In a the buy & sell forum I see many people listing the shutter counts for the Z8/Z9 bodies or in the WTB posts, people want to know how many shots taken are on the bodies. Why is this important? For instance, I bought two Z9s a few months ago for a project. One body was used for a stop motion video project and we logged a lot of frames (hundreds of thousands) in the process. Does that make that body somehow worse than other, which was used as a backup? The main camera was in a cage and used remote triggering so the body appears new but we just took a lot of frames using high speed bursts. With an e-shutter how does that degrade the condition of this camera in a second sale scenario?
People are idiots. There is no such thing as "shutter count" in the historical sense on a shutterless camera. Any number reported would be functionally useless in determining the age or how the camera was used. I could take 100,000 shots in a single day.
Just being inquisitive here...
Doesn't the sensor "wear" due to heat stress?
Like, if you shot 8 hours of non stop video, that would stress the sensor and related circuitry paths?
Battery, card slots, etc?
It’s a different technology, so you have to stop using old rules. In 8-hours, for example, a Z9 shooting 4k 60 video could take 1,728,000 frames. In DSLR terms, you probably would have been going on your 3rd or 4th shutter replacement. The cards could handle it and the batteries would still show “new”. It’s a new world with new guidelines.
But, I'm guessing, the sensor still does "wear" from heat stress?
This has always been the bane of sensors, shooting long videos induces heat stress.
I think it starts showing up as more noise to the sensor?
You have to let it cool off to start "fresh".
terencepatrick wrote:
In a the buy & sell forum I see many people listing the shutter counts for the Z8/Z9 bodies or in the WTB posts, people want to know how many shots taken are on the bodies. Why is this important? For instance, I bought two Z9s a few months ago for a project. One body was used for a stop motion video project and we logged a lot of frames (hundreds of thousands) in the process. Does that make that body somehow worse than other, which was used as a backup? The main camera was in a cage and used remote triggering so the body appears new but we just took a lot of frames using high speed bursts. With an e-shutter how does that degrade the condition of this camera in a second sale scenario?...Show more →
If you where buying a used Z9, if all there things where equal including price, would you pick the one with 2 millon shutter count or 10K?
That alone doesn't tell the whole story but silicon breaks down- Transitors turning on and off causing them to degrade over time.
So is there merit in asking about shutter count alone?
Is there a better indication of use if you can't physically hold the camera on the buy/sell forum?
Probably not.
We can call people idiots and pretend its always the next guy that is stupid but a 3k dollar camera is a big purchase for some people. How else can you tell how much/little the camera was used vs just trusting them on what they did with the camera.
RustyRus wrote: terencepatrick wroteIn a the buy & sell forum I see many people listing the shutter counts for the Z8/Z9 bodies or in the WTB posts, people want to know how many shots taken are on the bodies. Why is this important? For instance, I bought two Z9s a few months ago for a project. One body was used for a stop motion video project and we logged a lot of frames (hundreds of thousands) in the process. Does that make that body somehow worse than other, which was used as a backup? The main camera was in a cage and used remote triggering so the body appears new but we just took a lot of frames using high speed bursts. With an e-shutter how does that degrade the condition of this camera in a second sale scenario?If you where buying a used Z9, if all things where equal would you pick the one with 2 millon shutter count or 10K?
That alone doesn't tell the whole story but silicon breaks down- Transitors turning on and off causing them to degrade over time.
So is there merit in asking about shutter count alone?
Is there a better indication of use if you can't physically hold the camera on the buy/sell forum?
Probably not.
We can call people idiots and pretend its always the next guy that is stupid but a 3k dollar camera is a big purchase for some people. How else can you tell how much/little the camera was used vs just trusting them on what they did with the camera....Show more →
I would argue that the age of the camera and what the person shoots is a better measure. The landscape guy will likely not take nearly as many frames as the sports shooter who's camera is a month old , vs landscape who bought his launch day. You can easily rack up thousands of photos on a silent camera with 0 blackout , doesn't mean the camera was abused ... it's doing what it's designed to do, and built to do. Unless the shutter count is excessive I wouldn't worry about it , there's guys out there already hitting close to 1 million frames.
p.1 #10Inquiries for Nikon Z8 / Z9 shutter counts.
JustShootMe wrote: RustyRus wroteterencepatrick wroteIn a the buy & sell forum I see many people listing the shutter counts for the Z8/Z9 bodies or in the WTB posts, people want to know how many shots taken are on the bodies. Why is this important? For instance, I bought two Z9s a few months ago for a project. One body was used for a stop motion video project and we logged a lot of frames (hundreds of thousands) in the process. Does that make that body somehow worse than other, which was used as a backup? The main camera was in a cage and used remote triggering so the body appears new but we just took a lot of frames using high speed bursts. With an e-shutter how does that degrade the condition of this camera in a second sale scenario?If you where buying a used Z9, if all things where equal would you pick the one with 2 millon shutter count or 10K?
That alone doesn't tell the whole story but silicon breaks down- Transitors turning on and off causing them to degrade over time.
So is there merit in asking about shutter count alone?
Is there a better indication of use if you can't physically hold the camera on the buy/sell forum?
Probably not.
We can call people idiots and pretend its always the next guy that is stupid but a 3k dollar camera is a big purchase for some people. How else can you tell how much/little the camera was used vs just trusting them on what they did with the camera.I would argue that the age of the camera and what the person shoots is a better measure. The landscape guy will likely not take nearly as many frames as the sports shooter who's camera is a month old , vs landscape who bought his launch day. You can easily rack up thousands of photos on a silent camera with 0 blackout , doesn't mean the camera was abused ... it's doing what it's designed to do, and built to do. Unless the shutter count is excessive I wouldn't worry about it , there's guys out there already hitting close to 1 million frames. ...Show more →
Agreed- All of the matters, shutter count is also part of that equation as well. Its a 1 year old Z8 with 3k count, vs a 1 year old Z8 with 989K. There is a difference - How much? Up to the person buying it but its not a pointless question.
p.1 #12Inquiries for Nikon Z8 / Z9 shutter counts.
Although there isn't a physical shutter on the Z8 and Z9, it's going to be the best indicator of how used it is. That and obvious physical wear and tear on the outside.
If a physically mint Z8 came up for sale with 2,000,000 images taken for $2500, I dunno if I'd pull the trigger. Technically I could be wrong about being skeptical about its reliability. I'd wouldn't have peace of mind relying on it.
p.1 #16Inquiries for Nikon Z8 / Z9 shutter counts.
RustyRus wrote: terencepatrick wroteIn a the buy & sell forum I see many people listing the shutter counts for the Z8/Z9 bodies or in the WTB posts, people want to know how many shots taken are on the bodies. Why is this important? For instance, I bought two Z9s a few months ago for a project. One body was used for a stop motion video project and we logged a lot of frames (hundreds of thousands) in the process. Does that make that body somehow worse than other, which was used as a backup? The main camera was in a cage and used remote triggering so the body appears new but we just took a lot of frames using high speed bursts. With an e-shutter how does that degrade the condition of this camera in a second sale scenario?We can call people idiots and pretend its always the next guy that is stupid but a 3k dollar camera is a big purchase for some people. How else can you tell how much/little the camera was used vs just trusting them on what they did with the camera.
p.1 #17Inquiries for Nikon Z8 / Z9 shutter counts.
terencepatrick wrote: RustyRus wroteterencepatrick wroteIn a the buy & sell forum I see many people listing the shutter counts for the Z8/Z9 bodies or in the WTB posts, people want to know how many shots taken are on the bodies. Why is this important? For instance, I bought two Z9s a few months ago for a project. One body was used for a stop motion video project and we logged a lot of frames (hundreds of thousands) in the process. Does that make that body somehow worse than other, which was used as a backup? The main camera was in a cage and used remote triggering so the body appears new but we just took a lot of frames using high speed bursts. With an e-shutter how does that degrade the condition of this camera in a second sale scenario?We can call people idiots and pretend its always the next guy that is stupid but a 3k dollar camera is a big purchase for some people. How else can you tell how much/little the camera was used vs just trusting them on what they did with the camera.Just for clarity, I did not call anyone an idiot.
Sorry- That was from another post- I know that was not your comment-
p.1 #18Inquiries for Nikon Z8 / Z9 shutter counts.
RoamingScott wrote: lukemeup wroteAll good points until you realize that a body with 3000 shutter count could have been used for 2000 hours of video. Which ironically would be far more "wear" due to heat on a camera than 100,000 stills
Not sure if I'd classify it as ironic - Roger Cicala from Lens Rentals posted an article years ago about how heavy video use prematurely-ages cameras.
p.1 #19Inquiries for Nikon Z8 / Z9 shutter counts.
When I first got my Z9, I went around showing my DSLR friends just how many shots the camera could take with a fast Cfast card. I'd hold the shutter button down and count up the hundreds of images it just took. With pre-capture, it was even more. So in the first few months, I probably racked up 10,000 or more image counts. I sold my Z9 to a friend so I could get the lighter Z8. I used pre-capture almost exclusively since I am a wildlife/bird photographer. My Z8 and his Z9 still work perfectly. So is our high "shutter" count bad for resale? I don't think I'd sell my Z8 if someone demanded the shutter count. Electronic firing is nowhere near the same as a mirrow slapping up and down continuously!
p.1 #20Inquiries for Nikon Z8 / Z9 shutter counts.
It'd be nice if these cameras had an hours meter, or maybe 2 hours meters: One for total hours switched on, one for video recording/pre-capture. The CMOS itself, if not mistreated by exposing it to radiation, extreme heat, overbright light that damages pixels, etc will likely last longer than the components on the logic board. The IBIS mechanism probably has a lifespan shorter than the CMOS or the board(s).