Marke, The only real and seemingly primary difference between the Angenieux S21 50 1.5 lens I bought from our mutual friend John from his Leica shop in Dearborn MI, is this original Angenieux lens produces colors that appear to be a far bit more pastel and "French" in tone and not as precise and accurate in tones as yours and Fred's photographs appear. Is this due to more modern coatings or could it even be from slight differences in the glass elements? The out of focus rendering appears very similar and subjectively to me extremely desirable, so when I get my copy this week it will be more the color comparisons than the rendering which I will initially be focussing on. I really like both your samples and Fred's so personally I feel there is real hope that this new lens from Light Lens Lab will provide many of us a fresh canvas to explore our creativity with our reportage Leica M bodies.
Mark, my first thought when I read your earlier comment about “French color”, was that it could possibly be a difference in contrast? If so, coatings could be a potential culprit.
If your original S21 lens renders colors similar to a Summilux v1 or a Summarit f1.5, which certainly render very pastel ( or at least my copies do), maybe it’s at least an expression/ evidence of very low contrast…
All images were taken wide open at f/1.5 under varying lighting conditions and subject distances.
Post-processing was kept minimal -- just a bit of sharpening and slight exposure tweaks. I used the Adobe Standard profile to better highlight the lens's natural color rendering.
I originally planned to dive straight into testing the lens for resolution and other technical traits, but honestly, I've just been having too much fun shooting with it.
That said, not to worry, I'll still be testing the lens thoroughly for resolution, distortion, coma, and more.
LEICA M10-PLight Lens Lab 50mm f/1.5 Z21 lens50mm1/4000s200 ISO-0.7 EV
LEICA M10-PLight Lens Lab 50mm f/1.5 Z21 lens50mm1/800s200 ISO-0.7 EV
LEICA M10-PLight Lens Lab 50mm f/1.5 Z21 lens50mm1/4000s200 ISO-0.7 EV
LEICA M10-PLight Lens Lab 50mm f/1.5 Z21 lens50mm1/4000s200 ISO-0.7 EV
LEICA M10-PLight Lens Lab 50mm f/1.5 Z21 lens50mm1/4000s200 ISO-0.7 EV
LEICA M10-PLight Lens Lab 50mm f/1.5 Z21 lens50mm1/4000s200 ISO-0.7 EV
LEICA M10-PLight Lens Lab 50mm f/1.5 Z21 lens50mm1/3200s200 ISO-0.7 EV
LEICA M10-PLight Lens Lab 50mm f/1.5 Z21 lens50mm1/4000s200 ISO-0.7 EV
After shooting with the Light Lens Lab 50mm f/1.5 Z21 for a few days, I got a clearer feel for how the lens performs and where it truly shines. I also realized that some compositions don't quite suit my personal shooting style when using this lens.
I usually frame my subject near the center and prefer pairing the lens with a higher MP body like the M10-R. This approach limits how I can compose scenes, but it also becomes a creative constraint that helps me see the world differently. When I want an off-center composition, I would prefer to crop slightly in post than use focus-and-recompose. That's because as you move toward or beyond the rule-of-thirds area, there's a noticeable drop in resolution/contrast and an increase in astigmatism.
I also avoid shooting subjects that span from the center to the edges while staying on the same focal plane. In those situations, the falloff in sharpness and contrast becomes quite noticeable and, in my view, a bit distracting (see example below). There's also pronounced outward field curvature at mid-distance that adds to that effect. You will notice in the image below that both the center and the very top corners are within the plane of focus, while the areas in between fall out..
Overall, I find the Z21 performs best when the subject is centered and doesn't extend too far outward. When that's the case, the natural drop-off in resolution and contrast actually helps with subject separation...almost working like an additional layer of blur to isolate the center more effectively.
Here's an example of the kind of compositions I usually avoid with this lens.
LEICA M10-RLight Lens Lab 50mm f/1.5 Z21 lens50mm1/2000s100 ISO-0.7 EV
I bet if someone posted some photos taken with a cheap Minolta MD 50mm f1.4 and said that this is some special, rather expensive Leica lens, there also will be people who defend the bokeh and rendering as really special and the lens as "worth the price".
There is much bullshit around, just like in the HiFi realm where old dudes with too much money believe that their golden USB cables sound significantly better.
As you can see from the comparison, the Z21 has greater contrast and sharpness than the S21. And I think that's bad. LLL, trying to improve these qualities, are following the path of Sigma, and as a result, you get a picture in which insignificant small details are brought to the foreground, which destroy the integral image created by vintage film optics.
The S21 does not push out small details, but it does not lose detail either. Small details are covered with a delicate veil that has nothing to do with blurriness. This characteristic of the lens should not have been removed. The S21 picture looks more harmonious, while the Z21 tears the integral image with exaggerated contrast and sharpness, right up to the appearance of moire.
When lens manufacturers realize what makes an image more artistic, then they will stop chasing sharpness. In the meantime, we have what we have.
*
Below you can find out what qualities artistic photography should have according to the famous Soviet artist Ilya Repin (1844-1930).
Ilya Repin on Photography as an Art (P. Lelyukhin. Magazine "Soviet Photo" No. 14, 1938)
It would be of interest to Soviet readers to read the statements of the famous Russian artist Ilya Repin on photography and on the conditions under which photography can be recognized as art.
In order to preserve the true meaning of his judgments as fully as possible, I will allow myself to reproduce the very setting of one of the conversations, during which the great artist expressed his attitude to photography with extraordinary clarity and vividness.
Repin examined a number of photographs, giving one or another comment on those that attracted his attention.
Finally, it was the turn of one landscape. The picture depicted the famous equestrian figure of Peter I on Senate Square, but it was not taken quite as usual. The picture was taken in the Alexander Garden.
In the foreground there were bushes in a fairly large plan, and in the middle of the picture, right from the bushes, a Falconet-like figure of Peter on horseback stood out beautifully. Nothing superfluous. This picture made a far from bad impression.
Looking at it, Repin remarked: "This could have been a good picture; its composition is not bad, but in this form, of course, it is no good."
Since I was literally amazed by such merciless criticism of a photograph that seemed excellent to me, Repin lingered on it and with the utmost completeness and clarity expressed his thoughts on the boundaries of photography as an art.
"Look," said Ilya Efimovich, "What do we see in this picture? Here, in the foreground, there are bushes of greenery; my eye can easily distinguish each individual leaf, and on the leaves you can count all the veins. Where is this good for?
What do we see in nature when we look at this Landscape? We see simply a green spot from which the figure of Peter on horseback emerges. No leaves, and certainly no veins on the leaves. Secondary details have obscured the main content of the picture.
After all, it is not what the lens sees that needs to be photographed, but what our eye sees, what the artist wanted to express.
I do not deny that there are cases when, in fact, it is necessary to take exactly such a protocol photo, and in such a way that the more fully it conveys all the subtle details of the original, the better. I just do not agree to recognize such a photo as a work of art, no matter how masterfully it is executed.
Only that photograph can claim to be a work of art, the subject of which is this or that artistic image, because outside of an artistic image there can be no art at all.
A photographer-artist must be able to reflect in a photo his attitude to the subject he depicts - only in this case can an artistic work, a work of art, be created.
These simple and convincing words were a revelation to me. The great artist demanded from photography not a pathetic copying of nature, but creativity!
I began to work hard on myself in order to put into practice the precepts of the great teacher, especially since in my soul I fully shared them. Apparently, I understood him correctly.
One day I showed I. E. Repin a landscape I had taken in Pavlovsk Park.
It was a pond surrounded by greenery, trees, with a white bridge thrown across the middle. This entire panorama was beautifully reflected in the water.
But in this picture you couldn’t see a single leaf, not a single blade of grass: the beautiful pond was framed by solid patches of greenery of various tones.
“Now this is a different matter!” said Ilya Efimovich, looking closely at the picture. “Look! There is nothing superfluous here, no accumulation of small details, leaves, grass, but there is a lot of mood! This is exactly how you should take a landscape!”...Show more →
As you can see from the comparison, the Z21 has greater contrast and sharpness than the S21. And I think that's bad. LLL, trying to improve these qualities, are following the path of Sigma, and as a result, you get a picture in which insignificant small details are brought to the foreground, which destroy the integral image created by vintage film optics.
The S21 does not push out small details, but it does not lose detail either. Small details are covered with a delicate veil that has nothing to do with blurriness. This characteristic of the lens should not have been removed. The S21 picture looks more harmonious, while the Z21 tears the integral image with exaggerated contrast and sharpness, right up to the appearance of moire.
When lens manufacturers realize what makes an image more artistic, then they will stop chasing sharpness. In the meantime, we have what we have.
*
Below you can find out what qualities artistic photography should have according to the famous Soviet artist Ilya Repin (1844-1930).
Ilya Repin on Photography as an Art (P. Lelyukhin. Magazine "Soviet Photo" No. 14, 1938)
...Show more →Earlier quoteIt would be of interest to Soviet readers to read the statements of the famous Russian artist Ilya Repin on photography and on the conditions under which photography can be recognized as art.
In order to preserve the true meaning of his judgments as fully as possible, I will allow myself to reproduce the very setting of one of the conversations, during which the great artist expressed his attitude to photography with extraordinary clarity and vividness.
Repin examined a number of photographs, giving one or another comment on those that attracted his attention.
Finally, it was the turn of one landscape. The picture depicted the famous equestrian figure of Peter I on Senate Square, but it was not taken quite as usual. The picture was taken in the Alexander Garden.
In the foreground there were bushes in a fairly large plan, and in the middle of the picture, right from the bushes, a Falconet-like figure of Peter on horseback stood out beautifully. Nothing superfluous. This picture made a far from bad impression.
Looking at it, Repin remarked: "This could have been a good picture; its composition is not bad, but in this form, of course, it is no good."
Since I was literally amazed by such merciless criticism of a photograph that seemed excellent to me, Repin lingered on it and with the utmost completeness and clarity expressed his thoughts on the boundaries of photography as an art.
"Look," said Ilya Efimovich, "What do we see in this picture? Here, in the foreground, there are bushes of greenery; my eye can easily distinguish each individual leaf, and on the leaves you can count all the veins. Where is this good for?
What do we see in nature when we look at this Landscape? We see simply a green spot from which the figure of Peter on horseback emerges. No leaves, and certainly no veins on the leaves. Secondary details have obscured the main content of the picture.
After all, it is not what the lens sees that needs to be photographed, but what our eye sees, what the artist wanted to express.
I do not deny that there are cases when, in fact, it is necessary to take exactly such a protocol photo, and in such a way that the more fully it conveys all the subtle details of the original, the better. I just do not agree to recognize such a photo as a work of art, no matter how masterfully it is executed.
Only that photograph can claim to be a work of art, the subject of which is this or that artistic image, because outside of an artistic image there can be no art at all.
A photographer-artist must be able to reflect in a photo his attitude to the subject he depicts - only in this case can an artistic work, a work of art, be created.
These simple and convincing words were a revelation to me. The great artist demanded from photography not a pathetic copying of nature, but creativity!
I began to work hard on myself in order to put into practice the precepts of the great teacher, especially since in my soul I fully shared them. Apparently, I understood him correctly.
One day I showed I. E. Repin a landscape I had taken in Pavlovsk Park.
It was a pond surrounded by greenery, trees, with a white bridge thrown across the middle. This entire panorama was beautifully reflected in the water.
But in this picture you couldn’t see a single leaf, not a single blade of grass: the beautiful pond was framed by solid patches of greenery of various tones.
“Now this is a different matter!” said Ilya Efimovich, looking closely at the picture. “Look! There is nothing superfluous here, no accumulation of small details, leaves, grass, but there is a lot of mood! This is exactly how you should take a landscape!”
interesting.......Reading this I am thinking I ought to capture some photos with a Jupiter 8 sonnar and so some comparisons with some of the modern clones of vintage lenses...... ! Might have to put that on the agenda soon.
Which picture looks more artistic? Cooke (top). Which picture is sharper and has more contrast? Sigma (bottom). If you are an artist, do not judge lenses only by sharpness tests, especially by crops. Judge the whole image.
As you can see from the comparison, the Z21 has greater contrast and sharpness than the S21. And I think that's bad. LLL, trying to improve these qualities, are following the path of Sigma, and as a result, you get a picture in which insignificant small details are brought to the foreground, which destroy the integral image created by vintage film optics.
The S21 does not push out small details, but it does not lose detail either. Small details are covered with a delicate veil that has nothing to do with blurriness. This characteristic of the lens should not have been removed. The S21 picture looks more harmonious, while the Z21 tears the integral image with exaggerated contrast and sharpness, right up to the appearance of moire.
When lens manufacturers realize what makes an image more artistic, then they will stop chasing sharpness. In the meantime, we have what we have.
*
Below you can find out what qualities artistic photography should have according to the famous Soviet artist Ilya Repin (1844-1930).
Ilya Repin on Photography as an Art (P. Lelyukhin. Magazine "Soviet Photo" No. 14, 1938)
...Show more →Earlier quoteIt would be of interest to Soviet readers to read the statements of the famous Russian artist Ilya Repin on photography and on the conditions under which photography can be recognized as art.
In order to preserve the true meaning of his judgments as fully as possible, I will allow myself to reproduce the very setting of one of the conversations, during which the great artist expressed his attitude to photography with extraordinary clarity and vividness.
Repin examined a number of photographs, giving one or another comment on those that attracted his attention.
Finally, it was the turn of one landscape. The picture depicted the famous equestrian figure of Peter I on Senate Square, but it was not taken quite as usual. The picture was taken in the Alexander Garden.
In the foreground there were bushes in a fairly large plan, and in the middle of the picture, right from the bushes, a Falconet-like figure of Peter on horseback stood out beautifully. Nothing superfluous. This picture made a far from bad impression.
Looking at it, Repin remarked: "This could have been a good picture; its composition is not bad, but in this form, of course, it is no good."
Since I was literally amazed by such merciless criticism of a photograph that seemed excellent to me, Repin lingered on it and with the utmost completeness and clarity expressed his thoughts on the boundaries of photography as an art.
"Look," said Ilya Efimovich, "What do we see in this picture? Here, in the foreground, there are bushes of greenery; my eye can easily distinguish each individual leaf, and on the leaves you can count all the veins. Where is this good for?
What do we see in nature when we look at this Landscape? We see simply a green spot from which the figure of Peter on horseback emerges. No leaves, and certainly no veins on the leaves. Secondary details have obscured the main content of the picture.
After all, it is not what the lens sees that needs to be photographed, but what our eye sees, what the artist wanted to express.
I do not deny that there are cases when, in fact, it is necessary to take exactly such a protocol photo, and in such a way that the more fully it conveys all the subtle details of the original, the better. I just do not agree to recognize such a photo as a work of art, no matter how masterfully it is executed.
Only that photograph can claim to be a work of art, the subject of which is this or that artistic image, because outside of an artistic image there can be no art at all.
A photographer-artist must be able to reflect in a photo his attitude to the subject he depicts - only in this case can an artistic work, a work of art, be created.
These simple and convincing words were a revelation to me. The great artist demanded from photography not a pathetic copying of nature, but creativity!
I began to work hard on myself in order to put into practice the precepts of the great teacher, especially since in my soul I fully shared them. Apparently, I understood him correctly.
One day I showed I. E. Repin a landscape I had taken in Pavlovsk Park.
It was a pond surrounded by greenery, trees, with a white bridge thrown across the middle. This entire panorama was beautifully reflected in the water.
But in this picture you couldn’t see a single leaf, not a single blade of grass: the beautiful pond was framed by solid patches of greenery of various tones.
“Now this is a different matter!” said Ilya Efimovich, looking closely at the picture. “Look! There is nothing superfluous here, no accumulation of small details, leaves, grass, but there is a lot of mood! This is exactly how you should take a landscape!”
I know that the majority likely disagrees, but this is exactly why, when I had both the Voigtlander 50/1 Nokton and the Leica Noctilux 50/1, I clearly preferred the Noctilux. It had nothing to do with blind brand loyalty. And why, after buying the TTArtisan 75/1.5 and comparing it to my pre-war CZJ Biotar 75/1.5, with many more examples than I posted here, I sold the TTArtisan and send the Biotar to Kanto camera for a CLA. And why, after exhaustively looking at image comparisons from the LLL 50/2 Rigid clone to the original Leica Rigid, I bought an original Rigid instead of the LLL, And why, after looking at LLL early promo comparisons of the LLL Z21 and the Angenieux S21, iI knew I didn’t want either one, but would have preferred the Angenieux in any case. The differences may be subtle, but the resulting “look” isn’t always subtle. IMO.
Maybe the LLL 50/1.2 Noctilux clone avoided the temptation of being sharper and contrastier than the original, not sure.
People like what they like and make purchases based on their goals, hopefully, and it’s all well and good either way. Speaking only for myself, the goal of most of the recreations, excellent in their own way, remind me of Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “The Birthmark”. Maybe the small “improvements” kill the one thing that made the originals so uniquely loved in the first place.
There are some interesting discussions going on there about what’s a photo, what’s a picture and what’s an image and what are the objective qualities of one or the other.
The lens is not an easy one but I feel it’s got a ton of potential.
A few practice shots.
I worked at a motion picture camera rental house in LA at the launch of the viable digital cinema camera era. Throughout most of 2007, the ARRI ST/LT where the top-of-the-line cameras. They cost as much as a house (well, maybe not in LA, but a house in most of the US). The most in-demand lenses were Cooke S4's and ARRI/Zeiss Ultra and Master Primes. On film, the performance of those lenses was stellar. People made art. Then, in late 2007/early 2008 the Red One launched and it only cost as much as a nice car and suddenly every DP had to reconsider what lenses they wanted. Digital, even at that early stage, was sharper than film. Master Primes became passé; Speed Panchros, Super Speeds and Super Baltars became the rage.
My point, I guess is, a part of photography-as-art is pragmatism (and also fashion) which is informed by a variety of factors (not least of which is recording media). As a person that (basically) only shoots film, I would prefer the slightly sharper version of a lens over the softer vintage correct counterpart as the media that I use inherently limits the perception of sharpness.
A small example - I have the LLL '1966' and it's basically too soft to reliably use on film. I also have the Voigtlander 50mm f/1 and its film results are fantastic. But, (in the rare instance) when I shoot on digital, I much prefer the look I get from the LLL. As for the LLL Z21, I like the look enough, but I get the feeling that shooting it with a film M might frustrate me. YMMV.
I noticed that the Z21 has significantly more chromatic aberrations than the S21. They appear not only against very bright areas of the image, such as the sky, a sunlit wall, but even against a white, not very bright sheet of paper. The blue fringing around the black lines and text in the test images really spoils the picture.
Listopad44 wrote:
Which picture looks more artistic? Cooke (top). Which picture is sharper and has more contrast? Sigma (bottom). If you are an artist, do not judge lenses only by sharpness tests, especially by crops. Judge the whole image.
I think the LLL 50/2 Speed Panchro II captures the spirit of the Cooke character, but it's not an exact optical match. From the comparisons I've seen, the LLL lens offers similarly warm, reddish tones and that signature glow many associate with the classic Cooke look.
I'll post a resolution comparison between the LLL 50/2 Speed Panchro II and the LLL 50/1.5 Z21, but I can already say they look very different. The SP2 has much flatter field curvature and more consistent performance across the entire frame. It's one of the only "classic" lenses I own that resolves well at the center, mid-field, and corners. The evenness is impressive, even though contrast remains low, which is part of the lens's character. On the other hand, lenses like the Z21 and "f/1.2 1966" show much more field curvature and dips in resolution throughout the frame.
From the images you posted above, I definitely prefer the look of the "Cooke" over the modern Sigma.