you can program in the focal length and the maximum aperture of up to 10 non-CPU lenses in the camera. Faster lenses, up to f/5.6, will enable that electronic rangefinder in-focus indicator feature. Hey, it is there and it works great, you might as well use it. The camera will give you not only the shutter speed but also the aperture used for the capture. A plus since that option is not available if you use non-Canon lenses on a Canon body. Remember? However, you have to remember to change the setting, each time you change a lens. Otherwise, it would take on the existing setting. If you have 10 non-CPU lenses programmed in the camera, operationwise it can be confusing....
Nik,
Thank you for your post. I will be using both platforms. I have "invested" plenty in Canon gear and as I mentioned in my original post, I am actually happy with it. I intend to get the most out of each system. I will look into the picture control you mentioned.
Joshua, first, yes, I figured you meant "not" in your message. Your answers to my questions have been most kind and very helpful! It's funny that you mention the ZF 100/2 and Ai-S 35/1.4; they're exactly what I want to use for the first while after getting the D700! If you've got some sample shots, I'd love to see them! By the way, my impression of the D700 VF sounds the same as yours. I also felt it to a tad brighter than that of the 5D.
I agree that it would be nice to have the AF indicators light up with non-CPU'd lenses, and my decision between the ZF 50/1.4 and Voigtlander 58/1.4 might be a lot easier now because the 58/1.4 is a CPU'd lens. For programming the lenses into the camera, can the lenses be named? Or is it a case of "lens 1", "lens 2", etc?
One again, thanks for the info. I have the ZF 100/2 already and use it with an adapter on my 5D, so I can also attest to its unrivalled sharpness from wide open. It truly is an amazing optic. I didn't know the 35/1.4 was close range corrected. I unfortunately missed a "brand new" one at a shop today. They had already sold it by the time I decided to get it. Bummer.
I've just downloaded the D700 manual (something I should have done from the beginning) and will have a read through it. I'll be back with more questions if I have any. Thanks again.
very nice pictures... might I agree that the 5d definitely looks sharper at these low ISOs, and also has a more pleasing color rendition. But the D3/D700 sensor rocks out at high ISOs.
orangefirefish wrote:
very nice pictures... might I agree that the 5d definitely looks sharper at these low ISOs, and also has a more pleasing color rendition. But the D3/D700 sensor rocks out at high ISOs.
The differences we're seeing in terms of colour and sharpness are most certainly due to differences in capture settings and post processing, and I think it would hasty and unfair to judge the performance of the two cameras from the samples we're seeing in this thread.