old-gregg wrote: EB-1 wroteSo it was easier not to rotate yourself, but then you were always cropping.When you rotate a truncated sensor, you're also cropping, but permanently, with no chance for correction afterwards. 1:1 is the correct aspect ratio. Has always been.
Apparently someone never learned how to compose through a good viewfinder.
Admittedly, you got both a portrait and landscape version of your image in a single frame with square. Today we take both if we want both, and don’t have to consciously “shoot loose” to get both as we often did back then.
But we all still love the Luddites! For you Gregg:
old-gregg wrote: EB-1 wroteSo it was easier not to rotate yourself, but then you were always cropping.When you rotate a truncated sensor, you're also cropping, but permanently, with no chance for correction afterwards. 1:1 is the correct aspect ratio. Has always been.
Not really. 1:1 (Square) maximizes the areal use of a given circle of coverage, but is not "correct" if that is not what is desired.
For example the circle of coverage (diagonal) for 24x36mm is about 43.3mm. That same circle of coverage will produce an ~30.6mm square image. If the subject matter is not suited to squares, then you are losing that 5.4mm of width.
The Hassle 6x6 lenses could have produced wider images than they did with an A16 back rather than just cropping down to 645.
Ultimately a round sensor would be best since it captures the full circle of coverage of the lens.
I believe there are or were some astro systems that used multiple square or rectangular sensors to approximate a circle.
Jack Flesher wrote:
But we all still love the Luddites! For you Gregg:
Hell yeah. Was it taken near the Turtle Rock in Marin? If yes, I have a few images of this tree.
@EB-1 No need to argue, I am not a fan of subjective arguments like "what's desired". Math and common sense do not care what anyone desires, they demand just one and only answer. The correct answer is the square because, as you correctly stated, it is the next most efficient after a circlular one. Everything else is just one's "pixel anxiety" which, in the age of modern pixel densities [1] and nobody printing anything, I will not take seriously.
[1] The 1:1 variant of the Sony A7RVI's sensor, assuming E-mount compatibility, would be 8,485x8,485px, don't tell me that's not enough for cropping.
old-gregg wrote: Jack Flesher wroteBut we all still love the Luddites! For you Gregg:Hell yeah. Was it taken near the Turtle Rock in Marin? If yes, I have a few images of this tree.
@EB-1@ No need to argue, I am not a fan of subjective arguments like "what's desired". Math and common sense do not care what anyone desires, they demand just one and only answer. The correct answer is the square because, as you correctly stated, it is the next most efficient after a circlular one. Everything else is just one's "pixel anxiety" which, in the age of modern pixel densities [1] and nobody printing anything, I will not take seriously.
[1] The 1:1 variant of the Sony A7RVI's sensor, assuming E-mount compatibility, would be 8,485×8,485px, don't tell me that's not enough for cropping....Show more →
No, that one was in Savana, GA IIRC. But now you've got me curious, where in Marin? It might almost be worth a trip up there! And now I can shoot it in digital!
Jack Flesher wrote:
No, that one was in Savana, GA IIRC. But now you've got me curious, where in Marin? It might almost be worth a trip up there! And now I can shoot it in digital!
robert614 wrote: Jack Flesher wroteWith IBIS and OSS so darn good nowadays, I shoot a lot more hand-held and hardly use the tripod. I also shoot vertical frequently, but at the same time historically have never bothered much changing my grip specifically for it either. Hence I'm in a bit of a quandary considering adding the grip base, and would appreciate comments from those who have used it. TIA.Traditionally, one of the reasons for buying a vertical grip has been extended battery life. But it seems like Sony’s new battery performs really well
So, unless you’re shooting extended periods in portrait orientation. Or you want the extra weight to balance out your telephoto setup. I don’t think it’s a must have. More of a nice to have
Personally, I have bought the VG for last three body generations. But I find I rarely used it. And sold them in near pristine condition when I upgraded bodies
Some guys are vertical grip people. I’ve found that I’m not really one of them ...Show more →
My experience, exactly! I purchased vertical grips for both my A1 II & A7RVI and have only used one of them, once. In the past, I have mostly used with big telephoto’s, but now use lighter lenses like the GM 300mm and don’t feel the need for the grip.
Also, at one time me I installed for portrait shooting but found that in the heat of shooting my muscle memory just had me reflexively tilting the camera 90 degrees and bending my wrist.
Only you can decide this for yourself. Above you find those that purchased the grip, expecting to like using it., but they don’t like the added weight and volume. Then there are those that reluctantly purchased it thinking to use it with larger, heavy lenses. That was my intent, but I have yet to remove the grip from the A7R6.