MKuran
Offline
• • •
Upload & Sell: On
|
Here was DxOs response to my question. Maybe it will help maybe not.
(Support & Assistance)
May 8, 2025, 3:47 AM GMT+2
Hello Michael,
Thank you for reaching out and for sharing your thoughtful questions and photography background.
We truly appreciate your interest in DxO products, and we understand how important it is to choose the right tool, especially when it comes to the critical task of noise reduction in high-quality wildlife photography.
First, we would like to acknowledge your experience and the care you're taking in evaluating your purchase especially considering your use of professional gear like the Nikon D9 and premium AF-S telephoto lenses. It's clear you're striving for the best in image quality, and we're here to help you.
Both DxO PureRAW 5 and DxO PhotoLab 8 Elite share the same underlying denoising technology, including the acclaimed DeepPRIME and DeepPRIME XD algorithms. As a result, the core noise reduction performance is effectively identical between the two applications.
However, the distinction lies in workflow and editing flexibility:
DxO PureRAW 5 is optimized for photographers who prefer to perform denoising and optical corrections as a preprocessing step before continuing their workflow in Photoshop or Lightroom. It excels in delivering clean, linear DNGs without requiring manual image adjustments.
DxO PhotoLab 8 , on the other hand, is a full-featured RAW editor. In addition to the same denoising engine, it offers advanced local adjustments, color and tone control, and masking tools. For users seeking a more hands-on and all-in-one editing environment, it provides extensive creative control.
Since you've worked extensively with Photoshop, PureRAW 5 was a logical and strong choice to fit into your existing pipeline. But if you're now exploring more comprehensive editing options or feel you'd benefit from localized control before exporting—PhotoLab 8 might be worth considering in addition to, not instead of, PureRAW.
We’ve heard community discussions as well regarding preferences between versions. However, please rest assured that PureRAW 5 builds upon v4 with performance improvements and usability enhancements. While subjective preference can vary (especially regarding interface changes or specific processing behaviors), PureRAW 5 continues to use the same DeepPRIME XD engine that delivers state-of-the-art results.
Unfortunately, earlier versions like PureRAW 4 are no longer available for download, and there is no official rollback option for already upgraded licenses.
What we can suggest:
If your sole goal is the highest quality denoising with minimal manual intervention, PureRAW 5 remains the most efficient solution, especially with your Nikon D9 and long-lens setup.
If you're now looking to gain more manual control post-denoising, or explore an all-in-one alternative, PhotoLab 8 can be trialed separately to evaluate how it fits into your broader editing workflow.
We hope this provides clarity and helps you feel confident in your purchase decision. If you have additional questions, we’d be more than happy to assist.
Kind regards,
DxO Labs Support Team
|
