fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2025 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2025Canon user here

  
 
AmbientMike
Offline
[X]
Details
p.2 #1Canon user here

john54 wrote:
I have lots of Canon gear. DSLR and multiple lenses.
I see a lot of good stuff regarding Mirrorless. However, at 70 years old, I can't find a good reason to switch to Mirrorless equipment. Am I wrong?

Thanks to all


I don't really think you are.

The 5DsR is still the highest mp Canon , and one of the highest available, it turns 10 this year. So it's not like it used to be, the iq seems like it's pretty similar vs older bodies. Are you having issues with your DSLR gear?

Mostly I got sick of hearing about mirrorless, especially Sony, on here, and have little intetest in mirrorless even though I was an early adopter. Once I saw everything going mirrorless and not having a choice between DSLR or mirrorless, pretty big negative. Pretty tech fatigued and I'll probably go some day, but 30fps isn't appealing, I don't shoot enough portraits to make eye af really appealing no real plans to go mirrorless might even avoid it, if I'm not already
Apr 01, 2025 at 09:25 AM
Carlo_M
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Canon user here
With regards to the EVF vs OVF...

I can agree to a certain extent that a bad-to-mediocre EVF has some definite trade-offs and drawbacks to a traditional and it definitely comes down to preference (e.g. which trade-offs are less in conflict with your personal preferences). I would include up to the quality of the EVF of the R6ii in that statement, a viewfinder I liked and successfully used for over a year, yet would still have certain longings for some OVF features (mostly around visual clarity).

With the R5ii EVF, nearly all of the trade-offs are gone, at least to my mind. And all of the benefits of an EVF are magnified over an OVF. Especially blackout free shooting and noiseless shooting: I'm not talking about silent shooting mode, bur rather turning the sound off and still retaining full performance of the electronic shutter whose performance in the R5ii is nearly indistinguishable from the mechanical or EFCS results.

I specifically went with the R5ii because I wanted 8K shooting, and my local Samy's didn't have an R1 in stock. I'm glad they didn't and it was a relatively easy choice for me, because when I went back a few months later and looked at the EVF in the R1...it would have made the camera choice a more agonizing one because holy moly is the R1 EVF incredible. In my limited experience with it, the R1 EVF basically eliminates any benefit of an OVF with its clarity, size and performance.
Apr 01, 2025 at 09:34 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Canon user here
john54 wrote:
. . . 70 years old . . . I can't find a good reason to switch to Mirrorless equipment . . .


What are your typical photographic subjects? That might help steer the discussion!

lemmy shoyu wrote:
Web search will reveal that RF 800mm F5.6 L and RF 1200mm F8 L suck like a tornado.


The only thing those lenses suck is a lot of money out of your wallet/account. Based on image samples and feedback by users with those lenses here on FM, image quality is not one of the areas where these suck. But if you want to wade into the internet discussion about these lenses 'simply' being the old EF v3 lenses with a custom 2x converter permanently attached, you're going to get a lot of opinions. Other opinions revolve around whether the flexibility of a 400 or 600 with TCs is more valuable than a fixed 800 or 1200. This of course depends on what each photographer needs/wants/expects. If you're reach limited even at 1200mm, then a 600 with TCs doesn't really offer more, whereas with the 1200 you can still add TCs (atmospheric issues notwithstanding). Having spoken to someone at Canon about the rationale behind these lenses, I suspect their development was not just aimed at niche photographers, but maybe more so at niche institutional/governmental needs (think LEAF - Law Enforcement & Armed Forces).

As for RF lenses in general compared to EF, every RF upgrade I have made has optically and functionally outperformed the EF equivalent. That's not to say all are such clear-cut 'wins' for RF.
Apr 01, 2025 at 09:38 AM
kirbic
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Canon user here
I (sorta) resemble the OP, in that I'm 66. I made the leap to mirrorless a bit less than 2 years ago (to the R5, from the 5D Mk IV). I will not look back, in fact I am considering replacing the 5D IV with a second R5.
My experience with the RF lenses is that many (not all) are quite superior to their EF brethren (I'm thinking the 85/1.2, the 135/1.8, the 100-500 4.5-7.1...
For me the AF performance is what makes the mirrorless bodies so compelling. I just shot a wedding casually (unpaid as a gift to the bride and groom) and just had fun. Nailed focus with beautiful consistency in scenarios where a DSLR would have struggled.
It's been posted before in this thread, but the main thing is having fun. For me, mirrorless has been a *lot* of fun!
Apr 01, 2025 at 10:17 AM
rrxjon
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Canon user here
OP, I'm older than you, and while all the many advantages of RF system previously noted are true, there is a disadvantage that may or may not be relevant here, possibly age related. Having shot sports, events, portraits, name it, since spooling film in a darkroom, digital photography always seemed to be making shooting, processing, touching up, printing etc, easier, faster, better. Setting up the R5 over a year ago turned into an exercise in teeth grinding frustration for me. The manual is something like a thousand pages, and there are only so many utube vids you can watch before inducing narcolepsy. Took me over a month to get it set up to shoot without having to think about it anymore- there is so much customization (some even with contradictory quirks), well, the point of all this jabber is my teeth are smoother, and I adapted to spooling film in the dark without as many spikes in blood pressure. If you shoot a variety of subjects there is a hump to get over, but if you do you may grudgingly admit to the improvement.
Apr 01, 2025 at 11:19 AM
osidesurfer
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Canon user here
If you shoot sports or wildlife, there are good reasons to upgrade because of the major autofocus improvements. If you take pictures of people and you feel like you miss focus too often, the eye tracking features in the mirrorless cameras virtually eliminate that. If you have an old DSLR and you feel like it doesn't have enough dynamic range to lift shadows, a newer camera (DSLR or mirrorless) will help with this. If the above isn't true for you, your current DSLR is fine. Any DSLR from the past 20 or so years will produce great images.

Kevin
Apr 01, 2025 at 12:03 PM
EB-1
Online
Details
p.2 #7Canon user here
rrxjon wrote:
OP, I'm older than you, and while all the many advantages of RF system previously noted are true, there is a disadvantage that may or may not be relevant here, possibly age related. Having shot sports, events, portraits, name it, since spooling film in a darkroom, digital photography always seemed to be making shooting, processing, touching up, printing etc, easier, faster, better. Setting up the R5 over a year ago turned into an exercise in teeth grinding frustration for me. The manual is something like a thousand pages, and there are only so many utube vids you can watch before
...Show more →

The R5 II is just different enough that you have to go through all the menus again. Custom functions don't have the same options as the R5 for inexplicable reasons. If the IQ were not worse, it would be easy to just replace all R5s with R5 IIs, but it's getting farther away from what was nice about the 5DsR.

EBH
Apr 01, 2025 at 02:17 PM
lemmy shoyu
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Canon user here
rscheffler wrote:
lemmy shoyu wroteWeb search will reveal that RF 800mm F5.6 L and RF 1200mm F8 L suck like a tornado.
The only thing those lenses suck is a lot of money out of your wallet/account. Based on image samples and feedback by users with those lenses here on FM, image quality is not one of the areas where these suck. But if you want to wade into the internet discussion about these lenses 'simply' being the old EF v3 lenses with a custom 2x converter permanently attached, you're going to get a lot of opinions . . . As for RF lenses in general compared to EF, every RF upgrade I have made has optically and functionally outperformed the EF
...Show more →

shuttermuse.com/canon-rf-800mm-and-rf-1200mm-lenses

fstoppers.com/gear/why-shouldnt-buy-canons-new-lenses

fredmiranda forum

the-digital-picture.com/Reviews/Canon-RF-800mm-F5-6-L-IS-USM-Lens

canon lens mtf charts

Anyone willing to spend time searching the web will find more opinions on these lenses.
Apr 01, 2025 at 02:44 PM
Jeff Nolten
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Canon user here
A few years older than you. I mostly photograph while traveling but my travels are to natural and wildlife locations, so mostly landscapes and wildlife. Been doing this all my adult life; like Hawkerman, my first camera was a Pentax Spotmatic.

My suggestion is that if money is not a problem and you shoot more than landscapes, i.e. wildlife, go for the R5. A magnificent camera. and the RF lenses are better than their EF equivalents. The RF 24-105 L and RF 100-500 L are wonderful. The other RF lenses like the 16 f2.8 and 35 f1.8 have no equal in the EF lineup. Those lenses make a generalist kit that will capture just about anything and is lighter in weight than my previous equivalent 5D4 kit.

I never shot a 5DSR so the R5's 45 MP was a significant upgrade for me. The relatively few 5DSR images I evaluated didn't look better at the pixel level than my APS-C cameras and the 5D4's image quality was better, IMHO. The R5 has both the IQ and the resolution - paired with a 100-500 I don't need to bring an APS-C body any more.

Then there is the tracking AF, as has been mentioned, the focus stacking, the live histogram in the VF, the 12 FPS mechanical and 20 FPS electronic shutter, the 4K 60 FPS instant video always available with the dedicated button, the IBIS for non-IS lenses, the ability to use APS-C lenses, etc. etc.

After getting over the humiliation of saying I'd never go mirrorless, I've never looked back..Just a great camea kit. I have also felt no need to go R5II. Doesn't add anything for my use.

The configuration of an R body is more intimidating than the DSLRs. Every button is customizable. This takes time but is very useful. I have the * button configured to go into full screen tracking mode so that if a bird flies across the sky, no matter what mode I'm in it will find it, focus on it, and track it! So worth the frustration of figuring out the settings.

Good luck with your decision. I have lots of wonderful 5D# images and those will never go away. That is important to consider too.
Apr 02, 2025 at 06:59 PM
Dragonfire
★ Featured Winner
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Canon user here
I love posts where the OP asks a question and never returns.
Apr 03, 2025 at 06:59 AM
Sy Sez
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Canon user here
Depends upon your mobility, and to what degree you wish to continue your devotion to photography.
I went mirrorless with the EOS R5 in 2020 at age 88, with no regrets, and still at it, though at a somewhat lesser degree, at 93, so I say go for it.
Apr 03, 2025 at 07:27 AM
roboticspro
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Canon user here
Dragonfire wrote:
I love posts where the OP asks a question and never returns.


Frank...Amen on that one...
Apr 03, 2025 at 09:12 AM
well69
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Canon user here
Sell everything you have and go full rf.


Why?

Because it's better.
Because you have the money.
Because the annoyance and challenge will keep you sharp they way some do sodoku or bridge.
Do it for the challenge, the reward, and for longevity you will receive it taking on a new challenge you old dog.

But most of all, do it for fun because you can.
Apr 24, 2025 at 08:18 PM
SkippyW
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Canon user here
Try one!

Go to a camera store and check one out, if there's one nearby, or rent a body and an EF-R lens adapter for a day or two and see what you think.

Apr 25, 2025 at 06:57 AM
CanonMark
Offline
Details
p.2 #15Canon user here
As with all new shiny features, I think the best advice is to try it to see if it helps your workflow and use cases at all. Maybe rent a nice mirrorless body (with EF -> RF converter) to use over a weekend, and see if it brings you joy.
May 02, 2025 at 01:39 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister