p.6 #1What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
EB-1 wrote:
The 500/4 IS II is still excellent on 45MP R5 II as it was on 50MP 5DsR in 2015. It holds up relly well to the 1.4x III, but the 2x III is not so great. I'm sure they could make a better, lighter 500/4, but nobody seems to like that FL.
EBH
I love that lens, small, sharp and easy to carry for 3-4 hours a day. Never did understand why the 500mm FL is not popular. But, it is a killer lens on the R5..
p.6 #6What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
jakelindsay wrote:
Apart from the Macro kings Sony 100mm F2.8 GM and M. Zuiko 90mm F 3.5 it would definitely be:
GF 45-100mm F4
I was excited to try the GF 45-100 f4 but was a little disappointed with it wide open on the GFX100S. Had a bit of CA that took away from the sharpness
p.6 #7What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
On Nikon, I'd say the 105 f2.8 S Z-mount, but before that it was the G version, which stopped down is still pretty amazing. The G version had some CA wide open, that completely goes away at f5.6 and tighter. I think I took this one at f14
The Nikon 70-200 f2.8 S Z-mount is also crazy sharp. Apparently the V2 is even sharper, which I find a bit mind boggling.
p.6 #8What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
sungphoto wrote: jakelindsay wroteApart from the Macro kings Sony 100mm F2.8 GM and M. Zuiko 90mm F 3.5 it would definitely be:
GF 45-100mm F4I was excited to try the GF 45-100 f4 but was a little disappointed with it wide open on the GFX100S. Had a bit of CA that took away from the sharpness
Yeah I haven't noticed it but I rarely shoot it wide open. Stopped down it's just been razor sharp throughout its focal length in my experience.
p.6 #10What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Agree with this completely - the new Nikon 70-200mm 2.8 S II is incredibly sharp.... but to me.... a bit soulless. The new Sony 50-150 F2.0, on the other hand, is perhaps not as sharp, but I greatly prefer its rendering.
Lance B wrote:
A very sharp lens is all very good, but it is not the be-all-and-end-all as far as lens desirability is concerned, IMO. There are many other attributes that make up a great lens, sharpness only being one of them and even then it may not be a priority for some uses. Right tool for the right job. Many of my favourite images are from lenses going back many years that wouldn't be considered sharp compared to the modern day lenses and I dare say that having a sharper lens wouldn't have made them any more desirable.
p.6 #11What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
For me personally, it's the Voigtländer APO-Lanthar 65/2.0 Macro in terms of sharpness, color rendering, and microcontrast.
In my personal opinion, this is the best and sharpest lens across all camera systems.
p.6 #12What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
For me two standout.
1. Sigma 40mm 1.4 Art (as others have noted).
2. Tokina Opera 50mm 1.4 (ie. rebadged Pentax D FA 50mm F1.4). IMO, a relatively unknown gem. I'd put it slightly behind the 40 Art and that's saying something b/c that lens is in a league of its own.
p.6 #13What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Several standouts:
- Viltrox 35mm F1.8 EVO ll is sharper than my Voigtlander 35mm F2 APO, and sharper than the 35 GM.
- 70-200 F2.8 GM2 is really sharp, so much so that even with the 2x TC I was getting good results birding with it.
- Sigma 85mm f1.4 Art is ridiculously sharp.
- Sigma 56mm F1.4 for APSC was ridiculously sharp.
p.6 #15What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
'Sigma 85mm f1.4 Art is ridiculously sharp.
- Sigma 56mm F1.4 for APSC was ridiculously sharp.'
Indeed. "Ridiculously" is an adverb meaning: 'in a way that is silly, unreasonable, or extreme to the point of being laughable.' Never a truer word than one spoken in jest.
What happens though, with such lenses, is that the viewer is forced to notice the extreme sharpness as having greater priority and importance than the image itself. The lens's acutance actually usurps the photo as the main attraction. The Sigma Syndrome is very popular.
p.6 #17What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
Dang, these belong in the "which lens has the most pop"thread. I've never really wanted a manual lens before, but...
dalegaspi wrote: Al Trujillo wroteVoigtlander 65mm APO-Lanthar...likely the best I've ever owned.yep. sharp corner-to-corner and almost imperceptible LoCA at f2 at all distances including 1:2 macro (thanks to its FLE design)
p.6 #19What was your sharpest lens, regardless of manufacturer or focal length?
philip_pj wrote:
What happens though, with such lenses, is that the viewer is forced to notice the extreme sharpness as having greater priority and importance than the image itself. The lens's acutance actually usurps the photo as the main attraction.
Not necessarily, Philip. You can take excellent photos (photographically speaking) even with very sharp lenses.
The average viewer won’t focus on the fine details of a beautiful photo—they’ll just look at the photo.
In photography, as in high-fidelity audio, the principle of “non-subtraction” applies. The equipment must not remove information from the signal it records or reproduces. Nor should it add spurious signals (noise, distortion, aberrations, fringing, onion rings, etc.).