I used a polarizing filter on my relatively new-ish Canon 70-200 F/4 for the first time today with my Digital Rebel and everything came out out of focus. It wasn't far enough out through the tiny little viewfinder so that I noticed (actually the one time I noticed I blamed it on the diopter) but looking them on the computer shows how off they were. It seems like the actual plane of focus ended up behind the auto-focus point. The camera/lens combo doesn't seem to have any focus issues once the filter is out of the picture. Thoughts on what might be going on?
A linear polarizer can interfere with AF. Be sure to use a circular polarizer. Also be sure there is enough light. Another possibility is that it is a cheap filter that degrades image quality.
It's supposed to be a circular filter. The brand is Crystal-Optics if that means anything. I don't remember it being all that cheap in cost. One other detail that I left out that might be important is that it's a 77mm thread filter with a 77-67 step down ring to attach it to the lens. Could it be possible that the auto-focus needs somehow the whole filter surface?
Crystal-Optics I've never heard of them in 30+ years. Try a B+W, a Heliopan or a high-end Hoya. Perhaps try a polarizer filter at the store to be sure there is not a len/body calibration issue.
Had a couple Crystal-Optics UV filters once upon a time. Bought them from "one of those NY outfits" (not B&H or Adorama) before I knew any better. Basically when I bought a lens I was asked if I wanted UV filters to go with them. I said yes, and Crystal-Optics was what I got. About the cheapest you could get was my impression, although the price wasn't the cheapest.
I would try to return it and get my money back, then order one of the brands EB-1 suggested.
As stated, you might have a linear polarizing filter as opposed to a CirPl. Do you still have the original packaging so as to be able to confirm that you indeed have a CirPl as opposed to a linear polarizing filter.
If you just bought it, as was suggested, consider taking it back for a better quality CirPl or at least for one that you're sure is a CirPl. Should make a difference.
Thanks. I bought it some time ago and it shows some wear, so I don't think I'll be able to return it, but that said, I'll probably try one of the other brands with someone with a return policy. We don't have any decent camera stores in the area, so it'll have to be online, which could be a pain, but oh well.
EB-1 wrote:
Crystal-Optics I've never heard of them in 30+ years. Try a B+W, a Heliopan or a high-end Hoya. Perhaps try a polarizer filter at the store to be sure there is not a len/body calibration issue.
EB
You must not look on ebay much. I've seen boatloads of Crystal-Optics stuff on there & it's the majority of the cheap junk sold there. I suspect that is the problem; like others have said, head over to maxsaver & buy a good B+W CPL.
There was a thread several months ago with a photographer having serious focus and contrast issues with his high quality lens. After several back and forth questions with other forum members, we discovered that he was using a cheap Quant** UV filter. Once he removed it the image quality improved immediately and dramatically.
If you are shooting subjects that you want to warm up a little I would suggest the Mooses Filter. It is a combination of a circular polarizer and an 81-A warming filter in one unit. Otherwise buy the highest end circular polarizer you can justify. Some very good suggestions were made above.
claudermilk wrote:
You must not look on ebay much. I've seen boatloads of Crystal-Optics stuff on there & it's the majority of the cheap junk sold there. I suspect that is the problem; like others have said, head over to maxsaver & buy a good B+W CPL.
No, I don't look on eBay for gear such as filters that can be purchased new at many retailers. I made some mistakes with mediocre filters in the late 70s then went with the name brands thereafter.
The worst filter I ever saw was a Cokin UV 67mm manufactured from plastic that contained small bubbles and was wavy. Talk about cheap junk guaranteed to distort an image! It made a foot thick Tiffen Protecto green-glass filter look good.
Yep, go for the B+W. I bought a 77mm B+W slim circular polarizer and it wasn't cheap, but the only problems I've ever had where when I forget to take off my sunglass before looking through the viewfinder.
If you have another polarizer or even some polarized sunglasses you can test to find out if it is only linear or has additional circular scrambling layer.