BastianK wrote: Fred Miranda wrotethrice wroteFred Miranda wroteBeing outclassed in rendering/bokeh... that must be a new measure as I find this to be very subjective. .I would usually agree but yeesh I can't imagine anyone choosing the VM bokeh over the Thypoch. Maybe you got a golden copy and there's something wrong with Bastian's haha.
I think the Thypoch has inverse field curvature at all focus distances, it will be interesting to see a fresh comparison when Bastian gets a production sample. looking at the coma tests there's something off with his Thypoch at infinity.I think what you find pleasing in terms of bokeh and rendering might not match someone else's preferences. Personally, I'm not a big fan of excessively smooth rendering; I prefer it when there's a bit more character and structure in the out-of-focus areas. But, of course, that's just my personal taste, and I don't believe a lens that offers that is necessarily superior or inferior to others.I have yet to find someone who can tell me what is great about that field curvature bringing the corners back into focus even though they shouldn't be.
I find that objectively wrong, ugly and distracting. I am also pretty sure it is the reason the Laowa 28mm 1.2 and 45mm 0.95 did not gather a lot of fans.
highdesertmesa wrotethrice wrotehighdesertmesa wrotethrice wrote...but yeesh I can't imagine anyone choosing the VM bokeh over the Thypoch...If all I shot were lens tests, I would agree.Do you shoot better stuff than Bastian? I've always found his samples and tests exceptional.
Do you have better real-world comparisons between these two lenses?His samples are designed to elicit differences between the lenses at varying distances, and it's extremely informative and helpful for how these lenses compare on a non-M sensor.Had you read the comparison you would have noticed that all the tests of the M-mount lenses have been conducted on a Leica M10.
highdesertmesa wrotethrice wrote...but yeesh I can't imagine anyone choosing the VM bokeh over the Thypoch...If all I shot were lens tests, I would agree.Also here I wonder if you actually had a look at that article.
I don't know of anyone else who goes through the trouble of comparing no less than six lenses and even finding a model to sit still long enough to dial through all of them.
I wish someone else did that, because then I wouldn't have to and could spend my time with something way more enjoyable....Show more →
Well, that’s when I get for skim reading, seeing a reference to Sony, and going straight to the photos. I’m sorry for misrepresenting your test by wrongly saying they were taken all on a non-M sensor.
highdesertmesa wrote: BastianK wroteFred Miranda wrotethrice wroteFred Miranda wroteBeing outclassed in rendering/bokeh... that must be a new measure as I find this to be very subjective. .I would usually agree but yeesh I can't imagine anyone choosing the VM bokeh over the Thypoch. Maybe you got a golden copy and there's something wrong with Bastian's haha.
I think the Thypoch has inverse field curvature at all focus distances, it will be interesting to see a fresh comparison when Bastian gets a production sample. looking at the coma tests there's something off with his Thypoch at infinity.I think what you find pleasing in terms of bokeh and rendering might not match someone else's preferences. Personally, I'm not a big fan of excessively smooth rendering; I prefer it when there's a bit more character and structure in the out-of-focus areas. But, of course, that's just my personal taste, and I don't believe a lens that offers that is necessarily superior or inferior to others.I have yet to find someone who can tell me what is great about that field curvature bringing the corners back into focus even though they shouldn't be.
I find that objectively wrong, ugly and distracting. I am also pretty sure it is the reason the Laowa 28mm 1.2 and 45mm 0.95 did not gather a lot of fans.
highdesertmesa wrotethrice wrotehighdesertmesa wrotethrice wrote...but yeesh I can't imagine anyone choosing the VM bokeh over the Thypoch...If all I shot were lens tests, I would agree.Do you shoot better stuff than Bastian? I've always found his samples and tests exceptional.
Do you have better real-world comparisons between these two lenses?His samples are designed to elicit differences between the lenses at varying distances, and it's extremely informative and helpful for how these lenses compare on a non-M sensor.Had you read the comparison you would have noticed that all the tests of the M-mount lenses have been conducted on a Leica M10.
highdesertmesa wrotethrice wrote...but yeesh I can't imagine anyone choosing the VM bokeh over the Thypoch...If all I shot were lens tests, I would agree.Also here I wonder if you actually had a look at that article.
I don't know of anyone else who goes through the trouble of comparing no less than six lenses and even finding a model to sit still long enough to dial through all of them.
I wish someone else did that, because then I wouldn't have to and could spend my time with something way more enjoyable.Well, that’s when I get for skim reading, seeing a reference to Sony, and going straight to the photos. I’m sorry for misrepresenting your test by wrongly saying they were taken all on a non-M sensor.
That’s a great and mature response James. Good to see such civility on the forum.
nehemiahphoto wrote: highdesertmesa wroteBastianK wroteFred Miranda wrotethrice wroteFred Miranda wroteBeing outclassed in rendering/bokeh... that must be a new measure as I find this to be very subjective. .I would usually agree but yeesh I can't imagine anyone choosing the VM bokeh over the Thypoch. Maybe you got a golden copy and there's something wrong with Bastian's haha.
I think the Thypoch has inverse field curvature at all focus distances, it will be interesting to see a fresh comparison when Bastian gets a production sample. looking at the coma tests there's something off with his Thypoch at infinity.I think what you find pleasing in terms of bokeh and rendering might not match someone else's preferences. Personally, I'm not a big fan of excessively smooth rendering; I prefer it when there's a bit more character and structure in the out-of-focus areas. But, of course, that's just my personal taste, and I don't believe a lens that offers that is necessarily superior or inferior to others.I have yet to find someone who can tell me what is great about that field curvature bringing the corners back into focus even though they shouldn't be.
I find that objectively wrong, ugly and distracting. I am also pretty sure it is the reason the Laowa 28mm 1.2 and 45mm 0.95 did not gather a lot of fans.
highdesertmesa wrotethrice wrotehighdesertmesa wroteIf all I shot were lens tests, I would agree.Do you shoot better stuff than Bastian? I've always found his samples and tests exceptional.
Do you have better real-world comparisons between these two lenses?His samples are designed to elicit differences between the lenses at varying distances, and it's extremely informative and helpful for how these lenses compare on a non-M sensor.Had you read the comparison you would have noticed that all the tests of the M-mount lenses have been conducted on a Leica M10.
highdesertmesa wrotethrice wrote...but yeesh I can't imagine anyone choosing the VM bokeh over the Thypoch...If all I shot were lens tests, I would agree.Also here I wonder if you actually had a look at that article.
I don't know of anyone else who goes through the trouble of comparing no less than six lenses and even finding a model to sit still long enough to dial through all of them.
I wish someone else did that, because then I wouldn't have to and could spend my time with something way more enjoyable.Well, that’s when I get for skim reading, seeing a reference to Sony, and going straight to the photos. I’m sorry for misrepresenting your test by wrongly saying they were taken all on a non-M sensor.That’s a great and mature response James. Good to see such civility on the forum.
Thanks. I have to check myself every so often. I've taken IQ tests and scored well, but I always perform very poorly in general reading comprehension testing. Sometimes I have to read things three or four times. So if I skim read something, all bets are off
My choice of lens used would be based primarily on size - would I enjoy using it? - and then flare resistance would be the next big one. So it would be the CV.
If I was a dedicated landscape photographer, I could see my choice being different.
Desmolicious wrote:
would I enjoy using it?
Talking only about the ergonomics and not the results, Thypoch gets a negative score from me in this category
I like the size, flare resistance, ergonomics, more structured draw and contrast of the CV. I like the price, better midzone performance at large apertures, less optical vignetting and lack of FC on the Thypoch.
So, essentially, trade-offs per usual 🤷🏼♂️ For my purposes, I lean CV, but going to process some Thypoch files to ascertain that.
rji2goleez wrote: rico_rico wroteDesmolicious wroteFebruary and no snow? Yeah, way to warm for this time 😬Same here in Minnesota. Next two days it will be 60-65 F. Easily 35 degrees higher than normal.
Steve Spencer wrote: rji2goleez wroterico_rico wroteDesmolicious wroteFebruary and no snow? Yeah, way to warm for this time 😬Same here in Minnesota. Next two days it will be 60-65 F. Easily 35 degrees higher than normal.In like a lamb . . .
Have we seen this compared to the Q/Q2/Q3 Summilux 28/1.7 ... IQ or size (on M)?
It looks good, just wondering what the gain / loss / diff is for when I might want to use the Q vs. the Voigt (AF / Macro notwithstanding) for rendering.
Steve Spencer wrote: rji2goleez wroterico_rico wroteDesmolicious wroteFebruary and no snow? Yeah, way to warm for this time 😬Same here in Minnesota. Next two days it will be 60-65 F. Easily 35 degrees higher than normal.In like a lamb . . .
RustyBug wrote:
Have we seen this compared to the Q/Q2/Q3 Summilux 28/1.7 ... IQ or size (on M)?
It looks good, just wondering what the gain / loss / diff is for when I might want to use the Q vs. the Voigt (AF / Macro notwithstanding) for rendering.
I don’t think any 28 beats the Q for rendering, but I’m a biased Q fan. Two completely different bokeh styles, but each has their own charm. The Q may get bested in the corners by the 28 1.5 by a stop or two. But the Q is otherwise optically very well corrected for everything but distortion. The Q is also sharp at the point of focus wide open regardless of where in the frame the subject is and at any distance. The 28 1.5 is softer wide open close up when the subject is near the intersection of the rule of thirds.
This is based on what I remember from having the 28 1.5 currently and in the past owning several copies of Q, Q2, and Q2 Mono, so someone with both may be able to test and say for sure.