TravelinBriNY wrote:
Jack Flesher wrote
rob_ww wrote
I cannot see any significant advantage to this lens over the existing Sony 24-50. Yes, you do get 20mm on the wide end, but if I want wider than 24 I am likely to want the option of wider than 20 too, depending on the composition. The extra 10mm on the long end is not worth considering. The size, weight and price are comparable, but the f2.8, esp. on the long end, is critical. Just my 2c. I have to say I thought that way too until I started using the 20-70 — having the 20-24 bit of range is darn handy. Having it now, I’d definitely give up the 10mm on the long end for it.
Given Dustin’s review, I’d definitely stick with my Sony 20-70 over this Sigma. The Sigma hits f4 quickly anyway, and needs a hefty amount of corrections. Sigma also zooms backwards from Sony which gets confusing when switching between lenses. But I do like the size…
My issue right now, is the 24-70/2.8 GMii is just so darn good optically that I don’t want to use anything else in that range. It’s quickly becoming my goto. It’s a little bigger than I’d like for travel, but it’s so good I’m caving anyway. My 20-70 may hit the B&S soon… I am caught between 3 lenses - the 20-70, 24-70 and 20-200. As you note, the 24-70/2.8 GM II is just on another level for overall sharpness, but the 20-70 is close, small and has a real bonus in that extra on there wide side. The 20-200 is nowhere near as good as either, but I love having the long range, which I find I use more and more in street shooting...
There's no universal one right answer, of course. My recent trip was with others, with different interests and some set timing. Kind of rushed and shared things concerns. A 20-200 might be a good choice there. If traveling alone or more opportunities for deliberative work, more "carry" capacity, then more or different choices work.
I'll put my ff lenses on my A6700 to compare size for A7C series roles. Even that is a moving target. I think the 20-200, 28-200 are getting, for me, "might as well go A7s over A7C" size, the A6700 and 70-350 or 50-300 is a nice alternative to the xx-400s for zoos, wild animal parks with crowds and walking.