So is the only relevant Sigma F mount glass the Art stuff? Blakehfreeman wrote:
Buy the FL and enjoy the bargain. The FL is a lens that could be released in 2026 and would be tremendous.
JadedWriter wroteAnybody have any opinions on the Sigma 70-200 Sport? I'm always bouncing between buying that and rebuying the FL.
For indoor sports on a D3S, f/2.8 is not optional. It is the whole game. That rules out the f/4. Between the 2.8s, the VR2 is the sweet spot used. It is sharper than the VR1 wide open and much cheaper than the FL. The Tamron G2 is genuinely good and the VC is excellent. But the Nikon focuses a touch faster in bad gym light, and that matters for soccer. If money is tight, a clean VR1 still takes great photos. Most of the difference between these shows up at 100 percent crops, not in prints.
oliverwilliams wrote:
For indoor sports on a D3S, f/2.8 is not optional. It is the whole game. That rules out the f/4. Between the 2.8s, the VR2 is the sweet spot used. It is sharper than the VR1 wide open and much cheaper than the FL. The Tamron G2 is genuinely good and the VC is excellent. But the Nikon focuses a touch faster in bad gym light, and that matters for soccer. If money is tight, a clean VR1 still takes great photos. Most of the difference between these shows up at 100 percent crops, not in prints.
I think I've convinced myself that the FL is what my goal should be, but will keep an eye out for good deals on the VR2.
jonshonda wrote:
Thanks for helping me back off the 80-200 ledge guys. I saw a chance to buy and flip whilst possibly using the 80-200 2.8 whilst I wait for a deal on the FL. I reached out, and while the seller does have two batteries and a charger, no lens or camera body caps....which makes me think he may have procured it in an odd way?
I had the Tamron SP, assumed the Sigma was going to be an upgrade from that. I did not like the side switches on the Tamron though, they kept getting switched on and off with the camera at my side. I upgraded from an FL after that and at some point sold it thinking I'd never shoot DSLR again. freaklikeme wrote: JadedWriter wroteAnybody have any opinions on the Sigma 70-200 Sport? I'm always bouncing between buying that and rebuying the FL.Assuming we're talking F-mount, it's good and very competitive with the VR II. The last Tamron SP is a bit better and faster to focus, though.
I owned the VR2. The VR2 is no slouch, even today. I didn't have an issue with focus breathing, because I almost never had a subject closer than 3 meters from me. It's worth buying today. The optics are stellar. 100% recommend this lens if you rarely approach MFD. Avoid if you are going to do any focus stacking at all.
From the one time I used the VRI, it's the heaviest and longest of the lot. It looks like a telescope if the hood is on. This lens made me money, but it did not bring me joy due to the weight.
The FL, which I currently own, works flawlessly on the D700 that I also own. Hopefully that gives you some peace of mind, if you don't trust Nikon's spec sheet. The noticeable advantages are the reduced weight, no more focus breathing, and improved VR. If you plan to go on long hikes, shoot at distances less than 3m, or want to shoot consistently sharp pics 1/30 at 200mm, this is the lens for you. I also 100% recommend this lens.
I don't know what the prices are on any of these. I'm not in the market to buy or sell them as my next 70-200 will be Z mount, whenever I transition to mirrorless. I've never tried the Tamron or Sigma, but people seem to like them.
Unless your use case swings you one way or the other, you can't go wrong with either the VRII or the FL. To answer the question of "what's the consensus on f-mount 70-200s," the consensus is they're all respectable lenses. Turns out a lot of us are advanced amateurs or pros who investigate the limitations of the equipment. Which is a good thing because we can tell you all about them here