Nikon has had my brand spanking new 70-200 VR for over a month now, it was delivered around the 15th of february and showed up in their system on the 22nd. I delivered it with a detailed description of the problem and printed photos showing the problem.
The lens was listed as a B1 repair (adjustment, parts replaced) for bad focus, soft on right side; and eventually was listed as in "Billing". All seemed well.
On the 10th of March I e-mailed them asking if there was anything else I needed to do as my lens had been listed as billing for a little over a week now. They e-mailed me back and said my lens was in the quality control labs and after testing it would be sent back to me.
On the 20th I called and talked to Sean who said my lens should be done and didn't know why it hadn't shipped out. He would put in for an overnight shipment to me and I put in a request for a phone call once someone had put their hands on my lens.
Today (21st of March) I received the following e-mail:
--------
Hello,
Thank you for contacting Nikon Service Relations. We have a technician looking at your lens, they were inquiring as to what you mean by 'Hitch' Also they would like to have the camera here to test with. We can ship this out to you today, however it will be shipped as no problems found. Please let me know how you wish to procede.
Mike G.
Nikon Service Relations.
------------
WTF?!?! I replied:
-------------
I'm not sure I've ever used the word "hitch" in any of my
descriptions. The lens was previously listed as being 'in shop' for a
B1 level service repair for being soft on the right side of the frame.
I also included photos with the lens when I sent it to Nikon
demonstrating the problem which is most apparent at 135mm and all the
way up to 200mm as taken on a D300. It was also apparent on a D70 and
a D2x.
Has the lens been serviced at this point or not? According to the
website the lens has already been in the shop and repaired. If the
lens has not been serviced after being in Nikon's possession for a
month I'd really like an explanation for that and why my repair
statues listed it as 'in shop for a minor repair ; moderate parts
replaced' I would appreciate a telephone call at xxx-xxx-xxxx
----------------
I feel your pain. My 200-400/f4 was in for the 2nd time. The 1st time, it was for back-focus, which they adjusted. Only they adjusted it too much and now it was all front-focused. So I sent it back (they were very good about taking care of expedited shipping), but then I see on the website the status was
• TO GWO
• NO PROBLEM FOUND NO REDO
• FRONT FOCUS ISSUES. SEE LETTER
so I called and talked to (Sean, I think) and asked "What do you mean no problem!?" He tried to track it down and have me talk to the tech that reported it as such, hoping to get to it before it was shipped, but alas, it showed up on my door step this morning... shipped overnight, apparantly.
I'm at work, but will be redoing my tests tonight to if anything has changed.
Sorry Jammy... The only consolation I have is that if a lens goes in for a 3rd time, it automatically goes across a supervisors desk. Nikon support does seem really good on the phone about sending you a mailing label for a re-repair. It just sucks that it might take that many times to get the issue fixed.
Oh, and when my lens was checked in after they received, it also was listed with a status of "B2 MAJOR PARTS REPLACED". I think that is an initial estimate of what the repair might be based on the description of the problem... not the after-the-fact status of what actually was done... so in your case it might be the same type of deal... they just sat on it in the shop after the initial checkin.
Call and say that you need to speak to a manager immediatly. you may be on hold for a while, but explain the situation and they will work very hard to fix it and they may even do it for free.
Last summer I sent my D2H in and they lost it and sent it back un-repaired (well, in all fairness I sent it in for a focus re-calibration and the service bulletin fix, they only did the service bulletin fix), then tried to charge me again when I sent it in a few months ago, I called and talked to a manager after getting the run around, and it was fixed and back in my hands within 5 days.
Service today is a crap-shoot from any of the camera and/or lens suppliers. Some people get lucky and a lot get the same treatment you got. It makes you want to reach out and grab the "service" rep by the throat and squeeze very, very hard until his face turns a deep bluish-purple. All you can do is keep on trying to go high enough on their food chain that you finally get to talk to someone who cares. Always be polite but firm and unyielding until you get satisfaction.
I just spent an hour on the phone with a very nice Joe, Apparently service techs don't see images you send with your lens or maybe even read the description of the problem. How ridiculous is that? He apparently forwarded the test images to the techs...
Joe made note that I tested the lens with multiple bodies and all my other lenses work fine on the D300. They were asking me to send the body in for testing as well, that got a good laugh out of me. Yeah sure, after you've had the lens for a month I'd be happy to just send a body in as well.
Apparently they'll be retesting the lens and if I don't hear from them by Wed I'm supposed to give them a call. Looks like I might be renting yet another 70-200 for a wedding on Sat.
Anyone interested in a "within specification" 70-200 VR. I sell it to you really cheap.
Dont really want to make things worse, but when it comes back i would be checking the serial number.
To me that level of incompetance could involve even greater failings within their system
Fingers crossed for You
Tim
Tim Ashton wrote:
Dont really want to make things worse, but when it comes back i would be checking the serial number.
To me that level of incompetance could involve even greater failings within their system
Fingers crossed for You
Tim
Rest assured I'll be checking the serial. Hell I'd be happy if they just sent me a new lens.
The thing is, no one can account for what happened to the lens between the 22nd of February and when I asked about it on the 10th of March. There is no paper trail before that!
His response was, "Yah that is strange." Perhaps some lens fairies fixed it between those dates and didn't fill out the paper work.
My 70-200 was at Nikon for over a month as well. They were waiting for a part, which I guess had to be shipped from Japan. But I did find them to be very responsive to my calls and they did call me back several times. And while they initially wanted to charge me for the 70-200 repair claiming "it took a hit", when I challenged them they backed down and did it gratis. I did pay (at the same time) for an out-of-warranty D200 repair. I'm not sure the D200 was really broken, but it did come back in far better condition than when it was new. They must have aligned it.
I certainly would ignore the advice to raise hell. I've always found them to be responsive. I would assume the technician got his issues mixed up. Hope you don't to wait as long as Zoe.
I have been to Melville. Nikon's building is moderate in size. The repair facility seems to be a little hole in the wall in the basement. Even if it took up the whole basement, it couldn't be to big. They cover 1/2 of the repairs in the country. Need I say more. This speaks to their commitment, IMHO it dosen't say much. Having to speak to El Segundo, to have them call Melville is crazy. Jammy you are right, their flow of info with the end user is cr***. Their whole system needs an update, and a lot more staff. The new facility in El Segundo, I have heard good stories about it, but Nikon repair has a long way to go.