fredmiranda.com Login

Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?

  
 
BillD208
Offline
Details
p.7 #1Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
boldcolors wrote:
BillD208 wrote@boldcolors@@@ You can always outsource your photo editing if you want. there are some very good retouchers/editors out there
Yeah but outsourcing a lot gets very expensive


It does but if you factor it into your session fee it's a wash. I realize not everyone has a session fee but for those who do it can be worth it to open up a ton of time.

Feb 06, 2026 at 02:56 PM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.7 #2Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
Kevner wrote:
Good Gawd Man, have you not seen The Terminator. The entire movie is about the time loop of a Polaroid Photograph. The photographic print that saves humanity. Won't have prints in the future.....indeed not!


Oh... I always thought that was a Kodamatic image. It doesn't look like a Polaroid. But, of course that's not the point. Anyway, our future won't look like that.
Feb 06, 2026 at 03:00 PM
EB-1
Online
Details
p.7 #3Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
It looked like Kodamatic print (probably a Trimprint) in the movie IIRC, but there were several movies and maybe some of them used Polaroids. The polarids far outlasted Kodak after the Kodaks lost the infringement lawsuit. I liked the larger print size of the Kodamatic, but the original SX70 was a better camera than the Kodamatics.

EBH
Feb 06, 2026 at 03:19 PM
EB-1
Online
Details
p.7 #4Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
AmbientMike wrote:
EB-1 wroteWhy bother shooting with cheap lenses? Full stop.

EBH
50/1.8 is much lighter. I suppose the 50/1.2's are sharper, but i can't really justify carrying a 2lb 50mm

Its not a high percentage use fl on landscape, though a very important fl. And a bag of 2 lb lenses is too heavy.


Point taken. Some inexpensive lenses are better than more complex higher cost lenses. I overreacted to "cheap."

EBH
Feb 06, 2026 at 03:23 PM
gdanmitchell
Online
Details
p.7 #5Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
StephenS_CP wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteOr one of Musk’s robots is trained to do the photography, and AI agents then take the files and automatically process and select and send them to the automatied firm whose AIs take the files and builde and automatically print the wedding book/portfolio, and then a robo-truck picks them up and delivers them…
...and we all live in a Star Trek world where AI productivity provides for all our needs, nobody has to work for a living, money is not used, and we are free to live a life of self-fulfilled accomplishments.



That would be lovely, wouldn’t it?

Are you seeing a lot of evidence of tech bros turning their increasingly grotesque earnings to helping those put out of work? I missed that story…

The alternate trajectory is one that has been explored in literature including some science fiction, where the smaller and smaller group who control the technology wall themselves and their luxurious world off from the increasingly poverty stricken masses…

Edited on Feb 06, 2026 at 03:56 PM · View previous versions
Feb 06, 2026 at 03:53 PM
Kevner
Offline
Details
p.7 #6Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
Jonas B wrote:
Kevner wroteGood Gawd Man, have you not seen The Terminator. The entire movie is about the time loop of a Polaroid Photograph. The photographic print that saves humanity. Won't have prints in the future.....indeed not!
Oh... I always thought that was a Kodamatic image. It doesn't look like a Polaroid. But, of course that's not the point. Anyway, our future won't look like that.


You are correct sir, it WAS a Kodachrome 960 Instant camera. I had to look it up.
Feb 06, 2026 at 03:54 PM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.7 #7Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
Kevner wrote:
You are correct sir, it WAS a Kodachrome 960 Instant camera. I had to look it up.


Thank you.
I remember 1985 when Terminator premiered in the city where I live. I took my girlfriend with me, and somewhere in the middle of the film, she nudged me and whispered that she was the only girl in the theater.
In the end we both enjoyed the movie.
Feb 06, 2026 at 04:36 PM
bmike-vt
Offline
Details
p.7 #8Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
I agree with you. But be careful you might get your post deleted (again).

RoamingScott wrote:
boldcolors wroteI am actually bit surprised that we still have to fiddle with RAW editing. And by that I don't mean that the camera should fix everything in JPEG. The RAW developers are still behind in the AI tech. Sure, we have AI masking, De-noise, upscale and generative is becoming more and more common. There are also some impressive retouching tools with "one click" magic more or less.

But the basic editing is still there. AI could easily transform your image to an awardwinning master piece from a technical perspective. And I mean REALLY high end edited image that ususally takes hours to achieve. The tech is there already. It's coming slowly with AI consistency match, refernce match etc but still far from what I believe could be very much possible today.

Would Adobe be phasing out themselves? Possibly. Boring? Yes. But it would be a huge timesaver. We did outsource this back in the filmdays you know (at least I did). I love taking pictures and sometimes editing but if there are too many images to edit the fun becomes a burden. YMMV
We could just rename the thread to "why bother shooting" at that point.

Feb 06, 2026 at 05:29 PM
Karl Witt
Offline
Details
p.7 #9Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
Why bother with a cheap lens?

Been looking this thread over ...... cheap could be a lens that is MF, or super slow AF, could have sloppy focus ring, could have noisy AF motor yet be optically pleasing

I have a few that have fit into these parameters and I always shoot RAW as I feel that gives me the photographer the most control even if I don't need it.

If I have a lens that is a loser, I just get rid of it, why battle severe optical deficiencies? Or just understand them and shoot a parameter that avoids them.

Creating an image overcomes technical deficiencies at times. For me RAW is the only format unless you want predetermined outcomes.

Karl
Feb 06, 2026 at 06:57 PM
Manu-K1
Offline
Details
p.7 #10Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
I think the premise is just false; choosing to shoot RAW has nothing to do with the quality of the lens. It's a workflow choice. With time, RAW processors are getting better and better, and I can reprocess pictures taken 15 years ago with better result I could imagine at the time.

Using RAW, you can target different media and optimize the output for each of them. A picture may be oversharpened for the screen but has the right amount for print. You don't have as much control with JPEG.

HDR screens are more and more available. JPEG, being limited to 8 bits per channel, will not benefit as much as new formats like JPEGXL you will be able to produce from your original RAW file.
Feb 07, 2026 at 05:02 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

snegron7
Offline
Details
p.7 #11Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?


StephenS_CP wrote:
snegron7 wrote
kirbic wroteJust to reiterate what I stated in post #17 on page 1 of this thread, ACR (and Lr) do support this lens. Support was introduced with v 17.2, which would have been April 2025. If you have not updated lately, that is likely the reason you don't have profiles for the lens.
I'll log in and check it again. Thanks!
Curious minds want to know. Have you logged in and checked it yet?

It would be useful to us if you would provide the following:
1) the Release/version of PhotoShop you are using
2) the Release/version of ACR you are using

That might help us understand why you aren't getting the lens profile assistance (distortion, vignetting, diffraction corrections) that are causing you so much grief.

You made the same statement about the Tamron 11-28 RF in a different thread. I don't have the RF 16-28 so I haven't been able to respond to your not being able to get corrections for this particular lens, but
...Show more →


Update:

I had a chance to log in to Adobe ACR last night. Apparently there is a lens profile for my Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM! It did make a bit of a difference, but doesn't seem to help much with the distortion at the wide end. Thank you, this will cut my processing time in half!
Feb 07, 2026 at 07:54 AM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.7 #12Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
snegron7 wrote:
Update:

I had a chance to log in to Adobe ACR last night. Apparently there is a lens profile for my Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM! It did make a bit of a difference, but doesn't seem to help much with the distortion at the wide end. Thank you, this will cut my processing time in half!



kirbic told you about the lens profile and adviced you about checking your version of ACR and Photoshop, Feb 04 at page 1. That's 3 days ago and maybe it shows how eager you were to solve the problem. Kudos to kirbic and other members here who let you know or reminded you about the problem/solution though.

I sometimes find it irritating when people ask questions at forums and never get back again on the topic. This thread is a similar phenomena but worse: you have replied to people you find unfriendly but not even read (?) the good advice you have been given. It's strange and a bit sad.
Feb 07, 2026 at 09:00 AM
Erictator
Offline
Details
p.7 #13Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
snegron7 wrote:
Posting this on both Canon and Sony subforums, as I own cameras and lenses in both systems (R6II, A7c, A7iv).

Serious, non-troll baiting question; why bother shooting in RAW if you are using low end, consumer oriented, Non "L" or "GM" lenses? I currently have the following lenses for the above-mentioned cameras I own:

- Canon RF 16mm f2.8 STM
- Canon RF 28mm f2.8 STM
- Canon RF 24mm f1.8 Macro
- Canon RF 35mm f1.8 Macro
- Canon RF 50mm f1.8 STM
- Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM
- Canon RF 24-240mm f4-6.3
- Canon EF 28mm f1.8 USM
...Show more →

You could also ask, why put good oil into a cheap car motor... maybe to make it run better and get the most out of it that you can?

I always thought the opposite question was more intriguing... Why put a cheap filter on the front of an expensive lens. Spend all that money just to get degraded images?

Or, why buy the highest DR capable camera on the market, and instead of getting ~13 DR RAW files only shoot it in 8 bit JPG mode? A cheap lens is still capable of showing banding in sunsets, why not try to avoid that?

There are some cheap lenses in my bag (old MF, vintage glass) that I love the rendering of and some are capable of resolving very sharp images, at least in the center or stopped down, so I still shoot the same lossless RAW and process the same as my modern good glass. Why not give the cheap glass the same opportunity for its best DR, IQ, and editability?

If you just want the convenience of JPG and hate editing, that is a completely different story, then yeah, do your thing. The good news is, the JPG engine in some modern camera's rivals what many are capable in PP. Those with decent PP skills and that have the time and want more control, or the ability to "save" an image, tend to prefer RAW. It's nice to have choices for sure.

Eric
Feb 07, 2026 at 09:28 AM
snegron7
Offline
Details
p.7 #14Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?


Jonas B wrote:
snegron7 wroteUpdate:

I had a chance to log in to Adobe ACR last night. Apparently there is a lens profile for my Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM! It did make a bit of a difference, but doesn't seem to help much with the distortion at the wide end. Thank you, this will cut my processing time in half!
kirbic told you about the lens profile and adviced you about checking your version of ACR and Photoshop, Feb 04 at page 1. That's 3 days ago and maybe it shows how eager you were to solve the problem. Kudos to kirbic and other members here who let you know or reminded you about the problem/solution though.

I sometimes find it irritating when people ask questions at forums and never get back again on the topic. This thread is a similar phenomena but worse: you have replied to people you find unfriendly but not even read (?) the good advice
...Show more →


Wow! What is your problem today? You are aware that many of us on this site have an actual life don't you? I work for a living and I'm a bit busy. Did you not read my response two days ago stating that I would get to it as soon as I had the chance? Obviously not.

As for the "good advice" I have been given throughout this thread, you might want to re-read (or maybe actually read) my responses of gratitude. Did I snap back at the unnecessarily rude comments made by three people here? Absolutely! I don't appreciate or tolerate any type of bullying AT ALL, and I confront it head on. Since the moderators here on FM have done nothing whatsoever to stop rude, bullying comments from some people , then I address it immediately.

Now, back to the original topic I posted about; why bother using RAW when you have sub-par (cheap) lenses. Yes, lens profiles are great when you have them. HOWEVER, my particular lens (Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM) was released in JANUARY 2025, and there were NO PROFILES AVAILABLE IN ACR at the time.

My last overseas trip was in October of 2025. When I downloaded my images, there was no option to select any orofiles on ACR FOR ME at the time. Was I at fault for not updating Adobe despite assuming that because I have a monthly subscription it would automatically update? Sure. Did I update my Adobe app anyway sometime in December because I received a marketing email from Adobe talking about "taking advantage of other apps in my subscription " ? Yes. Did I think that maybe ACR might have updated to include lens profiles for my RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM? No, because it didn't occur for me to check (remmber my asumption about my subscription?).

Most likely you're probably going to cherry-pick a line or two of my response to make it fit with your narrative about me being some horrible, irresponsible troll. My response to you in advance is that I really, really don't care. If you want to make a positive difference, try going after the actual trolls who have ruined this once wonderful site.
Feb 07, 2026 at 10:03 AM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.7 #15Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?


snegron7 wrote:
StephenS_CP wrote
snegron7 wrote
kirbic wroteJust to reiterate what I stated in post #17 on page 1 of this thread, ACR (and Lr) do support this lens. Support was introduced with v 17.2, which would have been April 2025. If you have not updated lately, that is likely the reason you don't have profiles for the lens.
I'll log in and check it again. Thanks!
Curious minds want to know. Have you logged in and checked it yet?

It would be useful to us if you would provide the following:
1) the Release/version of PhotoShop you are using
2) the Release/version of ACR you are using

That might help us understand why you aren't getting the lens profile assistance (distortion, vignetting, diffraction corrections) that are causing you so much grief.

You made the same statement about the Tamron 11-28 RF in a different thread. I don't have the RF 16-28 so I haven't been able to respond to your not being able to get corrections for this particular lens, but I do have the Tamron 11-28.
-- The Tamron lens corrections have been applied to photos that I took in June 2025 and cataloged into Lightroom. I took those images 4 months earlier than the images you've posted to your "Tamron Lens ... Samples" folder, dated from Oct. 2025
-- While I don't have the RF 16-28, both Lightroom Develop module (i.e., the LR ACR frontend) and Photoshop ACR window show that the corrections for the RF 16-28 are available and can be applied even to my Tamron lens. The lens correction for that lens is clearly available in the current Adobe software releases.
Update:

I had a chance to log in to Adobe ACR last night. Apparently there is a lens profile for my Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM! It did make a bit of a difference, but doesn't seem to help much with the distortion at the wide end. Thank you, this will cut my processing time in half!


You may still want to try processing with the default lens profiles and denoising in DxO PureRAW (free to test for 30 days) and compare with the result of doing the same in ACR. Note that PureRAW exports linear (demosaiced) DNG. The demosaicing algorithm of DxO is different from that of Adobe, as well as the denoising quality. You will have to test and compare the results to know whether there is a useful difference.
Feb 07, 2026 at 10:34 AM
snegron7
Offline
Details
p.7 #16Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?


Erictator wrote:
snegron7 wrotePosting this on both Canon and Sony subforums, as I own cameras and lenses in both systems (R6II, A7c, A7iv).

Serious, non-troll baiting question; why bother shooting in RAW if you are using low end, consumer oriented, Non "L" or "GM" lenses? I currently have the following lenses for the above-mentioned cameras I own:

- Canon RF 16mm f2.8 STM
- Canon RF 28mm f2.8 STM
- Canon RF 24mm f1.8 Macro
- Canon RF 35mm f1.8 Macro
- Canon RF 50mm f1.8 STM
- Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM
- Canon RF 24-240mm f4-6.3
- Canon EF 28mm f1.8 USM
- Canon EF 50mm f1.8 STM
- Canon EF 85mm f1.8 USM
- Canon EF-S 17-55mm f2.8
- Canon EF 17-40mm f4.0L
- Canon EF 70-200mm f2.8L
- Canon EF 300mm f4.0L

For Sony:

- Tamron 17-28mm f2.8
- Tamron 20-40mm f2.8
- Tamron 28-200mm f2.8-5.6
(I used to own several other lenses for Sony FE mount but sold them all the first time I sold off all my Sony-related equipment. Several months later I repurchased an A7c and decided to buy just the lenses I used the most which are the Tamrons I listed above).

Lower end lenses like the ones that I own, rely heavily on in-camera computational corrections. When shooting RAW, you see the "true" image recorded with these lenses. The distortion, vignetting, and lack of contrast is extremely visible in the RAW images with these lensed. After spending a bunch of time on PS "correcting" the RAW images, I end up with what the camera JPEG looked like had I shot in JPEG to begin with. Serious question: why waste time shooting in RAW when I'm going to spend hours in PS correcting lens flaws? The only lens I get decent RAW images that hardly need any corrections on my part is with the Tamron 17-28mm f2.8.

Before I get the usual troll (we all know who he is) saying "you need to shoot with better lenses" or "you need to learn how to take pictures", "you're always complaining", etc., understand two things:

1. This post was meant for folks who can contribute opinions on why shooting RAW is still a good idea even though manually correcting lens issues is time consuming and yields results similar to sooc jpegs.

2. If you are that troll, move along, don't participate in this thread. No one likes you anyway.
You could also ask, why put good oil into a cheap car motor... maybe to make it run better and get the most out of it that you can?

