1bwana1 wrote:
James Markus wrote
1bwana1 wrote
What are the specifications of the files those scanners output.
Tha Valoi gives you RAW files, at full 14bit depth, more DR than film has, whatever mpx the camera has. Wonderful to edit those files. Plus, you get a macro lens for many other uses. Hard to beat all those advantages. I didn't find file formats saved info with the default software, and the bundled scanner specific Plustex version of Silverfast is probably been trimmed for the bundle. I have the same software version for another scanner, but saving in raw has been problematic since Lasersoft has their own proprietory raw format. There were three levels of the software for my scanner - I got the SE + of silverfast v9. It's really capable software, but a bit deep to learn. The reason I mention this is there are hardware specs, and hardware specs using Silverfast floating around the web on both scanners. Silverfast specs make the scanner appear more capable than the manufacturer claims,
Taken from the web site
135i ai
Approx. 360 seconds for maximum scanning area color at 3600 dpi (IR enabled) (6 MINUTES PER FRAME!))
Approx. 25 minutes for maximum scanning area at maximum resolution: 7200dpi (IR enabled) PER FRAME
Dynamic Range 3.4
9000i ai
3,600 dpi: Approx. 20 sec & 40 sec with IR scanning (This is almost the same as the LS-4000 & LS-5000 at 4000dpi)
7,200 dpi: Approx. 40 sec & 120 sec with IR scanning
Dynamic Range 3.6 (with Silverfast the DR = 4.01)
I'm not slamming these scanners. You just need to be aware that a 36 exposure roll will take between 3.6 hours at 3600dpi IR enabled and 15 hours on the 135i ai at 7200dpi to scan. That is a long slog imo. The 9000i would be considerably less.
I've been using Silverfast since the late 1990s on a Nikon LS-1000. It increased the image quality immensely, but the scanner is limited by hardware to 8bit color. Still makes great 5400dpi scans with great color, when the oem software could only do crappy color at 2700dpi. The 5400dpi scan only took 60 seconds back then, and it drove me crazy. Reading that I don't know why anyone would go that route. Valoi camera scanning takes about 1/60 seconds. I can scan a roll of 36 frame film in under 5 minutes. It gives you a RAW file almost any editor can work with. It provides 12 -15 stops of DR. You get the full resolution of the camera you use. All in an inexpensive, compact form factor. It can scan a variety of film formats.
Valoi seems like an easy choice for most of us.
It’s just a slightly more expensive option given I don’t have a macro lens, but of course then you have a macro lens to use long term for your photography.
It’s probably the better option over a plustek