fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2008 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2008A bird in the hand . . .

  
 
dcains
Offline

p.1 #1A bird in the hand . . .
Should I be laughing or crying? I'll tell you why. I've owned an absolutely amazing 28-70L for a few months now (bought here on FM), and after getting to know it well I thought maybe it was just the slightest bit soft at 70mm with apertures larger than f/4.5. Barely noticeable, really. So, anal dumbass that I am, I sent it off to Jamesburg for a tune-up on Jan 2, in anticipation of my pending 10-day trip to the Big Island (I leave tomorrow). First I'm told they'll take care of it for free, after all it is an L, and I'm a better than average customer. The next day, the price is now $110, which I still gladly paid with my AMEX card. Two weeks pass, and I ask what's become of my most favored lens. I'm told the lens will be back in my hands by Monday 1/21. I call on Monday, and now they're waiting for parts, "Call back Friday". On Friday I'm told the lens is unfixable, no parts available, and that it will be replaced with something of equal or greater value (my lens has a 2001 date code, btw). Fine, I say, and I'm waiting for my new 24-70L to arrive. I call again Tuesday 1/29, and I'm told my replacement lens isn't there yet, but to call back Thursday (today). After getting the runaround for about 40 minutes, I worked my way up the command chain to a factory rep named Nate, and he's happy to tell me my brand new 28-135 IS will be shipping shortly. I commended Nate on his little joke, and he says he's dead serious. I'm getting a $200 kit lens (or paperweight, perhaps) in exchange for my fabulous 28-70L and $110. After a bit of cursing, I'm now speaking to Roderick, some higher level supervisor, and he says he'll have to investigate and call me back. I just got the call, and he's sticking to the 28-135 IS deal. I told him his offer was an insult, and now I'll only accept either my unmolested 28-70L and $110 refund, or the new 24-70L and I'm done discussing the other deal. What's going on here? Anyone else think they F'ed up my lens and they're trying to screw me? Any ideas? Anyone know who else to call at Canon?

I hate for this posting to come off like a DPReview rant, but this is a 28-70L we're talking about, and I am in fact a very good customer of Canon's, all the way back to an A1 and lots of FD glass 30 years ago. Worst part is I sent in a lens that essentially had nothing wrong with it, thus the title of this posting.

Dean

Edited on Jan 31, 2008 at 11:36 AM
Jan 31, 2008 at 11:31 AM
thedigitalbean
Offline
Details
p.1 #2A bird in the hand . . .
yea, sounds like they screwed something up and are trying to screw you. Don't take it. Document everything and keep on them to provide you with one of your two stated options.
Jan 31, 2008 at 11:43 AM
Hrow
Offline
Details
p.1 #3A bird in the hand . . .
thedigitalbean wrote:
yea, sounds like they screwed something up and are trying to screw you. Don't take it. Document everything and keep on them to provide you with one of your two stated options.



This sounds like good advice to me, especially the part about documenting EVERYTHING because that's just insulting. There is something seriously amiss with Canon's service and attitude these days.
Jan 31, 2008 at 12:13 PM
jkurkjia
Offline
Details
p.1 #4A bird in the hand . . .
dcains wrote:
Should I be laughing or crying? I'll tell you why. I've owned an absolutely amazing 28-70L for a few months now (bought here on FM), and after getting to know it well I thought maybe it was just the slightest bit soft at 70mm with apertures larger than f/4.5. Barely noticeable, really. So, anal dumbass that I am, I sent it off to Jamesburg for a tune-up on Jan 2, in anticipation of my pending 10-day trip to the Big Island (I leave tomorrow). First I'm told they'll take care of it for free, after all it is an L,
...Show more →

Dean, sorry to hear of your incredible situation. IMO Canon should have no problem replacing your lens with a new one or actually fixing the d@mn thing. Problem is that lens has proven to problematic from the standpoint of AF and even a brand new lens may not be the equal of your old one (but at least a brand new one "should be" fixable).

The fact that they don't have parts seems like a very peculiar situation to me; maybe Canon is preparing to stop support of the lens and release a new model replacement.

Well, my fingers are crossed for you; hope you situation improves quickly. Have you considered talking to the supervisor's boss (if in your shoes this would be my next step)?

Regards,

Joe Kurkjian


Jan 31, 2008 at 12:28 PM
Duncan Gibson
Offline
Details
p.1 #5A bird in the hand . . .
This is unbelievable to me. Are they really offering to replace a lens that retails for more than $1000 with a lens that retails for less than $500? That makes no sense.
Jan 31, 2008 at 12:32 PM
Mark Peters
Offline
Details
p.1 #6A bird in the hand . . .
Just to play the contrarian for a moment.

The lens is out of warranty. Why would Canon be expected to fix it for free? I've never seen a label on my L lenses that they have a lifetime replacement guarantee.

As such, if they are unable to fix it, all I would expect you would receive is the lens back. I was with you right up to the part about it was unfixable and they would be sending you something of equal or greater value. Why would they have any obligation to replace your out or warranty lens?

Additionally, if they attempted to correct the problem and it is indeed unfixable, they are out the labor costs, thus I would not expect a refund of the labor costs either.

Again, all I would expect is a return of the lens and an explanation that it was unfixable. If they refunded the $110, that would be a bonus.





Jan 31, 2008 at 12:45 PM
jam51
Offline
Details
p.1 #7A bird in the hand . . .
Write the CEO of Canon USA and Canon Japan and cc the Better Business Bureau and your state's attorney general. Sony would not refund a $70 overcharge for software I did not receive on a laptop I bought. Sony apologetically called me within a week in response to the note I sent to Howard Stringer, CEO of Sony. Worth a try.
Jan 31, 2008 at 12:47 PM
ward1066
Offline
Details
p.1 #8A bird in the hand . . .
sounds like they broke it, hope they can at least send you something L quality.
Jan 31, 2008 at 01:07 PM
dcains
Offline
Details
p.1 #9A bird in the hand . . .
mjp734 wrote:
Just to play the contrarian for a moment.

The lens is out of warranty. Why would Canon be expected to fix it for free? I've never seen a label on my L lenses that they have a lifetime replacement guarantee.

As such, if they are unable to fix it, all I would expect you would receive is the lens back. I was with you right up to the part about it was unfixable and they would be sending you something of equal or greater value. Why would they have any obligation to replace your out or warranty lens?

Additionally, if they attempted to
...Show more →

I absolutely don't think for a minute they should fix this lens for free (I gladly paid the $110), but my suspicion is that the lens has somehow become damaged. There was nothing really wrong with the lens when I sent it in, autofocus or otherwise, except for the slightest softness using the largest apertures at 70mm. Canon offered to replace the lens, without any request on my part, but I would expect them to honor that offer at this point. My last conversation ended with my request to have my 28-70L sent back, assuming it's still intact, but as I said, I think they've damaged it somehow. If they broke it, they owe me a replacement, no question, and the 28-135 IS isn't going to do the trick, and from their initial offer, the 24-70L was the replacement mentioned.

I appreciate your points as the devil's advocate, but I'm just not seeing Canon's side to this issue, and the kit lens offered is truly an insult. At this point, I feel like a total idiot for even sending it to Canon, and I'd be most happy just to have it back in hand.
Jan 31, 2008 at 01:15 PM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.1 #10A bird in the hand . . .
Yup, they must have broken or lost your lens and now they are trying to procreate with ya.

I see two fair solution options here:
(1) Canon returns your 28-70 in the original condition + service cost refund. If that is not feasible, then....
(2) Canon replaces your lens with the 24-70, and no service cost refund.
Jan 31, 2008 at 01:21 PM
Xavier Rival
Offline
Details
p.1 #11A bird in the hand . . .
This story is absolutely incredible! I am not sure I would have expected a 24-70 replacement (even with added $$$ on your side), but the least you should get is to have your lens back in a shape no worse than when it left your home. Only litigious case would be, if the lens had been damaged during shipping (in that case, the carrier liability would be engaged).

One thing though:

On Friday I'm told the lens is unfixable, no parts available, and that it will be replaced with something of equal or greater value (my lens has a 2001 date code, btw). Fine, I say, and I'm waiting for my new 24-70L to arrive.

The term "value" may be considered subjective. If it is $$$ value, then if they assess a 7 years old 28-70 lens as 30 or 20% of the value of a new lens of the same type, then yes, it is not surprising to see them sending a 28-135. Now, if you refer to the "photographic value" of the lens (image quality, zoom range and wide aperture, build quality, etc), then only the 24-70 qualifies as a sound replacement.

Anyway, I hope you are going to get your 28-70 back, in the same (very usable) shape as it was before you sent it in.
Jan 31, 2008 at 01:32 PM
Karl Witt
Offline
Details
p.1 #12A bird in the hand . . .
I think Canon's original offering to fix it for free was a courtesy offer and probably figured it was a rather simple bench calibration, they did this for me on a 14yr old 400.
Perhaps the expected bench adj became more involved and required a part hence the $110 which you agreed to. Now the seemingly unfair part, your lens left in very good working condition needing only an 'anal' adjustment. It should be able to be returned to you in the same condition you sent it in perhaps less some type of diagnostic fee.
I would hope that you could make another call to Canon customer service and explain the series of events and be fortunate enough to get to talk to someone with much more authority that would actually investigate the entire event.
Simply put, I would agree that I would just expect my original lense sent back in the same working order as sent as if you denied the service to be performed, again less some type of bench service fee for trouble shooting the isssue.
This seems as frustrating as trying to talk sense to my local cable company!
I hope and think that there is someone within Canon that is going to do the right thing for you, your Canon equipment listing sure shows a lot of loyalty, I would hate to lose you as a 'happy' customer................
Karl
Jan 31, 2008 at 01:32 PM
Xavier Rival
Offline
Details
p.1 #13A bird in the hand . . .
Forgot to add: I think that at this point, the very first thing to find out is whether your lens is in a worse shape now than when you did send it or not, and to assess what "unfixable" means (I am thinking about further damage, possibly in the mail).
Jan 31, 2008 at 01:33 PM
joekraft
Offline
Details
p.1 #14A bird in the hand . . .
Nothing new to add, other than sorry to hear this. It's frustrating just to read.
Jan 31, 2008 at 01:35 PM
Mark Peters
Offline
Details
p.1 #15A bird in the hand . . .
If the item was damaged in their care, then I would agree with you that they need to make this right. And that to me is what needs to be determined. I would ask quite succinctly for them to explain exactly what has been done to the item, what condition it is in, and how it came to be in that condition. I would ask for one or more photographs of it to document it's condition.

I would then ask to whom I could speak to file a damage claim. I would also begin taking screen shots of every 28-70 offered in the B/S, e-bay, etc. to establish the replacement cost of the item. It would be cheaper for them however, to ship you a 24-70 which is the current equivalent that they produce, than to send you a check for your item.

An unsolicited offer to replace an out of warranty item is quite suspicious in my mind. They are not a charity, and this would make me suspect that they have somehow rendered the item unusable - or simply lost it in the process.


Jan 31, 2008 at 01:46 PM
dcains
Offline
Details
p.1 #16A bird in the hand . . .
I want my lens back, as it was before I sent it in, but I just have a gut feeling it's too late for that. They've been much too obtuse in not being able to tell me what state it's in, and that bothers me more than anything right now. How tough can it be to see if it's sitting on a shelf somewhere in their service department? The other issue is that I'm going to be out of communication range for the next 12 days, as Verizon (my cell provider) doesn't have coverage where I'll be, and Canon will only speak to me on the phone. I just told them to put all of this on hold until I'm back in Florida, because I'm afraid they'll send the 28-135, and delivery to my home will constitute settlement to this case. Even if I do get the 28-70L back in original condition, this experience will have left a very bad taste in my mouth, and Canon is going to have a very tough time getting my loyalty back. It's a real shame, because I've never thought twice about buying camera gear I've wanted, but I sure will now.

Edited on Jan 31, 2008 at 01:52 PM
Jan 31, 2008 at 01:51 PM
PetKal
Offline
Details
p.1 #17A bird in the hand . . .
Dean, one suggestion: once you've dealt with a couple of supervisors who are giving you a bit of a run around, it becomes productive to escalate the issue to the level of their director responsible for the service department.That way you'd be doing Canon a favour too because you are giving them a chance to address the problem right by an appropriate level of authority. In addition, that way a possible problem in their department may be identified to them....good managers generally like to know that sorta stuff.
Jan 31, 2008 at 02:05 PM
dcains
Offline
Details
p.1 #18A bird in the hand . . .
Oh, I agree 100%, but I've got to shut this down for now. I've got to get my gear packed, and take care of some things around the house before my trip. If I can, I'll try to compose an email on the first leg of my flight and shoot it to Canon in-between planes. After that, I've got to get myself in vacation mode, and worry about this in two weeks.
Jan 31, 2008 at 02:12 PM
rceres
Offline
Details
p.1 #19A bird in the hand . . .
When you give them your lens and they say hey, we'll adjust it for free - that's a verbal contract. When you agreed to pay $110 you modified the contract, but the basic agreement/understanding between the parties is the same. You give them a lens and $110 and they adjust it and give it back to you. They are now, any way you look at it, in violation of their end of the contract. I agree with CAM51 "Write the CEO of Canon USA and Canon Japan and cc the Better Business Bureau and your state's attorney general." I'll add that you should contact AMEX as well and dispute the charge. Might be worth one last call if you can get to a high enough level to tell them what you are about to do and give them one last chance to make this right.
Jan 31, 2008 at 02:23 PM
BenV
Offline
Details
p.1 #20A bird in the hand . . .
buy a 24-70 from a local camera shop, then return it when u get back, and just pay the restocking fee, lol
Jan 31, 2008 at 02:26 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister