fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2024 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2024Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0

  
 
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.11 #1Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
1bwana1 wrote:
bernardl wrote
1bwana1 wrote
bernardl wrote
1bwana1 wrote
bernardl wroteYou understood we are talking about new features?

The a9III works very well. Not at the level of perfection you are describing in terms of people AF but very well. I can’t say it’s significantly better than the Z8/Z9 though. Overall a bit better at best.

Cheers,
Bernard
Just curious Bernard what you think a th components in Nikon cameras that define its "development platform". How do you think this differs from what other manufacturers are doing?
What I have been referring to as development platform is the set of software development tools and processes turning a prioritized set of requirements into a continuous stream of functional deliveries.

Cheers,
Bernard
You don't think the other companies also do this? I believe that they do. Some on a much larger scale and over a much broader scope.

In fact some in the industry have expanded their tools into an API available to their customers to develop their own capabilities and deliverables.

For an example of this just look at the camera infrastructure that ran yesterday's Super Bowl. Amazing in both capability and scale. A platform far beyond anything Nikon has even considered doing.

Your description of what Nikon is doing sounds like a customer orientated sales pitch that every software/tech company I have ever owned or did business with puts out. It actually says very little.

To operate at scale with deliveries a company must have a well defined set of processes and tools in place. If we accept scale as such an indicator then just comparing Sony to Nikon should put this into perspective.

https://downloadcenter.nikonimglib.com/en/index.html

https://www.sony.com/electronics/support

As you can see the scale and diversity of what Sony is dealing with is on a whole different level than Nikon.

Of course as far as benefit provided to users like us the real difference lies in the choices made in Boardroom, not the technology. In the case of useful upgrades with important feature enhancement in the narrow range of products of interest to this forum, I will say that Nikon is much more focused than Sony. But this is likely a business decision, not the result of some technically superior development platform.
I believe that most companies want to do this, but implementing it is very challenging, especially with the programming languages camera firmwares are developed with.

It's not about the number of projects running in parallel, it's about the ability to run an agile approach on a mission critical piece of code. If you owned several software companies as you claim you did, then you know extremely well how difficult this is.

And Sony hasn't shown the first bit of hint demonstrating that they can do it.

Cheers,
Bernard
If you don't see that capability in a company like Sony which is the World leader and innovator in a variety of technology industries including imaging the I think your glasses must be heavly obscured by bias.

Your description of Nikon's development platform could have been cpy and pasted from a money raise pitch deck or a sales brochure.

You are ust being silly now. But I think you know that very well.


I don't doubt that Sony imaging could put in place an agile firmware development platform if they decided to, but I don't believe that they have and it's not an easy task to achieve, again considering the technical constraints of firmware development.

You are probably right that them not having put in place such a capability is the result of Sony not wishing to compromise future sales of new hardware by delivering additional value to existing customers. A boardroom decision as you call it.

Cheers,
Bernard

Feb 12, 2024 at 05:35 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.11 #2Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
bernardl wrote:
1bwana1 wrote
bernardl wrote
1bwana1 wrote
bernardl wrote
1bwana1 wroteJust curious Bernard what you think a th components in Nikon cameras that define its "development platform". How do you think this differs from what other manufacturers are doing?
What I have been referring to as development platform is the set of software development tools and processes turning a prioritized set of requirements into a continuous stream of functional deliveries.

Cheers,
Bernard
You don't think the other companies also do this? I believe that they do. Some on a much larger scale and over a much broader scope.

In fact some in the industry have expanded their tools into an API available to their customers to develop their own capabilities and deliverables.

For an example of this just look at the camera infrastructure that ran yesterday's Super Bowl. Amazing in both capability and scale. A platform far beyond anything Nikon has even considered doing.

Your description of what Nikon is doing sounds like a customer orientated sales pitch that every software/tech company I have ever owned or did business with puts out. It actually says very little.

To operate at scale with deliveries a company must have a well defined set of processes and tools in place. If we accept scale as such an indicator then just comparing Sony to Nikon should put this into perspective.

https://downloadcenter.nikonimglib.com/en/index.html

https://www.sony.com/electronics/support

As you can see the scale and diversity of what Sony is dealing with is on a whole different level than Nikon.

Of course as far as benefit provided to users like us the real difference lies in the choices made in Boardroom, not the technology. In the case of useful upgrades with important feature enhancement in the narrow range of products of interest to this forum, I will say that Nikon is much more focused than Sony. But this is likely a business decision, not the result of some technically superior development platform.
I believe that most companies want to do this, but implementing it is very challenging, especially with the programming languages camera firmwares are developed with.

It's not about the number of projects running in parallel, it's about the ability to run an agile approach on a mission critical piece of code. If you owned several software companies as you claim you did, then you know extremely well how difficult this is.

And Sony hasn't shown the first bit of hint demonstrating that they can do it.

Cheers,
Bernard
If you don't see that capability in a company like Sony which is the World leader and innovator in a variety of technology industries including imaging the I think your glasses must be heavly obscured by bias.

Your description of Nikon's development platform could have been cpy and pasted from a money raise pitch deck or a sales brochure.

You are ust being silly now. But I think you know that very well.
I don't doubt that Sony imaging could put in place an agile firmware development platform if they decided to, but I don't believe that they have and it's not an easy task to achieve, again considering the technical constraints of firmware development.

You are probably right that them not having put in place such a capability is the result of Sony not wishing to compromise future sales of new hardware by delivering additional value to existing customers. A boardroom decision as you call it.

Cheers,
Bernard



Agile development process is absolutely not a new concept, it is decades old. Some of my companies were practicing it back in the 1990s. There have been many careers built on this concept, and consulting companies have been doing this work a very long time.

I never implied that Sony has put in place agile development due to boardroom decisions. The number of products, across a wide range of industry categories, and technology innovation on both the hardware and software side stand as strong evidence to the robustness of Sony's development process. To argue otherwise makes no sense.


I say that Nikon's approach to firmware releases is different that Sony's. Also keep in mind that many of the updates in Nikon's firmware releases just implement features that were printed in Nikon literature and promises made at the time of product release. Whatever Nikon's development process is, it was unable to get this done in time for the release of the product. Currently, I think that Nikon's attitude on this is much more customer centric than Sony's.

Feb 12, 2024 at 06:22 PM
DWOfPaul
Offline
Details
p.11 #3Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
I feel like this conversation has gone way off the rails. But my opinion, as someone that works in software development too (mostly on the product development side), Nikon and Sony are both more than capable of delivering FW updates with meaningful enhancements (Agile or not). I think the challenge is more on the business side than engineering side.

Cameras where traditionally hardware products, where what shipped out the door was what you got. Especially since the transition to mirrorless cameras have basically become computers. Now it's a business question of if they think they can be more competitive by adding new improvements to existing models, or just making new models.

Personally I think cameras will eventually become like smart phones where they get at least X years of feature improvements.

It's been pretty clear for a long time that Nikon and Sony have taken fairly diffrent product strategies with their cameras, software aside. For example Nikon has made many well rounded do it all type cameras for their time generation such as the D700, D850, and Z8. While Sony has taken the approach more of cameras for more specific niches, such as the a7r and a7s lines. At the end of the day there are consumers that prefer both, so it's good for the market as a whole that there are many options available today.
Feb 12, 2024 at 06:30 PM
Jman13
Offline
Details
p.11 #4Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
Ok: So official word on pixel shift with flash:

It works. I'm dumb.

Not that what I reported earlier wasn't accurate, because it was....but, I was dumb. See, my flash batteries were nearly dead...I didn't realize just how nearly dead until I couldn't even get it to shoot a single shot on normal shooting when I got home to try again....and I realized it wasn't even able to fully charge the capacitor.

So this morning...it's true that it fired my test shot, then failed to fire at all in pixel shift mode, then fired again after I finished pixel shift mode. But the reason that happend is because the batteries were so low that it took like 30 seconds to recycle the flash....and so it didn't get power again until after the pixel shift was finished.

Put in fresh batteries and - yup, works perfectly. Sorry about the confusion and unintentional misinformation! Now to edit all my previous comments.
Feb 12, 2024 at 07:17 PM
snapsy
Offline
Details
p.11 #5Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
@Jman13, Thanks. One "dumb" post out of the thousands helpful ones you've made is a ratio I'd love to have.
Feb 12, 2024 at 07:32 PM
dalegaspi
Offline
Details
p.11 #6Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
Jman13 wrote:
Ok: So official word on pixel shift with flash:

It works. I'm dumb.

Not that what I reported earlier wasn't accurate, because it was....but, I was dumb. See, my flash batteries were nearly dead...I didn't realize just how nearly dead until I couldn't even get it to shoot a single shot on normal shooting when I got home to try again....and I realized it wasn't even able to fully charge the capacitor.

So this morning...it's true that it fired my test shot, then failed to fire at all in pixel shift mode, then fired again after I finished pixel shift
...Show more →

that solves that mystery!

thanks.
Feb 12, 2024 at 07:33 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.11 #7Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
DWOfPaul wrote:
I feel like this conversation has gone way off the rails. But my opinion, as someone that works in software development too (mostly on the product development side), Nikon and Sony are both more than capable of delivering FW updates with meaningful enhancements (Agile or not). I think the challenge is more on the business side than engineering side.

Cameras where traditionally hardware products, where what shipped out the door was what you got. Especially since the transition to mirrorless cameras have basically become computers. Now it's a business question of if they think they can be more competitive by
...Show more →

Exactly. To think otherwise is foolish.
Feb 12, 2024 at 08:23 PM
bernardl
Offline
Details
p.11 #8Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
So since they are not limited in any way by technology, let’s just hope that in the future Sony puts the value for their customers at the center and decides to start delivering for existing cameras new functions not available/announced at release such as auto capture or pixel shift.

These could be functions available in competing cameras, other Sony cameras or completely new functions invented from scratch. They could be means to achieve better performance or usability (dedicated bird mode on the Z9/Z8) or ways to expand the envelope of usage (auto capture or pixel shift).

One example of opportunity to do just that would be to add focus stacking to the a1.

Considering that Sony is now probably on a 4 years update cycle, failure to adopt such a policy would mean that photographers hoping for new capabilities would have to decide on their continued usage of the brand based on initial specs alone. That used to be common sense but with Nikon having moved the bar the referential has changed.
Feb 13, 2024 at 12:34 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.11 #9Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
bernardl wrote:
So since they are not limited in any way by technology, let’s just hope that in the future Sony puts the value for their customers at the center and decides to start delivering for existing cameras new functions not available/announced at release such as auto capture or pixel shift.

These could be functions available in competing cameras, other Sony cameras or completely new functions invented from scratch. They could be means to achieve better performance or usability (dedicated bird mode on the Z9/Z8) or ways to expand the envelope of usage (auto capture or pixel shift).

One example of opportunity to do
...Show more →

Certainly there are many Sony users who agree strongly with that. In fact, there has been significant pressure put on Sony over this issue by the user base. In response Sony has promised a firmware update that is said to be due very shortly. From what has already announced to be included in this update, I am not very impressed or excited to get it. It absolutely would not be delivering the value that recent Nikon updates have provided. There are rumors of very big surprise feature inclusions, but I am not optimistic on that front.

I get the impression from Sony that they are not inclined to give such value. As the #1 camera company in Full Frame Mirrorless cameras and lenses (in both value and units), they may mistakenly not feel the need to compete on this. That would be a mistake in my opinion. If Sony does start adding great value through firmware updates in response to what Nikon is doing, then all Sony users should be very grateful to Nikon for that. I know I will be.
Feb 13, 2024 at 01:54 PM
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #10Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
bernardl wrote:
So since they are not limited in any way by technology, let’s just hope that in the future Sony puts the value for their customers at the center and decides to start delivering for existing cameras new functions not available/announced at release such as auto capture or pixel shift.

These could be functions available in competing cameras, other Sony cameras or completely new functions invented from scratch. They could be means to achieve better performance or usability (dedicated bird mode on the Z9/Z8) or ways to expand the envelope of usage (auto capture or pixel shift).

One example of opportunity to do
...Show more →

Yep sure many A1 owners are unhappy they still have class leading initial specs of 50mp, 30fps RAW, 9/5mp EVF. Most of them seem to be eagerly awaiting the A1ii now they have seen what the A9 III can do.

Imagine the poll - what would you rather have:

1. A1ii, or

2. A1 + "focus stacking"



Bernard - with all due respect thinking like yours is why Nikon decided not to pursue the mirrorless market in the first place.

Similarly many A7riv/A7rv owners unhappy they still have class leading specs of 60mp and dynamic range. Oh and a class leading AF system/EVF now too.

As for those poor A9 users - heck that thing is so far behind! More than a few Nikon/Sony shooters think the A9 still outperforms the Z9 with FW4.1 for BIF. Certainly 6 years later it is still a very good performer and quite competitive with most flagships of today. And the recently released upgrade - phew now that's a real beast of an upgrade - I mean I really wanted focus stacking boo hoo, so unhappy.

Oh and for those APS-C users there is the a6700 with AF performance as good as many flagships - just like that, right out of the box - no firmware update required.

On the Nikon side what do we have - another firmware update - YAWN. Focus stacking - really, wow - bigger YYAAWWNN.

Wake me up when important things get updated like FPS, EVF resolution and refresh rate and the AF system.

Interestingly how keenly the Z6/Z6ii users are awaiting new Z6iii hardware and speculating that it will have Expeed7, like the Z8/Z9. No firmware update to keep them happy - no siree - better performing hardware is what they really want.

Definitely you need to work on those Z6 users - they don't seem all that convinced that a FW update is going to give them their "Tesla" moment, they seem pretty convinced a hardware upgrade will. Heck some even speculating it will be a speed demon to rival the A9III !
Feb 13, 2024 at 06:35 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #11Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
I know reading a room requires the bare minimum of self awareness but
Feb 13, 2024 at 06:40 PM
youie
Offline
Details
p.11 #12Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
Are we still talking about Nikon's Z8 firmware 2.0 update?
I just joined in, and I'm kind of lost after readind the last few pages of this thread!
Feb 13, 2024 at 06:47 PM
sjms
Offline
Details
p.11 #13Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
it's one of those things that you learn to walk away from.
Feb 13, 2024 at 06:50 PM
groob
Offline
Details
p.11 #14Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
It's officially turned pathetic and weird.
Feb 13, 2024 at 08:17 PM
Alistair1
Offline
Details
p.11 #15Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0


duncang wrote:
bernardl wroteSo since they are not limited in any way by technology, let’s just hope that in the future Sony puts the value for their customers at the center and decides to start delivering for existing cameras new functions not available/announced at release such as auto capture or pixel shift.

These could be functions available in competing cameras, other Sony cameras or completely new functions invented from scratch. They could be means to achieve better performance or usability (dedicated bird mode on the Z9/Z8) or ways to expand the envelope of usage (auto capture or pixel shift).

One example of opportunity to do just that would be to add focus stacking to the a1.

Considering that Sony is now probably on a 4 years update cycle, failure to adopt such a policy would mean that photographers hoping for new capabilities would have to decide on their continued usage of the brand based on initial specs alone. That used to be common sense but with Nikon having moved the bar the referential has changed.
Yep sure many A1 owners are unhappy they still have class leading initial specs of 50mp, 30fps RAW, 9/5mp EVF. Most of them seem to be eagerly awaiting the A1ii now they have seen what the A9 III can do.

Imagine the poll - what would you rather have:

1. A1ii, or

2. A1 + "focus stacking"



Bernard - with all due respect thinking like yours is why Nikon decided not to pursue the mirrorless market in the first place.

Similarly many A7riv/A7rv owners unhappy they still have class leading specs of 60mp and dynamic range. Oh and a class leading AF
...Show more →

Aren't the options:

1. A1ii, or

2. A1 + focus stacking + $7,000

Or perhaps

1. A1ii - $7,000 or

2. A1 + "focus stacking"

or even

1. A1ii - $7,000 or

2. A1 + focus stacking + pre-capture + auto-capture + bug fixes + cat sounds

Feb 13, 2024 at 08:38 PM
Kry27
Offline
Details
p.11 #16Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
@ thread
Feb 13, 2024 at 11:54 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #17Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
Hint: use the "report" button on desktop for off topic posts. Fred is highly responsive. I have enough people blocked in this thread where I can't untangle it enough to even see their posts to report them or I'd do it myself.
Feb 14, 2024 at 09:09 AM
Spectro
Offline
Details
p.11 #18Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
Unfortunately it’s a trend of many Nikon Forum threads. After about a page of on topic discussion the thread devolves into an off topic technical or brand measurebating discussion.

youie wrote:
Are we still talking about Nikon's Z8 firmware 2.0 update?
I just joined in, and I'm kind of lost after readind the last few pages of this thread!

Feb 14, 2024 at 09:11 AM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.11 #19Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
youie wrote:
Are we still talking about Nikon's Z8 firmware 2.0 update?
I just joined in, and I'm kind of lost after readind the last few pages of this thread!


As soon as the purchase decisions of a select few get 'threatened' by something Nikon does, which seems to be quite often, the threads go off the rails - so if you just joined in, this is unfortunately the new normal. There is no other explanation for such a desperate need for validation and highly defensive posts we see here regularly. We're all living rent free in a few people's heads just because of the brand we shoot - imagine that.

If you ever need a break, head over to the Canon forums. It's a much more peaceful place and I cannot recall a single instance of those members coming over to the Nikon forum with unhinged rants to make themselves feel better.
Feb 14, 2024 at 10:51 AM
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.11 #20Nikon Z8 firmware 2.0
CanadaMark wrote:
youie wroteAre we still talking about Nikon's Z8 firmware 2.0 update?
I just joined in, and I'm kind of lost after readind the last few pages of this thread!
As soon as the purchase decisions of a select few get 'threatened' by something Nikon does, which seems to be quite often, the threads go off the rails - so if you just joined in, this is unfortunately the new normal. There is no other explanation for such a desperate need for validation and highly defensive posts we see here regularly. We're all living rent free in a few people's heads just because of the brand we shoot - imagine that.

If you ever need a break, head over to the Canon forums. It's a much more peaceful place and I
...Show more →

Dude - you're totally confused - this has nothing to do with what Nikon does or doesn't do. Personally I would love it if they released an A1 or an A9III, I would have no hesitation picking up a Nikon now or at any time in the future. I do it all the time just to see if they have gotten good enough yet to replace my current gear.

This has to do with stupid claims that Nikon is the new Tesla

C'mon surely even you guys must find that funny, particularly in light of the fact that the claim is made on virtually the same day some other manufacturer releases a consumer camera with global shutter - which caught everyone by surprise.

A bit of self-deprecating humour never hurt anyone.
Feb 14, 2024 at 10:10 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister