OK. I give up. Nothing will get their attention more than being served with an actual lawsuit (which you would accomplish by filling out a form at the small claims division of your courthouse stating what happened and mailing it to the sheriff of the town where the registered agent is located for service) and having to contemplate hiring a lawyer at a price far in excess of the lens value. Corporations are not allowed to represent themselves so they have to hire a lawyer. Because of this Canon would be likely to contact you and see what could be done to avoid that situation.
John Power wrote:
Nothing will get their attention more than being served with an actual lawsuit (which you would accomplish by filling out a form at the small claims division of your courthouse stating what happened and mailing it to the sheriff of the town where the registered agent is located for service) and having to contemplate hiring a lawyer at a price far in excess of the lens value. Corporations are not allowed to represent themselves so they have to hire a lawyer. Because of this Canon would be likely to contact you and see what could be done to avoid that situation....Show more →
Good advice also. But even small claims lawsuits are a bother for the victim too. Which is why David Estes advice to pursue a couple of calm, formal letters first, making the formal demand for the original lens or better, is the preliminary route.
If (and only if) Canon does not resolve it at that level, then the victim can with great weight say to the judge, "Your honor, I made a calm and reasoned attempt to retrieve my lens and this is documented by this letter. The professional quality and value of my lens are documented by these prints and independent assessments. I ask that you rule that Canon make me whole by providing a lens of the same model of identical or higher quality, or a modern lens of equal or higher quality. Such a lens would be a new 24-70 mm f/2.8 L from their professional line, documented here, and not any consumer grade lens."
I am not a lawyer, but it seems to me that the reason lawyers write formal demand letters on the behalf of their clients is to lay the groundwork for a suit if the demand fails. You do not need a lawyer to write the actual demand letter, but by writing it, your demand (attempt at resolution) is documented. Send by certified, return receipt mail so they are formally on record as having received it. Send a copy (clearly marked "copy") by ordinary mail to their legal department. You don't even have to know the exact designation, just address it to "Legal Department" at Canon USA's head office. You can be sure that a lawyer there will be on the phone immediately to the service center enquiring why your lens or a new equivalent wasn't sent yesterday.
As others have pointed out, writing to the Better Business Bureau and such is sending a mosquito to fight the elephant. I think John Power is right. At this point nothing will get results like a lawsuit or a threat of a lawsuit, but you shouldn't actually threaten a lawsuit; the threat must be hidden and implicit in the simple, direct, clear, determined, no-nonsense tone of the demand letter. You can even begin it "This is a formal demand for the return of my lens or one with equal performance. I formally reject the offer of the lesser performing and lesser value consumer grade lens. ... "
A demand letter might work if, as I have said, it is mailed directly to the CEO of the USA division so it drifts down rather than up. My fee for a service like this would be about $150-$200 so dcains has a rough idea as to what it would cost.
AJ Nadershahi wrote:
Maybe we should bring this to the attention of Chuck Westfall and see what kind of spin he can put on it.
Yeah, that wasn't nice of me.
You know, if you want to explore the letter-writing route, you might as well copy Chuck on the message as well. Can't hurt... all it takes is one person above the tech support guys to get the ball rolling. He's answered enough silly questions in his tech tips column that it's obvious he reads everything he gets. If you can't find his email address, his column is here: http://www.digitaljournalist.org/issue0802/tech-tips.html
Good luck, Dean. Canon did royally shaft you here. I don't think anyone would think any less of you if you temporarily suspended the "do no harm" thing.
Stay tuned, as this may be resolved today. I've found a sympathetic "customer liaison" at one of Canon's customer service offices in VA, and he claims to have the authority to get a replacement 24-70L sent. FWIW, he's at the same level as Roderick (out on vacation until Wednesday), and so far his efforts seem genuine. We'll see . . .
Even with a positive outcome, Canon higher-ups are going to see my documentation of this fiasco.
dcains wrote:
FWIW, he's at the same level as Roderick (out on vacation until Wednesday), and so far his efforts seem genuine. We'll see . . .
Sound's like the trick is to get this resolved and have your lens back in your hands before Wed. so this Roderick fellow can't come back into the loop and muck things up. Good luck!
BenV wrote:
buy a 24-70 from a local camera shop, then return it when u get back, and just pay the restocking fee, lol
And what if you're the next person to buy that lens, and see that it has been used, then demand another copy because it is a "used" lens. I fail to see how screwing over a camera shop is going to solve the problem.
dcains wrote:
Stay tuned, as this may be resolved today. I've found a sympathetic "customer liaison" at one of Canon's customer service offices in VA, and he claims to have the authority to get a replacement 24-70L sent. FWIW, he's at the same level as Roderick (out on vacation until Wednesday), and so far his efforts seem genuine. We'll see . . .
Even with a positive outcome, Canon higher-ups are going to see my documentation of this fiasco.
Hopefully things work out as they should, considering they broke your lens.
I think the moral of this story is that we should obsess about our gear less and concentrate more on doing our part in making an image. Well, at least I know I should...
Looks like Canon has a 28-70L in a warehouse somewhere, and the new rep assisting me (Ivan) is waiting for confirmation of its availability, otherwise he said they have plenty of 24-70L's available. All would be refurbs with a 6-month warranty, and I'd be happy with either alternative. Nice to finally have someone thoughtful on the case, and I'm hoping this will all be over by the end of the week. Funny how still no one at the service center has given a clear answer about what happened to my 28-70L, so I can only guess it was damaged or has gone missing.
"Funny how still no one at the service center has given a clear answer about what happened to my 28-70L, so I can only guess it was damaged or has gone missing."
I would be very polite to Ivan, but I would still follow up on what happened to your lens.
The $110 will likely be refunded, although I wouldn't be upset if it wasn't. I sent my lens in for service, and as long as I get a 28-70L or 24-70L which works properly, I'm back where I wanted to be in the first place.
Ivan seems to be a genuinely nice guy, and he's been very helpful, but I think he's feeling a bit threatened at this point and wants this over as quickly as I do. It's apparent that Canon has been 100% at fault, and things could have been handled much better on their part. They'll hear about it in a letter, but otherwise, when the replacement lens is in-hand and checked out, I'm done with this. Maybe I'll just print this thread and send it to them
dcains wrote:
Ivan seems to be a genuinely nice guy, and he's been very helpful, but I think he's feeling a bit threatened at this point and wants this over as quickly as I do.
It is almost certain that Canon USA or Canon Inc. (Japan) scans fora like this one and they may have noticed this thread already.
Monito wrote:
It is almost certain that Canon USA or Canon Inc. (Japan) scans fora like this one and they may have noticed this thread already.
I tend to agree. Roderick's 'vacation' probably means he's been taken off the case and Ivan has been instructed to get it settled to Dean's satisfaction ASAP without further damage.
I might have to drive to NJ if it were me and once there have a sit in. Those are these things we use to do in the early 70's. I am not leaving until I have my lens back or a new one to replace it. You did say you were a nurse right? Find the original guy that was trying to screw you and offer him a prostate exam with a 400f/2.8 IS Lens. Be sure to use no Vaseline at all. Just a horrible story, horrible. Hope things work out for you!!
dcains wrote:
The $110 will likely be refunded, although I wouldn't be upset if it wasn't. I sent my lens in for service, and as long as I get a 28-70L or 24-70L which works properly, I'm back where I wanted to be in the first place.
Ivan seems to be a genuinely nice guy, and he's been very helpful, but I think he's feeling a bit threatened at this point and wants this over as quickly as I do. It's apparent that Canon has been 100% at fault, and things could have been handled much better on their part. They'll hear about it in a letter, but otherwise, when the replacement lens is in-hand and checked out, I'm done with this. Maybe I'll just print this thread and send it to them ...Show more →
Dean,
I have been following this thread from the start I think Forwarding this thread their way, as long as it gets to the correct brass, it is the best so far!! You have been very patient with Canon NJ, and most of all a wonderful, loyal customer to Canon USA.
Good luck, please, I think we all want to hear a go end to this sad start of sending a lens in to get fixed! Terry Bartick
And what this really proves is that the old adage about a happy customer only tells a few people about his experience while an unhappy person tells everyone is quite true..... Which in part colors our opinion of entities such as this - all we hear about is the bad cases (and don't get me wrong, this is absolutely a bad case.)
On the positive side, if you get a refurb (or new) I presume you will also get the warranty that comes with it......