I always thought the opposite question was more intriguing... Why put a cheap filter on the front of an expensive lens. Spend all that money just to get degraded images?

Or, why buy the highest DR capable camera on the market, and instead of getting ~13 DR RAW files only shoot it in 8 bit JPG mode? A cheap lens is still capable of showing banding in sunsets, why not try to avoid
...Show more →

No! Not the filter debate!! Just kidding! 😀
I guess I should've clarified my definition of "cheap" lenses. By cheap, I didn't mean inexpensive lenses from years past. I have several inexpensive lenses that are optically fantastic (like most of my 50mm f1.8 lenses from Canon, Nikon and Pentax).

Back in "the old days" I looked for lenses that were designed to have the least amount of optical flaws. Most of these lenses were near perfect when stopped down a bit.

Fast forward to current days. Many manufacturers are relying more on software than on optical construction to achieve good images. These newer lenses are sometimes more compact and lighter in weight than more expensive, optically enhanced lenses. They also sell for less money than their more expensive counterparts like "L" or "GM" series lenses.

And therein lies what I personally consider a problem. When looking at a RAW image taken by these newer, more compact, more "affordable" lenses, you can see their optical design compromises. Yes, there are lens profiles in many photo editing programs, but when many lenses are first released, these profiles are not readily available.

Shooting RAW does provide us with more options to edit an image to our liking, but it can be time consuming, especially when you don't use lens profiles. And this is where my initial "inspiration" for this post started: to my knowledge when I wrote the original post, there were no lens profiles for the RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM that I owned (I confirmed last night that there were lens profiles for that lens thanks to several helpful folks here). Correcting extreme vignetting, softness and extreme distortion in RAW for this lens before getting the chance to work on other image enhancements was a nightmare for me. In my very personal opinion, this was quite frustrating, and promted me to express how I haven't had this issue in RAW when using lenses that don’t rely so heavily on software (like lenses that are designed optically better to begin with). Again, I have older, inexpensive lenses that don’t require so much work in RAW.

Also, if it were not for lens profiles, most of the current, newer RF lenses I own when opened in RAW look terrible in terms of vignetting, distortion and softness. Most of my lenses are not super expensive lenses like the L or GM series, so I call them "cheap" lenses. I should've chosen a better word to describe them, but I couldn't think of one.
Feb 07, 2026 at 10:40 AM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.7 #17Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
Jonas B wrote:
kirbic told you about the lens profile and adviced you about checking your version of ACR and Photoshop, Feb 04 at page 1. That's 3 days ago and maybe it shows how eager you were to solve the problem. Kudos to kirbic and other members here who let you know or reminded you about the problem/solution though.

I sometimes find it irritating when people ask questions at forums and never get back again on the topic. This thread is a similar phenomena but worse: you have replied to people you find unfriendly but not even read (?) the good advice
...Show more →


snegron7 wrote:
Wow! What is your problem today? You are aware that many of us on this site have an actual life don't you? I work for a living and I'm a bit busy. Did you not read my response two days ago stating that I would get to it as soon as I had the chance? Obviously not.

As for the "good advice" I have been given throughout this thread, you might want to re-read (or maybe actually read) my responses of gratitude. Did I snap back at the unnecessarily rude comments made by three people here? Absolutely! I don't appreciate
...Show more →

Your WA zoom has been supported by ACR since the spring 2025. Just saying... Anyway, Adobe Creative Cloud is not their best work but you should really check the preferences and the options for auto-updating your software.
I don't care about the rest of your ramblings.
Feb 07, 2026 at 10:48 AM
Mike_5D
Offline
Details
p.7 #18Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
snegron7 wrote:
Erictator wrote
snegron7 wrotePosting this on both Canon and Sony subforums, as I own cameras and lenses in both systems (R6II, A7c, A7iv).

Serious, non-troll baiting question; why bother shooting in RAW if you are using low end, consumer oriented, Non "L" or "GM" lenses? I currently have the following lenses for the above-mentioned cameras I own:

- Canon RF 16mm f2.8 STM
- Canon RF 28mm f2.8 STM
- Canon RF 24mm f1.8 Macro
- Canon RF 35mm f1.8 Macro
- Canon RF 50mm f1.8 STM
- Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM
- Canon RF 24-240mm f4-6.3
- Canon EF 28mm f1.8 USM
- Canon EF 50mm f1.8 STM
- Canon EF 85mm f1.8 USM
- Canon EF-S 17-55mm f2.8
- Canon EF 17-40mm f4.0L
- Canon EF 70-200mm f2.8L
- Canon EF 300mm f4.0L

For Sony:

- Tamron 17-28mm f2.8
- Tamron 20-40mm f2.8
- Tamron 28-200mm f2.8-5.6
(I used to own several other lenses for Sony FE mount but sold them all the first time I sold off all my Sony-related equipment. Several months later I repurchased an A7c and decided to buy just the lenses I used the most which are the Tamrons I listed above).

Lower end lenses like the ones that I own, rely heavily on in-camera computational corrections. When shooting RAW, you see the "true" image recorded with these lenses. The distortion, vignetting, and lack of contrast is extremely visible in the RAW images with these lensed. After spending a bunch of time on PS "correcting" the RAW images, I end up with what the camera JPEG looked like had I shot in JPEG to begin with. Serious question: why waste time shooting in RAW when I'm going to spend hours in PS correcting lens flaws? The only lens I get decent RAW images that hardly need any corrections on my part is with the Tamron 17-28mm f2.8.

Before I get the usual troll (we all know who he is) saying "you need to shoot with better lenses" or "you need to learn how to take pictures", "you're always complaining", etc., understand two things:

1. This post was meant for folks who can contribute opinions on why shooting RAW is still a good idea even though manually correcting lens issues is time consuming and yields results similar to sooc jpegs.

2. If you are that troll, move along, don't participate in this thread. No one likes you anyway.
You could also ask, why put good oil into a cheap car motor... maybe to make it run better and get the most out of it that you can?

I always thought the opposite question was more intriguing... Why put a cheap filter on the front of an expensive lens. Spend all that money just to get degraded images?

Or, why buy the highest DR capable camera on the market, and instead of getting ~13 DR RAW files only shoot it in 8 bit JPG mode? A cheap lens is still capable of showing banding in sunsets, why not try to avoid that?

There are some cheap lenses in my bag (old MF, vintage glass) that I love the rendering of and some are capable of resolving very sharp images, at least in the center or stopped down, so I still shoot the same lossless RAW and process the same as my modern good glass. Why not give the cheap glass the same opportunity for its best DR, IQ, and editability?

If you just want the convenience of JPG and hate editing, that is a completely different story, then yeah, do your thing. The good news is, the JPG engine in some modern camera's rivals what many are capable in PP. Those with decent PP skills and that have the time and want more control, or the ability to "save" an image, tend to prefer RAW. It's nice to have choices for sure.

Eric
No! Not the filter debate!! Just kidding! 😀
I guess I should've clarified my definition of "cheap" lenses. By cheap, I didn't mean inexpensive lenses from years past. I have several inexpensive lenses that are optically fantastic (like most of my 50mm f1.8 lenses from Canon, Nikon and Pentax).

Back in "the old days" I looked for lenses that were designed to have the least amount of optical flaws. Most of these lenses were near perfect when stopped down a bit.

Fast forward to current days. Many manufacturers are relying more on software than on optical construction to achieve good
...Show more →

This reminds me of the time (before we met) when my wife bought a shelving unit with hex cap screws. She didn't have a socket set so she used a pair of pliers to assemble it. It must have taken half the night. It would have been faster to go buy the right tool than suffer with the wrong one. Work smarter, not harder.
Feb 07, 2026 at 10:48 AM
snegron7
Offline
Details
p.7 #19Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?


ruthenium wrote:
snegron7 wrote
StephenS_CP wrote
snegron7 wrote
kirbic wroteJust to reiterate what I stated in post #17 on page 1 of this thread, ACR (and Lr) do support this lens. Support was introduced with v 17.2, which would have been April 2025. If you have not updated lately, that is likely the reason you don't have profiles for the lens.
I'll log in and check it again. Thanks!
Curious minds want to know. Have you logged in and checked it yet?

It would be useful to us if you would provide the following:
1) the Release/version of PhotoShop you are using
2) the Release/version of ACR you are using

That might help us understand why you aren't getting the lens profile assistance (distortion, vignetting, diffraction corrections) that are causing you so much grief.

You made the same statement about the Tamron 11-28 RF in a different thread. I don't have the RF 16-28 so I haven't been able to respond to your not being able to get corrections for this particular lens, but I do have the Tamron 11-28.
-- The Tamron lens corrections have been applied to photos that I took in June 2025 and cataloged into Lightroom. I took those images 4 months earlier than the images you've posted to your "Tamron Lens ... Samples" folder, dated from Oct. 2025
-- While I don't have the RF 16-28, both Lightroom Develop module (i.e., the LR ACR frontend) and Photoshop ACR window show that the corrections for the RF 16-28 are available and can be applied even to my Tamron lens. The lens correction for that lens is clearly available in the current Adobe software releases.
Update:

I had a chance to log in to Adobe ACR last night. Apparently there is a lens profile for my Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM! It did make a bit of a difference, but doesn't seem to help much with the distortion at the wide end. Thank you, this will cut my processing time in half!
You may still want to try processing with the default lens profiles and denoising in DxO PureRAW (free to test for 30 days) and compare with the result of doing the same in ACR. Note that PureRAW exports linear (demosaiced) DNG. The demosaicing algorithm of DxO is different from that of Adobe, as well as the denoising quality. You will have to test and compare the results to know whether there is a useful difference.



Thank you! I absolutely am going to try DXO PureRAW, as I've been wanting to get away from Adobe for some time now. I really dislike their subscription model, plus they increased my monthly bill. Thanks!
Feb 07, 2026 at 10:49 AM
snegron7
Offline
Details
p.7 #20Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?


Jonas B wrote:
Jonas B wrotekirbic told you about the lens profile and adviced you about checking your version of ACR and Photoshop, Feb 04 at page 1. That's 3 days ago and maybe it shows how eager you were to solve the problem. Kudos to kirbic and other members here who let you know or reminded you about the problem/solution though.

I sometimes find it irritating when people ask questions at forums and never get back again on the topic. This thread is a similar phenomena but worse: you have replied to people you find unfriendly but not even read (?) the good advice you have been given. It's strange and a bit sad.
snegron7 wroteWow! What is your problem today? You are aware that many of us on this site have an actual life don't you? I work for a living and I'm a bit busy. Did you not read my response two days ago stating that I would get to it as soon as I had the chance? Obviously not.

As for the "good advice" I have been given throughout this thread, you might want to re-read (or maybe actually read) my responses of gratitude. Did I snap back at the unnecessarily rude comments made by three people here? Absolutely! I don't appreciate or tolerate any type of bullying AT ALL, and I confront it head on. Since the moderators here on FM have done nothing whatsoever to stop rude, bullying comments from some people , then I address it immediately.

Now, back to the original topic I posted about; why bother using RAW when you have sub-par (cheap) lenses. Yes, lens profiles are great when you have them. HOWEVER, my particular lens (Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM) was released in JANUARY 2025, and there were NO PROFILES AVAILABLE IN ACR at the time.

My last overseas trip was in October of 2025. When I downloaded my images, there was no option to select any orofiles on ACR FOR ME at the time. Was I at fault for not updating Adobe despite assuming that because I have a monthly subscription it would automatically update? Sure. Did I update my Adobe app anyway sometime in December because I received a marketing email from Adobe talking about "taking advantage of other apps in my subscription " ? Yes. Did I think that maybe ACR might have updated to include lens profiles for my RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM? No, because it didn't occur for me to check (remmber my asumption about my subscription?).

Most likely you're probably going to cherry-pick a line or two of my response to make it fit with your narrative about me being some horrible, irresponsible troll. My response to you in advance is that I really, really don't care. If you want to make a positive difference, try going after the actual trolls who have ruined this once wonderful site.
Your WA zoom has been supported by ACR since the spring 2025. Just saying... Anyway, Adobe Creative Cloud is not their best work but you should really check the preferences and the options for auto-updating your software.
I don't care about the rest of your ramblings.


Thanks for the unsolcited advice. You are now on my "ignore list" like the other 3 trolls here. Bye!
Feb 07, 2026 at 10:51 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister