fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2025 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2025After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV

  
 
cvrle59
Offline
Details
p.7 #1After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
"I have no idea why you think I'm a troll still, I've used the D850 for about 10 years (on global campaigns and covers of major magazine, GQ etc if that counts for anything)."

I would at least google when d850 was released, then I would learn how many years are from August of 2017 until now 😃
Jan 26, 2025 at 10:06 AM
urbanwild
Offline
Details
p.7 #2After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
The whole thing about eyelash focus and no pupil focus......if your depth of field is that razor thin, you're probably not getting the rest of the face in focus either......so does it really matter? Would it not be a better shot to take a step or two back and get some more of that beautiful face in focus?
Jan 26, 2025 at 10:57 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.7 #3After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
urbanwild wrote:
The whole thing about eyelash focus and no pupil focus......if your depth of field is that razor thin, you're probably not getting the rest of the face in focus either......so does it really matter? Would it not be a better shot to take a step or two back and get some more of that beautiful face in focus?


It's almost like someone who has GQ covers would know that, huh?

The best part of the internet is you can just say whatever you want
Jan 26, 2025 at 10:58 AM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.7 #4After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
DOF is thin even at half body distance with lenses like the 85mm f1.2. With these higher megapixel sensors I often like to turn one portrait into two or three framings, from half body to head and shoulders to tight headshot. If this flexibility is lost because a camera is actively choosing to focus on the eyelash or nose for whatever reason and the eyes are not in sharp focus, that's a bummer. But I can't determine if that's what is happening with these users complaining about "eyelash AF". Is it something they're doing wrong or is it something strange with Nikon's focus algorithm?

If I grab a Z8 + 85mm f1.2, a Canon R5II + RF 85mm f1.2, and a Sony A1II + 85mm f1.4 GMII, will the Z8 struggle to nail sharp focus on the the eye when using wide AF-C human eye-AF? I'm guessing not since there isn't THAT much talk about it, but I do wonder why it is a reoccurring discussion. Is it because some additional focus settings need to be adjusted on the Z8?

urbanwild wrote:
The whole thing about eyelash focus and no pupil focus......if your depth of field is that razor thin, you're probably not getting the rest of the face in focus either......so does it really matter? Would it not be a better shot to take a step or two back and get some more of that beautiful face in focus?

Jan 26, 2025 at 11:11 AM
Vinnie_VdB
Offline
Details
p.7 #5After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
So lucky I do wildlife and not need to bother with eye lashes (from humans)
Jan 26, 2025 at 11:14 AM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.7 #6After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
Threads like this make me wonder how I've been an event photographer, where the bulk of my existence is indoor work using Z mount for the last 4 years I even use Fuji X mount. I don't know what the issue is.
Jan 26, 2025 at 12:11 PM
Vinnie_VdB
Offline
Details
p.7 #7After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
JadedWriter wrote:
Threads like this make me wonder how I've been an event photographer, where the bulk of my existence is indoor work using Z mount for the last 4 years I even use Fuji X mount. I don't know what the issue is.


After seeing all these Nikon vs. Sony posts derailing do I not wonder anymore, but hey, I feel you man :-)
Jan 26, 2025 at 12:50 PM
JadedWriter
Offline
Details
p.7 #8After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
"Sony elitism" is one of the reasons why I got off of Sony. The other reason is their patented digital hotshoe that is just poorly designed. I do way too much flash work for that thing.
Vinnie_VdB wrote:
JadedWriter wroteThreads like this make me wonder how I've been an event photographer, where the bulk of my existence is indoor work using Z mount for the last 4 years I even use Fuji X mount. I don't know what the issue is.
After seeing all these Nikon vs. Sony posts derailing do I not wonder anymore, but hey, I feel you man :-)


Jan 26, 2025 at 12:59 PM
jlafferty
Offline
Details
p.7 #9After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
woof2025 wrote:
From one of the most prominent digi tech's in LA that works with all the camera systems all the time and is a bit of a tech nerd recently posted on threads: "Yall, I’m a digital tech. My job is to check focus and I work with every camera out there. R5 mkII is unmatched. Face tracking on Nikon misses constantly. It’s been a problem on literally every shoot with Z8/Z9 for me".


I know George personally. He’s a good guy and an excellent digitech, but that’s an entirely different thing than being a shooter. Everyone comes up against the limits of their area of expertise occasionally. I wrote him in Threads and he hasn’t replied, but if you’re expecting Nikon to behave like Canon or Sony, you’re going to be disappointed. “Missing constantly” isn’t even something that happens with my lowly Z6 🤷🏻‍♂️
Jan 26, 2025 at 01:05 PM
Alistair1
Offline
Details
p.7 #10After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV


woof2025 wrote:
Alistair1 wrote
AlphaPhotography wroteThat's the first I'm hearing about Nikon not opening the lens fully beyond f5.6 to acquire focus, but I never really looked into it either. That's interesting that they'd take that approach vs what Sony and Canon are doing. Do you have a source about this describing how the system operates?

jlafferty wroteI think it’s kind of widely known by now that Nikon doesn’t open the lens fully beyond 5.6 to acquire focus, and some people have designed a workaround for this with assigned buttons and settings.

If you’re having trouble getting focus I’d get a focus assist LED either off camera or on the hotshoe- there’s tiny cube lights that run maybe 2-3 hours on a charge.

For on-camera speedlight shooters there are green laser kits you can buy online that accomplish focus assist similar to red focus assist lights that event shooters relied on for years with SLRs. ML cameras don’t respond to red.

It’s also widely known that Nikon’s press materials promising something like -10EV focusing are based on using a 1.2 lens.

All of this said I haven’t encountered a situation where I’m finding the Z8 struggling, and I only have two relatively slow lenses as my kit: 24-120 f/4, and the 40/2. I shoot a lot with an OG Z6 and get an 80% hit rate. The Z8 is above 95% and in fact I find myself taking big chances on shots I wouldn’t get with an SLR and it delivers over and over, to my delight.

I think event shooters in dark nightclubs, concert shooters in weird lighting have reason to test the Z8 out, or need to outfit themselves with 1.2 lenses ideally… but conventional shoots like portrait/ecomm/fashion/beauty it’s a no brainer walk in the park to get critical focus.

AlphaPhotography wroteThat's interesting. I wonder what they're doing differently.

ronno wroteOne overarching thing I will say about AF on these Z cameras is this:
If you are shooting in the dark, you’re way better off using a fast lens like a 1.2,1.4, 1.8…
Using an F/4 or slower lens as it gets dark can yield inconsistent focusing in a way that my Canons/Sonys never did when the light dimmed.
I have had Z8, Z7II, Z6II, D810, D750 etc etc etc.

When my friend got the Z9 in the first year - he commented that he loved the camera, but the focus was just bad in the dark.

The accuracy of the focus systems in these Z cameras seems to be *particularly* sensitive to the amount of light hitting the sensor - more so than the other systems I use (Canon and Sony - which may take a little longer to focus when it gets dark, but when their focus indicator goes green, I can be sure it’s focused...*even when using slow lenses*)
That's not the full story.
Thom Hogan: "On the Z8/Z9 focus is performed at the aperture you’ve set unless you select an aperture physically smaller than f/5.6 (higher number), where the camera will leave the aperture set to f/5.6 for focus operations". [TH -- "If a lens has a smaller maximum aperture than f/5.6—for instance, the 800mm f/6.3 PF VR S—the camera will focus at the lens’ maximum aperture only."]

This is done to avoid focus inaccuracies caused by focus breathing at wide apertures. It would be better if Nikon made this parameter user configurable. Especially since Z lenses ( together with rf mount lenses) generally have low focus breathing.
The matter has been discussed at length elsewhere. But if further discussion is required, a new thread is preferable.
From an earlier comment, it is clear that this thread was started under an alias by a well known troll, he has already achieved 5 pages of misinformed nonsense and it is best to let the thread die.
Most wildlife shooters who once frequented these pages now use Back Country Gallery where active forum mediation prevents participation by trolls. Genuine questions get genuinely informative responses.
I have no idea why you think I'm a troll still, I've used the D850 for about 10 years (on global campaigns and covers of major magazine, GQ etc if that counts for anything). I bought the Z8 and in tests it kept missing focus slightly. I returned it and got my new Sony A7RV yesterday and so far it seems to be more accurate. For what I do, in my workflow with my lenses. If it works for you then great, no worries. My experience with the Z8 won't make your camera work less well. From one of the
...Show more →
Would love to see a link to your work.
Jan 26, 2025 at 01:12 PM
Orsonneke
Offline
Details
p.7 #11After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
I have the advantage being able to use Nikon and Sony with the best lenses wide open!
Using my Z8 with the 85/1.2 and the plena in AF-C and subject detection on , I ALMOST NEVER HAVE PERFECT FOCUS ON THE EYE BALL : MOST ON THE EYE LASHES AND THE GLASS FRAME!
This is reality and is confirmed by most of my Nikon friends.
Taking my wife’s Sony aiii and a eg. 135/1.8 or 85/1.4 GM ii wide , ALL shots are perfect sharp on the eyeball!
While I prefer my NEF files above the Sony ones , I think Nikon definitely has a job to do!
Jan 26, 2025 at 02:04 PM
sungphoto
Offline
Details
p.7 #12After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
cvrle59 wrote:
"I have no idea why you think I'm a troll still, I've used the D850 for about 10 years (on global campaigns and covers of major magazine, GQ etc if that counts for anything)."

