draacor wrote:
I made the crazy decision to buy 4 headlamps one from each brand. . . .
It appears that your "one from each brand" excluded Zebralight. Any reason why?
I suggest you order a Zebralight as well to test against the other brands. I think its bulletproof simplicity may win you over. (Though Fenix may come close, at higher weight/complexity.) Zebralight doesn't win any marketing derbies, but has for years produced amazingly competent lights.
Black Diamond. I've had four Black Diamond headlamps fail on me, and seen buddies' Black Diamond headlamps fail at least as many times. To Black Diamond's credit, they've replaced my lights, and those of friends, a few times. But they eventually said, "Enough--we won't replace these headlamps any more."
While I like Black Diamond products in general, I say nay to their headlamps. A failing headlamp is dangerous. Black Diamond seriously let me and my friends down in this regard. And when their headlamps kept failing, why limit replacements, instead of replacing them with something that worked?
Petzl. On my desk right now is a friend's failed Petzl headlamp. Pretty sure I can fix it--either by replacing a wire or an LED element. But again, who wants a headlamp that fails in the field?
Red light vs. dim white light: This as a false dilemma. Zebralights are highly programmable, and this programmability includes selectable levels of dimming. My astrophotography choice is a red Zebralight, set very dim. Agreed, a red light sometimes confuses my brain on the hike out of the astrophotography spot, in which case I switch to a white Zebralight. But for working the camera, give me very dim red light.
Diffusion. Among Zebralights, there are (at least) these diffusion choices: Flood, floody, spot. Floody is somewhere between flood and spot, and this is what works best for my perception. YMMV.
Zebralight: Solid aluminum, one button, lightweight, tough, no gimmicks. Not much marketing that I've seen--just really good lights.