fredmiranda.com Login

Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?

  
 
snegron7
Offline
Details
p.5 #1Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?


kirbic wrote:
Just to reiterate what I stated in post #17 on page 1 of this thread, ACR (and Lr) do support this lens. Support was introduced with v 17.2, which would have been April 2025. If you have not updated lately, that is likely the reason you don't have profiles for the lens.


I'll log in and check it again. Thanks!
Feb 05, 2026 at 01:57 PM
Oscarsmadness
Offline
Details
p.5 #2Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
I don't know how I found this thread, as I shoot neither Sony nor Canon. However, I have wondered this same thing.

I like sooc jpegs a lot. The camera (Nikon in my case) does a good job at correcting lens imperfections. Where the RAWs make sense is 1) when I'm working near the limits of what the SENSOR can do, 2) if I'm on a shoot and getting paid for it, 3) if I'm using a character lens.

For a lot of my personal stuff, I normally don't keep the RAWs just because the baked in corrections are so good. I record RAW+JPEG. During the cull, I delete the RAWs and keep the jpeg if I'm happy with the jpeg.
Feb 05, 2026 at 02:05 PM
snegron7
Offline
Details
p.5 #3Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?


Oscarsmadness wrote:
I don't know how I found this thread, as I shoot neither Sony nor Canon. However, I have wondered this same thing.

I like sooc jpegs a lot. The camera (Nikon in my case) does a good job at correcting lens imperfections. Where the RAWs make sense is 1) when I'm working near the limits of what the SENSOR can do, 2) if I'm on a shoot and getting paid for it, 3) if I'm using a character lens.

For a lot of my personal stuff, I normally don't keep the RAWs just because the baked in corrections are so good. I
...Show more →


Welcome to the thread! 😀
Feb 05, 2026 at 02:09 PM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.5 #4Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
snegron7 wrote:
ruthenium wroteAt first, I misunderstood your post. The answer to the title question "Why bother shooting raw with cheap lenses?" is simply: because you can (you have this option). This starting question can be mistaken for wondering why you may need raw at all, and you received some good responses from FMers who restated the benefits of processing from raw.
It is reading your (unfortunately long) opening post that gave me the real sense of your problem, quote "After spending a bunch of time on PS "correcting" the RAW images, I end up with what the camera JPEG looked like had I shot in JPEG to begin with. Serious question: why waste time shooting in RAW when I'm going to spend hours in PS correcting lens flaws?"

I understand that your frustration is actually with the process. Specifically, with the time and effort the process takes in Photoshop. Basically, to me this is a software problem, and you have two choices. One is to abandon processing raw from the "cheap lenses" altogether, as you are musing in the opening post. The other is to make changes in your processing pipeline/routine.

That second option isn't trivial, as it requires trying other software. This can be at the very least time-consuming. Many people would naturally be very reluctant to try new software after developing sufficient confidence with one product.

The simplest option you can try is probably this. Try DxO PureRAW. This app shall apply all lens corrections as well as denoise your raw, then export the result to PS where you can continue processing. I suggest this as an option, not as a sure solution to your problem. I don't know if this option should work to your satisfaction.
Ultimately, I agree with you that your present experience with PS is not worth it. It is frustrating and it kills the joy of doing photography. Yet, my impression is that your problem is a software problem, and the solution lies in making software changes.
Thank you! I have been looking into an alternative for Adobe. DXO PureRAW seems to be a favorite among many people. I will definitely give them a try! On a side note; would you happen to know if DXO PureRAW has lens profiles for the Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM? Thank you!


Yes, Canon RF 16-28mm F2.8 IS STM (RAW) is supported, and the lens corrections as well as denoising can be applied in DxO PureRAW 5 (as well as in DxO Photolab 9) automatically, with all default settings (you may need to click on the corrections to enable). The lens corrections that are avaialble: lens softness correction (sharpening), distortion correction, vignetting correction, and chromatic aberrations. For raw denoising, there are two DeepPRIME options: one is less and the other is more aggressive. This second option also does some detail refining. Of all the corrections, you may want to pay attention to the vignetting correction, because the natural vignette of a lens may or may not need to be corrected, depending on the subject, and this correction may or may not need to be at 100%.

You can check the availability of other lens profiles from DxO on https://www.dxo.com/supported-cameras/
The advantage of DxO lens profiles is that they usually work well with the default settings.

The difference between DxO PureRAW and Photolab is that the latter is meant to be used for complete post-processing from raw to jpeg and has more options (including outstanding masking options). DxO PureRAW is a basic version of Photolab, intended for those who may want to continue processing in a different app. In my work, most corrections are done in Capture One, however, these corrections are often done on denoised dng files originating from DxO Photolab, rather than on the raw files.


Feb 05, 2026 at 02:54 PM
snegron7
Offline
Details
p.5 #5Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?


ruthenium wrote:
snegron7 wrote
ruthenium wroteAt first, I misunderstood your post. The answer to the title question "Why bother shooting raw with cheap lenses?" is simply: because you can (you have this option). This starting question can be mistaken for wondering why you may need raw at all, and you received some good responses from FMers who restated the benefits of processing from raw.
It is reading your (unfortunately long) opening post that gave me the real sense of your problem, quote "After spending a bunch of time on PS "correcting" the RAW images, I end up with what the camera JPEG looked like had I shot in JPEG to begin with. Serious question: why waste time shooting in RAW when I'm going to spend hours in PS correcting lens flaws?"

I understand that your frustration is actually with the process. Specifically, with the time and effort the process takes in Photoshop. Basically, to me this is a software problem, and you have two choices. One is to abandon processing raw from the "cheap lenses" altogether, as you are musing in the opening post. The other is to make changes in your processing pipeline/routine.

That second option isn't trivial, as it requires trying other software. This can be at the very least time-consuming. Many people would naturally be very reluctant to try new software after developing sufficient confidence with one product.

The simplest option you can try is probably this. Try DxO PureRAW. This app shall apply all lens corrections as well as denoise your raw, then export the result to PS where you can continue processing. I suggest this as an option, not as a sure solution to your problem. I don't know if this option should work to your satisfaction.
Ultimately, I agree with you that your present experience with PS is not worth it. It is frustrating and it kills the joy of doing photography. Yet, my impression is that your problem is a software problem, and the solution lies in making software changes.
Thank you! I have been looking into an alternative for Adobe. DXO PureRAW seems to be a favorite among many people. I will definitely give them a try! On a side note; would you happen to know if DXO PureRAW has lens profiles for the Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM? Thank you!
Yes, Canon RF 16-28mm F2.8 IS STM (RAW) is supported, and the lens corrections as well as denoising can be applied in DxO PureRAW 5 (as well as in DxO Photolab 9) automatically, with all default settings (you may need to click on the corrections to enable). The lens corrections that are avaialble: lens softness correction (sharpening), distortion correction, vignetting correction, and chromatic aberrations. For raw denoising, there are two DeepPRIME options: one is less and the other is more aggressive. This second option also does some detail refining. Of all the corrections, you may want to pay attention to
...Show more →


Thank you!!!!
Feb 05, 2026 at 04:18 PM
johnctharp
Offline
Details
p.5 #6Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
Looks like the OP has been appropriately spoon-fed ten seconds worth of google searching, so we can lock this one down.
Feb 05, 2026 at 04:25 PM
snegron7
Offline
Details
p.5 #7Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?


johnctharp wrote:
Looks like the OP has been appropriately spoon-fed ten seconds worth of google searching, so we can lock this one down.


So, you're the new moderator?
Feb 05, 2026 at 04:47 PM
johnctharp
Offline
Details
p.5 #8Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
snegron7 wrote:
So, you're the new moderator?


I think this thread is finished.
Feb 05, 2026 at 05:09 PM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.5 #9Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?

Why Bother Shooting RAW?

Why Bother Shooting with Cheap Lenses?

Feb 05, 2026 at 05:40 PM
StephenS_CP
Offline
Details
p.5 #10Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
Post deleted by responder

Edited on Feb 05, 2026 at 07:13 PM · View previous versions
Feb 05, 2026 at 07:00 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

aCuria
Offline
Details
p.5 #11Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
snegron7 wrote:
shadow9d9 wroteAs already explained by another, this is a fundamental understanding of what the files mean. Jpeg are presharpened and enhanced by an algorithm. A raw is a blank slate with more data. So, I cannot comprehend how one can state that they like a jpeg better than a raw...it doesn't show an understanding of the material.

A person that has never used a camera and is looking for advice? Sure. But someone with experience makes it just such an odd thing to say.

snegron7 wrote
DWOfPaul wroteIf you are happy with the JPEGs there is nothing wrong with that. I usually do Raw + JPEG. I have the JPEG files for quick use and the Raw files for editing. I couldn't picture setting my camera to jpeg only, though. I find white balance adjustment alone is a good enough reason to have Raw files. Then if you do more than basic edeting JPEG files start to fall apart quickly due to the compression artifacts and limited bit depth. For example, having banding apear in the sky. It really doesn't matter what lens you use for white balance and banding to be an issue. If anything, I find my self pusing the files from "cheaper" lenses more to try and make up for the optics a bit.

Also, LR usually has profiles for lenses that get you most of the way there, so I definitely don't find my self spening hours trying to correct for lens flaws such as distortion and vignetting.

BTW I put cheaper in quotes because the flaws that are often in cheaper mainstream lenses from companies like Sony, Canon, and Tamron, are not purely to save cost, but to make trade offs such as lens size and weight. It just so happens to work out that by making a lens smaller and relying more on software for things like vignetting correction usually leads to cheaper lenses.
Thanks! I currently shoot RAW + JPEG, but I find myself liking the JPEG image much more than the RAW image (especially with my R6II).

I totally get the marketing behind smaller lens designs available a more affordable prices. However, there have been several older non-L or GM lenses I've used that are optically better than most of my current lenses. Most of my current lenses rely heavily on software and that is very apparent in the RAW files. I've also had lenses in the past that even with software showed heavy vignetting (Tamron 28-75mm f2.8 G2 which I was never happy with).
I understand your concern. I probably didn't express myself as concisely as I should have.

Example:

1. I use my Canon R6II with a Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM to take a picture of a building. My R6II is set to RAW + JPEG.

2. I get home, remove the SD card from my R6II, insert it into a card reader that's plugged into my laptop, and save my images to a folder on my desktop.

3. I then open that folder to view the picture I took of that building. In order to view the RAW version of that image, I
...Show more →

There is a simple solution... I shoot RAW + JPEG, if the JPEG looks good for my use case, then that's what I use.

However if I make a print then I want to edit the RAW file. Soft proofing off a jpeg is not such a good idea.
Feb 05, 2026 at 07:07 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.5 #12Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
aCuria wrote:
snegron7 wrote
shadow9d9 wroteAs already explained by another, this is a fundamental understanding of what the files mean. Jpeg are presharpened and enhanced by an algorithm. A raw is a blank slate with more data. So, I cannot comprehend how one can state that they like a jpeg better than a raw...it doesn't show an understanding of the material.

A person that has never used a camera and is looking for advice? Sure. But someone with experience makes it just such an odd thing to say.

snegron7 wrote
DWOfPaul wroteIf you are happy with the JPEGs there is nothing wrong with that. I usually do Raw + JPEG. I have the JPEG files for quick use and the Raw files for editing. I couldn't picture setting my camera to jpeg only, though. I find white balance adjustment alone is a good enough reason to have Raw files. Then if you do more than basic edeting JPEG files start to fall apart quickly due to the compression artifacts and limited bit depth. For example, having banding apear in the sky. It really doesn't matter what lens you use for white balance and banding to be an issue. If anything, I find my self pusing the files from "cheaper" lenses more to try and make up for the optics a bit.

Also, LR usually has profiles for lenses that get you most of the way there, so I definitely don't find my self spening hours trying to correct for lens flaws such as distortion and vignetting.

BTW I put cheaper in quotes because the flaws that are often in cheaper mainstream lenses from companies like Sony, Canon, and Tamron, are not purely to save cost, but to make trade offs such as lens size and weight. It just so happens to work out that by making a lens smaller and relying more on software for things like vignetting correction usually leads to cheaper lenses.
Thanks! I currently shoot RAW + JPEG, but I find myself liking the JPEG image much more than the RAW image (especially with my R6II).

I totally get the marketing behind smaller lens designs available a more affordable prices. However, there have been several older non-L or GM lenses I've used that are optically better than most of my current lenses. Most of my current lenses rely heavily on software and that is very apparent in the RAW files. I've also had lenses in the past that even with software showed heavy vignetting (Tamron 28-75mm f2.8 G2 which I was never happy with).
I understand your concern. I probably didn't express myself as concisely as I should have.

Example:

1. I use my Canon R6II with a Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM to take a picture of a building. My R6II is set to RAW + JPEG.

2. I get home, remove the SD card from my R6II, insert it into a card reader that's plugged into my laptop, and save my images to a folder on my desktop.

3. I then open that folder to view the picture I took of that building. In order to view the RAW version of that image, I have to use Adobe Photoshop ACR (Adobe Camera Raw).

4. When ACR shows me the RAW image of the building, it looks dark, warped, soft, with heavy vignetting, and low contrast. It appears at first glance Like a picture taken with an old, 110 film camera from the 1970's (pardon the reference, but I'm old).

5. I then proceed to "work" on the image in ACR to improve the vignetting, lack of contrast, darkness, white balance, optical disortion, etc.

6. After finally getting the image to look like what I remember the building actually looked like in real life, I open it in Photoshop.

7. I then compare it to the original JPEG image (remmber that I shot with both RAW + JPEG when I first captured the image of the building?). I realize that both images are pretty much the same; the RAW image I just finished processing AND the JPEG image hat was first captured when I took the image to begin with.

8. I then become frustrated for having spent so much time in ACR when I could have just used the original JPEG that I captured initially when I shot the image. After all, both my original JPEG and my proceesed RAW images look nearly identical; both look good.

9. My frustration = TIME spent processing that RAW image.
There is a simple solution... I shoot RAW + JPEG, if the JPEG looks good for my use case, then that's what I use.

However if I make a print then I want to edit the RAW file. Soft proofing off a jpeg is not such a good idea.


Best advice…
Feb 05, 2026 at 07:12 PM
StephenS_CP
Offline
Details
p.5 #13Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
snegron7 wrote:
kirbic wroteJust to reiterate what I stated in post #17 on page 1 of this thread, ACR (and Lr) do support this lens. Support was introduced with v 17.2, which would have been April 2025. If you have not updated lately, that is likely the reason you don't have profiles for the lens.
I'll log in and check it again. Thanks!


Curious minds want to know. Have you logged in and checked it yet?

It would be useful to us if you would provide the following:
1) the Release/version of PhotoShop you are using
2) the Release/version of ACR you are using

That might help us understand why you aren't getting the lens profile assistance (distortion, vignetting, diffraction corrections) that are causing you so much grief.

You made the same statement about the Tamron 11-28 RF in a different thread. I don't have the RF 16-28 so I haven't been able to respond to your not being able to get corrections for this particular lens, but I do have the Tamron 11-28.
-- The Tamron lens corrections have been applied to photos that I took in June 2025 and cataloged into Lightroom. I took those images 4 months earlier than the images you've posted to your "Tamron Lens ... Samples" folder, dated from Oct. 2025
-- While I don't have the RF 16-28, both Lightroom Develop module (i.e., the LR ACR frontend) and Photoshop ACR window show that the corrections for the RF 16-28 are available and can be applied even to my Tamron lens. The lens correction for that lens is clearly available in the current Adobe software releases.
Feb 05, 2026 at 07:18 PM
snegron7
Offline
Details
p.5 #14Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?


StephenS_CP wrote:
snegron7 wrote
kirbic wroteJust to reiterate what I stated in post #17 on page 1 of this thread, ACR (and Lr) do support this lens. Support was introduced with v 17.2, which would have been April 2025. If you have not updated lately, that is likely the reason you don't have profiles for the lens.
I'll log in and check it again. Thanks!
Curious minds want to know. Have you logged in and checked it yet?

It would be useful to us if you would provide the following:
1) the Release/version of PhotoShop you are using
2) the Release/version of ACR you are using

That might help us understand why you aren't getting the lens profile assistance (distortion, vignetting, diffraction corrections) that are causing you so much grief.

You made the same statement about the Tamron 11-28 RF in a different thread. I don't have the RF 16-28 so I haven't been able to respond to your not being able to get corrections for this particular lens, but
...Show more →


Haven't had a chance today because I've been repairing several watches (very time-consuming work that requires focus and precision- and yes, I was able to take a few minutes here and there to respond to this post, but firing up the laptop was not a priority today). I will definitely update you once I do. Hopefully (time permitting) tomorrow.
Feb 05, 2026 at 07:24 PM
aznduk123
Offline
Details
p.5 #15Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
For me, no one has yet called out any differences between cheaper lens and nicer lens even with prints
Feb 05, 2026 at 07:45 PM
johnctharp
Offline
Details
p.5 #16Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
aznduk123 wrote:
For me, no one has yet called out any differences between cheaper lens and nicer lens even with prints


Most 50/1.8 lenses are 'nicer' than the professional ~24-70/2.8 lenses in terms of sharpness at f/2.8 and smaller - they're also cheaper, smaller, and lighter.

But they may not be 'nicer'.
Feb 05, 2026 at 07:59 PM
MintMar
Offline
Details
p.5 #17Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
I could not bring myself to read five pages, so... Raw or not raw is a completely independent issue from cheap/expensive lenses. Raw offers tweakable white balance and beyond-8bits RGB color depth as a totally basic features. Here I conclude my case.
Feb 05, 2026 at 10:02 PM
Caleb Williams
Offline
Details
p.5 #18Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
SkippyW wrote:
This time of year, I'm shooting more indoor track than anything else. And I have a quick turn-around or else it's not relevant after a few hours. LOTS of images over a few hours to cull, and end up using almost all jpg.

BUT...the RAW file is there if I need it. It's a backup.


Similar situation to yours with other shooters I've worked with, but Outdoor T&F: Shoot all of Card 1 in JPEG for easy and quick editing work. Card two is RAW and used to for later review and tweaking for their personal use.

Obviously this is a setup where you have two card slots that can record JPEG and RAW separately where the editor only needs JPEGs and the photo themselves want the RAW for later.
Feb 06, 2026 at 12:43 AM
patotts
Offline
Details
p.5 #19Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
I shot RAW because Jared Polin/FroKnowsPhoto says so...
Feb 06, 2026 at 02:01 AM
Bedon
Offline
Details
p.5 #20Why Bother Shooting RAW with Cheap Lenses?
snegron7 wrote:
shadow9d9 wroteAs already explained by another, this is a fundamental understanding of what the files mean. Jpeg are presharpened and enhanced by an algorithm. A raw is a blank slate with more data. So, I cannot comprehend how one can state that they like a jpeg better than a raw...it doesn't show an understanding of the material.

A person that has never used a camera and is looking for advice? Sure. But someone with experience makes it just such an odd thing to say.

snegron7 wrote
DWOfPaul wroteIf you are happy with the JPEGs there is nothing wrong with that. I usually do Raw + JPEG. I have the JPEG files for quick use and the Raw files for editing. I couldn't picture setting my camera to jpeg only, though. I find white balance adjustment alone is a good enough reason to have Raw files. Then if you do more than basic edeting JPEG files start to fall apart quickly due to the compression artifacts and limited bit depth. For example, having banding apear in the sky. It really doesn't matter what lens you use for white balance and banding to be an issue. If anything, I find my self pusing the files from "cheaper" lenses more to try and make up for the optics a bit.

Also, LR usually has profiles for lenses that get you most of the way there, so I definitely don't find my self spening hours trying to correct for lens flaws such as distortion and vignetting.

BTW I put cheaper in quotes because the flaws that are often in cheaper mainstream lenses from companies like Sony, Canon, and Tamron, are not purely to save cost, but to make trade offs such as lens size and weight. It just so happens to work out that by making a lens smaller and relying more on software for things like vignetting correction usually leads to cheaper lenses.
Thanks! I currently shoot RAW + JPEG, but I find myself liking the JPEG image much more than the RAW image (especially with my R6II).

I totally get the marketing behind smaller lens designs available a more affordable prices. However, there have been several older non-L or GM lenses I've used that are optically better than most of my current lenses. Most of my current lenses rely heavily on software and that is very apparent in the RAW files. I've also had lenses in the past that even with software showed heavy vignetting (Tamron 28-75mm f2.8 G2 which I was never happy with).
I understand your concern. I probably didn't express myself as concisely as I should have.

Example:

1. I use my Canon R6II with a Canon RF 16-28mm f2.8 STM to take a picture of a building. My R6II is set to RAW + JPEG.

2. I get home, remove the SD card from my R6II, insert it into a card reader that's plugged into my laptop, and save my images to a folder on my desktop.

3. I then open that folder to view the picture I took of that building. In order to view the RAW version of that image, I
...Show more →

Do whatever you like....

Nowadays, you need to have good stuff if you want to take pictures...I mean you need good PC, good softwares and renew them.

I might need to spend money into new software and pc upgrade instead of having so many lenses

I agree with you about that most of the time jpeg are about the same if you have GOOD SHOOTING conditions.

Proceed raw is not a big deal, you have profile with a recent software and PC will work without you pay a lot of attention.
Feb 06, 2026 at 05:17 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister