CKrueger wrote: pechance wroteI started looking at the A7RV and honestly a bit of envy crept in. The thought of 1.5+ stops better DR is very appealing. Also it seems the ultra wide options for FF (especially Sony mount) are much stronger than options for Fuji.Regardless of whether you’re shooting RAW or JPEG, have you played with Fuji’s DR settings?
If you’re shooting RAW, it doesn’t CREATE DR, but it does make it easier to shoot high DR scenes. It basically sets a fake higher ISO, and applies a curve to give you what looks like more dynamic range, at the cost of added shadow noise. And the viewfinder remains WYSIWYG; you aren’t shooting a dark viewfinder, knowing that you’re going to crank a Shadows slider later in LR.
When I shoot JPEG, I get more DR on ready-to-use files. When I shoot RAW, it’s easier to shoot due to an accurate viewfinder, and the RAW files look correct at import-time in LR.
The added noise is at thing to live with compared to a FF camera, but like others have said, if you’re PPing files, today’s NR tools means noise isn’t much of a factor.
For an UWA, have you looked at the 10-18/2.8? It’s smaller and faster than the 10-24, which I agree is a bit of a beast on a Fuji X body.
And as for your sample images…. are you unhappy with those? They seem good to me! I wouldn’t change systems just for a small improvement in these images....Show more →
A thread on this topic a while back seemed to conclude that there’s no evidence that the different DR settings affect the data image data in the raw files. So there’s not really any advantage over just exposing for the highlights and raising the shadows in post if you shoot raw.
The story with jpg files is, of course, completely different.
That’s correct. It is basically “pre post-processing”, baking in ISO and curve differences.
But that’s helpful, like a viewfinder crop when the RAW data is retained.
I use it for RAW cause challenging DR shots are specifically where I want to know I nailed the exposure, and the histogram and blinkies when shooting in DR200/400 are “accurate”.
ETTR is an obnoxious thing to manage when I am trying to be creative.
gdanmitchell wrote: CKrueger wrotepechance wroteI started looking at the A7RV and honestly a bit of envy crept in. The thought of 1.5+ stops better DR is very appealing. Also it seems the ultra wide options for FF (especially Sony mount) are much stronger than options for Fuji.Regardless of whether you’re shooting RAW or JPEG, have you played with Fuji’s DR settings?
If you’re shooting RAW, it doesn’t CREATE DR, but it does make it easier to shoot high DR scenes. It basically sets a fake higher ISO, and applies a curve to give you what looks like more dynamic range, at the cost of added shadow noise. And the viewfinder remains WYSIWYG; you aren’t shooting a dark viewfinder, knowing that you’re going to crank a Shadows slider later in LR.
When I shoot JPEG, I get more DR on ready-to-use files. When I shoot RAW, it’s easier to shoot due to an accurate viewfinder, and the RAW files look correct at import-time in LR.
The added noise is at thing to live with compared to a FF camera, but like others have said, if you’re PPing files, today’s NR tools means noise isn’t much of a factor.
For an UWA, have you looked at the 10-18/2.8? It’s smaller and faster than the 10-24, which I agree is a bit of a beast on a Fuji X body.
And as for your sample images…. are you unhappy with those? They seem good to me! I wouldn’t change systems just for a small improvement in these images.A thread on this topic a while back seemed to conclude that there’s no evidence that the different DR settings affect the data image data in the raw files. So there’s not really any advantage over just exposing for the highlights and raising the shadows in post if you shoot raw.
The story with jpg files is, of course, completely different.
CKrueger wrote:
That’s correct. It is basically “pre post-processing”, baking in ISO and curve differences.
But that’s helpful, like a viewfinder crop when the RAW data is retained.
I use it for RAW cause challenging DR shots are specifically where I want to know I nailed the exposure, and the histogram and blinkies when shooting in DR200/400 are “accurate”.
ETTR is an obnoxious thing to manage when I am trying to be creative.
gdanmitchell wroteCKrueger wrotepechance wroteI started looking at the A7RV and honestly a bit of envy crept in. The thought of 1.5+ stops better DR is very appealing. Also it seems the ultra wide options for FF (especially Sony mount) are much stronger than options for Fuji.Regardless of whether you’re shooting RAW or JPEG, have you played with Fuji’s DR settings?
If you’re shooting RAW, it doesn’t CREATE DR, but it does make it easier to shoot high DR scenes. It basically sets a fake higher ISO, and applies a curve to give you what looks like more dynamic range, at the cost of added shadow noise. And the viewfinder remains WYSIWYG; you aren’t shooting a dark viewfinder, knowing that you’re going to crank a Shadows slider later in LR.
When I shoot JPEG, I get more DR on ready-to-use files. When I shoot RAW, it’s easier to shoot due to an accurate viewfinder, and the RAW files look correct at import-time in LR.
The added noise is at thing to live with compared to a FF camera, but like others have said, if you’re PPing files, today’s NR tools means noise isn’t much of a factor.
For an UWA, have you looked at the 10-18/2.8? It’s smaller and faster than the 10-24, which I agree is a bit of a beast on a Fuji X body.
And as for your sample images…. are you unhappy with those? They seem good to me! I wouldn’t change systems just for a small improvement in these images.A thread on this topic a while back seemed to conclude that there’s no evidence that the different DR settings affect the data image data in the raw files. So there’s not really any advantage over just exposing for the highlights and raising the shadows in post if you shoot raw.
The story with jpg files is, of course, completely different.
The EC knob usually does it for me. (Most often I’m in aperture priority mode when shooting street and similar subjects with the xT5.)
I’m generally pretty good at estimating the EC offset at this point, and if in doubt I’ll over adjust slightly since I’d rather make a mistake in that direction and deal with it in post.
That might sound like a compromise if we assume that the AE system is always right, but it certainly is not! So I think my hit rate is likely as good and as close to right as using a dynamic range mode.
Anyway, my main point here was to remind people that what these setting do when shooting jpg (alter the image data in the jpg file) is quite different from what happens in raw mode (the recorded image data is not changed).
gdanmitchell wrote: CKrueger wrotepechance wroteI started looking at the A7RV and honestly a bit of envy crept in. The thought of 1.5+ stops better DR is very appealing. Also it seems the ultra wide options for FF (especially Sony mount) are much stronger than options for Fuji.Regardless of whether you’re shooting RAW or JPEG, have you played with Fuji’s DR settings?
If you’re shooting RAW, it doesn’t CREATE DR, but it does make it easier to shoot high DR scenes. It basically sets a fake higher ISO, and applies a curve to give you what looks like more dynamic range, at the cost of added shadow noise. And the viewfinder remains WYSIWYG; you aren’t shooting a dark viewfinder, knowing that you’re going to crank a Shadows slider later in LR.
When I shoot JPEG, I get more DR on ready-to-use files. When I shoot RAW, it’s easier to shoot due to an accurate viewfinder, and the RAW files look correct at import-time in LR.
The added noise is at thing to live with compared to a FF camera, but like others have said, if you’re PPing files, today’s NR tools means noise isn’t much of a factor.
For an UWA, have you looked at the 10-18/2.8? It’s smaller and faster than the 10-24, which I agree is a bit of a beast on a Fuji X body.
And as for your sample images…. are you unhappy with those? They seem good to me! I wouldn’t change systems just for a small improvement in these images.A thread on this topic a while back seemed to conclude that there’s no evidence that the different DR settings affect the data image data in the raw files. So there’s not really any advantage over just exposing for the highlights and raising the shadows in post if you shoot raw.
The story with jpg files is, of course, completely different.
The different DR settings affect either the exposure (at the base ISO) or the analogue gain applied toward the signal from the sensor (at ISO above the base). I have seen no evidence for a curve applied on the raw data with DR200 or DR400.
Regarding "there’s not really any advantage over just exposing for the highlights" - this depends. There is no advantage when shooting from a tripod and when one has enough time to use the exposure compensation. The advantage of setting DR to Auto is when doing candid/street photography and in general when the scene and the light are fluid and one has no time for exposure compensation. This is the case of what I do mostly (point and shoot), and I keep DR set to Auto. When shooting at the base ISO, this is equivalent to allowing the camera to apply exposure compensation of -1 (when it decides that this is needed). This is obviously a crude way of trying to prevent overexposure but it is acceptable when there is simply no time for using the manual exposure compensation and when shooting a GFX camera that has a good dynamic range to begin with.
