Knut. wrote:
Considering vignetting correction one has to remember that jpegs only have 8 bit colour depth. Raising the corner illumination will thus yield cleaner results if done on 14 bit raw images.
If the camera is doing it, then it's doing it before the JPEG conversion, i.e. using the raw image data from the sensor.
johnctharp wrote: Knut. wroteConsidering vignetting correction one has to remember that jpegs only have 8 bit colour depth. Raising the corner illumination will thus yield cleaner results if done on 14 bit raw images.If the camera is doing it, then it's doing it before the JPEG conversion, i.e. using the raw image data from the sensor.
Yes, but in camera this is mostly done for the not-cheap original lenses of the camera manufacturer. In camera raw conversion with proper vignetting correction is not regularly done on all third party lenses. If you revert to (cheaper) third party lenses that don‘t get in camera jpeg conversion WITH vignetting correction, you are better off with raws when doing this in post.
Knut. wrote: Steve Spencer wroteKnut. wroteRethinking this problem: What makes a lens, cheaper for a manufacturer to produce?
- not correcting distortion
- not correcting lateral chromatic aberrations
- less bright lens (f 2.8 or f4)
- more vignetting
All of these issues can be addressed in post (less bright lens by increasing ISO and reducing the consecutively increased noise in post). Performance of these „software corrections“ improves most, if it is applied to raw images,
Thus, the cheaper a lens is, the more it will profit from shooting raw and adding corrections in post. A clever manufacturer could actually exploit this: He can concentrate on the aberrations that cannot be corrected in post (astigmatism, LOCA, coma) and let the aberrations mentionen above fall as they may, knowing that raw processing will allow to ameliorate them.Actually all these aberrations can be handled very well in jpeg processing as well. Automatic processing, whether jpeg, heif, or as the file is read into the RAW converter is pretty easy with all these aberrations. It has nothing to do with what type of format being used. And yes, not controlling these aberrations does allow cheaper lenses that still produce very good results. Correcting them does have a small impact most of the time, but the impact is typically small so leaving them uncorrected to a fair degree has become common in modern lenses and especially less expensive ones.I agree that correction can be done to some extent with jpegs. But with DXO for example, the highest level of noise reduction is only available with raw images. I do not use lightroom, but for DXO this is definitely the case.
I would also expect correction of LACA and distortion to be more efficient and eating less resolution if it is done on raws as well, but here the effect might not be as pronounced.
Considering vignetting correction one has to remember that jpegs only have 8 bit colour depth. Raising the corner illumination will thus yield cleaner results if done on 14 bit raw images.
The question, the OP asked, was: „Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?“
My strong feeling is that cheap lenses profit even more from raw processing (versus sticking to the in camera jpegs) than expensive, highly corrected lenses with low vignetting, large aperture (lower ISO possible when shooting), less distortion and better LOCA correction. The latter might not need much correction at all....Show more →
I think you are misunderstanding a few things here:
1) When the camera converts a file to jpeg, it still uses the RAW file to do so. Remember the RAW file is simply what is read off the sensor, so of course any file has to start with that. The difference between saving in RAW or jpeg is just whether the camera does the processing or the user does the processing with the aid of software.
2) Distortion, vignetting, and lateral CA whether done in camera or automatically as the RAW file is read into the processing software is done by starting with the RAW file and applying automatic corrections. Only if you tweak these automatic corrections (and for these aberrations I almost never do) does it matter whether the camera applies them or the post processing program applies them. Sometimes the camera might have slightly better corrections and sometimes the software might have slightly better corrections, but I have never seen that. These corrections seem to be supplied by the camera maker to the RAW processing programs and work the same way when applied by the camera or the RAW processor. Of course the camera has these corrections from day one and sometimes there is a bit of a delay before a given RAW processor has them as this thread has discussed but once they are available in both they seem to work exactly the same way: the camera or processor applies the same adjustments automatically from the same RAW file read off the sensor.
3) Slower aperture is another matter. A slower max aperture makes it easier to make a lens with fewer aberrations. When a camera maker makes a lens with a narrower max aperture, they can typically make it both cheaper and with fewer aberrations than a faster lens with a wider max aperture. Wider aperture lenses, which typically cost more, therefore often need more corrections than narrower aperture lenses that cost less. These more expensive lenses may benefit more from shooting in RAW because they benefit from non-automatic corrections and more sophisticated processing techniques like local adjustments and layers.
