aCuria wrote: pdog109 wrotenmerc_photos wroteNot trash, just not nearly as good of value as the 400 4.5.
But yeah, nearly everyone I know who ordered the 600 6.3 either returned it or cancelled the order in favor of the 400 4.5.Oh yeah I agree, the trash comment was just in jest of the fact of all the 600 returns apparently based on test charts and 9mm difference. It seems there is no point to the 600s existence if 400+1.4x is the same. The 600 6.3 is still pretty awesome though as evidenced by the great images in this thread (not mine though, those are trash since I don't know how to shoot).
I don't care about saving money though, I paid $1000 extra to not carry 166 grams, I still have trauma from carrying 600f4 for 3 years. Compared to 400/4.5 + 1.4TC, the 600/6.3 seems to have lower CA, better edge performance, lower weight, better ergonomics. I suspect I would enjoy using the 600 more because the TC is unlikely to come off the 400/4.5
I would expect better edge performance, and also slightly better bokeh for the 600mm 6.3, better crop-ability for distant shots on a high res camera, and perhaps an overall slightly better 3 dimensional look to the images, in short: an absence of all the usual suspect hallmarks of an external TC.
For birding, where you will usually crop at least to aps-c size with a 400mm lens, these things may not matter all that much with exception perhaps of the better crop-ability on distant shots, and the 400mm bare seems a stunning lens to have when you need the extra light gathering more than the extra reach. The 300GM has been shown to produce some stunning images with the 1.4TXC at 420mm f4 that cannot be equalled at 600mm f5.6 (with 2xTC) in any way. No substitute for more light coming in.
The reviews comparing the 600/6.3 versus the 400/4.5 + 1.4TC are never going to be consistent, simply because the reviewers are testing brandnew copies of GM lenses and combining one (the 400) with an all purpose 1.4TC that they may have been using for years in all sorts of conditions, and I don't expect them all to have an optimal copy. If you have a very good sample of the 1.4TC, I assume that centre area sharpness is going to be on par, simply because the front 2/3 of both lenses is identical.
So far I've been impressed with the 600mm f6.3. Been shooting in really poor light the last few days (10k-20k ISO) and AF/IQ both seem really good considering. The weight is nice coming from the 300mm f2.8 + 2x tele, much easier for longer captures. I'll get the test charts out over the weekend and see how they compare, but the sharpness of the 600mm seems at least on par with, and possibly slightly better than the 300mm + 2x tele so far. More reliable AF also.
onimusha370 wrote:
So far I've been impressed with the 600mm f6.3. Been shooting in really poor light the last few days (10k-20k ISO) and AF/IQ both seem really good considering. The weight is nice coming from the 300mm f2.8 + 2x tele, much easier for longer captures. I'll get the test charts out over the weekend and see how they compare, but the sharpness of the 600mm seems at least on par with, and possibly slightly better than the 300mm + 2x tele so far. More reliable AF also.
Hard seeing all these great 600mm shots. Not a single Aussie store has it in stock I can find and it's been like that since a small initial batch hit our shores on release. Lens is discounted though by $600AU.
pdog109 wrote:
Took the holiday off and went up to New Mexico for some birding. Much easier to walk around all day with 600 6.3 lighter than a cloud.
Very nice captures! We likely crossed paths, I was up there this past Wednesday and left Friday afternoon when the rain rolled in.
I'm still working on shots to share, I'll post some soon. I couldn't believe the ponds being all but dry. I spoke with one of the team that works there and she mentioned they had a large infrastructure project that was delayed and kept them from filling up the ponds. They were just starting last week... I would imagine in the next couple of weeks they will be full. I shot with the 600 and 400-800 ... occasional TC as well. The 600 is a pleasure to use!
hatch1921 wrote: pdog109 wroteTook the holiday off and went up to New Mexico for some birding. Much easier to walk around all day with 600 6.3 lighter than a cloud.Very nice captures! We likely crossed paths, I was up there this past Wednesday and left Friday afternoon when the rain rolled in.
I'm still working on shots to share, I'll post some soon. I couldn't believe the ponds being all but dry. I spoke with one of the team that works there and she mentioned they had a large infrastructure project that was delayed and kept them from filling up the ponds. They were just starting last week... I would imagine in the next couple of weeks they will be full. I shot with the 600 and 400-800 ... occasional TC as well. The 600 is a pleasure to use!
Thanks! Aha nice, yeah I was out at Bosque on Thursday morning, under-dressed and cold! It was my first time there, I thought there would be more birds, makes sense though yeah not much water. I did get a lifer Ross's Goose though! I'll have to go back in a few weeks then, and bring more layers haha. A few years ago I was at Whitewater draw in AZ and there was so many Sandies out there making a huge racket you couldn't hear your self think!
pdog109 wrote: hatch1921 wrotepdog109 wroteTook the holiday off and went up to New Mexico for some birding. Much easier to walk around all day with 600 6.3 lighter than a cloud.Very nice captures! We likely crossed paths, I was up there this past Wednesday and left Friday afternoon when the rain rolled in.
I'm still working on shots to share, I'll post some soon. I couldn't believe the ponds being all but dry. I spoke with one of the team that works there and she mentioned they had a large infrastructure project that was delayed and kept them from filling up the ponds. They were just starting last week... I would imagine in the next couple of weeks they will be full. I shot with the 600 and 400-800 ... occasional TC as well. The 600 is a pleasure to use!
HatchThanks! Aha nice, yeah I was out at Bosque on Thursday morning, under-dressed and cold! It was my first time there, I thought there would be more birds, makes sense though yeah not much water. I did get a lifer Ross's Goose though! I'll have to go back in a few weeks then, and bring more layers haha. A few years ago I was at Whitewater draw in AZ and there was so many Sandies out there making a huge racket you couldn't hear your self think!
The lack of water didn't do us any favors but it's also a little early in the migration. December/January are typically great, it's really cold and the colors have faded but there's more wildlife to photograph. I would expect by the middle of December most of the ponds will have water in them. Another place to check out when you go back, north of Socorro there's Ladd S. Gordon's Water Foul Complex. It's a good place to photograph in the evening as the backdrop has the mountains to the east.
I've been out to White Water draw before, the water was low but there were plenty of birds to photograph.
Looks like you had a nice trip, there's always something to photograph there.
Pixel Perfect wrote:
Hard seeing all these great 600mm shots. Not a single Aussie store has it in stock I can find and it's been like that since a small initial batch hit our shores on release. Lens is discounted though by $600AU.
Just saw this posted on facebook 400 and 600 lightweight prime group:
If any Australians are interested in the 400 or 600, check out Camera House!. 400 which i just bought is A$3299.
Update!. Digidirect has just matched it and you receive a free 2X extender.