Choderboy wrote:
But then, of course, a 1.4TC can also be added to the 600.
arbitrage wroteWhen you add the 1.4TC to the 400 then the MM is identical at .25x.
You can add 2X to 400 without much diffraction then
If you shoot 800+ most of the time 600 may have an advantage.
I hope someone with both lenses will post at least a real life shot with 400+1.4x and 600 alone to prove or disprove above theory. Both should be pretty close in magnification if above theory is true. I'd like to see a subject that's around 30-50 ft.
I would assume adding 2xTC to 600 would not be worthwhile.
I also assume 2xTC to 400 would be a close call.
This with 50-68mp sensors.
With A9III, different story.
I don't use 600/4 with 2x, but have been meaning to try that with A9III.
Rare use case, but good to know before that case arises.
arbitrage wrote: Choderboy wroteBut then, of course, a 1.4TC can also be added to the 600.
arbitrage wroteWhen you add the 1.4TC to the 400 then the MM is identical at .25x.And then you can add a 2x to the 400.
And then you can add a 2x to the 600...but trust me, you don't want to....the image is worse than without it.
Several people have done that comparison but every test I have seen was near MFD.
I want to see comparison at more typical shooting distance.
Jemini wrote:
You can add 2X to 400 without much diffraction then
If you shoot 800+ most of the time 600 may have an advantage.
I hope someone with both lenses will post at least a real life shot with 400+1.4x and 600 alone to prove or disprove above theory. Both should be pretty close in magnification if above theory is true. I'd like to see a subject that's around 30-50 ft.
Jemini wrote: Choderboy wroteBut then, of course, a 1.4TC can also be added to the 600.
arbitrage wroteWhen you add the 1.4TC to the 400 then the MM is identical at .25x.You can add 2X to 400 without much diffraction then
If you shoot 800+ most of the time 600 may have an advantage.
I hope someone with both lenses will post at least a real life shot with 400+1.4x and 600 alone to prove or disprove above theory. Both should be pretty close in magnification if above theory is true. I'd like to see a subject that's around 30-50 ft.
both taken with setup on each shoulder to minimize changes in distance. uncropped images; pm with email address if you want raw files. I have no idea how far the subject is...Jemini did show me the steps...just haven't done it yet
ILCE-7RM6FE 600mm F6.3 GM OSS lens600mmf/6.31/4000s1250 ISO0.0 EV
Thang wrote: Jemini wroteChoderboy wroteBut then, of course, a 1.4TC can also be added to the 600.
arbitrage wroteWhen you add the 1.4TC to the 400 then the MM is identical at .25x.You can add 2X to 400 without much diffraction then
If you shoot 800+ most of the time 600 may have an advantage.
I hope someone with both lenses will post at least a real life shot with 400+1.4x and 600 alone to prove or disprove above theory. Both should be pretty close in magnification if above theory is true. I'd like to see a subject that's around 30-50 ft.both taken with setup on each shoulder to minimize changes in distance. uncropped images; pm with email address if you want raw files. I have no idea how far the subject is...Jemini did show me the steps...just haven't done it yet
Thank you Thang. So they are pretty close. I sent you PM for raw files. I can post distances once I receive raw files or OOC jpgs
Thang wrote: Jemini wroteThanks for the files Thang. The 600mm shot was at 10.63 meters and 560mm was at 10.33 meters. a foot apart according the ExifGuess I did lean in/out a bit on these shots
I guess a foot is not going to make much difference in magnification when the distance is 30 ft. This is the kind of average working distance for small/average sized birds IMO. Thanks for doing this Thang
In my experience distance info is not accurate.
I tested by refocusing on the same subject at about 20 metres.
It was lights in a pole so hard to lean up
EXIF showed significant variation.
Still, good test!
Thang wrote: Jemini wroteThanks for the files Thang. The 600mm shot was at 10.63 meters and 560mm was at 10.33 meters. a foot apart according the ExifGuess I did lean in/out a bit on these shots
Choderboy wrote:
In my experience distance info is not accurate.
I tested by refocusing on the same subject at about 20 metres.
It was lights in a pole so hard to lean up
EXIF showed significant variation.
Still, good test!
Thang wroteJemini wroteThanks for the files Thang. The 600mm shot was at 10.63 meters and 560mm was at 10.33 meters. a foot apart according the ExifGuess I did lean in/out a bit on these shots
It depends on camera+lens combo. Nikon cameras reports almost perfect distance. I haven't checked A1II for accuracy. But from exif I know it was close. I will check it with 400mm manually when I get a chance.