At the higher ISO, the DR200/400 settings reduce the analogue gain (rather than the exposure). When the ISO is above the base, the exposure compensation should be used only in full manual and when the ISO is not in Auto.
^^^
As to "no advantage" I could have clarified that this means there's no native improvement in the capabilities of the raw file (e.g. a different curve, less noise, etc) when using the feature when shooting in raw. (I'm focused on that since there has been an assumption to the contrary floating around.)
As I wrote a couple of posts earlier:
Anyway, my main point here was to remind people that what these setting do when shooting jpg (alter the image data in the jpg file) is quite different from what happens in raw mode (the recorded image data is not changed).
gdanmitchell wrote:
^^^
As to "no advantage" I could have clarified that this means there's no native improvement in the capabilities of the raw file (e.g. a different curve, less noise, etc) when using the feature when shooting in raw. (I'm focused on that since there has been an assumption to the contrary floating around.)
As I wrote a couple of posts earlier:
Earlier quoteAnyway, my main point here was to remind people that what these setting do when shooting jpg (alter the image data in the jpg file) is quite different from what happens in raw mode (the recorded image data is not changed).
YMMV.
Yes, the EC and DR settings are two independent ways of preventing clipping of the highlights in raw files.
The difference is only in that the former is adjusted manually, whereas the latter can be (and, perhaps, is intended to be) used mostly in Auto.
Indeed, to the best of my knowledge, "there's no native improvement in the capabilities of the raw file" one way or the other.
The concern is about fitting all (or as much as possible) raw data into the dynamic range of the camera (e.g., 14 or 16 bit) without clipping or overflow.
ruthenium wrote: gdanmitchell wrote^^^
As to "no advantage" I could have clarified that this means there's no native improvement in the capabilities of the raw file (e.g. a different curve, less noise, etc) when using the feature when shooting in raw. (I'm focused on that since there has been an assumption to the contrary floating around.)
As I wrote a couple of posts earlier:
Earlier quoteAnyway, my main point here was to remind people that what these setting do when shooting jpg (alter the image data in the jpg file) is quite different from what happens in raw mode (the recorded image data is not changed).
YMMV.Yes, the EC and DR settings are two independent ways of preventing clipping of the highlights in raw files.
The difference is only in that the former is adjusted manually, whereas the latter can be (and, perhaps, is intended to be) used mostly in Auto.
Indeed, to the best of my knowledge, "there's no native improvement in the capabilities of the raw file" one way or the other.
The concern is about fitting all (or as much as possible) raw data into the dynamic range of the camera (e.g., 14 or 16 bit) without clipping or overflow.
If by “ fitting all (or as much as possible) raw data into the dynamic range of the camera (e.g., 14 or 16 bit) without clipping or overflow” you mean avoiding blown highlights, the only difference between the DR method and adjusting the exposure manually is that it is an automatic approximation when the camera does it and potentially more precise and tailored when the photographer does it (as I do).
In any case, rather than digging too deeply into the semantics of this, again, the main point is that the setting on Fujifilm cameras does not do anything different to the raw file than if one lowered the exposure to avoid blowing highlights and then raised the shadows in post. Either way, aside from the basic exposure choice, the data in the raw file are not modified but, for example, increasing the value of dark tones or applying a curve, things that probably do happen to the jpg file when the setting is used with them.
gdanmitchell wrote: ruthenium wrotegdanmitchell wrote^^^
As to "no advantage" I could have clarified that this means there's no native improvement in the capabilities of the raw file (e.g. a different curve, less noise, etc) when using the feature when shooting in raw. (I'm focused on that since there has been an assumption to the contrary floating around.)
As I wrote a couple of posts earlier:
Earlier quoteAnyway, my main point here was to remind people that what these setting do when shooting jpg (alter the image data in the jpg file) is quite different from what happens in raw mode (the recorded image data is not changed).
YMMV.Yes, the EC and DR settings are two independent ways of preventing clipping of the highlights in raw files.
The difference is only in that the former is adjusted manually, whereas the latter can be (and, perhaps, is intended to be) used mostly in Auto.
Indeed, to the best of my knowledge, "there's no native improvement in the capabilities of the raw file" one way or the other.
The concern is about fitting all (or as much as possible) raw data into the dynamic range of the camera (e.g., 14 or 16 bit) without clipping or overflow.If by “ fitting all (or as much as possible) raw data into the dynamic range of the camera (e.g., 14 or 16 bit) without clipping or overflow” you mean avoiding blown highlights, the only difference between the DR method and adjusting the exposure manually is that it is an automatic approximation when the camera does it and potentially more precise and tailored when the photographer does it (as I do).
In any case, rather than digging too deeply into the semantics of this, again, the main point is that the setting on Fujifilm cameras does not do anything different to the raw file than if one lowered the exposure to avoid blowing highlights and then raised the shadows in post. Either way, aside from the basic exposure choice, the data in the raw file are not modified but, for example, increasing the value of dark tones or applying a curve, things that probably do happen to the jpg file when the setting is used with them....Show more →
Yes, what I said means "avoiding blown highlights." In other words, we want the signal from the brightest pixels to be digitized under 65,535 (in the case of a 16-bit raw file, for example). This assumes that the brightest pixels are not saturated in the first place.
There are actually two independent causes for blown highlights: (1) too much light that exceeds the full well capacity of the sensor, and (2) an excessive analog gain applied toward the signal from the sensor.
When the ISO is in Auto, the 1st problem can happen only at the base ISO. This is when either EC or DR settings can be used to avoid blown highlights. The 2nd problem is a concern when the auto ISO is above base, e.g., at or above ISO 500 on my GFX100S II. It is this 2nd cause of blown highlights that is best prevented by using the DR setting set to Auto.
pechance wrote:
Headed on a once in a lifetime trip around the Mediterranean. I have shot with Fuji's for many years (since the xpro1 first came out). If I can use a tripod, I do and shoot at low ISOs to manage noise, but tripods are not allowed in many churches and museums. I started looking at the A7RV and honestly a bit of envy crept in. The thought of 1.5+ stops better DR is very appealing. Also it seems the ultra wide options for FF (especially Sony mount) are much stronger than options for Fuji. Both the Viltrox 13 and the Sigma 12 carry some concerns open wide, although reportedly great in the center and mid frame.
I could sell some older equipment to fund the A7RV and a lens or two if needed.
The whole reason I left Nikon all those years ago was weight and even though bodies like the A7RV are not that much larger than the XT5, the lenses are bigger and heavier.
Or, I could upgrade my 16-80 to the 16-55 ii which reviews say is sharp edge to edge at 2.8 at both 16 and 55 which would be a step up from my 16-80. I have extensively used the 16-80 around Europe and while super convenient, 16-18 and 65-80 are not strong areas for sharpness. I need to stop down to 5.6 to improve the corners which in dark churches pushes my ISO up. Being able to shoot at 2.8 would buy me two stops of lower ISO which would help the noise concerns.
I had originally planned to use my 18/1.4 and 33 as the main lenses for the trip, but the convenience and less weight of the 16-55 over two lenses is alluring.
The whole reason I left Nikon all those years ago was weight and even though bodies like the A7RV are not that much larger than the XT5, the lenses are bigger and heavier.
Below are some of the shots I got last week with the 10-24/4 up in St. Louis. Wanted to test to see if that lens would work in dark churches handheld.
Shooting in a church and similar spaces is challenging.
The objectives are conflicting:
-One may want to shoot wide open to get more light, however, this means a shallow DoF
-One may want to use a slow SS, however when there are moving people, a slow SS can be a problem.
A f/2.8 APS-C lens is equivalent to f/4.2 (with the equivalent focal length). This is probably a reasonable compromise for the DoF vs light gathering. In some places a full-frame equivalent f/2.8 lens can work as well (about f/2 on APS-C).
When a slow SS can be used, a good IBIS can help a lot. When considering a new camera, ask whether one can use it hand-held with shutter speeds like 1/2s (or even 1 s).
Something that is also very important is using good denoising in post (e.g. in Lr, DxO, or C1). This can help a lot - more than buying a new camera or lens.
Regarding "The thought of 1.5+ stops better DR is very appealing" - you need to be more specific here.
I am afraid of bringing up the subject of equivalence, because it seems most people hate this.
Nevertheless, a full-frame camera has a better dynamic range vs an APS-C only at the base ISO and near the base ISO (and possibly at the ISO when the dual-gain is activated). The new A7RVI is a special case that requires using the mechanical shutter and only in the low ISO range.
At the higher ISO, there is no or a negligible difference in DR when a full-frame and an APS-C camera are set to acquire equivalent images. This is when the same amount of light is allowed to fall on their sensors, by using equivalent apertures and the same shutter speed (this condition should not be confused with the condition of the same lightness, that is the same ISO, when the images from FF and APS-C sensors are not equivalent). Send me a PM if you have any questions about this.
The bottom line: don't buy a full-frame camera if you know that the ISO on your APS-C camera should be at ISO 320 or higher in a typical shooting scenario in a church. In this case, a FF camera is not going to give you any useful advantage in DR in equivalent images.
ruthenium wrote: pechance wroteHeaded on a once in a lifetime trip around the Mediterranean. I have shot with Fuji's for many years (since the xpro1 first came out). If I can use a tripod, I do and shoot at low ISOs to manage noise, but tripods are not allowed in many churches and museums. I started looking at the A7RV and honestly a bit of envy crept in. The thought of 1.5+ stops better DR is very appealing. Also it seems the ultra wide options for FF (especially Sony mount) are much stronger than options for Fuji. Both the Viltrox 13 and the Sigma 12 carry some concerns open wide, although reportedly great in the center and mid frame.
I could sell some older equipment to fund the A7RV and a lens or two if needed.
The whole reason I left Nikon all those years ago was weight and even though bodies like the A7RV are not that much larger than the XT5, the lenses are bigger and heavier.
Or, I could upgrade my 16-80 to the 16-55 ii which reviews say is sharp edge to edge at 2.8 at both 16 and 55 which would be a step up from my 16-80. I have extensively used the 16-80 around Europe and while super convenient, 16-18 and 65-80 are not strong areas for sharpness. I need to stop down to 5.6 to improve the corners which in dark churches pushes my ISO up. Being able to shoot at 2.8 would buy me two stops of lower ISO which would help the noise concerns.
I had originally planned to use my 18/1.4 and 33 as the main lenses for the trip, but the convenience and less weight of the 16-55 over two lenses is alluring.
The whole reason I left Nikon all those years ago was weight and even though bodies like the A7RV are not that much larger than the XT5, the lenses are bigger and heavier.
Below are some of the shots I got last week with the 10-24/4 up in St. Louis. Wanted to test to see if that lens would work in dark churches handheld.
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55541842728_2d9f83ec18_b.jpgSTL basilica 91- by paul chance, on FlickrShooting in a church and similar spaces is challenging.
The objectives are conflicting:
-One may want to shoot wide open to get more light, however, this means a shallow DoF
-One may want to use a slow SS, however when there are moving people, a slow SS can be a problem.
A f/2.8 APS-C lens is equivalent to f/4.2 (with the equivalent focal length). This is probably a reasonable compromise for the DoF vs light gathering. In some places a full-frame equivalent f/2.8 lens can work as well (about f/2 on APS-C).
When a slow SS can be used, a good IBIS can help a lot. When considering a new camera, ask whether one can use it hand-held with shutter speeds like 1/2s (or even 1 s).
Something that is also very important is using good denoising in post (e.g. in Lr, DxO, or C1). This can help a lot - more than buying a new camera or lens.
Regarding "The thought of 1.5+ stops better DR is very appealing" - you need to be more specific here.
I am afraid of bringing up the subject of equivalence, because it seems most people hate this.
Nevertheless, a full-frame camera has a better dynamic range vs an APS-C only at the base ISO and near the base ISO (and possibly at the ISO when the dual-gain is activated). The new A7RVI is a special case that requires using the mechanical shutter and only in the low ISO range.
At the higher ISO, there is no or a negligible difference in DR when a full-frame and an APS-C camera are set to acquire equivalent images. This is when the same amount of light is allowed to fall on their sensors, by using equivalent apertures and the same shutter speed (this condition should not be confused with the condition of the same lightness, that is the same ISO, when the images from FF and APS-C sensors are not equivalent). Send me a PM if you have any questions about this.
The bottom line: don't buy a full-frame camera if you know that the ISO on your APS-C camera should be at ISO 320 or higher in a typical shooting scenario in a church. In this case, a FF camera is not going to give you any useful advantage in DR in equivalent images....Show more →
Spot on analysis. I remember 10 years ago when I was contemplating trading my Sony A7 for an Xpro2, I found a comparison of noise performance etc between the two. It was well done, and showed no useful advantages the at base iso, and even then the difference was so small as to be of only theoretical interest. Some of that was the 'generation' effect from a later sensor and processors, but things have got much better since then, especially with post processing tools.
Nothing new of course, a Hasselblad was only better for church interiors than a Leica if you put it on a tripod, the better and faster lenses for good 35mm cameras made then much better for hand held and similar use. The greater DoF meant you could use slower films with better resolution and lower grain too.
i shoot sony a7iv for my pro work and bought a new x100vi recently for travel and candids as well as backup for my pro work, for me the x100vi is second to none for pure enjoyment and what travel cameras are all about, image quality is excelent, is it better than my a7iv No! but im not getting paid and dont have to produce 100% keepers either. but that beautiful leather case looks and keeps the camera tiny that no other system offers.
Thanks everyone for the feedback. Think I have made my decision.
1. I know my Fuji's really well and don't want to worry about learning something new while overseas.
2. Given that FF normally is about 1.5 stops better, another option is to use faster lenses and lean into focus at hyperfocal distance. I have the 18/1.4 and 33/1.4 and have picked up the Sigma 12/1.4 (for dark churches interiors and such - also I do Milky Way shots here in the states and this is a good lens for astro so it will get used a lot.) If I went FF, I would need slower lenses to keep size reasonable - looks like 2.8 or slower - so that is at least 2 stops lower ISO with the Fuji which should put it fairly close in DR.
3. Trust IBIS more - been practicing and 1/8 is very doable at 18mm for me which is at least 2 stops slower than I have trusted in the past.
The 18 and 33 are outstanding optics and to replicate on Sony, I'd need to use the GM lenses thus $$$ and bigger.
While I love the rendering and size of the Voigt kit (pancakes and lanthars) - I lose WR, AF. To get edge to edge IQ with the pancakes that gets close to the fuji primes, I would need to stop down to 4 or 5.6.
I had seriously considered the 16-55ii but at $1400, those funds could get other stuff I want (perhaps some other body in the future like the mythical XPro4 with a 9.44 EVF and all the other features I want) given I already have the two 1.4 primes. Based on past trips to Switzerland and Ireland, I usually take about 60-70% around an 18mm FoV on APSC and another 20% at the 35mm and 10% at various other focal lengths. I will take the 70-300 on the trip but not carry unless I expect to need it - like the view of the Acropolis in Athens from across town. I may toss in the Voigt 75/1.9 in my daily bag just in case. I expect I will have the 18/1.4 on the XT5 the vast majority of the time.
On my past trips, where I used my 16-80 if my ratings for good/great shots showed I varied my focal range more, the convenience of the zoom would make more sense. While I came back with good images from the previous trips - I did notice the softness in the edges / corners at both ends. I just tend to see compositions better at 18mm.
I plan to wear the camera across my shoulder and have the 12 & 33 in a small waist bag and not need to carry a backpack or shoulder bag while walking around for hours.
Thanks for your summary. I've been racking my brain over this same issue. I decided that I could find equivalent lenses for *most* situations. Your plan sounds perfect. what I still can't decide is, is there really a "full frame look"? Is there something about the sensor that makes images less noisy and look a little bit more premium? I'm going to try it out and will let you know.
dan_had wrote:
Thanks for your summary. I've been racking my brain over this same issue. I decided that I could find equivalent lenses for *most* situations. Your plan sounds perfect. what I still can't decide is, is there really a "full frame look"? Is there something about the sensor that makes images less noisy and look a little bit more premium? I'm going to try it out and will let you know.
If the base ISO of your APS-C camera is 125, then it cannot obtain images with the same field of view & the same depth of field & the same shutter speed as a full-frame camera when the ISO on the FF camera is below 250 (e.g. 100 or 200).
When shooting a full-frame camera at ISO above 250, then the full-frame sensor has no advantage over the APS-C, assuming these sensors utilize the same technology (that is true in most cases, except a few exceptions such as Sony A7V or A7RVI that benefit from the dual output gain at low ISO with mechanical shutter). In any case, it is safe to claim that at ISO above 500, there should be no advantage when using a FF sensor vs APS-C with the top-end APS-C bodies.
Unrelated to the sensors are the choices of fast lenses. For full-frame F1.2 and F1.4 lenses there might be no APS-C lenses that can produce equivalent depths of field and project equivalent amounts of light onto a sensor.
Thus, to take advantage of what FF can do and APS-C cannot, one typically has to shoot at f/1.2 - 1.4 and/or at ISO 100 - 200.
To answer the questions of the kind that you are asking, one would benefit from learning the basic ideas of photographic equivalence. This is a well-established approach to comparing camera systems that have sensors of different sizes.
ruthenium wrote: dan_had wroteThanks for your summary. I've been racking my brain over this same issue. I decided that I could find equivalent lenses for *most* situations. Your plan sounds perfect. what I still can't decide is, is there really a "full frame look"? Is there something about the sensor that makes images less noisy and look a little bit more premium? I'm going to try it out and will let you know.If the base ISO of your APS-C camera is 125, then it cannot obtain images with the same field of view & the same depth of field & the same shutter speed as a full-frame camera when the ISO on the FF camera is below 250 (e.g. 100 or 200).
When shooting a full-frame camera at ISO above 250, then the full-frame sensor has no advantage over the APS-C, assuming these sensors utilize the same technology (that is true in most cases, except a few exceptions such as Sony A7V or A7RVI that benefit from the dual output gain at low ISO with mechanical shutter). In any case, it is safe to claim that at ISO above 500, there should be no advantage when using a FF sensor vs APS-C with the top-end APS-C bodies.
Unrelated to the sensors are the choices of fast lenses. For full-frame F1.2 and F1.4 lenses there might be no APS-C lenses that can produce equivalent depths of field and project equivalent amounts of light onto a sensor.
Thus, to take advantage of what FF can do and APS-C cannot, one typically has to shoot at f/1.2 - 1.4 and/or at ISO 100 - 200.
To answer the questions of the kind that you are asking, one would benefit from learning the basic ideas of photographic equivalence. This is a well-established approach to comparing camera systems that have sensors of different sizes....Show more →
Fuji does have a 50mm f/1, but by and large the aps-c systems other than Fuji are starved of good fast primes. Fuji shows the advantages if it's just light gathering power you need, with more compact primes than the equivalent FoV and similar aperure for FF.
The sector that needs the FoV and DoF of a FF 85 1.2 is a pretty small segment of the market, DoF is hardly enough to get nose and ears 'sharp' for a portrait.
gyoung143 wrote: ruthenium wrotedan_had wroteThanks for your summary. I've been racking my brain over this same issue. I decided that I could find equivalent lenses for *most* situations. Your plan sounds perfect. what I still can't decide is, is there really a "full frame look"? Is there something about the sensor that makes images less noisy and look a little bit more premium? I'm going to try it out and will let you know.If the base ISO of your APS-C camera is 125, then it cannot obtain images with the same field of view & the same depth of field & the same shutter speed as a full-frame camera when the ISO on the FF camera is below 250 (e.g. 100 or 200).
When shooting a full-frame camera at ISO above 250, then the full-frame sensor has no advantage over the APS-C, assuming these sensors utilize the same technology (that is true in most cases, except a few exceptions such as Sony A7V or A7RVI that benefit from the dual output gain at low ISO with mechanical shutter). In any case, it is safe to claim that at ISO above 500, there should be no advantage when using a FF sensor vs APS-C with the top-end APS-C bodies.
Unrelated to the sensors are the choices of fast lenses. For full-frame F1.2 and F1.4 lenses there might be no APS-C lenses that can produce equivalent depths of field and project equivalent amounts of light onto a sensor.
Thus, to take advantage of what FF can do and APS-C cannot, one typically has to shoot at f/1.2 - 1.4 and/or at ISO 100 - 200.
To answer the questions of the kind that you are asking, one would benefit from learning the basic ideas of photographic equivalence. This is a well-established approach to comparing camera systems that have sensors of different sizes.Fuji does have a 50mm f/1, but by and large the aps-c systems other than Fuji are starved of good fast primes. Fuji shows the advantages if it's just light gathering power you need, with more compact primes than the equivalent FoV and similar aperure for FF.
The sector that needs the FoV and DoF of a FF 85 1.2 is a pretty small segment of the market, DoF is hardly enough to get nose and ears 'sharp' for a portrait.
Gerry
I can think of one group of enthusiasts who might be attracted by fast or relatively fast primes on full-frame bodies with fast-readout sensors: bird, wildlife, and sport photographers.
I am not really familiar with the long telephoto APS-C options, but it seems that XF400mm F4.5 might be the fastest long one. Images taken with this lens should be the same as (equivalent to) ones taken with a full-frame 600mm lens closed to F6.7-6.8. (It is worth noting that a F4.4 APS-C lens gives the same exposure - light per unit sensor area - as a F4.4 full-frame lens, whereas it projects about 1.2 stops less light onto an APS-C sensor as a whole; thus, resultinging in a reduced dynamic range and more visible noise).
Having said the above, I don't mean to suggest that buying a fast modern full-frame camera system should make a meaningful difference for every user - only for experienced, dedicated wildlife or sports photographers this can be important. Even then, taking good pictures is probably 90% (or more) due to the knowledge and experience of the photographer and being in the right place at the right time.
dan_had wrote:
Thanks for your summary. I've been racking my brain over this same issue. I decided that I could find equivalent lenses for *most* situations. Your plan sounds perfect. what I still can't decide is, is there really a "full frame look"? Is there something about the sensor that makes images less noisy and look a little bit more premium? I'm going to try it out and will let you know.
As to a “full frame look,” I tend to doubt it, or at least think that it is so subtle that you’d only likely notice it if you looked closely at pretty large prints.
As I write this I’m sitting in a room with a bunch of my prints from both FF and APS-C systems (from multiple cameras and brands), and nothing striking about the difference jumps out at me.
I still use a FF system for some kinds of photography, in particular my landscape work where I shoot from the tripod and bring along a larger set of high quality lenses. But my street/travel photography is done (exclusively these days) with an APS-C system, and I’m pretty certain that no one would look at the prints and say, “Oh, but I can tell you used a smaller sensor.”
At the end of the post-processing chain, any difference in noise is generally meaningless and invisible. I suppose that if you inspect SOOC images at 200% before post-processing that you can measure “more noise” on a smaller sensor system, all else being equal. But in photographs that have been through a typical post-processing workflow? Not likely.
Dan and I agree on almost everything. I think there’s definitely something to the “full frame look” as compared to a similar output APSC, but it’s mitigated by apertures past f4; and moreover, the only folks that will notice it are other (and likely the more anal) photographers.
Back to the original question. You have a beloved kit you know and trust. Get the new 16–55, it’s notably better than the 16-80 at f2.8 and 4, and a little cleaner at f5.6. Save the Sony experience for when you’re in a place you can directly compare them in use and output with the lenses you’d likely use.
I mentioned earlier about the switch I made and why; I gained one system that offered both more and yet allowed for a travel kit option almost as compact as my Fuji APSC kit. Dan has explained why he uses 2 kits — the same net result as mine, one for more and one compact. Others have shared why they travel with a bigger kit, more still and compact enough for them. I prefer to be a 1 kit guy, albeit with multiple bodies and a few overlapping lenses to suit different situations — mainly because all remain cross compatible and so I can easily mix and match depending, but that’s me.
BUT, the only way you’ll know what is best for you is to try and compare. And that’s best done in a controlled shooting situation and not while on a vacation. Enjoy the vacation, test whatever when you get back.