I would at least google when d850 was released, then I would learn how many years are from August of 2017 until now 😃


best comment in the thread. OP is so elite he got the D850 almost 3 years before it was released.
Jan 26, 2025 at 02:07 PM
cmm1398
Offline
Details
p.7 #13After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
Can someone remove their eyelashes, test, and get back with us? Thanks in advance.
Jan 26, 2025 at 02:08 PM
tzhang4284
Offline
Details
p.7 #14After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV

woof2025 wrote:
Alistair1 wrote
AlphaPhotography wroteThat's the first I'm hearing about Nikon not opening the lens fully beyond f5.6 to acquire focus, but I never really looked into it either. That's interesting that they'd take that approach vs what Sony and Canon are doing. Do you have a source about this describing how the system operates?

jlafferty wroteI think it’s kind of widely known by now that Nikon doesn’t open the lens fully beyond 5.6 to acquire focus, and some people have designed a workaround for this with assigned buttons and settings.

If you’re having trouble getting focus I’d get a focus assist LED either off camera or on the hotshoe- there’s tiny cube lights that run maybe 2-3 hours on a charge.

For on-camera speedlight shooters there are green laser kits you can buy online that accomplish focus assist similar to red focus assist lights that event shooters relied on for years with SLRs. ML cameras don’t respond to red.

It’s also widely known that Nikon’s press materials promising something like -10EV focusing are based on using a 1.2 lens.

All of this said I haven’t encountered a situation where I’m finding the Z8 struggling, and I only have two relatively slow lenses as my kit: 24-120 f/4, and the 40/2. I shoot a lot with an OG Z6 and get an 80% hit rate. The Z8 is above 95% and in fact I find myself taking big chances on shots I wouldn’t get with an SLR and it delivers over and over, to my delight.

I think event shooters in dark nightclubs, concert shooters in weird lighting have reason to test the Z8 out, or need to outfit themselves with 1.2 lenses ideally… but conventional shoots like portrait/ecomm/fashion/beauty it’s a no brainer walk in the park to get critical focus.

AlphaPhotography wroteThat's interesting. I wonder what they're doing differently.

ronno wroteOne overarching thing I will say about AF on these Z cameras is this:
If you are shooting in the dark, you’re way better off using a fast lens like a 1.2,1.4, 1.8…
Using an F/4 or slower lens as it gets dark can yield inconsistent focusing in a way that my Canons/Sonys never did when the light dimmed.
I have had Z8, Z7II, Z6II, D810, D750 etc etc etc.

When my friend got the Z9 in the first year - he commented that he loved the camera, but the focus was just bad in the dark.

The accuracy of the focus systems in these Z cameras seems to be *particularly* sensitive to the amount of light hitting the sensor - more so than the other systems I use (Canon and Sony - which may take a little longer to focus when it gets dark, but when their focus indicator goes green, I can be sure it’s focused...*even when using slow lenses*)
That's not the full story.
Thom Hogan: "On the Z8/Z9 focus is performed at the aperture you’ve set unless you select an aperture physically smaller than f/5.6 (higher number), where the camera will leave the aperture set to f/5.6 for focus operations". [TH -- "If a lens has a smaller maximum aperture than f/5.6—for instance, the 800mm f/6.3 PF VR S—the camera will focus at the lens’ maximum aperture only."]

This is done to avoid focus inaccuracies caused by focus breathing at wide apertures. It would be better if Nikon made this parameter user configurable. Especially since Z lenses ( together with rf mount lenses) generally have low focus breathing.
The matter has been discussed at length elsewhere. But if further discussion is required, a new thread is preferable.
From an earlier comment, it is clear that this thread was started under an alias by a well known troll, he has already achieved 5 pages of misinformed nonsense and it is best to let the thread die.
Most wildlife shooters who once frequented these pages now use Back Country Gallery where active forum mediation prevents participation by trolls. Genuine questions get genuinely informative responses.
I have no idea why you think I'm a troll still, I've used the D850 for about 10 years (on global campaigns and covers of major magazine, GQ etc if that counts for anything). I bought the Z8 and in tests it kept missing focus slightly. I returned it and got my new Sony A7RV yesterday and so far it seems to be more accurate. For what I do, in my workflow with my lenses. If it works for you then great, no worries. My experience with the Z8 won't make your camera work less well. From one of the
...Show more →

I had the Sony a7r v and now a Nikon z6iii. The Sony eye af looks a lot better to me for photos. For videos, I don’t see much of a difference.

On the z8, did you use top tier glass? On Sony, I found that GM lenses and fast primes do a lot better than zooms. I didn’t see much acuity even with say the Nikon 50mm f1.8 so I do think Sony does a better job.

I went with the z6iii since I wanted a video oriented camera in the $2k range and it’s better than anything Sony has at that price point. However if I had a bigger budget, I’d go with the a1 or a1 iii over the a7rv. I used to have a Sony a1 but most of my camera budget is tied up in Leica these days.

I’ll also add after spending a year with Leica AF and Fuji AF, Nikon AF is amazing in comparison so it’s all relative.
Jan 26, 2025 at 02:08 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.7 #15After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
So, let's get over whether the OP is a troll or not. Maybe he is and maybe he isn't. So what? He posted on an issue that many people in this thread confirms exists. Pretty much everyone who has posted on this thread, that shoots both systems confirm that when relying on Eye AF the Nikon Z AF tends to miss focus with some frequency, or is a bit fussy in workflow to improve the hit rate.

They also confirm that the Sony is both easier, and more accurate with a high hit rate even wide open at f/1.2.

For most people I think the issue is more important than the motivations of the OP. Why don't we just address the issue, which appears to be real, and is not subject to speculations on motivation. No one seems able to prove the status of the OP or his motivations. Given this, trying to distract by blaming the motivations of the OP is probably not the most productive path to understanding the issue.

I may have a project coming up where I am trying to decide whether to go all Leica (M,SL) or mix Leica M with Sony A1. Going all Leica would be nice, but Leica SL AF is not even close to Sony A1. For the people portion I just did a series of test using my Sony A1 with a variety of F/1.2 and F1/4 GM primes of different focal lengths and a 24-70 f/2.8 GM and a 70-200 f/2.8 GM Zooms. (the leica SL did OK but not even close to the A1) I shot well over 100 test images using Sony Eye AF in a variety of lighting and movement scenarios. The shooting workflow was just stupid simple. Wide Area focus, point the camera at the subject and shoot. Zooming in to check focus I don't think the Sony missed the pupil even once when visible in the image. Amazing! I agree a simple challenge with decent lighting, easy subjects, not very fast movement, and limited in scope. Conclusion, Sony A1 Eye AF is easy and reliable.

I really don't have access to the equipment to test a Z8/9 on a level playing field. The zoom part would be good, but the Nikon primes would be a problem. I could adapt my GMs but that would not be level either.

So, I will leave it at this. The posts claiming that the Sony AF is simple to use, accurate focusing on the pupil, and reliable, for me are confirmed. The Nikon Z AF judging from the posts in this thread, even from Nikon users, at least has a more difficult workflow, even then may not be accurate at times, even in skilled hands. However, this difference is not likely large enough that either camera system couldn't be used for any purpose/even/project with good result.

Troll or not, the OP's thread has provided at least some visibility into this issue, so has had value.
Jan 26, 2025 at 03:58 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.7 #16After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
If I had the 85mm f1.2 Z for my Z8 I'd be able to test it against my R5II + RF 85mm f1.2, but part of my decision to get the 85mm f1.2 Z hinges on knowing that I can rely on the eye-AF the same way I can on my R5II and my previous Sony cameras.

1bwana1 wrote:
So, let's get over whether the OP is a troll or not. Maybe he is and maybe he isn't. So what? He posted on an issue that many people in this thread confirms exists. Pretty much everyone who has posted on this thread, that shoots both systems confirm that when relying on Eye AF the Nikon Z AF tends to miss focus frequently, or is a bit fussy in workflow to improve the hit rate.

They also confirm that the Sony is both easier, and more accurate with a high hit rate even wide open at f/1.2.

For most people I think
...Show more →
Jan 26, 2025 at 04:07 PM
tzhang4284
Offline
Details
p.7 #17After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
AlphaPhotography wrote:
If I had the 85mm f1.2 Z for my Z8 I'd be able to test it against my R5II + RF 85mm f1.2, but part of my decision to get the 85mm f1.2 Z hinges on knowing that I can rely on the eye-AF the same way I can on my R5II and my previous Sony cameras.

1bwana1 wroteSo, let's get over whether the OP is a troll or not. Maybe he is and maybe he isn't. So what? He posted on an issue that many people in this thread confirms exists. Pretty much everyone who has posted on this thread, that shoots both systems confirm that when relying on Eye AF the Nikon Z AF tends to miss focus frequently, or is a bit fussy in workflow to improve the hit rate.

They also confirm that the Sony is both easier, and more accurate with a high hit rate even wide open at f/1.2.

For most people I think the issue is more important the the motivations of the OP. Why don't we just address the issue, which appears to be real, is not subject to speculation. No one seems able to prove the status of the OP or his motivations. Given this, trying to distract from the issue by blaming the motivations of the OP is probably not the most productive path to understanding the issue.

I may have a project coming up where I am trying to decide whether to go all Leica (M,SL) or mix Leica M with Sony A1. Going all Leica would be nice, but Leica SL AF is not even close to Sony A1. For the people portion I just did a series of test using my Sony A1 with a variety of F/1.2 and F1/4 GM primes of different focal lengths and a 24-70 f/2.8 GM and a 70-200 f/2.8 GM Zooms. I shot well over 100 test images using Sony Eye AF in a variety of lighting and movement scenarios. The shooting workflow was just stupid simple. Wide Area focus, point the camera at the subject and shoot. Zooming in to check focus I don't think the Sony missed the pupil even once. Agree a simple challenge with decent lighting, easy subjects, and not very fast movement. Conclusion, easy and reliable.

I really don't have access to the equipment to test a Z8/9 on a level playing field. The zoom part would be good, but the Nikon primes would be a problem. I could adapt my GMs but that would not be level either.

So, I will leave it at this. The posts claiming that the Sony AF is simple to use, accurate focusing on the pupil, and reliable, for me are confirmed. The Nikon Z AF judging from the posts in this thread even from Nikon users is at least has a more difficult workflow, and even then may not be as accurate at times even in skilled hands. However, this difference is not likely large enough that either camera system couldn't be used for any purpose/even/project with good result.

Troll or not, the OP's thread has provided at least some visibility into this issue, so has had value.


If you have the budget, I think the best way to answer this question is to test out the Z8 and the Nikon 135mm plena and compare. It has the best Nikon optics and their best AF motors. This removes all confounding factors with respect to optical quality and/or AF motor quality.

I think one of Sony’s major advantages is the use of linear af motors in all their recent lenses. It allows perfectly fine tuned AF that I don’t think other manufacturers fully have yet. I see the difference on my Leica Q3 43mm APO - the AF algorithms are actually pretty good and the optics certainly are top notch so when it hits, it hits well and the eye AF is Sony level. However if the AF motors lags for any reason, it results in less sharpness in the eye and lower keepers.
Jan 26, 2025 at 04:22 PM
cmm1398
Offline
Details
p.7 #18After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
It’s fascinating how someone who doesn’t own Nikon equipment feels so compelled to dive headfirst into a conversation about Nikon’s AF performance. I mean, who needs actual firsthand experience when you can just weigh in with secondhand opinions and amplify what’s likely a sock or troll post? Truly groundbreaking stuff.

But really, what’s the motivation here? A deep concern for Nikon users? A sudden passion for debating the nuances of AF systems you don't use? Or is it just a case of wanting to run down other systems to prop up their preferred brand? Hard to say, but it’s quite the commitment to champion a conversation started by someone who probably created the thread just to stir the pot.

If the goal is really to help, wouldn’t it make more sense to contribute to discussions about gear you actually own and use? You know, where you can provide meaningful insights instead of fanning the flames of what might be a troll agenda.


1bwana1 wrote:
So, let's get over whether the OP is a troll or not. Maybe he is and maybe he isn't. So what? He posted on an issue that many people in this thread confirms exists. Pretty much everyone who has posted on this thread, that shoots both systems confirm that when relying on Eye AF the Nikon Z AF tends to miss focus with some frequency, or is a bit fussy in workflow to improve the hit rate.

They also confirm that the Sony is both easier, and more accurate with a high hit rate even wide open at f/1.2.

For most people
...Show more →

Jan 26, 2025 at 04:27 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.7 #19After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
I agree with that based on my experience going from Sony to Canon. I find many of Canon's lenses AF to be rather poor and noisy, including all of their budget STM lenses (16mm, 35mm, etc) as well as some of their higher end lenses I still own like the 28-70mm f2 and RF 85mm f1.2. With Sony every lens I owned was blazing fast and silent AF, including some cheaper options like the 85mm f1.8, which I still own and use adapted on my Nikon ZF.

tzhang4284 wrote:
AlphaPhotography wroteIf I had the 85mm f1.2 Z for my Z8 I'd be able to test it against my R5II + RF 85mm f1.2, but part of my decision to get the 85mm f1.2 Z hinges on knowing that I can rely on the eye-AF the same way I can on my R5II and my previous Sony cameras.

1bwana1 wroteSo, let's get over whether the OP is a troll or not. Maybe he is and maybe he isn't. So what? He posted on an issue that many people in this thread confirms exists. Pretty much everyone who has posted on this thread, that shoots both systems confirm that when relying on Eye AF the Nikon Z AF tends to miss focus frequently, or is a bit fussy in workflow to improve the hit rate.

They also confirm that the Sony is both easier, and more accurate with a high hit rate even wide open at f/1.2.

For most people I think the issue is more important the the motivations of the OP. Why don't we just address the issue, which appears to be real, is not subject to speculation. No one seems able to prove the status of the OP or his motivations. Given this, trying to distract from the issue by blaming the motivations of the OP is probably not the most productive path to understanding the issue.

I may have a project coming up where I am trying to decide whether to go all Leica (M,SL) or mix Leica M with Sony A1. Going all Leica would be nice, but Leica SL AF is not even close to Sony A1. For the people portion I just did a series of test using my Sony A1 with a variety of F/1.2 and F1/4 GM primes of different focal lengths and a 24-70 f/2.8 GM and a 70-200 f/2.8 GM Zooms. I shot well over 100 test images using Sony Eye AF in a variety of lighting and movement scenarios. The shooting workflow was just stupid simple. Wide Area focus, point the camera at the subject and shoot. Zooming in to check focus I don't think the Sony missed the pupil even once. Agree a simple challenge with decent lighting, easy subjects, and not very fast movement. Conclusion, easy and reliable.

I really don't have access to the equipment to test a Z8/9 on a level playing field. The zoom part would be good, but the Nikon primes would be a problem. I could adapt my GMs but that would not be level either.

So, I will leave it at this. The posts claiming that the Sony AF is simple to use, accurate focusing on the pupil, and reliable, for me are confirmed. The Nikon Z AF judging from the posts in this thread even from Nikon users is at least has a more difficult workflow, and even then may not be as accurate at times even in skilled hands. However, this difference is not likely large enough that either camera system couldn't be used for any purpose/even/project with good result.

Troll or not, the OP's thread has provided at least some visibility into this issue, so has had value.
If you have the budget, I think the best way to answer this question is to test out the Z8 and the Nikon 135mm plena and compare. It has the best Nikon optics and their best AF motors. This removes all confounding factors with respect to optical quality and/or AF motor quality.

I think one of Sony’s major advantages is the use of linear af motors in all their recent lenses. It allows perfectly fine tuned AF that I don’t think other manufacturers fully have yet. I see the difference on my Leica Q3 43mm APO - the AF algorithms
...Show more →
Jan 26, 2025 at 04:29 PM
mapgraphs
Offline
Details
p.7 #20After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
Funny how the OP sounds like someone who posted similar opinions some time back, about a different model, under a different ID. GQ covers and faulty Nikon AF, now that rings a bell... And then there's Steve... ; - )
Jan 26, 2025 at 04:42 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister