p.13 #1After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
Thank you for clarifying
bernardl wrote: Buckeye2604 wroteAlphaPhotography wroteOh gotcha, thanks. Do you know which setting he was referring to? I'll look again in a bit
Buckeye2604 wroteAlphaPhotography wroteI will try those recommendations.
For "Set the interruption setting to the lower possible value (highest possible reactivity)" you mean g7 AF tracking sensitivity set to 1 (High), correct?
What is the purpose of burst shooting vs single shot? Sometimes I'm shooting with OCF so burst isn't even an option.
I'm not sure how these settings could fix the problem people have been describing (the camera using eye-AF focusing on the eyelash or hat brim, etc) since they seem unrelated but I will test them and report back. I'll do further testing once I'm able to get ahold of a faster telephoto prime but in the meantime I'll see what I can discern with my 40mm f2.
bernardl wroteEye AF isn't broken, I have outstanding results with these settings so I am confident that anyone genuinely trying this approach will confirm my experiences. This discussion already took place several times and people with issues confirmed the improvements.
And again, I have first hand experience comparing the Z8/Z9 with these settings to the best Sonys with clear results.
It would have taken a few minutes for the OP to test these had he been interested in tapping into the potential of the Z8. Yet he never reacted to my suggestions.
Considering the time span between his initial question and his purchase of a Sony I am fully confident that the conclusion was foregone and that my advice and positive comment about the performance of the Z8 was ignored because it should have changed the conclusion.
Cheers,
BernardG7 is a video setting.If I had to guess the focus tracking with lock on setting (a3).Yes, apologies for my earlier inaccurate answer, it is indeed a3 set to 1 and erratic that provides the most reliable eye pupil focusing results for me. As mentioned, along with the other settings I proposed.
Add to that AF-C mode in Focus + Release configuration. Important one I should have mentioned. And that's a1. In summary, my recommendation, in decreasing order of importance/impact is the following:
- Use your lenses as open as possible depending on situation, f1.2 provides the best AF performance. Pro lenses have more responsive focus adjustment and will obviously deliver better results,
- Use AF-C in Focus + Release mode (setting a1)
- Set setting a3 to the lower possible value (highest possible reactivity) of 1 and use erratic
- Use custom AF area set as a box covering the area of the EVF where the face is likely to be seen with subject recognition limited to people (other types of subjects not selected), that's in the Photo shooting menu under "AF subject detection options"
- Deactivate IBIS if you don't really need it
- Set your EVF View mode to adjust for use of viewing when possible (not setting reflected), setting d9. I am not sure this one really impacts though
- When possible, shoot in short bursts instead of single shot. It provides a lot more data for the camera to get one absolutely perfect. All Sony bodies I tried also performed better this way as well.
And indeed, there is nothing complex about Nikon's AF, once set up the shooting experience is basically point and shoot.
p.13 #2After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
Beautiful shots. I understand that ultra shallow DOF may seem silly but I do often like the look and I don't think it's unprofessional. It's simply a creative choice. It's also fairly lens dependent. A head and shoulders or tight headshot with a 135mm f1.8 will have very thin DOF but there's nothing outrageously OOF besides the ears. It makes for the smoothest possible bokeh and nice falloff with the hair. I also like some shots where only one eye is the focal point and in focus with a half turned face. Critical focus on the eye is always critical.
One of my favorite shoots (and shots) from many years ago was of some family members where I used my 90mm macro lens to get ultra tight shots of their eyes wide open at f2.8. Very little was in focus besides their eyes. The falloff was dreamy. They and their mom loved them. If focus was missed even slightly it would have ruined the shot along with all of the headshots and even the head and shoulders shots. DOF is very thin at these distances, especially with an 85mm f1.2 or f1.4 (one of my other favorite lenses I was using). Could I have tried to 3D track the eye in each shot? Probably. Could I have tried to use AF single point on the eye? Probably. Would these methods risk missing focus on the eye with that thin of DOF? Without a doubt. Eye-AF has made for an absolutely thoughtless workflow that allows me to focus (pun intended) on everything else going on with a shoot and not even worry about checking focus after the fact. In AF-C it achieves perfect focus even if the subject is moving as long as my shutter speed is high enough. It's that good. If I encountered a system/camera/lens that regressed my workflow back to having to do more to achieve the same or worse result I'd hate it.
I'm hopeful that this Nikon issue is a non-issue for me. But if it is or can't be relied upon it would be a huge factor in my decision to stick with the camera or use something else. I lean heavily on eye-AF and I've become too accustomed to it being flawless to accept inaccuracies now. Unless there is some true defect with the algorithm or other strange issue going on I am confident that I can get consistent results on Nikon with the right settings and quality lenses. But only time will tell. I'll report back once I'm able to do more testing and have better lenses.
urbanwild wrote: AlphaPhotography wroteThanks for the insight. I'll play around with the AF boxes. I haven't used my Z8 with multiple people in a scene yet so it may prove useful for that. My workflow with Canon is to use wide-AF and it detects each person (eye-AF) with a left/right arrow that allows you to toggle between subjects using the joystick. Does Nikon have anything similar to this?
As for the eyelash AF and Trump's portrait, I'm not sure what settings they used but I'm sure any of us could get a sharp retina in a controlled environment, probably even 95% of the time using eye-AF. What myself and others are concerned with are those strange occasional misses that people have been discussing for a couple years while using eye-AF and why they occur. Is it something that can be adjusted with software? Is it a lens issue? Is it front focusing due to lighting? Obviously difficult to pinpoint but again not an issue I ever saw pop-up with Sony or Canon (except for adapted lenses front focusing many years ago) so it seems to be Nikon specific whatever it is. It's just strange to me that some people seem to pretend it doesn't exist. Maybe it doesn't for some but it's clear that it does for others. My best guess is that it's just the AF algorithm getting confused in certain situations, especially glasses or headwear, occasionally eyelashes for whatever reason. I actually vaguely remember having that issue with glasses shooting Sony many years ago, where it would focus on the glasses instead of the eye (A7RII maybe?)
urbanwild wroteAlphaPhotography wroteRoamingScott wroteThe reality of the situation is I could post my exact button layout and settings and in another set of hands, totally different output would be possible due to differing skill levels, reaction times, anticipation zone focusing, and a slew of other factors. I've put in the 10,000 hours and can get great results out of any brand, so these conversations are squarely in the realm of amateurs unwilling to do the same, or pros expecting to pick up a new toy and expect it to work just like their totally different one of which they've put a ton of time into learning the ins and outs.
Then there would be bitching that Scott oversold the capabilities of the camera and must be a brand whore falsely advocating for an inferior product, so why bother with all that?
My Z cameras are on Area with subject detection the vast majority of the time and the results speak for themselves. It's why I post so many photos, to counteract all this inferiority complex FUD propagated by a handful of loser Sony fanboys that come here to waste away their sunset years.I can assure you that is the wrong approach. There are plenty of extremely helpful settings recommendations on this forum across all brands. To avoid posting your settings because you think it won't work in someone else's hands or because you think you'll get some sort of backlash is silly. This forum was built around helping others and sharing.
But it is good to know that for you Auto Area with subject detection works well. Many others in this thread have inferred that it doesn't and that more complex settings adjustments are needed for consistent focus.For what it's worth, I also use Area with subject detection where I need autofocus. What I like with the new Nikon cameras is the different shapes of boxes you can use. Some say it's too overwhelming / too much to scroll through, but I often find in busy conditions where I really want to be specific, I quickly change the shape of the AF area to pull the right subject out of the crowd. I do it with a quick spin of a wheel with a button pushed down.....super quick. In very difficult conditions, I may just do spot focus, which again is a quick button press which I've selected. All told, I've been pretty impressed with the AF with the Z8 and Zf. My Z6ii isn't as good (and the Z7 is worse), but both are still very effective with stationary subjects. Eyelash AF comments....well, see my comment earlier.
With my old D500, D25 tracking worked wonders. I don't use that so much anymore as I find the area eye-AF works well on mirrorless. I always thought the D850 AF was inferior to the D500 due to the AF zones available, so I'll infer that the Z8 is better than the D850 without a direct comparison.
I think dangling a comparison with another brand from the get-go just invited a certain individual to the show where he repeats his "Sony is better" rant which is evident in his history of posts.....so no doubt that set the mood in a spiral again. It's similar to going to a restaurant and telling everyone the food there isn't as good as next door. I'll trust that the OP isn't a troll who has 2 accounts and simply suggest staying out of the comparisons and just ask for advice about the system people here use (how effective it is, their workflow, etc). One may say this is a sensitive bunch after years of Sony marketing targeted against Nikon, but the truth is that people here are just a little tired of it now that we're a couple of years beyond the Nikon AF challenges and there's enough in this forum to suggest that Nikon, Canon and Sony are all very similar with AF (despite some small differences). I believe this has been discovered yet again in this thread.Yes to the first question......easy peasy and I think Nikon was praised for its control over which eye / face you can toggle back and forth with back in the day. One subject to focus on in an uncomplicated field shouldn't be a challenge for these systems in reasonable light.
Sharing the Trump shot was a half-joke because it supported my statement about how the pros will shoot with a tighter aperture to ensure they had the appropriate amount of detail (they weren't shooting at f1.2 in close). If you look back at the shot, you'll notice that his whole head is in focus. When people (like me at times) shoot wide open and get too close because we're excited to shoot wide open, the shots look less professional to me. It's all good fun trying to get a razor thin depth of field just right, but in most cases it doesn't do much in terms of professional-looking images. So eye-AF only hitting the lashes......well, you're probably taking a limited shot anyway regardless of system and retina sharpness from my perspective (others may rightfully disagree).
Where I will agree with you above is with the eye glasses. I definitely find eye- AF will get tricked by eye glasses with my Zf eye-AF (will have to check through Z8 shots). Not sure how this compares with other systems. But again, what I really want is a shot that has the nose, glasses, eye lashes, eyes and the ears all in focus at the least in most images. So I'm fighting myself more than the camera by not stepping back or adjusting my aperture.
I'm not concerned with getting 100% focus accuracy in all types of situations. I think that's a lot to expect out of any system and you can drive yourself nuts trying to sort it out. My livelihood doesn't depend on it and I get many more images than I need in most situations with the AF. What's more important to me are the lenses, feel of the camera, workflow, and more importantly, the IQ / output. I've never been upset with Nikon's AF enough to worry about it, but a search through my images will tell you if your shooting needs differ from mine.
Best advice I can give you though - step away from the keyboard and pick up the Z8 You will learn more from shooting than you will from more time on this thread for now! Congrats on the Z8. It's a phenomenal camera. I'll close this message up with a couple of shots taken with the Z8, an ftz and the 400mm f2.8 (f-mount).....the ironman athletes were cycling at about 35km/h towards me. I used area mode eye-AF. If you go to my website, you'll see more like this. With the Z8, it was like a hot knife through butter getting these athletes in focus. The last shot I added was from a fundraiser where I would have changed the area of the AF box so that I ensured I had the lead rider(s). All of the shots below would have been at f2.8 at 400mm (moving vehicle on the last one I may add). The Z8 is great!
p.13 #3After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
AlphaPhotography wrote:
Beautiful shots. I understand that ultra shallow DOF may seem silly but I do often like the look and I don't think it's unprofessional. It's simply a creative choice. It's also fairly lens dependent. A head and shoulders or tight headshot with a 135mm f1.8 will have very thin DOF but there's nothing outrageously OOF besides the ears. It makes for the smoothest possible bokeh and nice falloff with the hair. I also like some shots where only one eye is the focal point and in focus with a half turned face. Critical focus on the eye is always critical.
I can appreciate what you're saying, but the first shot is a good example where there's still lots of depth of field to get the tip of the nose and past the eye. So even if you only want one eye in focus, it's still nice to have more facial details. My earlier point is you should never be in a situation where the eyelashes are in focus but not the iris and I think this first image shows this well.
The second shot we'll have to agree that we have different perspectives. While I don't think it's a bad shot at all, I think it would be a better shot with a little more depth of field. It would even be better if both eyes were equally sharp as the face is straight on. But I appreciate artistic freedom and would imagine there could be a time when this small depth of field on a face could work nicely......but for me it would be limited applications.
p.13 #4After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
ronno wrote:
Re ” Still in my experience eyelash af is very rare. Heck, it’s rare with a Z6ii and 85 1.2. “
Yes, I had good focus with the Z6/Z7II and fast lenses - however as we have noted, the issues arise when using slower lenses (f/4.0…) and the light dims.
Buckeye2604 wroteAlphaPhotography wroteYou find it ridiculous that the new user of a camera system who asked for advice and instead received dozens (hundreds?) of attacks and accusations from the community he's just joined could be pushed towards another brand?
bernardl wrote1bwana1 wrotebernardl wroteI have acknowledged the summary created by the neutral observer.
I am stating facts resulting from first hand experience with Sony and Nikon cameras. The fact that you consider these as inflammatory or negative is surprising. And I don't believe you have first hand experiences demonstrating that I am wrong.
Cheers,
BernardYour experiences are not facts that apply to other people. Just like your conclusion about the OP are not facts.
I am not trying to disprove anything about which camera performs at what level. That has never been the point of my posts in this thread.How would you know that the fact of my positive experiences using the Z8 in an optimized way with excellent results does not apply to other people?
You have not tried my recommendations, the OP has not tried them either. Others did tried them and reproduced my results.
The answer is that it doesn't match your view that Sony's eye AF is superior. That's all there is to it, isn't it?
So I am sorry, I fail to understand the objective of your posts in this thread.
And I did not present my conclusions about the motivation of the OP as a fact. This is clearly my opinion but based on a reasonable set of observations. Could there be another interpretation? Yes certainly, but I don't see how it would be more likely. I certainty find ridiculous the idea that a person would sell or buy a camera because people are, according to you, unfriendly in a forum.
Cheers,
BernardIt was initially one guy that called the OP a troll after a page of replies which the OP has now said he was too experienced to even bother responding to (lol). Then, the resident gaslighter blew it up from there. Also the OP talked big about his identity =/= camera brands, so I don’t think a group of strangers would influence his decision to try a different brand, that was always the plan when this topic was started.
Canon has done the same.
Wouldn’t be surprised if Nikon improved on its accuracy when their version of AI chip comes out.
Still in my experience eyelash af is very rare. Heck, it’s rare with a Z6ii and 85 1.2.
This is precisely why this issue is absurd. If you shoot a subject 5 feet from the camera at 100mm f/4, the DoF slightly over 2". DoF behind the subject is slightly more than 1". Please show me the human whose eyeball is more than 1" from their eyelash. Also, please show me who is shooting portraits at 100mm and 5 feet from the subject. This has never made any sense, which is why I think the 3 people who talk about it are doing something wrong.
p.13 #5After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
groob wrote: ronno wroteRe ” Still in my experience eyelash af is very rare. Heck, it’s rare with a Z6ii and 85 1.2. “
Yes, I had good focus with the Z6/Z7II and fast lenses - however as we have noted, the issues arise when using slower lenses (f/4.0…) and the light dims.
Buckeye2604 wroteAlphaPhotography wroteYou find it ridiculous that the new user of a camera system who asked for advice and instead received dozens (hundreds?) of attacks and accusations from the community he's just joined could be pushed towards another brand?
bernardl wrote1bwana1 wroteYour experiences are not facts that apply to other people. Just like your conclusion about the OP are not facts.
I am not trying to disprove anything about which camera performs at what level. That has never been the point of my posts in this thread.How would you know that the fact of my positive experiences using the Z8 in an optimized way with excellent results does not apply to other people?
You have not tried my recommendations, the OP has not tried them either. Others did tried them and reproduced my results.
The answer is that it doesn't match your view that Sony's eye AF is superior. That's all there is to it, isn't it?
So I am sorry, I fail to understand the objective of your posts in this thread.
And I did not present my conclusions about the motivation of the OP as a fact. This is clearly my opinion but based on a reasonable set of observations. Could there be another interpretation? Yes certainly, but I don't see how it would be more likely. I certainty find ridiculous the idea that a person would sell or buy a camera because people are, according to you, unfriendly in a forum.
Cheers,
BernardIt was initially one guy that called the OP a troll after a page of replies which the OP has now said he was too experienced to even bother responding to (lol). Then, the resident gaslighter blew it up from there. Also the OP talked big about his identity =/= camera brands, so I don’t think a group of strangers would influence his decision to try a different brand, that was always the plan when this topic was started.
Canon has done the same.
Wouldn’t be surprised if Nikon improved on its accuracy when their version of AI chip comes out.
Still in my experience eyelash af is very rare. Heck, it’s rare with a Z6ii and 85 1.2.This is precisely why this issue is absurd. If you shoot a subject 5 feet from the camera at 100mm f/4, the DoF slightly over 2". DoF behind the subject is slightly more than 1". Please show me the human whose eyeball is more than 1" from their eyelash. Also, please show me who is shooting portraits at 100mm and 5 feet from the subject. This has never made any sense, which is why I think the 3 people who talk about it are doing something wrong.
p.13 #6After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
There are times when the camera indicates that it has locked eye focus, when it has missed entirely. It's not just an issue of eyelashes versus eyeball… Sometimes it's far enough off that the eyes are not in focus at all, ruining the shot.
Besides, just because you don’t shoot that way, doesn’t mean nobody else does…
groob wrote: ronno wroteRe ” Still in my experience eyelash af is very rare. Heck, it’s rare with a Z6ii and 85 1.2. “
Yes, I had good focus with the Z6/Z7II and fast lenses - however as we have noted, the issues arise when using slower lenses (f/4.0…) and the light dims.
Buckeye2604 wroteAlphaPhotography wroteYou find it ridiculous that the new user of a camera system who asked for advice and instead received dozens (hundreds?) of attacks and accusations from the community he's just joined could be pushed towards another brand?
bernardl wrote1bwana1 wroteYour experiences are not facts that apply to other people. Just like your conclusion about the OP are not facts.
I am not trying to disprove anything about which camera performs at what level. That has never been the point of my posts in this thread.How would you know that the fact of my positive experiences using the Z8 in an optimized way with excellent results does not apply to other people?
You have not tried my recommendations, the OP has not tried them either. Others did tried them and reproduced my results.
The answer is that it doesn't match your view that Sony's eye AF is superior. That's all there is to it, isn't it?
So I am sorry, I fail to understand the objective of your posts in this thread.
And I did not present my conclusions about the motivation of the OP as a fact. This is clearly my opinion but based on a reasonable set of observations. Could there be another interpretation? Yes certainly, but I don't see how it would be more likely. I certainty find ridiculous the idea that a person would sell or buy a camera because people are, according to you, unfriendly in a forum.
Cheers,
BernardIt was initially one guy that called the OP a troll after a page of replies which the OP has now said he was too experienced to even bother responding to (lol). Then, the resident gaslighter blew it up from there. Also the OP talked big about his identity =/= camera brands, so I don’t think a group of strangers would influence his decision to try a different brand, that was always the plan when this topic was started.
Canon has done the same.
Wouldn’t be surprised if Nikon improved on its accuracy when their version of AI chip comes out.
Still in my experience eyelash af is very rare. Heck, it’s rare with a Z6ii and 85 1.2.This is precisely why this issue is absurd. If you shoot a subject 5 feet from the camera at 100mm f/4, the DoF slightly over 2". DoF behind the subject is slightly more than 1". Please show me the human whose eyeball is more than 1" from their eyelash. Also, please show me who is shooting portraits at 100mm and 5 feet from the subject. This has never made any sense, which is why I think the 3 people who talk about it are doing something wrong.
p.13 #7After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
ronno wrote:
There are times when the camera indicates that it has locked eye focus, when it has missed entirely. It's not just an issue of eyelashes versus eyeball… Sometimes it's far enough off that the eyes are not in focus at all, ruining the shot.
Besides, just because you don’t shoot that way, doesn’t mean nobody else does…
groob wroteronno wroteRe ” Still in my experience eyelash af is very rare. Heck, it’s rare with a Z6ii and 85 1.2. “
Yes, I had good focus with the Z6/Z7II and fast lenses - however as we have noted, the issues arise when using slower lenses (f/4.0…) and the light dims.
Buckeye2604 wroteAlphaPhotography wroteYou find it ridiculous that the new user of a camera system who asked for advice and instead received dozens (hundreds?) of attacks and accusations from the community he's just joined could be pushed towards another brand?
bernardl wroteHow would you know that the fact of my positive experiences using the Z8 in an optimized way with excellent results does not apply to other people?
You have not tried my recommendations, the OP has not tried them either. Others did tried them and reproduced my results.
The answer is that it doesn't match your view that Sony's eye AF is superior. That's all there is to it, isn't it?
So I am sorry, I fail to understand the objective of your posts in this thread.
And I did not present my conclusions about the motivation of the OP as a fact. This is clearly my opinion but based on a reasonable set of observations. Could there be another interpretation? Yes certainly, but I don't see how it would be more likely. I certainty find ridiculous the idea that a person would sell or buy a camera because people are, according to you, unfriendly in a forum.
Cheers,
BernardIt was initially one guy that called the OP a troll after a page of replies which the OP has now said he was too experienced to even bother responding to (lol). Then, the resident gaslighter blew it up from there. Also the OP talked big about his identity =/= camera brands, so I don’t think a group of strangers would influence his decision to try a different brand, that was always the plan when this topic was started.
Canon has done the same.
Wouldn’t be surprised if Nikon improved on its accuracy when their version of AI chip comes out.
Still in my experience eyelash af is very rare. Heck, it’s rare with a Z6ii and 85 1.2.This is precisely why this issue is absurd. If you shoot a subject 5 feet from the camera at 100mm f/4, the DoF slightly over 2". DoF behind the subject is slightly more than 1". Please show me the human whose eyeball is more than 1" from their eyelash. Also, please show me who is shooting portraits at 100mm and 5 feet from the subject. This has never made any sense, which is why I think the 3 people who talk about it are doing something wrong.
Ok, then you admit there is no such thing as an eyeball versus eyelash issue--which is what I said. And if focus "misses entirely," don't you think the photographer should be able to recognize that? Which is also my point -- if the subject is out of focus, why are you taking the photo and then blaming the camera for taking an OOF photo? Wouldn't it be even more obvious that your subject is OOF when you're zoomed in to 120 mm and standing 5 feet from the subject? None of this makes any sense.
Somehow, the eyelash shooters have defied the laws of math and physics and found situations where the camera is focused correctly just before they take the photo but then winds up >4" out of focus when they take the photo. Again, this doesn't make sense beyond operator error.
p.13 #8After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
Eye AF is machine learning.
By now all the brands have stunningly good AF algos, the difference will be in their ability to get access to the widest possible set of training data to identify the eyes in a moving subject. But that will only make a difference for border cases that only represent a few % of images at best.
Either way, my hunch is that Nikon is bound to win this race because of their superior offering for online images storage. They just need to expand this offering to more cameras in their range beyond the Z6III.
p.13 #9After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
groob wrote: ronno wroteThere are times when the camera indicates that it has locked eye focus, when it has missed entirely. It's not just an issue of eyelashes versus eyeball… Sometimes it's far enough off that the eyes are not in focus at all, ruining the shot.
Besides, just because you don’t shoot that way, doesn’t mean nobody else does…
groob wroteronno wroteRe ” Still in my experience eyelash af is very rare. Heck, it’s rare with a Z6ii and 85 1.2. “
Yes, I had good focus with the Z6/Z7II and fast lenses - however as we have noted, the issues arise when using slower lenses (f/4.0…) and the light dims.
Buckeye2604 wroteAlphaPhotography wroteYou find it ridiculous that the new user of a camera system who asked for advice and instead received dozens (hundreds?) of attacks and accusations from the community he's just joined could be pushed towards another brand?It was initially one guy that called the OP a troll after a page of replies which the OP has now said he was too experienced to even bother responding to (lol). Then, the resident gaslighter blew it up from there. Also the OP talked big about his identity =/= camera brands, so I don’t think a group of strangers would influence his decision to try a different brand, that was always the plan when this topic was started.
Canon has done the same.
Wouldn’t be surprised if Nikon improved on its accuracy when their version of AI chip comes out.
Still in my experience eyelash af is very rare. Heck, it’s rare with a Z6ii and 85 1.2.This is precisely why this issue is absurd. If you shoot a subject 5 feet from the camera at 100mm f/4, the DoF slightly over 2". DoF behind the subject is slightly more than 1". Please show me the human whose eyeball is more than 1" from their eyelash. Also, please show me who is shooting portraits at 100mm and 5 feet from the subject. This has never made any sense, which is why I think the 3 people who talk about it are doing something wrong.Ok, then you admit there is no such thing as an eyeball versus eyelash issue--which is what I said. And if focus "misses entirely," don't you think the photographer should be able to recognize that? Which is also my point -- if the subject is out of focus, why are you taking the photo and then blaming the camera for taking an OOF photo? Wouldn't it be even more obvious that your subject is OOF when you're zoomed in to 120 mm and standing 5 feet from the subject? None of this makes any sense.
Somehow, the eyelash shooters have defied the laws of math and physics and found situations where the camera is focused correctly just before they take the photo but then winds up >4" out of focus when they take the photo. Again, this doesn't make sense beyond operator error....Show more →
So we shouldn't blame the camera for the AF not working, we should blame the operator for not noticing the AF didn't work and for pressing the shutter button anyway.
p.13 #10After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
That's maybe the most bizarre part. I've had a couple people DM me with examples of missed focus where the camera shows that it nailed focus but clearly missed. I think due to the hostility in this thread they did not want to get involved in all the drama but they have had these same missed focus issues with their Nikon Z8/Z9. I honestly don't know what is going on. Some users claim they get perfect focus every time, others are having ongoing issues to the point where they are switching systems. One user messaged me with several missed focus wildlife examples. The camera shows it nailed focus on subjects across multiple examples and frames but it missed often. My best guess is it's just an algorithm thing where Nikon's focus system in eye-AF can get confused and miss where Sony and Canon don't (or do far less). Someone else speculated that Sony and Canon are using AI chips/detection now while Nikon is not (yet). I'm not that worried about it going into the future because I can't imagine that it's something that Nikon won't fix with the Z9II and beyond but I hope it doesn't turn out to be an issue with my Z8.
It's silly that the "solution" according to some members here is "just don't take photos where DOF is thin".
ronno wrote:
There are times when the camera indicates that it has locked eye focus, when it has missed entirely. It's not just an issue of eyelashes versus eyeball… Sometimes it's far enough off that the eyes are not in focus at all, ruining the shot.
Besides, just because you don’t shoot that way, doesn’t mean nobody else does…
groob wroteronno wroteRe ” Still in my experience eyelash af is very rare. Heck, it’s rare with a Z6ii and 85 1.2. “
Yes, I had good focus with the Z6/Z7II and fast lenses - however as we have noted, the issues arise when using slower lenses (f/4.0…) and the light dims.
Buckeye2604 wroteAlphaPhotography wroteYou find it ridiculous that the new user of a camera system who asked for advice and instead received dozens (hundreds?) of attacks and accusations from the community he's just joined could be pushed towards another brand?
bernardl wroteHow would you know that the fact of my positive experiences using the Z8 in an optimized way with excellent results does not apply to other people?
You have not tried my recommendations, the OP has not tried them either. Others did tried them and reproduced my results.
The answer is that it doesn't match your view that Sony's eye AF is superior. That's all there is to it, isn't it?
So I am sorry, I fail to understand the objective of your posts in this thread.
And I did not present my conclusions about the motivation of the OP as a fact. This is clearly my opinion but based on a reasonable set of observations. Could there be another interpretation? Yes certainly, but I don't see how it would be more likely. I certainty find ridiculous the idea that a person would sell or buy a camera because people are, according to you, unfriendly in a forum.
Cheers,
BernardIt was initially one guy that called the OP a troll after a page of replies which the OP has now said he was too experienced to even bother responding to (lol). Then, the resident gaslighter blew it up from there. Also the OP talked big about his identity =/= camera brands, so I don’t think a group of strangers would influence his decision to try a different brand, that was always the plan when this topic was started.
Canon has done the same.
Wouldn’t be surprised if Nikon improved on its accuracy when their version of AI chip comes out.
Still in my experience eyelash af is very rare. Heck, it’s rare with a Z6ii and 85 1.2.This is precisely why this issue is absurd. If you shoot a subject 5 feet from the camera at 100mm f/4, the DoF slightly over 2". DoF behind the subject is slightly more than 1". Please show me the human whose eyeball is more than 1" from their eyelash. Also, please show me who is shooting portraits at 100mm and 5 feet from the subject. This has never made any sense, which is why I think the 3 people who talk about it are doing something wrong.
Jan 31, 2025 at 12:39 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.13 #11After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
AlphaPhotography wrote:
That's maybe the most bizarre part.
I actually think the most bizzare part is your recency towards instigation through your posts and threads.
p.13 #12After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
I have hundreds of posts on FM dating back years to when I shot with Sony. You can read through them all if you'd like. There's no agenda besides to learn about and discuss camera gear, lenses, photography and more recently videography. I shoot with Canon and now also Nikon.
If you are bothered by this thread why do you keep posting here? There's plenty of other discussions to participate in or contribute to.
RoamingScott wrote: AlphaPhotography wroteThat's maybe the most bizarre part.I actually think the most bizzare part is your recency towards instigation through your posts and threads.
p.13 #13After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
It all depends on what firmware you’re running. I hated my Z8 after the first shoot. Then I upgraded to the latest firmware. It tracks perfectly now. And like any tool, you have to learn its quirks. All three systems are about equal now, they just have things to learn.
And a proper lens makes a huge difference. Especially in lower light.
p.13 #14After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
Each system has own problem/problems. It is a fact you want to acknowledge or not.
if there is no problem with the Nikon AF, then why this thread is still going, and going, and going?
Just do not say all these people are trolls and Nikon haters, that's a buxxShit!
Sony has a "Sony colors" problem. Sony colors still sucks. It is a fact you want to acknowledge or not.
Canon seems has a problem with the Video codecs and files sizes. Lenses are too big and too expensive.
And so on so on.
None of them care about you or your needs. This is a childish fight.
Feb 02, 2025 at 12:07 AM
RoamingScott
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.13 #15After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
Thanks for keeping the thread alive 😁
tester_V wrote:
Each system has own problem/problems. It is a fact you want to acknowledge or not.
if there is no problem with the Nikon AF, then why this thread is still going, and going, and going?
Just do not say all these people are trolls and Nikon haters, that's a buxxShit!
Sony has a "Sony colors" problem. Sony colors still sucks. It is a fact you want to acknowledge or not.
Canon seems has a problem with the Video codecs and files sizes. Lenses are too big and too expensive.
And so on so on.
None of them care about you or your needs. This is a childish fight. ...Show more →
p.13 #16After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
I agree. It's weird that people will pretend otherwise regardless of system. In another recent thread there was one Canon fanboy adamantly defending every flaw ad nauseum. I don't understand people putting blinders on for the sake of brand loyalty. They're just brands. They all have their flaws and quirks. It's much better to discuss and learn about them openly so companies can become aware of them and fix them through firmware and/or new hardware.
And the video codecs and file sizes on Canon have always driven me nuts, especially with my previous R5. For a while their compressed formats were nearly impossible to edit on most machines except for some of the newer Mac's with Apple Silicon. I'd also love to see options for lower resolution compressed raw file sizes. I think Sony is the only one who offers this currently. But Sony's firmware support SUCKS. A family member has an A1 and the lack of updates has bothered him since he spent so much on their flagship camera.
tester_V wrote:
Each system has own problem/problems. It is a fact you want to acknowledge or not.
if there is no problem with the Nikon AF, then why this thread is still going, and going, and going?
Just do not say all these people are trolls and Nikon haters, that's a buxxShit!
Sony has a "Sony colors" problem. Sony colors still sucks. It is a fact you want to acknowledge or not.
Canon seems has a problem with the Video codecs and files sizes. Lenses are too big and too expensive.
And so on so on.
None of them care about you or your needs. This is a childish fight. ...Show more →
Feb 02, 2025 at 01:54 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
Activity
[X]
Details
p.13 #17After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
Here's Julia Trotti commenting on and showing off a lack of iris focus on a side facing subject.
I don't know if Sony can do this better, though in my experience, it's likely, but it proves my earlier point that if your DOF is SO thin that the outer edge of the eyeball is in focus (closest part to you) and the iris is out of focus, you're shooting at the wrong aperture regardless.
p.13 #18After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
If I can get a GFX100S, a camera with a far worse AF system than a Nikon Z8 to do this: GF1S1277 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr GF1S1362 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
On top of having a Nikon Z9 do this: Z09_9308 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr Z09_8974 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr Z09_8938 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Also going to chuck in some Z9 portraits while I'm at it: Z09_9610 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr Z09_4284 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr Z09_4510 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr Z09_4520 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr Z09_9463 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr Z09_2256 1 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr Z09_8483 by Marcus Beasley, on Flickr
Long story short. Is the AF system "perfect?" No. Can it get the job done? Yes. AlphaPhotography wrote:
Beautiful shots. I understand that ultra shallow DOF may seem silly but I do often like the look and I don't think it's unprofessional. It's simply a creative choice. It's also fairly lens dependent. A head and shoulders or tight headshot with a 135mm f1.8 will have very thin DOF but there's nothing outrageously OOF besides the ears. It makes for the smoothest possible bokeh and nice falloff with the hair. I also like some shots where only one eye is the focal point and in focus with a half turned face. Critical focus on the eye is always critical.
One of my favorite shoots (and shots) from many years ago was of some family members where I used my 90mm macro lens to get ultra tight shots of their eyes wide open at f2.8. Very little was in focus besides their eyes. The falloff was dreamy. They and their mom loved them. If focus was missed even slightly it would have ruined the shot along with all of the headshots and even the head and shoulders shots. DOF is very thin at these distances, especially with an 85mm f1.2 or f1.4 (one of my other favorite lenses I was using). Could I have tried to 3D track the eye in each shot? Probably. Could I have tried to use AF single point on the eye? Probably. Would these methods risk missing focus on the eye with that thin of DOF? Without a doubt. Eye-AF has made for an absolutely thoughtless workflow that allows me to focus (pun intended) on everything else going on with a shoot and not even worry about checking focus after the fact. In AF-C it achieves perfect focus even if the subject is moving as long as my shutter speed is high enough. It's that good. If I encountered a system/camera/lens that regressed my workflow back to having to do more to achieve the same or worse result I'd hate it.
I'm hopeful that this Nikon issue is a non-issue for me. But if it is or can't be relied upon it would be a huge factor in my decision to stick with the camera or use something else. I lean heavily on eye-AF and I've become too accustomed to it being flawless to accept inaccuracies now. Unless there is some true defect with the algorithm or other strange issue going on I am confident that I can get consistent results on Nikon with the right settings and quality lenses. But only time will tell. I'll report back once I'm able to do more testing and have better lenses.
...Show more →urbanwild wroteAlphaPhotography wroteThanks for the insight. I'll play around with the AF boxes. I haven't used my Z8 with multiple people in a scene yet so it may prove useful for that. My workflow with Canon is to use wide-AF and it detects each person (eye-AF) with a left/right arrow that allows you to toggle between subjects using the joystick. Does Nikon have anything similar to this?
As for the eyelash AF and Trump's portrait, I'm not sure what settings they used but I'm sure any of us could get a sharp retina in a controlled environment, probably even 95% of the time using eye-AF. What myself and others are concerned with are those strange occasional misses that people have been discussing for a couple years while using eye-AF and why they occur. Is it something that can be adjusted with software? Is it a lens issue? Is it front focusing due to lighting? Obviously difficult to pinpoint but again not an issue I ever saw pop-up with Sony or Canon (except for adapted lenses front focusing many years ago) so it seems to be Nikon specific whatever it is. It's just strange to me that some people seem to pretend it doesn't exist. Maybe it doesn't for some but it's clear that it does for others. My best guess is that it's just the AF algorithm getting confused in certain situations, especially glasses or headwear, occasionally eyelashes for whatever reason. I actually vaguely remember having that issue with glasses shooting Sony many years ago, where it would focus on the glasses instead of the eye (A7RII maybe?)
urbanwild wroteAlphaPhotography wroteRoamingScott wroteThe reality of the situation is I could post my exact button layout and settings and in another set of hands, totally different output would be possible due to differing skill levels, reaction times, anticipation zone focusing, and a slew of other factors. I've put in the 10,000 hours and can get great results out of any brand, so these conversations are squarely in the realm of amateurs unwilling to do the same, or pros expecting to pick up a new toy and expect it to work just like their totally different one of which they've put a ton of time into learning the ins and outs.
Then there would be bitching that Scott oversold the capabilities of the camera and must be a brand whore falsely advocating for an inferior product, so why bother with all that?
My Z cameras are on Area with subject detection the vast majority of the time and the results speak for themselves. It's why I post so many photos, to counteract all this inferiority complex FUD propagated by a handful of loser Sony fanboys that come here to waste away their sunset years.I can assure you that is the wrong approach. There are plenty of extremely helpful settings recommendations on this forum across all brands. To avoid posting your settings because you think it won't work in someone else's hands or because you think you'll get some sort of backlash is silly. This forum was built around helping others and sharing.
But it is good to know that for you Auto Area with subject detection works well. Many others in this thread have inferred that it doesn't and that more complex settings adjustments are needed for consistent focus.For what it's worth, I also use Area with subject detection where I need autofocus. What I like with the new Nikon cameras is the different shapes of boxes you can use. Some say it's too overwhelming / too much to scroll through, but I often find in busy conditions where I really want to be specific, I quickly change the shape of the AF area to pull the right subject out of the crowd. I do it with a quick spin of a wheel with a button pushed down.....super quick. In very difficult conditions, I may just do spot focus, which again is a quick button press which I've selected. All told, I've been pretty impressed with the AF with the Z8 and Zf. My Z6ii isn't as good (and the Z7 is worse), but both are still very effective with stationary subjects. Eyelash AF comments....well, see my comment earlier.
With my old D500, D25 tracking worked wonders. I don't use that so much anymore as I find the area eye-AF works well on mirrorless. I always thought the D850 AF was inferior to the D500 due to the AF zones available, so I'll infer that the Z8 is better than the D850 without a direct comparison.
I think dangling a comparison with another brand from the get-go just invited a certain individual to the show where he repeats his "Sony is better" rant which is evident in his history of posts.....so no doubt that set the mood in a spiral again. It's similar to going to a restaurant and telling everyone the food there isn't as good as next door. I'll trust that the OP isn't a troll who has 2 accounts and simply suggest staying out of the comparisons and just ask for advice about the system people here use (how effective it is, their workflow, etc). One may say this is a sensitive bunch after years of Sony marketing targeted against Nikon, but the truth is that people here are just a little tired of it now that we're a couple of years beyond the Nikon AF challenges and there's enough in this forum to suggest that Nikon, Canon and Sony are all very similar with AF (despite some small differences). I believe this has been discovered yet again in this thread.Yes to the first question......easy peasy and I think Nikon was praised for its control over which eye / face you can toggle back and forth with back in the day. One subject to focus on in an uncomplicated field shouldn't be a challenge for these systems in reasonable light.
Sharing the Trump shot was a half-joke because it supported my statement about how the pros will shoot with a tighter aperture to ensure they had the appropriate amount of detail (they weren't shooting at f1.2 in close). If you look back at the shot, you'll notice that his whole head is in focus. When people (like me at times) shoot wide open and get too close because we're excited to shoot wide open, the shots look less professional to me. It's all good fun trying to get a razor thin depth of field just right, but in most cases it doesn't do much in terms of professional-looking images. So eye-AF only hitting the lashes......well, you're probably taking a limited shot anyway regardless of system and retina sharpness from my perspective (others may rightfully disagree).
Where I will agree with you above is with the eye glasses. I definitely find eye- AF will get tricked by eye glasses with my Zf eye-AF (will have to check through Z8 shots). Not sure how this compares with other systems. But again, what I really want is a shot that has the nose, glasses, eye lashes, eyes and the ears all in focus at the least in most images. So I'm fighting myself more than the camera by not stepping back or adjusting my aperture.
I'm not concerned with getting 100% focus accuracy in all types of situations. I think that's a lot to expect out of any system and you can drive yourself nuts trying to sort it out. My livelihood doesn't depend on it and I get many more images than I need in most situations with the AF. What's more important to me are the lenses, feel of the camera, workflow, and more importantly, the IQ / output. I've never been upset with Nikon's AF enough to worry about it, but a search through my images will tell you if your shooting needs differ from mine.
Best advice I can give you though - step away from the keyboard and pick up the Z8 You will learn more from shooting than you will from more time on this thread for now! Congrats on the Z8. It's a phenomenal camera. I'll close this message up with a couple of shots taken with the Z8, an ftz and the 400mm f2.8 (f-mount).....the ironman athletes were cycling at about 35km/h towards me. I used area mode eye-AF. If you go to my website, you'll see more like this. With the Z8, it was like a hot knife through butter getting these athletes in focus. The last shot I added was from a fundraiser where I would have changed the area of the AF box so that I ensured I had the lead rider(s). All of the shots below would have been at f2.8 at 400mm (moving vehicle on the last one I may add). The Z8 is great!
p.13 #19After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
I honestly think that if you're dealing with severe backlighting you put the camera on "idiot mode" and manage the AF box yourself. RoamingScott wrote:
Here's Julia Trotti commenting on and showing off a lack of iris focus on a side facing subject.
I don't know if Sony can do this better, though in my experience, it's likely, but it proves my earlier point that if your DOF is SO thin that the outer edge of the eyeball is in focus (closest part to you) and the iris is out of focus, you're shooting at the wrong aperture regardless.
p.13 #20After testing Z8 and having focus issues I may go to the Sony A7RV
AlphaPhotography wrote:
I agree. It's weird that people will pretend otherwise regardless of system.
Nobody is pretending. The problem is we're on the internet, and you're having trouble separating competent people from incompetent, and there's no way to hold people accountable or judge their competence from forum posts. At some point it's just best to get the camera in hand and see for yourself what's possible. I do this every time a new camera emerges that I get a sense I might choose as my next workhorse - rent for a long weekend and put it through its paces, and decide for myself if it's a good creative partner. No sense chasing your tail with so much speculative nonsense, or trusting others to make up your mind for you.