The relation of cost with the need for non-automatic processing of files is probably a pretty weak relation as some very expensive lenses need very little correction with non-automatic processing but some types of non-automatic processing (like trying to correct axial CA or purple fringing) are likely to be needed with fast aperture lenses and these will typically cost more than slower aperture lenses.
Steve Spencer wrote: Knut. wroteSteve Spencer wroteKnut. wroteRethinking this problem: What makes a lens, cheaper for a manufacturer to produce?
- not correcting distortion
- not correcting lateral chromatic aberrations
- less bright lens (f 2.8 or f4)
- more vignetting
All of these issues can be addressed in post (less bright lens by increasing ISO and reducing the consecutively increased noise in post). Performance of these „software corrections“ improves most, if it is applied to raw images,
Thus, the cheaper a lens is, the more it will profit from shooting raw and adding corrections in post. A clever manufacturer could actually exploit this: He can concentrate on the aberrations that cannot be corrected in post (astigmatism, LOCA, coma) and let the aberrations mentionen above fall as they may, knowing that raw processing will allow to ameliorate them.Actually all these aberrations can be handled very well in jpeg processing as well. Automatic processing, whether jpeg, heif, or as the file is read into the RAW converter is pretty easy with all these aberrations. It has nothing to do with what type of format being used. And yes, not controlling these aberrations does allow cheaper lenses that still produce very good results. Correcting them does have a small impact most of the time, but the impact is typically small so leaving them uncorrected to a fair degree has become common in modern lenses and especially less expensive ones.I agree that correction can be done to some extent with jpegs. But with DXO for example, the highest level of noise reduction is only available with raw images. I do not use lightroom, but for DXO this is definitely the case.
I would also expect correction of LACA and distortion to be more efficient and eating less resolution if it is done on raws as well, but here the effect might not be as pronounced.
Considering vignetting correction one has to remember that jpegs only have 8 bit colour depth. Raising the corner illumination will thus yield cleaner results if done on 14 bit raw images.
The question, the OP asked, was: „Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?“
My strong feeling is that cheap lenses profit even more from raw processing (versus sticking to the in camera jpegs) than expensive, highly corrected lenses with low vignetting, large aperture (lower ISO possible when shooting), less distortion and better LOCA correction. The latter might not need much correction at all.I think you are misunderstanding a few things here:
1) When the camera converts a file to jpeg, it still uses the RAW file to do so. Remember the RAW file is simply what is read off the sensor, so of course any file has to start with that. The difference between saving in RAW or jpeg is just whether the camera does the processing or the user does the processing with the aid of software.
2) Distortion, vignetting, and lateral CA whether done in camera or automatically as the RAW file is read into the processing software is done by starting with the RAW file and applying automatic corrections. Only if you tweak these automatic corrections (and for these aberrations I almost never do) does it matter whether the camera applies them or the post processing program applies them. Sometimes the camera might have slightly better corrections and sometimes the software might have slightly better corrections, but I have never seen that. These corrections seem to be supplied by the camera maker to the RAW processing programs and work the same way when applied by the camera or the RAW processor. Of course the camera has these corrections from day one and sometimes there is a bit of a delay before a given RAW processor has them as this thread has discussed but once they are available in both they seem to work exactly the same way: the camera or processor applies the same adjustments automatically from the same RAW file read off the sensor.
3) Slower aperture is another matter. A slower max aperture makes it easier to make a lens with fewer aberrations. When a camera maker makes a lens with a narrower max aperture, they can typically make it both cheaper and with fewer aberrations than a faster lens with a wider max aperture. Wider aperture lenses, which typically cost more, therefore often need more corrections than narrower aperture lenses that cost less. These more expensive lenses may benefit more from shooting in RAW because they benefit from non-automatic corrections and more sophisticated processing techniques like local adjustments and layers.
The relation of cost with the need for non-automatic processing of files is probably a pretty weak relation as some very expensive lenses need very little correction with non-automatic processing but some types of non-automatic processing (like trying to correct axial CA or purple fringing) are likely to be needed with fast aperture lenses and these will typically cost more than slower aperture lenses....Show more →
I do not believe that I misunderstand things. It boils down to the question, which raw converter is superior: the in camera raw converter or the raw converter I use in post. In addition, will the raw converter in-camera do certain processing steps for a given lens at alI?
I uderstood the OP in the sense: If you have a cheap lens (third party lenses, legacy lens, adapted lens; whatever), is the extra effort to process it in post worth it? Or are the aberrations of cheap lenses such as nuisance, that it isn’t worth the effort?
It now really comes down to what has made the cheap lenses cheaper.
The practical implications of the statements I make are limited to the existing combination of camera, lens and raw converter (in my case DXO and Sony A1, and many legacy/third party lenses I use). But I imagine, that it can be generalized to other combinations.
1) In camera noise reduction is definitely poorer than noise reduction in post. If the cheaper lenses comparison boils down to, for example:
- GM 50/1.4 II, image shot at f2 and ISO 1600 versus
- Cheap 50mm/ff2.8 lens and ISO 6400
=> I find that putting the raw image through DXO‘s top noise reduction algorithm salvages nearly 2 stops in noise, which I do not get when using the in camera jpeg conversion of the A1.
2) Many third party lenses do not get vignetting correction when I process these images from raw to jpeg in camera. Considering the 8 bit colour depth of jpegs and assuming 2-3 stops that the corners need to be elevated on wide and ultra wide angles, this loses 1-2 bit of colour depth in the corners. Crunched colours, that I may avoid losing when processing a raw file in post.
3) LACA: On many lenses which I use on the Sony A1, the A1 does not correct lateral chromatic aberations. Thus LACA correction is not available at all, if I use in camera body raw to JPEG conversion on many cheap lenses I own.
4) Same story concerning distortion correction: It is just not done in camera for many lenses. If I do it with DXO, result are better if I work on raw files. (I know it is available for the more expensive orignial Sony lenses and some third party lenses like Sigma).
Things apear to boil down to the definition of the cheaper lens: If it is a high-tech lens (for lack of a better wording) that has the relevant parameters (vignetting, distortion etc.) stored in the lens and the lens can pass this data to the camera and the camera accepts this information for processing, then the camera may well provide a reasonable raw to jpeg conversion (but still have poorer noise reduction). If this does not work, as with many cheap legacy lenses or often with lenses of Chinese provenence, then processing raw files in post is the best approach.
I say this with some frustration, since I also do not like the time effort it often takes to do this raw to jpeg conversion in post. I often skip it, make do with the in camera jpegs, but go back to the stored raws when I want to print some of these images.
Knut. wrote: Steve Spencer wroteKnut. wroteSteve Spencer wroteKnut. wroteRethinking this problem: What makes a lens, cheaper for a manufacturer to produce?
- not correcting distortion
- not correcting lateral chromatic aberrations
- less bright lens (f 2.8 or f4)
- more vignetting
All of these issues can be addressed in post (less bright lens by increasing ISO and reducing the consecutively increased noise in post). Performance of these „software corrections“ improves most, if it is applied to raw images,
Thus, the cheaper a lens is, the more it will profit from shooting raw and adding corrections in post. A clever manufacturer could actually exploit this: He can concentrate on the aberrations that cannot be corrected in post (astigmatism, LOCA, coma) and let the aberrations mentionen above fall as they may, knowing that raw processing will allow to ameliorate them.Actually all these aberrations can be handled very well in jpeg processing as well. Automatic processing, whether jpeg, heif, or as the file is read into the RAW converter is pretty easy with all these aberrations. It has nothing to do with what type of format being used. And yes, not controlling these aberrations does allow cheaper lenses that still produce very good results. Correcting them does have a small impact most of the time, but the impact is typically small so leaving them uncorrected to a fair degree has become common in modern lenses and especially less expensive ones.I agree that correction can be done to some extent with jpegs. But with DXO for example, the highest level of noise reduction is only available with raw images. I do not use lightroom, but for DXO this is definitely the case.
I would also expect correction of LACA and distortion to be more efficient and eating less resolution if it is done on raws as well, but here the effect might not be as pronounced.
Considering vignetting correction one has to remember that jpegs only have 8 bit colour depth. Raising the corner illumination will thus yield cleaner results if done on 14 bit raw images.
The question, the OP asked, was: „Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?“
My strong feeling is that cheap lenses profit even more from raw processing (versus sticking to the in camera jpegs) than expensive, highly corrected lenses with low vignetting, large aperture (lower ISO possible when shooting), less distortion and better LOCA correction. The latter might not need much correction at all.I think you are misunderstanding a few things here:
1) When the camera converts a file to jpeg, it still uses the RAW file to do so. Remember the RAW file is simply what is read off the sensor, so of course any file has to start with that. The difference between saving in RAW or jpeg is just whether the camera does the processing or the user does the processing with the aid of software.
2) Distortion, vignetting, and lateral CA whether done in camera or automatically as the RAW file is read into the processing software is done by starting with the RAW file and applying automatic corrections. Only if you tweak these automatic corrections (and for these aberrations I almost never do) does it matter whether the camera applies them or the post processing program applies them. Sometimes the camera might have slightly better corrections and sometimes the software might have slightly better corrections, but I have never seen that. These corrections seem to be supplied by the camera maker to the RAW processing programs and work the same way when applied by the camera or the RAW processor. Of course the camera has these corrections from day one and sometimes there is a bit of a delay before a given RAW processor has them as this thread has discussed but once they are available in both they seem to work exactly the same way: the camera or processor applies the same adjustments automatically from the same RAW file read off the sensor.
3) Slower aperture is another matter. A slower max aperture makes it easier to make a lens with fewer aberrations. When a camera maker makes a lens with a narrower max aperture, they can typically make it both cheaper and with fewer aberrations than a faster lens with a wider max aperture. Wider aperture lenses, which typically cost more, therefore often need more corrections than narrower aperture lenses that cost less. These more expensive lenses may benefit more from shooting in RAW because they benefit from non-automatic corrections and more sophisticated processing techniques like local adjustments and layers.
The relation of cost with the need for non-automatic processing of files is probably a pretty weak relation as some very expensive lenses need very little correction with non-automatic processing but some types of non-automatic processing (like trying to correct axial CA or purple fringing) are likely to be needed with fast aperture lenses and these will typically cost more than slower aperture lenses.I do not believe that I misunderstand things. It boils down to the question, which raw converter is superior: the in camera raw converter or the raw converter I use in post. In addition, will the raw converter in-camera do certain processing steps for a given lens at alI?
I uderstood the OP in the sense: If you have a cheap lens (third party lenses, legacy lens, adapted lens; whatever), is the extra effort to process it in post worth it? Or are the aberrations of cheap lenses such as nuisance, that it isn’t worth the effort?
It now really comes down to what has made the cheap lenses cheaper.
The practical implications of the statements I make are limited to the existing combination of camera, lens and raw converter (in my case DXO and Sony A1, and many legacy/third party lenses I use). But I imagine, that it can be generalized to other combinations.
1) In camera noise reduction is definitely poorer than noise reduction in post. If the cheaper lenses comparison boils down to, for example:
- GM 50/1.4 II, image shot at f2 and ISO 1600 versus
- Cheap 50mm/ff2.8 lens and ISO 6400
=> I find that putting the raw image through DXO‘s top noise reduction algorithm salvages nearly 2 stops in noise, which I do not get when using the in camera jpeg conversion of the A1.
2) Many third party lenses do not get vignetting correction when I process these images from raw to jpeg in camera. Considering the 8 bit colour depth of jpegs and assuming 2-3 stops that the corners need to be elevated on wide and ultra wide angles, this loses 1-2 bit of colour depth in the corners. Crunched colours, that I may avoid losing when processing a raw file in post.
3) LACA: On many lenses which I use on the Sony A1, the A1 does not correct lateral chromatic aberations. Thus LACA correction is not available at all, if I use in camera body raw to JPEG conversion on many cheap lenses I own.
4) Same story concerning distortion correction: It is just not done in camera for many lenses. If I do it with DXO, result are better if I work on raw files. (I know it is available for the more expensive orignial Sony lenses and some third party lenses like Sigma).
Things apear to boil down to the definition of the cheaper lens: If it is a high-tech lens (for lack of a better wording) that has the relevant parameters (vignetting, distortion etc.) stored in the lens and the lens can pass this data to the camera and the camera accepts this information for processing, then the camera may well provide a reasonable raw to jpeg conversion (but still have poorer noise reduction). If this does not work, as with many cheap legacy lenses or often with lenses of Chinese provenence, then processing raw files in post is the best approach.
I say this with some frustration, since I also do not like the time effort it often takes to do this raw to jpeg conversion in post. I often skip it, make do with the in camera jpegs, but go back to the stored raws when I want to print some of these images.
Well the OP wasn't talking about third party lenses. He was talking about Canon lenses shot on a Canon camera and Sony lenses shot on a Sony camera.
It is true that third party lenses don't typically have any in camera corrections. If you want corrections, and any many of them will look considerably better with corrections, then you will have to process them in software after shooting and RAW files will have an advantage,
It is also true that software generally does a better job of noise reduction than in camera settings, but that wasn't one of the things you talked about in the post I responded to. We agree about noise reduction being better when processed with software from a RAW file.
What I was pointing out is that for OEM lenses, that in camera and software corrections for distortion, lateral CA, and vignetting are typical identical and both types of corrections are made from the RAW file. For such lenses it rarely matter if the corrections are done in camera or in software after shooting.
Steve Spencer wrote: Knut. wroteSteve Spencer wroteKnut. wroteSteve Spencer wroteKnut. wroteRethinking this problem: What makes a lens, cheaper for a manufacturer to produce?
- not correcting distortion
- not correcting lateral chromatic aberrations
- less bright lens (f 2.8 or f4)
- more vignetting
All of these issues can be addressed in post (less bright lens by increasing ISO and reducing the consecutively increased noise in post). Performance of these „software corrections“ improves most, if it is applied to raw images,
Thus, the cheaper a lens is, the more it will profit from shooting raw and adding corrections in post. A clever manufacturer could actually exploit this: He can concentrate on the aberrations that cannot be corrected in post (astigmatism, LOCA, coma) and let the aberrations mentionen above fall as they may, knowing that raw processing will allow to ameliorate them.Actually all these aberrations can be handled very well in jpeg processing as well. Automatic processing, whether jpeg, heif, or as the file is read into the RAW converter is pretty easy with all these aberrations. It has nothing to do with what type of format being used. And yes, not controlling these aberrations does allow cheaper lenses that still produce very good results. Correcting them does have a small impact most of the time, but the impact is typically small so leaving them uncorrected to a fair degree has become common in modern lenses and especially less expensive ones.I agree that correction can be done to some extent with jpegs. But with DXO for example, the highest level of noise reduction is only available with raw images. I do not use lightroom, but for DXO this is definitely the case.
I would also expect correction of LACA and distortion to be more efficient and eating less resolution if it is done on raws as well, but here the effect might not be as pronounced.
Considering vignetting correction one has to remember that jpegs only have 8 bit colour depth. Raising the corner illumination will thus yield cleaner results if done on 14 bit raw images.
The question, the OP asked, was: „Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?“
My strong feeling is that cheap lenses profit even more from raw processing (versus sticking to the in camera jpegs) than expensive, highly corrected lenses with low vignetting, large aperture (lower ISO possible when shooting), less distortion and better LOCA correction. The latter might not need much correction at all.I think you are misunderstanding a few things here:
1) When the camera converts a file to jpeg, it still uses the RAW file to do so. Remember the RAW file is simply what is read off the sensor, so of course any file has to start with that. The difference between saving in RAW or jpeg is just whether the camera does the processing or the user does the processing with the aid of software.
2) Distortion, vignetting, and lateral CA whether done in camera or automatically as the RAW file is read into the processing software is done by starting with the RAW file and applying automatic corrections. Only if you tweak these automatic corrections (and for these aberrations I almost never do) does it matter whether the camera applies them or the post processing program applies them. Sometimes the camera might have slightly better corrections and sometimes the software might have slightly better corrections, but I have never seen that. These corrections seem to be supplied by the camera maker to the RAW processing programs and work the same way when applied by the camera or the RAW processor. Of course the camera has these corrections from day one and sometimes there is a bit of a delay before a given RAW processor has them as this thread has discussed but once they are available in both they seem to work exactly the same way: the camera or processor applies the same adjustments automatically from the same RAW file read off the sensor.
3) Slower aperture is another matter. A slower max aperture makes it easier to make a lens with fewer aberrations. When a camera maker makes a lens with a narrower max aperture, they can typically make it both cheaper and with fewer aberrations than a faster lens with a wider max aperture. Wider aperture lenses, which typically cost more, therefore often need more corrections than narrower aperture lenses that cost less. These more expensive lenses may benefit more from shooting in RAW because they benefit from non-automatic corrections and more sophisticated processing techniques like local adjustments and layers.
The relation of cost with the need for non-automatic processing of files is probably a pretty weak relation as some very expensive lenses need very little correction with non-automatic processing but some types of non-automatic processing (like trying to correct axial CA or purple fringing) are likely to be needed with fast aperture lenses and these will typically cost more than slower aperture lenses.I do not believe that I misunderstand things. It boils down to the question, which raw converter is superior: the in camera raw converter or the raw converter I use in post. In addition, will the raw converter in-camera do certain processing steps for a given lens at alI?
I uderstood the OP in the sense: If you have a cheap lens (third party lenses, legacy lens, adapted lens; whatever), is the extra effort to process it in post worth it? Or are the aberrations of cheap lenses such as nuisance, that it isn’t worth the effort?
It now really comes down to what has made the cheap lenses cheaper.
The practical implications of the statements I make are limited to the existing combination of camera, lens and raw converter (in my case DXO and Sony A1, and many legacy/third party lenses I use). But I imagine, that it can be generalized to other combinations.
1) In camera noise reduction is definitely poorer than noise reduction in post. If the cheaper lenses comparison boils down to, for example:
- GM 50/1.4 II, image shot at f2 and ISO 1600 versus
- Cheap 50mm/ff2.8 lens and ISO 6400
=> I find that putting the raw image through DXO‘s top noise reduction algorithm salvages nearly 2 stops in noise, which I do not get when using the in camera jpeg conversion of the A1.
2) Many third party lenses do not get vignetting correction when I process these images from raw to jpeg in camera. Considering the 8 bit colour depth of jpegs and assuming 2-3 stops that the corners need to be elevated on wide and ultra wide angles, this loses 1-2 bit of colour depth in the corners. Crunched colours, that I may avoid losing when processing a raw file in post.
3) LACA: On many lenses which I use on the Sony A1, the A1 does not correct lateral chromatic aberations. Thus LACA correction is not available at all, if I use in camera body raw to JPEG conversion on many cheap lenses I own.
4) Same story concerning distortion correction: It is just not done in camera for many lenses. If I do it with DXO, result are better if I work on raw files. (I know it is available for the more expensive orignial Sony lenses and some third party lenses like Sigma).
Things apear to boil down to the definition of the cheaper lens: If it is a high-tech lens (for lack of a better wording) that has the relevant parameters (vignetting, distortion etc.) stored in the lens and the lens can pass this data to the camera and the camera accepts this information for processing, then the camera may well provide a reasonable raw to jpeg conversion (but still have poorer noise reduction). If this does not work, as with many cheap legacy lenses or often with lenses of Chinese provenence, then processing raw files in post is the best approach.
I say this with some frustration, since I also do not like the time effort it often takes to do this raw to jpeg conversion in post. I often skip it, make do with the in camera jpegs, but go back to the stored raws when I want to print some of these images.Well the OP wasn't talking about third party lenses. He was talking about Canon lenses shot on a Canon camera and Sony lenses shot on a Sony camera.
It is true that third party lenses don't typically have any in camera corrections. If you want corrections, and any many of them will look considerably better with corrections, then you will have to process them in software after shooting and RAW files will have an advantage,
It is also true that software generally does a better job of noise reduction than in camera settings, but that wasn't one of the things you talked about in the post I responded to. We agree about noise reduction being better when processed with software from a RAW file.
What I was pointing out is that for OEM lenses, that in camera and software corrections for distortion, lateral CA, and vignetting are typical identical and both types of corrections are made from the RAW file. For such lenses it rarely matter if the corrections are done in camera or in software after shooting....Show more →
Thank you for sticking with this. I obviously misunderstood his post in the sense, that he wanted to use his Canon glas on Sony bodies. If the question was, using his lenses on original Canon bodies, and these lenses transfer information (LACA, vignetting, distortion) to the body, then in body correction of these aberrations will probably be reasonably done as you suggest. We agree, that noise reduction may still warant raw conversion in post.
2. When the camera produces a jpg file it does so by using built-in raw post-processing processes.
3. The photographer may have some general control over the in-camera processing of the raw file, but it is limited and tends to be global.
5. The jpg output of the the camera raw-conversion and subsequent process incorporates permanent alterations to the captured image that cannot be undone.
6. Because the jpg file is “lossy-compressed” much of the original image data from the raw file is permanently lost and there is far less leeway for subsequent processing of the image.
7. Exporting the raw file from the camera and converting it during post-processing gives the photographer significantly more power over the image data.
8. If the photographer does not want or need that power, it is still possible to let the raw conversion software apply automatic conversion processes much like those in the camera, with very similar results.
9. If a photographer is always happy with the in-camera raw file generation, then that photographer may no want to bother with exporting a raw file.
10. A safe option is to capture both raw and jpg files in-camera, with the raw versions there as a backup for any files that might be rescued in post. An alternative is to just shoot raw mode and use the raw converter’s default conversions in post.
11. Regardless of what lens you use, the potential advantages of retaining raw file data are not limited to expensive lenses or to. so-called “lens corrections” or “lens optimization.” They include the ability to alter color balance, curves, noise levels, and more and to do so with tools such as various kinds of masks… and more.
Knut. wrote:
I do not believe that I misunderstand things. It boils down to the question, which raw converter is superior: the in camera raw converter or the raw converter I use in post.
Well, unfortunately we cannot really make this comparison. The reason is that, for a raw converter to 'work', it must then output a 'linear' demosaiced file with no further processing - and almost no cameras actually do that. This would be doing the raw conversion, optionally doing stuff like lens corrections, and then saving to a .BMP or .TIFF file instead of the highly lossily compressed .JPEG or .HEIF files we get from cameras today.
So there's really two things we're comparing:
1. in-camera processing
and
2. the camera JPEG / HEIF engine
The problem is that #2 has such a profound impact on final image quality that the effects of #1 cannot be reliably distinguished. We can make some observations of course but we should limit conclusions due to the limits of the comparison.
The conundrum addressed by the OP was (I was late myself in understanding this):
- If your lens does not pass information concerning vignetting, LACA, distortion etc. to the raw converter on your PC/Mac, then developing these images becomes much more tedious. Considering that he had 2000+ images to develop (raw conversion + adjustment), he felt that going the raw path with out-of-camera conversion was not worth it, especially since the in camera raw conversion + adjustment appeared sufficiently good to him.
„cheap lens“ was meant to mean a lens that gets correction of aberrations in camera, but which does not pass this information on to the raw converter on the PC/Mac. Possibly, because the profiles are still missing in the latter raw converter.
(The OP may correct me, if I have misunderstood this point)
You cannot argue with this subjective point, „is the extra time needed, worth it?“ I believe many might do with the in camera jpegs if thay have the possibility to go back to raws later when they want a better image. Thus saving both (raw + jpeg) might be the reasonable approach.
Knut. wrote:
You cannot argue with this subjective point, „is the extra time needed, worth it?“
gdanmitchell wrote:
I read that question… as a question rather than as a point.
I too think that was the question, and a problematic one to that. Everybody have to judge by themselves how long time of post-processing their images are worth.
and
The OP has now, several times, been suggested to update his software as that would save him from all, or at least the vast part, of the work that worried him at the first place.
So, I may shoot about ten real keepers a year. A real keeper is an image I judge good enough to end up in a photo book or on a wall for a long time. I can spend time on those, no problem. Your workflow may look different... ;-)
I just wanted to suggest, that it is a very personal decision how much time investment in an image is „worth it“. If you need to develop 2000+ images, you might not even have the time to do it and you may be inclined to compromise for the bulk of these images.
As Jonas said: a few of your pictures may be dear to you, in these cases you will most likely be grateful if you still have the raws available to pull the most out of the raws. Sometimes it will make a huge difference, many times it will be more subtle and at times the automatic procedure in-camera gets it just right.
As gdanmitchell has indicated. There is more to developing than pure raw processing. When you develop your image you take decisions:
- Do I want a light, airy high key rendering?
- Do I want a dark, moody rendering?
- Do I want a contrasty, gritty look?
- or a dreamy soft rendering?
The camara just cannot know which rendering is most appropriate for a certain image (and your artistic view will flow into the way you process a certain image as well). Importantly, all these things are best done on a raw image since the standard jpeg will most likely not have the latitude to allow for more excessive adaptations.
@OP:
I believe the profiles he needed for a certain lens were not available to him at the time he posted the somewhat frustrated (and a bit to general) original post. In the meantime the profiles appear available and as mentioned, the original alternatives appear moot.
I think its pretty obvious that raw is better for editing. What gets lost is that joegs can be edited quite a lot, too. Gimp basically a jpeg platform since it was 8 bit for years, here's one complicated example of stuff you could do to a jpeg:
I hate using raw thinking about how you're going to pp in the field. Just miserable. I went back to jpeg, just getting lighting and composition (mostly) right in the field, (not that one can completely get to not thinking about pp) for a few years, much happier
AmbientMike wrote:
I think its pretty obvious that raw is better for editing. What gets lost is that joegs can be edited quite a lot, too. Gimp basically a jpeg platform since it was 8 bit for years, here's one complicated example of stuff you could do to a jpeg:
I hate using raw thinking about how you're going to pp in the field. Just miserable. I went back to jpeg, just getting lighting and composition (mostly) right in the field, (not that one can completely get to not thinking about pp) for a few years, much happier
The pp I do in the field is just to send a few images to family and friends and use LR on my iPad. Really quite simple. I do all major post processing on my colour managed workstation back home.
chez wrote: AmbientMike wroteI think its pretty obvious that raw is better for editing. What gets lost is that joegs can be edited quite a lot, too. Gimp basically a jpeg platform since it was 8 bit for years, here's one complicated example of stuff you could do to a jpeg:
I hate using raw thinking about how you're going to pp in the field. Just miserable. I went back to jpeg, just getting lighting and composition (mostly) right in the field, (not that one can completely get to not thinking about pp) for a few years, much happierThe pp I do in the field is just to send a few images to family and friends and use LR on my iPad. Really quite simple. I do all major post processing on my colour managed workstation back home.
What I'm saying is, I dont want to think about pp I'm going to do later, in the field. I don't take a tablet, either
There are several layers of maturity in photography.
Realizing that lenses are more important than the body...
Realizing that technique is more important than gear...
And crucially, that finely honing your post processing abilities is more important than getting it perfectly right in camera (because that's not even possible).
There isn't a shot I take that I don't visualize as a final processed version. It's important that I give myself the best canvas for post to achieve that vision later.
Unless I’m working incredibly quickly — say for wildlife or street photography or similar or snaps of family and friends— I always think about how I will post process the image when shooting. My target is the file that gives me the best image data with which to work in post, not what looks OK coming straight out of the camera.
RoamingScott wrote:
There are several layers of maturity in photography.
Realizing that lenses are more important than the body...
Realizing that technique is more important than gear...
And crucially, that finely honing your post processing abilities is more important than getting it perfectly right in camera (because that's not even possible).
There isn't a shot I take that I don't visualize as a final processed version. It's important that I give myself the best canvas for post to achieve that vision later.
Oh please. I was reading your comments just the other day about how you shoot jpeg sometimes, in part because because it's potentially faster, in a different thread. Quit being ridiculous in your pathetic attempt to look down at me
gdanmitchell wrote:
Unless I’m working incredibly quickly — say for wildlife or street photography or similar or snaps of family and friends— I always think about how I will post process the image when shooting. My target is the file that gives me the best image data with which to work in post, not what looks OK coming straight out of the camera.
RoamingScott wrote:
There are several layers of maturity in photography.
Realizing that lenses are more important than the body...
Realizing that technique is more important than gear...
And crucially, that finely honing your post processing abilities is more important than getting it perfectly right in camera (because that's not even possible).
There isn't a shot I take that I don't visualize as a final processed version. It's important that I give myself the best canvas for post to achieve that vision later.
One of the most important levels of maturity is to understand thare are many different ways of getting to the final destination.
When I stopped trying to follow convention and follow what the normals do I improved substantially.