p.4 #1Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for Z-mount got announced!
glassartist wrote: Ripolini wrotemapgraphs wroteI've never seen anything from Voigtländer about them changing the lens recipe for a new mount.According to data published in Cosina website, the 50/2 Apo-Lanthar VM has a different design from that of 50/2 AL for E- and Z- mount. VM version has only two abnormal partial dispersion elements.
glassartist wroteWhy would film would have " the ability to receive the light coming from the lens even on an angle" when the goal was to have it lie flat against the 'platen'?Because film doesn't have microlenses on top of the emulsion. Both film and sensor must be flat, being (theoretically) flat the focus plane of SLR/DSLR/mirrorless cameras.Maybe I'm thinking about this wrong (which wouldn't surprise me), but shouldn't micro lenses help direct oblique rays down to the sensor surface? Or are you suggesting that unlike film where the film emulsion is on the surface, the micro lenses add depth and further offset the sensor?
Film has some tolerance when the light is on some angle. On the other hand the sensor needs to be vertical. If I am remembering correctly microlnnses was the Leica solution in order their older lenses to be usable on its digital cameras. I guess that the DLSR manufacturers (keep in mind that this is my assumption) as the were using larger diameter optics had less issues with that.
p.4 #2Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for Z-mount got announced!
stavrosf wrote:
BTW it seems that people in Germany started receiving their lenses (facebook posts and idealo.de availability site). I still waiting for mine (in Greece).
I should receive mine on Thursday.
glassartist wrote:
Maybe I'm thinking about this wrong (which wouldn't surprise me), but shouldn't micro lenses help direct oblique rays down to the sensor surface? Or are you suggesting that unlike film where the film emulsion is on the surface, the micro lenses add depth and further offset the sensor?
"Leica has adopted offset microlenses, to ensure that the pixels near the edge of the sensor can cope with light rays approaching the sensor at a very shallow angle. This is a particular challenge for lenses that mount very close to the sensor, especially when some of these optics were designed with film in mind." [https://www.dpreview.com/opinion/2213667251/leica-s-m11-risks-rendering-the-rangefinder-obsolete]
p.4 #8Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for Z-mount got announced!
Ripolini wrote:
Pictures coming soon.
First impressions.
Distant subjects: @ f/1.5 the center of the image is rather sharp; out of the DX area, performance declines. The lens is never as sharp as an Apo-Lanthar. W/open, it's about as sharp as an old Nikkor AI 50/1.8 stopped down to f/2.8. At intermediate apertures, the old 50/1.8 is probably better. Close subjects: with close subjects things get worse; with the subject in the central area of the frame, sharpness is similar to borders' at long distances; in the borders (well, I mean in the intersections of the line obtained with the rule of thirds) the image quality is barely acceptable, even @ f/2.
I'll continue testing the lens, then decide to keep it or not.
Distant subjects: @ f/1.5 the center of the image is rather sharp; out of the DX area, performance declines. The lens is never as sharp as an Apo-Lanthar. W/open, it's about as sharp as an old Nikkor AI 50/1.8 stopped down to f/2.8. At intermediate apertures, the old 50/1.8 is probably better. Close subjects: with close subjects things get worse; with the subject in the central area of the frame, sharpness is similar to borders' at long distances; in the borders (well, I mean in the intersections of the line obtained with the rule of thirds) the image quality is barely acceptable, even @ f/2.
I'll continue testing the lens, then decide to keep it or not.
p.4 #11Cosina Voigtländer Nokton 28/1.5 lens for Z-mount got announced!
Jepser wrote: glassartist wroteI can’t even find them on pre-order here in the US. Sigh.You can take comfort that the lens propably will be a lot less expensive than in europe when it shows up
Strangely, it's already available here in Europe, whereas the E-mount version still seems out-of-stock everywhere I look (unless they're selling like crazy, which I doubt).
It's listed at €999, so that's the same price as the 75 mm/1.5 and about 14% below the price of the 35 & 50 mm/2 II. Fair, I suppose. I would've expected more if the US price is $900.
Distant subjects: @ f/1.5 the center of the image is rather sharp; out of the DX area, performance declines. The lens is never as sharp as an Apo-Lanthar. W/open, it's about as sharp as an old Nikkor AI 50/1.8 stopped down to f/2.8. At intermediate apertures, the old 50/1.8 is probably better. Close subjects: with close subjects things get worse; with the subject in the central area of the frame, sharpness is similar to borders' at long distances; in the borders (well, I mean in the intersections of the line obtained with the rule of thirds) the image quality is barely acceptable, even @ f/2.
I'll continue testing the lens, then decide to keep it or not.
Now this is getting interesting… I was quite confident to order this lens in the next weeks, but now I‘m a bit hesitant. This is already the second time someone mentions that he is not really satisfied or impressed. I like my Nikon 28 1.4 E (F-Mount), but it looks a bit awkward and bulky on the Zf. I don‘t need autofokus or APO perfection, but I would really like it to be as good as my trusted 28 1.4 E…
Distant subjects: @ f/1.5 the center of the image is rather sharp; out of the DX area, performance declines. The lens is never as sharp as an Apo-Lanthar. W/open, it's about as sharp as an old Nikkor AI 50/1.8 stopped down to f/2.8. At intermediate apertures, the old 50/1.8 is probably better. Close subjects: with close subjects things get worse; with the subject in the central area of the frame, sharpness is similar to borders' at long distances; in the borders (well, I mean in the intersections of the line obtained with the rule of thirds) the image quality is barely acceptable, even @ f/2.
I'll continue testing the lens, then decide to keep it or not.
Summary: I'm not that positively impressed.Now this is getting interesting… I was quite confident to order this lens in the next weeks, but now I‘m a bit hesitant. This is already the second time someone mentions that he is not really satisfied or impressed. I like my Nikon 28 1.4 E (F-Mount), but it looks a bit awkward and bulky on the Zf. I don‘t need autofokus or APO perfection, but I would really like it to be as good as my trusted 28 1.4 E…
Looking forward to more impressions and samples…
Isn't the Nikon 28 f1.4 kind of legendary? As much as I love the IQ of the V35, V50 APO's - as well as the V75, I'd be shocked if it was in the same class as the Nikon at less than half the price . . .. I'm just hoping it has a bit of that Voigtlander essence in a compact, smoothly functioning body.
Distant subjects: @ f/1.5 the center of the image is rather sharp; out of the DX area, performance declines. The lens is never as sharp as an Apo-Lanthar. W/open, it's about as sharp as an old Nikkor AI 50/1.8 stopped down to f/2.8. At intermediate apertures, the old 50/1.8 is probably better. Close subjects: with close subjects things get worse; with the subject in the central area of the frame, sharpness is similar to borders' at long distances; in the borders (well, I mean in the intersections of the line obtained with the rule of thirds) the image quality is barely acceptable, even @ f/2.
I'll continue testing the lens, then decide to keep it or not.
Summary: I'm not that positively impressed.Now this is getting interesting… I was quite confident to order this lens in the next weeks, but now I‘m a bit hesitant. This is already the second time someone mentions that he is not really satisfied or impressed. I like my Nikon 28 1.4 E (F-Mount), but it looks a bit awkward and bulky on the Zf. I don‘t need autofokus or APO perfection, but I would really like it to be as good as my trusted 28 1.4 E…
Looking forward to more impressions and samples…Isn't the Nikon 28 f1.4 kind of legendary? As much as I love the IQ of the V35, V50 APO's - as well as the V75, I'd be shocked if it was in the same class as the Nikon at less than half the price . . .. I'm just hoping it has a bit of that Voigtlander essence in a compact, smoothly functioning body.
Yes, the 28 1.4 E is kind of legendary. I have a few Voigtlaender lenses for M- and Z-Mount, and I'm liking them all very much. My only "missing piece" is a 28 with a fairly wide aperture for my Zf. This 28 f1.5 for Z-Mount is very tempting, based on the experience with my other Voigtlaenders. I really hope it comes close to the Nikon, especially wide open (I love this look).
Another possibility would be the Thypoch 28 f1.4, but it is not chipped and thus I would not get the focus confirmation (green box). According to the reviews it also seems to be excellent.