fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Help needed to chose a system

  
 
Yaniv
Offline

p.1 #1Help needed to chose a system
Hi all,

i haven't been here for a long time and I need some advice.

for the past 8 years, I have been using the Canon 5D mark IV + 24-70 2.8 + 70-200 2.8 + 300 2.8

recently due to a stupid mistake, It was stolen from me.

So I am in the market for a new system.

First and foremost, I am not a pro, I shoot my kids mainly, and my extended family.
60% portraits 40% sports (my kids swimming...soccer etc..) just for my fun and I like to print (as big as I can get) the good ones and put them around my house/office.

I only want two lenses if it is possible to cover my use case I don't like to carry a lot of equipment and am not a fan of switching lenses.

Options I am thinking of:

Canon R5 + 28-70 2.0 + 100-300 2.8
Canon R3 + 28-70 2.0 + 100-300 2.8


I like the 45MP of the R5 for printouts, but someone told me the R3 is one hell of a camera, so it is here. The 5D sucked at focusing on sports fast action I always missed a lot of potential shots. Maybe it was me maybe it is me and the camera so anything the camera can help me I will appreciate it.

I started reading around and heard that a R5 mark II is coming in the next few weeks. should I wait?

i plan to buy and stick with it for many years.


Sorry for the long post, I appreciate some feedback and ideas on what to get.

Thanks!



Jun 09, 2024 at 06:56 PM
artsupreme
Online
Details
p.1 #2Help needed to chose a system
Yaniv wrote:
Hi all,

i haven't been here for a long time and I need some advice.

for the past 8 years, I have been using the Canon 5D mark IV + 24-70 2.8 + 70-200 2.8 + 300 2.8

recently due to a stupid mistake, It was stolen from me.

So I am in the market for a new system.

First and foremost, I am not a pro, I shoot my kids mainly, and my extended family.
60% portraits 40% sports (my kids swimming...soccer etc..) just for my fun and I like to print (as big as I can get) the good ones and put them
...Show more →

I own all of the above and I would say wait for the R5II as it should combine the pixels of the R5 and AF/speed of the R3. Even the current R5 is plenty to do what you want it for, but the R5II should have a stacked sensor with a fast readout speed that will nearly eliminate rolling shutter. I expect the R5II to have some amazing video specs as well, and even though you might not shoot video now you might find it fun to shoot with the R5II.

The R5II should be here in August according to the latest rumors but it keeps getting pushed back. Regardless, it will be worth the wait.
Jun 09, 2024 at 07:38 PM
vbnut
Offline
Details
p.1 #3Help needed to chose a system
artsupreme wrote:
I own all of the above and I would say wait for the R5II as it should combine the pixels of the R5 and AF/speed of the R3. Even the current R5 is plenty to do what you want it for, but the R5II should have a stacked sensor with a fast readout speed that will nearly eliminate rolling shutter. I expect the R5II to have some amazing video specs as well, and even though you might not shoot video now you might find it fun to shoot with the R5II.

The R5II should be here in August according to the
...Show more →

I hope you are right, as that would be a helluva camera, and if the R5II is that good, I can't even imagine what the R1 would be like (and yes, I've seen the development announcement and the accompanying rumors).
Jun 09, 2024 at 08:10 PM
tr1957
Offline
Details
p.1 #4Help needed to chose a system
How big a print is "as big as you can get"? If it's 40"x60" you'll want as many pixels as possible (R5), if you're talking more like 20"x30" or smaller, a 24 MP R6ii (which has autofocus similar the R3) would likely work fine. The 28-70 and 100-300 lenses are supposedly great performers but are pretty heavy. Also, is 28mm wide enough for any interior places you have or would a 24-105 (f2.8 or f4) be better?
Jun 09, 2024 at 11:40 PM
big country
Offline
Details
p.1 #5Help needed to chose a system
I've been shooting a lot of kids soccer this past year and in my opinion, the R3 smokes the R5 on AF. I have them set up exactly the same way, and the R3 just sticks on the kid, even when running behind the mesh net, the R5 will loose the kid. The R5 does great, especially compared to previously DSRL's, but the R3 is better.

i've made 40x60 prints with the 1dx (18 mp), and they turned out beautiful! but more megapixels isn't a bad thing for cropping.

Over the years, I've made a ton of 20x30 prints for clients using cameras that were 10-16 megapixels.

i like the r5 for its cropping abilities, but the r3 is a better camera, especially if you are using teleconverters on your lenses.

And if you're serious about the 100-300, I'll have some for sale, well under retail, from authorized dealer and canon carepak eligible.


Jun 10, 2024 at 05:40 AM
Sy Sez
Offline
Details
p.1 #6Help needed to chose a system
Judging from what you've found satisfactory for the past 8 years, it would seem you prioritize:
A Full frame body, fastest aperture lenses, focal lengths from 24mm at the wide end, and 300mm at the long end to be adequate.

For a two-lens kit the 28-70 F2, & 100-300 F2.8 certainly hit the mark, though the 24-70 gives you a bit wider perspective, at a pound lighter, and 2.8 is not exactly "slow".

As to the body, you couldn't go wrong with the R3, but if you have the patience, it might be worth waiting to see how the R5-2 measures up?
Jun 10, 2024 at 01:05 PM
JMattH
Offline
Details
p.1 #7Help needed to chose a system
For what you're doing, I'd skip the 100-300. Get the 24-105mm "kit" lens. (It's an L model lens, but was used in early R5 kits. Might still be today). For the 2nd lens I'd suggest the 100-500mm. And wait for the R5 II.
Jun 10, 2024 at 07:41 PM
volyrat
Offline
Details
p.1 #8Help needed to chose a system
If waiting until August (or when ever the R5ii shows up) isn't in the cards, maybe pick up a refurbished R6ii and your choice of lenses, then sell the R6ii when the R5ii shows up? At least you won't be without anything to shoot with for the summer.
Jun 11, 2024 at 07:58 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.1 #9Help needed to chose a system
I had a 5D4 and I really liked it. I had a 7D2 as well. I sold the 5D4 for an R which basically had the same sensor. I had so much fun with it my 7D2 never came out of the bag.

I then got the R5. Great cam but I did it because the R6 had only 20mp. My sweet spot for FF was 30. I eventually sold the R5 for the R6II and R7. The R6II is perfect for my needs. For family shots 24 is plenty I think. AF is amazing. It has more options AF mapping options than the R5. You can map Subject to Detect to a button which is the cats meow. I wish my R7 had that option.

Like others said the R5II will be out soon. This is an interesting video but just her opinion.



If you can afford the R3 then that may be for you.

Jun 11, 2024 at 11:42 PM
well69
Offline
Details
p.1 #10Help needed to chose a system
Look at the autofocus features on the r6mkii - why? Because those features and more will be on the 5dmkii.

If you can wait, do. Learn one excellent camera once and enjoy it for years and years.
Jun 14, 2024 at 06:07 PM
TJ Asher
Offline
Details
p.1 #11Help needed to chose a system
Another vote for the R6II (or even the little R8). Both are less expensive and the 24ish MP is fine. If you need to print super-huge, then Get Topaz AI and upscale it.

The autofocus and subject tracking on the R mount bodies is amazing compared to the EF mount bodies.

The tiny batteries of the R8 are rather annoying and last about 90 minutes of solid shooting so get spares if you go that route.

If you do go with R6II then get the grip for extra battery capacity.

Either way, once you get used to the R series it's really hard to go back to the EF mount bodies.
Jun 15, 2024 at 12:30 PM
Yaniv
Offline
Details
p.1 #12Help needed to chose a system
Thank you everyone for the feedback.

I have decided to go with the Canon R5+Grip + 28-70 2.0 + 100-300 2.8

The R5 current price did it for me, I also know I will upgrade later down the line to the R5 mark II, I am not willing to wait for it so I got what I can today. I ordered the R5 from this site's buy and sell forum (new with grip) I am waiting for it to arrive. For that price, it was a no-brainer for me.

Again, thank you as always it was beneficial.
Jun 15, 2024 at 06:10 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister