matsuib wrote:
As time goes by, I'm guessing that Canon might just not mention anything further, do a silent improvement in the newly released bodies, swap cameras out for the major organizations with large orders that complain, and let the rest of the world pound sand for awhile and only offer replacements to the most persistent and problematic customers. Blue dot can just be their gold standard, even if it's more like bronze or whatever.
Two recalls would seem pretty extraordinary (unless, as others mentioned, it was firmware, which a lot of people, including me, doubt).
I absolutely agree with your assessment of Canon letting most of us pound sand and I highly doubt another recall. To me, it just doesn't make any sense to use the capital resources (human & fabrication/mfg) that way.
Unless it really is a firmware update, another required "fix" should mean the writing is on the wall for the 1D3. Nikon's release (which trumps the 1D3 IMO) and Sony's forthcoming release, will change the landscape (assuming the Sony is any good). Canon's best bet would be to simply fix the problem internally (from an engineering/understanding perspective) and then replace the camera while incorporating the new technology in the next model (I'm hopeful it would be FF). This strategy eliminates more recalls, wasting engineering effort on a "failed" camera, and moves them forward. It might be their cheapest alternative.
The "1D Mark V" * press would/could be positive - assuming they can satisfactorily demonstrate a problem free AF. The 1D3 'problems" would be a thing of the past with no fix/repair required from an engineering point, effectively sweeping the whole thing under the rug. At some points, all companies have to bury their dead and move forward. It's time for canon to do the same.
* Mark IV is highly unlikely as Asian cultures don't like the number 4.
Edited on Feb 10, 2008 at 12:02 PM