fredmiranda.com Login

AI or not, and a few other things

  
 
shadow9d9
Offline
Details
p.3 #1AI or not, and a few other things
Mike_5D wrote:
chez wrote
michaeldwilson wrote
chez wrote
michaeldwilson wroteAI cannot move a penny two inches to the left on your desk. All those things requiring human activity and creativity will remain outside the powers of AI. Good wedding photographers, for instance, will always be in demand.
Wedding photographers in general in my neck of the woods are in less demand as the younger generation have less money to go around and have less interest in wedding photos…especially posed photos. My two boys had zero interest inweddi g photos…but one did have a camera for each table to allow others to document their day.
That's why I said "good" wedding photographers, people who know how to set up beautiful shots using the sun, background, clothing, etc.

Bottom line: You get what you pay for.
You don’t get it. Many young people that are getting married don’t want GOOD photos…they want simple capture the moment images like they get from their iPhones. I’ve talked to a couple of “good’ wedding photographers and they say the majority of their business is not from the two getting married, but their parents. The couple getting married don’t want that phony dressed up, nice lighting great background shot, but instead want that sporadic ugly composition that captures the moment shot.
They've grown up seeing awful photos get "great pic" on social media.


They also simply don't care, and don't have the money. And if they do, they don't want to waste it on that.
Feb 08, 2026 at 05:53 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.3 #2AI or not, and a few other things
chiron wrote:
chez wrote
michaeldwilson wrote
chez wrote
michaeldwilson wroteAI cannot move a penny two inches to the left on your desk. All those things requiring human activity and creativity will remain outside the powers of AI. Good wedding photographers, for instance, will always be in demand.
Wedding photographers in general in my neck of the woods are in less demand as the younger generation have less money to go around and have less interest in wedding photos…especially posed photos. My two boys had zero interest inweddi g photos…but one did have a camera for each table to allow others to document their day.
That's why I said "good" wedding photographers, people who know how to set up beautiful shots using the sun, background, clothing, etc.

Bottom line: You get what you pay for.
You don’t get it. Many young people that are getting married don’t want GOOD photos…they want simple capture the moment images like they get from their iPhones. I’ve talked to a couple of “good’ wedding photographers and they say the majority of their business is not from the two getting married, but their parents. The couple getting married don’t want that phony dressed up, nice lighting great background shot, but instead want that sporadic ugly composition that captures the moment shot.
Usually when there is a new technology, some forms fade but other new forms arise. With the rise of printing, illuminated manuscripts gave way to the novel. I think in an era when photographs and cameras are ubiquitous and easily used, the aesthetics of images changes, as you suggest. "Staged" photographs become less interesting; photographs made from the viewer's rather than the photographer's perspective have more emotional impact and authenticity and are preferred. Thus your son's camera-at-every-table at his wedding. But professional photographers who, like Jeffrey Ascough, can create a record of the experience of a wedding or other event,
...Show more →

Capturing the moment is what it’s all about. At my son’s wedding, you had at least a dozen people’s perspective of what that moment is which gives a totally different perspective than one guy walking around with his fancy camera. The images from the compact digital cameras were definitely good enough for social media as well as a small photo book. Too boot, there were hundreds of images submitted by attendees that used their phones. Overall, I was impressed with the result that was created.
Feb 08, 2026 at 06:10 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.3 #3AI or not, and a few other things
shadow9d9 wrote:
Mike_5D wrote
chez wrote
michaeldwilson wrote
chez wrote
michaeldwilson wroteAI cannot move a penny two inches to the left on your desk. All those things requiring human activity and creativity will remain outside the powers of AI. Good wedding photographers, for instance, will always be in demand.
Wedding photographers in general in my neck of the woods are in less demand as the younger generation have less money to go around and have less interest in wedding photos…especially posed photos. My two boys had zero interest inweddi g photos…but one did have a camera for each table to allow others to document their day.
That's why I said "good" wedding photographers, people who know how to set up beautiful shots using the sun, background, clothing, etc.

Bottom line: You get what you pay for.
You don’t get it. Many young people that are getting married don’t want GOOD photos…they want simple capture the moment images like they get from their iPhones. I’ve talked to a couple of “good’ wedding photographers and they say the majority of their business is not from the two getting married, but their parents. The couple getting married don’t want that phony dressed up, nice lighting great background shot, but instead want that sporadic ugly composition that captures the moment shot.
They've grown up seeing awful photos get "great pic" on social media.
They also simply don't care, and don't have the money. And if they do, they don't want to waste it on that.


That’s the bottom line. They don’t value the expense of a wedding photographer when there are much cheaper and in my opinion better way to capture the day.
Feb 08, 2026 at 06:12 PM
rd4tile
Offline
Details
p.3 #4AI or not, and a few other things
michaeldwilson wrote:
AI cannot move a penny two inches to the left on your desk. .


Yep, but the robots Elon's going to build in the local Tesla plant can!
Feb 08, 2026 at 06:47 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.3 #5AI or not, and a few other things
Surge or bubble?

'Big Tech Loses *$1.35 Trillion* in Market Value as AI Skepticism Grows'

https://www.breitbart.com/tech/2026/02/06/big-tech-loses-1-35-trillion-in-market-value-as-ai-skepticism-grows/

Feb 08, 2026 at 07:15 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.3 #6AI or not, and a few other things
AmbientMike wrote:
But someone still has to shoot photos of the wedding, at the wedding, etc so I don't really see AI replacing that.


Well it will have to be AI or amateur photographers since:

AmbientMike wrote:
Digital photography killed professional photography.


Feb 08, 2026 at 09:54 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #7AI or not, and a few other things

Imagemaster wrote:
AmbientMike wroteBut someone still has to shoot photos of the wedding, at the wedding, etc so I don't really see AI replacing that.
Well it will have to be AI or amateur photographers since:

AmbientMike wroteDigital photography killed professional photography.


Save it.

Go tell all the people that had to get out of photography that digital didn't kill pro photography. I'm sure they'd love to hear your arguments over semantics


Edited on Feb 09, 2026 at 10:58 AM · View previous versions
Feb 08, 2026 at 11:40 PM
johnvanr
Offline
Details
p.3 #8AI or not, and a few other things
Some people seem to have issues with change. Sure, things are going to change. The issue is whether the new tech actually improves whatever it seeks to improve. That’s where my issue with AI comes from: I believe it has enormous potential but it’s too often used for the wrong things and it’s too often, way too often, crap, whether it’s bogus information or stupid images.

And I say this as someone who studied newspaper journalism, then had to make the pivot to the internet and saw his profession decimated by that internet. Change happens.
Feb 09, 2026 at 01:34 AM
campy
Offline
Details
p.3 #9AI or not, and a few other things
I remember when I first started coming here, I was amazed how good some of the photos that were posted were. Then I started to realize that most of what I saw that had amazed me were probably average photos but were improved by very talented people with post processing skills. I'm not trying to take away their skills as a pro photographer, but you have to admit learning photoshop and others has allowed the photos that would have been deleted because of poor technique can now be saved. As for me I never enjoyed the post processing part of photography so most of my photos are "oh that's a nice picture" kind of photo. I still like and use Picassa for jpg's. I also like to shoot b&w film and to me it takes much more talent to get great photos from that than it does using digital cameras and processing software. The old wedding photographers that shot film didn't have the luxury of taking a couple of thousand shots and picking 25 for a book. What digital did to film, AI will do to professional photographers. I am not the type of person that would take credit for a photo that AI corrected and made it into a stunning photo. To me it's like hitting a golf shot close to the pin and hitting a golf shot that was wide left but hit the mound perfectly and bounced right and put the ball 3 feet from pin. It's just not the same feeling.
Feb 09, 2026 at 04:22 AM
ilkka_nissila
Offline
Details
p.3 #10AI or not, and a few other things
BigBabyMoses06 wrote:
It's coming, it's going to be worse than you think, and there is nothing you can do to stop it. It's going to impact every corner of the world, and in my opinion, decimate MUCH of the professional photography industry. Hobbyist will be fine, if companies survive the fallout from the professional side.

I believe within the next 2 years (honestly sooner probably) for my line of work (senior portraits, sport portraits, pro team / college / high school media days) people will be taking 2 or 3 photos with their cell phones (as source material for AI) and generating
...Show more →


I think for many people the value in photography is in its realism, it depicts real people in real moments and AI-generated fake photos will no doubt spread in social media but the will be considered worthless since everyone will be so tired of fake things. Yes, photographs are retouched in many cases but the degree of deviation of that from images of moments that never happened is huge.

If everything becomes free (because of low cost of production) then no one will be paid salaries and people won't have money to buy anything so society collapses. This won't happen as people realize what is going on and will value gen AI output at its true value which is zero. Hopefully the AI companies will be sued for copyright infringment and be ordered to pay compensation for the original creators of all the real images they took to train the AI models with, resulting in bankruptcies of the AI companies and then we can get back to making real things that benefit real people instead of hijacking the output of all skilled workers and replacing them with AI models to benefit broligarchs and broligarchs alone.
Feb 09, 2026 at 05:37 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Dilemma
Offline
Details
p.3 #11AI or not, and a few other things
Wait a second. They got divorced?! Not to go all TMZ here but no kidding?
Feb 09, 2026 at 11:39 AM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.3 #12AI or not, and a few other things
AmbientMike wrote:
Go tell all the people that had to get out of photography that digital didn't kill pro photography. I'm sure they'd love to hear your arguments over semantics


Maybe you should tell all the people that did NOT get out of photography, and those that are still in it, that despite digital they are lucky to have survived your death claim. Oh right, it was just your semantics.

Maybe you can understand these semantics. The introduction of digital versus film brought millions of more people into photography. That is a fact. If you can't figure out the advantages that both pro and amateurs found by using digital instead of film, you know nothing about the history of photography. Which Pro Sports Photographer do you think got the most assignments, the one that could forward his digital images that he just took to his editor in a few minutes, or the photographer that had to send his film to his editor to be developed before the editor could even see the images

Yeah, digital really killed pro photography.
Feb 09, 2026 at 12:01 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #13AI or not, and a few other things

Imagemaster wrote:
AmbientMike wroteGo tell all the people that had to get out of photography that digital didn't kill pro photography. I'm sure they'd love to hear your arguments over semantics
Maybe you should tell all the people that did NOT get out of photography, and those that are still in it, that despite digital they are lucky to have survived your death claim. Oh right, it was just your semantics.

Maybe you can understand these semantics. The introduction of digital versus film brought millions of more people into photography. That is a fact. If you can't figure out the advantages that both pro and amateurs found by using digital instead of film, you know nothing about the history of photography. Which Pro Sports Photographer do you think got the most
...Show more →

Your point is so idiotic I don't see the point in arguing with you

But go apply for one of the newspaper jobs that doesn't exist anymore, or open a portrait studio when the millions of people that you're so glad they got into photography are using their cellphones to take their own portraits
Feb 09, 2026 at 12:32 PM
Craig Gillette
Offline
Details
p.3 #14AI or not, and a few other things
It wasn't just "digital cameras," the "alchemy" went out of general photography for many people. The "guy with the good camera" also was the source of prints, beyond just running one of (or the only) the local drop off/pick up points. Mini-labs showed up everywhere and the specialized prints, the 8x10s of the classes, the sports teams, the scout troops, the "weddings," all the non pass-around twofers twin prints, became a more narrowed set of the business. Scanned film or prints were available to the masses, and printing became a "computer" process, not a dark room miracle.

Artists and presentation geniuses were still valuable but when button pushing replaced dark room chemistry, thyere were big changes. Much like when desk tops, etc., changed the world of the secretaries and data entry clerks. I stopped red-lining the report for someone else to retype, etc.
Feb 09, 2026 at 01:41 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.3 #15AI or not, and a few other things
AmbientMike wrote:
Your point is so idiotic I don't see the point in arguing with you


Only an idiot would not understand, and here you are arguing. Semantics again?

But go apply for one of the newspaper jobs that doesn't exist anymore, or open a portrait studio when the millions of people that you're so glad they got into photography are using their cellphones to take their own portraits


Well whoopee, you point out some examples to try and defend your universal claim that Digital photography killed professional photography.

I guess all those pro photographers you saw at the Super Bowl, Australian Open, and the Olympics did not get killed by their digital gear. Get someone else to explain it to you, as I don't have the right semantics.

Try repeating this to yourself Digital photography did NOT kill professional photography, just some of it. Digital photography did NOT kill professional photography, just some of it. Digital photography did NOT kill professional photography, just some of it.
Feb 09, 2026 at 02:18 PM
netexpress
Offline
Details
p.3 #16AI or not, and a few other things
Not doubt my friends! You should sell all your new Sony, Nikon, Canon, Fuji, Leica, Hasselblad and Zeiss equipment to me at $0.05 on dollar. I'm also buying lighting gear! </sarcasm>

Seriously though I've subscribed to a few AI software based systems for portrait photography and they can select the best pics and adjust them in real time while shooting. They don't replace the subject or the photographer they just make post so much easier and more precise. But they cost $$$

Obviously AI tools like denoising is helping us out. I've got some other art production type software that is improving with AI, etc.

But I look at my dads photos of Japan post-WWII. He flew over the signing of the treaty as a navel fighter pilot in a Hellcat and landed and documented everything in post-war Japan. How does AI even begin to impact that

And I look at my great uncle's photos who was a physics professor at Berkeley during WWII which are of a very personal and abstract nature - a true light warrior... can AI do that? Possibly one day, I'm not sure. Not yet.

I believe we stand to benefit. I think general AI LLMs are so far poor in non-quantitative things. Even in quantitative things and expert areas of focus general models are poor. But if trained for a specific purpose they can deliver (ex. radiology). But the point of my rambling is that specific tools can help us but they don't replace documentation of what is occurring around us or the abstract. Two-bit-adverts for "Mo's furniture store" are done and gone. Rest in peace!

The Tibetans create art and then destroy it only to create better art.

The Chinese book of changes the "I Ching" informs us that all things are in flux and all that is real is in flux.

My grandfathers last words to me on his deathbed was a "you will see much change during your life - don't be fearful - embrace it!" Indeed he saw the transition from the horse and buggy to the jet powered airplane and the first moon landing. God speed Grandfather!

So to my brothers and sisters on FM - embrace it!
Feb 09, 2026 at 03:45 PM
Kevner
Offline
Details
p.3 #17AI or not, and a few other things
In the context of this post, I think it is fair to say that the transition from analog to digital photography had a largely negative impact on the profession overall. We can see this in the following areas:

1) Collapse of the film industry resulting in the almost total loss of jobs in manufacturing and secondary industries such as film development.
2) Eventual loss of the consumer grade (snap shot) camera industry. This loss of market has a secondary impact on corporate reinvestment dollars that fuel innovation.
3) The collapse of the private darkroom and art print industry. - This one is particularly painful as pre-digital I often sold art prints for thousands. Now try selling a fine art digital print for the same value.
4) Severe reduction in darkroom support staff and retouching as digital tools are more efficient and less staff is required.
5) Reduction in print publication based image management for same reason. (Just imagine the main plot line in Ben Stillers' the Secret Life of Walter Mitty in today's digital world)

Overall, there are far fewer professionals and staff involved in photography as a career. We also see far fewer outlets for the development and advancement of photography as a creative art. Even though more photographs are being taken today, the digital transformation has radically remade the field.
Feb 09, 2026 at 04:01 PM
Mike_5D
Offline
Details
p.3 #18AI or not, and a few other things
netexpress wrote:
So to my brothers and sisters on FM - embrace it!


It's tough to remain optimistic and embrace a change whose own creators promise will make 99% of humanity unemployable effectively overnight.
Feb 09, 2026 at 04:14 PM
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #19AI or not, and a few other things

Imagemaster wrote:
AmbientMike wroteYour point is so idiotic I don't see the point in arguing with you
Only an idiot would not understand, and here you are arguing. Semantics again?

Earlier quoteBut go apply for one of the newspaper jobs that doesn't exist anymore, or open a portrait studio when the millions of people that you're so glad they got into photography are using their cellphones to take their own portraits
Well whoopee, you point out some examples to try and defend your universal claim that
Earlier quoteDigital photography killed professional photography.
I guess all those pro photographers you saw at the Super Bowl, Australian Open, and the Olympics did not get killed by their digital gear. Get someone else to explain it to you, as I don't have the right semantics.

Try repeating this to yourself
Earlier quoteDigital photography did NOT kill professional photography, just some of it.
Earlier quoteDigital photography did NOT kill professional photography, just some of it.
Earlier quoteDigital photography did NOT kill professional photography, just some of it.





Didn't really want to join a cult today, but you do you.

But the chanting sounds fun!

(No. Not really)
Feb 09, 2026 at 04:23 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.3 #20AI or not, and a few other things
Mike_5D wrote:
It's tough to remain optimistic and embrace a change whose own creators promise will make 99% of humanity unemployable effectively overnight.


Well I will let you know tomorrow if their promise was correct, or they were just using AmbientMilke's semantics and they really did not mean 99%.
Feb 09, 2026 at 06:11 PM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister