fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2023 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2023Z9 Firmware Update 4.10

  
 
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #1Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Here are the swallows - well just one - but I could easily acquire and track and the camera would seldom loose the bird, and usually my fault not the cameras. Acquisition and tracking is as good as you need now. The camera seems impervious to the background and water and would even acquire the swallows behind the reeds - although it would focus on the reeds not the bird behind the reeds.

Bear in mind the shutter speed was way too low for sharp images so this test really needs to be done with a shorter lens and birds a bit closer. Also normally I wouldn't bother with swallows at 1200mm.

There are a few examples of birds in the grass where Bird Eye AF tends to focus on the grass in front of the bird despite showing the EYE AF box. Wasn't particularly good at nailing focus on the Birds Eye in these situations. Not sure it is any worse than any other system though - I found it very hit and miss previously and would seldom stay on the eye so imo a big improvement and easy to nail focus when the birds head is clear of the grass.

On the crebe and some other birds it seemed to not quite nail focus on quite a few of shots - could be a bit of motion blur but it doesn't really look like motion blur to me. This is consistent with my experience previously where in low light it was a little hit and miss.

https://duncangroenewald.com/pages/collections/2023-10-05-swallow-1.html
Oct 05, 2023 at 01:56 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #2Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
duncang wrote:
Here are the swallows - well just one - but I could easily acquire and track and the camera would seldom loose the bird, and usually my fault not the cameras. Acquisition and tracking is as good as you need now. The camera seems impervious to the background and water and would even acquire the swallows behind the reeds - although it would focus on the reeds not the bird behind the reeds.

Bear in mind the shutter speed was way too low for sharp images so this test really needs to be done with a shorter lens and birds a
...Show more →

I'd be curious if you tried 3D tracking when they are partially obscured. I was getting Eye focus boxes with 3D tracking where Area was only giving me head or body.
Oct 05, 2023 at 01:59 PM
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #3Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
No I have never used 3D tracking. I was getting the the box on their eyes or head 99% of the time I would say, when they turned away it would give the head but hardly ever body - for the swallows or terns at a distance it was obviously just body - even then it was on the head a lot of the time at fair distance - much too far for a decent image.

The small fast bird enthusiasts are going to love this though. 

Apologies in advance, these are not downsampled.

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9/DSC_3536_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9/DSC_3537_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9/DSC_3538_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9/DSC_3539_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9/DSC_3540_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9/DSC_3541_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9/DSC_3542_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9/DSC_3543_DxD.jpg


https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9/DSC_3544_DxD.jpg

Skipping 5 in focus frames

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9/DSC_3550_DxD.jpg

Skipping another 6 in focus frames

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9/DSC_3556_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9/DSC_3557_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9/DSC_3558_DxD.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9/DSC_3559_DxD.jpg
Oct 05, 2023 at 02:50 PM
cvrle59
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Z9 Firmware Update 4.10


duncang wrote:
Here are the swallows - well just one - but I could easily acquire and track and the camera would seldom loose the bird, and usually my fault not the cameras. Acquisition and tracking is as good as you need now. The camera seems impervious to the background and water and would even acquire the swallows behind the reeds - although it would focus on the reeds not the bird behind the reeds.

Bear in mind the shutter speed was way too low for sharp images so this test really needs to be done with a shorter lens and birds a
...Show more →

Not even in my dreams, I would get that many swallow images in focus against that kind of background with current Z8 FW.
I just can't wait for this update on it.
Oct 05, 2023 at 02:50 PM
sonamair
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Did they remove 4.1 from the Nikon site
I just find 4.01
Oct 05, 2023 at 02:54 PM
lukemeup
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
sonamair wrote:
Did they remove 4.1 from the Nikon site
I just find 4.01


https://downloadcenter.nikonimglib.com/en/products/589/Z_9.html
Oct 05, 2023 at 02:58 PM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
duncang wrote:
Lance B wroteFrom my first day out using the new FW 4.10 on some Peregrin Falcons, it is quite amazing, instantaneous lock on and stays that way with the Z9 + 180-600 f5.6-6.3 VR S.
WHAT - so you do like the way Sony does things after all. It is quite amazing isn't it. Game changing some might say !!

Welcome to my world


Not at all. The Z9 is now way than any Sony but also I don't like Sony lenses, don't like Sony cameras. Love the Nikon Z7s, Z8 and Z9 and the Nikon lenses. You couldn't pay me enough money to use a dreaded Sony. Not only that, I would have to hang out on the Sony forums with their chips on their shoulder always trying to prove that they've made it with the big boys, Canon and Nikon. Oh, wait, no I could still hang out here like so many of those chip on their shoulder Sony people.
Oct 05, 2023 at 03:12 PM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Alistair1 wrote:
duncang wroteHappy to say I think Nikon has finally arrived on the scene. In auto area mode it feels just like me A1 ! Brilliant job Nikon. Seems to pick up swallows and terns nearly instantly now.
I am glad you said that because I could not quite believe what I was seeing, I thought it must be some placebo/wishful thinking effect on my part. I took it out to a seabird colony today and a few things I noticed:
1. It holds focus as the bird gets very close, previous firmware always lost focus way before MFD
2. It no longer wants to gab the BG
3. On a clear background it will grab focus a long way out when the subject is just a fuzzy smear in the VF, more like a DSLR in this regard
4. It is
...Show more →


I agree. I have been seeing no issues whatsoever using Auto Area AF mode. it seems to be a bit more intelligent in recognizing and acquiring/locking/tracking. 3D is lagging a bit but now that I am thinking about it, that sounds about right. 3D defaults to using 3 for the blocked shot setting. I have my blocked shot set to 5 for my Auto Area and Wide Area AF modes and that will use the setting of 5 when using Auto Area or Wide Area AF modes.
Oct 05, 2023 at 03:34 PM
duncang
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #9Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Lance B wrote:
duncang wrote
Lance B wroteFrom my first day out using the new FW 4.10 on some Peregrin Falcons, it is quite amazing, instantaneous lock on and stays that way with the Z9 + 180-600 f5.6-6.3 VR S.
WHAT - so you do like the way Sony does things after all. It is quite amazing isn't it. Game changing some might say !!

Welcome to my world
Not at all. The Z9 is now way than any Sony but also I don't like Sony lenses, don't like Sony cameras. Love the Nikon Z7s, Z8 and Z9 and the Nikon lenses. You couldn't pay me enough money to use a dreaded Sony. Not only that, I would have to hang out on the Sony forums with their chips on their shoulder always trying to prove that they've made it with the big boys, Canon and Nikon. Oh, wait, no I could still hang out here like so many of those chip on their shoulder Sony people.


Wow, you're with the big boys huh ! ooh Lala

Still a few things to work on though, big boy!

Crikey talk about a chip on the shoulder.

Anyway for those interested here is another weird focussing anomaly - not sure what was going on here but perhaps handholding at 1200mm just needs faster shutter speed. Definitely needed a burst to get a few sharp ones. I would have thought 1/1600 was more than fast enough given the bird was not moving much.

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9-2048/DSC_2671_FOCUS.png

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9-2048/DSC_2671_DxO_2048.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9-2048/DSC_2672_DxO_2048.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9-2048/DSC_2675_DxO_2048.jpg

https://duncangroenewald.com/img/photos/2023-10-05/Z9-2048/DSC_2676_DxO_2048.jpg
Oct 05, 2023 at 03:43 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #10Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Perfect auto area is not, I’ve gone out three times in different light today and gotten strange false positives in all sorts of scenarios. Most usually it’s some high contrast gap in foliage that registers as a bird. That said, it’s a minor quibble in relation to how much better actual bird focus is.

Eric214 wrote:
Alistair1 wrote
duncang wroteHappy to say I think Nikon has finally arrived on the scene. In auto area mode it feels just like me A1 ! Brilliant job Nikon. Seems to pick up swallows and terns nearly instantly now.
I am glad you said that because I could not quite believe what I was seeing, I thought it must be some placebo/wishful thinking effect on my part. I took it out to a seabird colony today and a few things I noticed:
1. It holds focus as the bird gets very close, previous firmware always lost focus way before MFD
2. It no longer wants to gab the BG
3. On a clear background it will grab focus a long way out when the subject is just a fuzzy smear in the VF, more like a DSLR in this regard
4. It is MUCH faster to analyse the scene and realise there is a bird in it
5. It's learning set seem to be much deeper in that it knows the various poses a BIF can take. It also knows much better where to look for the eye and if it loses it, it will regain it. For example when shooting gannets, previous firmware versions would be attracted to feet folded under and also to their black wingtips. In 5,000 odd exposures today, only once did it go to the feet as the bird passed by me but even then when the bird reached a different angle, the camera regained the eye.
6. This was all in auto area, I really did not need any other mode

I will post some examples later once I get them off the card.
I agree. I have been seeing no issues whatsoever using Auto Area AF mode. it seems to be a bit more intelligent in recognizing and acquiring/locking/tracking. 3D is lagging a bit but now that I am thinking about it, that sounds about right. 3D defaults to using 3 for the blocked shot setting. I have my blocked shot set to 5 for my Auto Area and Wide Area AF modes and that will use the setting of 5 when using Auto Area or Wide Area AF modes.



Edited on Oct 05, 2023 at 03:55 PM · View previous versions
Oct 05, 2023 at 03:53 PM
CanadaMark
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
I've tried FW 4.1 and I think it's a little stickier, but at least from my perspective it is not a night & day improvement. Maybe my opinion will change after more time with it. The Z9 with early firmware was easily hitting 90%+ keepers in the overwhelming majority of situations, so it's hard for me to tell if that's now 95% or whatever, at least in such a short amount of time. A good reminder of how spoiled we are perhaps haha.

I've posted this elsewhere, but here is a consecutive sequence of everyone's favorite hair splitting subject, flying straight towards the camera, horrible noon lighting (further challenging the AF system), and the too-slow-for-BIF 200-500 with Z9 FW 3.XX, 100% hit rate:

https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-tcvMwxR/0/9f0a17c3/X5/i-tcvMwxR-X5.jpg

Anyone can post an OOF sequence and blame the camera, but it's not really proof of anything other than that some people with questionable agendas always seem to have way more problems than anyone else

A lot of folks are moving over from other brands and it takes a while to learn all the nuances of a new system. When I rent cameras from other brands it takes me a while to get in the groove as well. Anyways, I always welcome FW improvements and it's really nice to hear it's made a noticeable difference for some folks. I'll be going out again this weekend though and maybe something will blow my mind, we will see. A lot of the more interesting birds have left for warmer weather though and I think all the swallows are gone until next year
Oct 05, 2023 at 03:59 PM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
RoamingScott wrote:
Perfect auto area is not, I’ve gone out three times in different light today and gotten strange false positives in all sorts of scenarios. Most usually it’s some high contrast gap in foliage that registers as a bird. That said, it’s a minor quibble in relation to how much better actual bird focus is.

Eric214 wrote
Alistair1 wrote
duncang wroteHappy to say I think Nikon has finally arrived on the scene. In auto area mode it feels just like me A1 ! Brilliant job Nikon. Seems to pick up swallows and terns nearly instantly now.
I am glad you said that because I could not quite believe what I was seeing, I thought it must be some placebo/wishful thinking effect on my part. I took it out to a seabird colony today and a few things I noticed:
1. It holds focus as the bird gets very close, previous firmware always lost focus way before MFD
2. It no longer wants to gab the BG
3. On a clear background it will grab focus a long way out when the subject is just a fuzzy smear in the VF, more like a DSLR in this regard
4. It is MUCH faster to analyse the scene and realise there is a bird in it
5. It's learning set seem to be much deeper in that it knows the various poses a BIF can take. It also knows much better where to look for the eye and if it loses it, it will regain it. For example when shooting gannets, previous firmware versions would be attracted to feet folded under and also to their black wingtips. In 5,000 odd exposures today, only once did it go to the feet as the bird passed by me but even then when the bird reached a different angle, the camera regained the eye.
6. This was all in auto area, I really did not need any other mode

I will post some examples later once I get them off the card.
I agree. I have been seeing no issues whatsoever using Auto Area AF mode. it seems to be a bit more intelligent in recognizing and acquiring/locking/tracking. 3D is lagging a bit but now that I am thinking about it, that sounds about right. 3D defaults to using 3 for the blocked shot setting. I have my blocked shot set to 5 for my Auto Area and Wide Area AF modes and that will use the setting of 5 when using Auto Area or Wide Area AF modes.


Well 2 days, 260 and 592 images and only 3 soft/missed focus frames total. Auto Area is better on my Z9 then 3d currently and virtually instant recognition, Lock on and Tracking including Snowy Egrets and sandpipers, American Avocets flying right at me.
Oct 05, 2023 at 04:02 PM
bs kite
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Eric214 wrote:
Vinnie_VdB wroteLet’s reverse the question. What do you hope to see in FW 5.0?
I don’t think it will happen, new major features might be for a Z9II of sorts.

Alistair1 wroteNot a major release then. What will they put in 5.0, if there is one?
Back in September or October of 2022 Nikon had an NPS zoom call and acknowledged that the engineers were looking into Pre Capture in Raw. I would assume 20fps in HE* but nothing as of yet. I think that would be the only thing left as a major update.



Hi Eric...

There is more needed. Thanks for inadvertently giving me the opening to bring this up.

I've repeatedly requested through NikonUsa for an update that would allow us with a handicap to overcome. It is Daltonism.
For us, the red or green boxes are invisible against most backgrounds. That is a major handicap and something Nikon can correct.

I've repeatedly left NikonUsa email records of what is needed and have kept the case open.

The remedy is simple: Tweak the options to allow any photographer to change the focusing box colors to any of the 4 Focus Peaking colors (vibrant red, vibrant yellow, vibrant white or vibrant blue....... each person would make his/her individual choice and could change the color for different backgrounds at any time).

I'll bet that people without the handicap would find the options helpful at times too.

Robert

300 million worldwide have some color blindness, 1 in 12 men and 1 in 200 women. We're not actually color*blind*, but rather deficient in a color band

Here is a quick look at what we cannot see. In the big mosaic there is a number 74. I am totally blind to it or any other number. Out of all 5 mosaics, the only number I can see is the number 12 in the first of the four smaller mosaics. The other three have no numbers that I can see.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ishihara_test

Edited on Oct 06, 2023 at 06:31 AM · View previous versions
Oct 05, 2023 at 04:22 PM
Lance B
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
duncang wrote:
Lance B wrote
duncang wrote
Lance B wroteFrom my first day out using the new FW 4.10 on some Peregrin Falcons, it is quite amazing, instantaneous lock on and stays that way with the Z9 + 180-600 f5.6-6.3 VR S.
WHAT - so you do like the way Sony does things after all. It is quite amazing isn't it. Game changing some might say !!

Welcome to my world
Not at all. The Z9 is now way than any Sony but also I don't like Sony lenses, don't like Sony cameras. Love the Nikon Z7s, Z8 and Z9 and the Nikon lenses. You couldn't pay me enough money to use a dreaded Sony. Not only that, I would have to hang out on the Sony forums with their chips on their shoulder always trying to prove that they've made it with the big boys, Canon and Nikon. Oh, wait, no I could still hang out here like so many of those chip on their shoulder Sony people.
Wow, you're with the big boys huh ! ooh Lala

Still a few things to work on though, big boy!

Crikey talk about a chip on the shoulder.

Anyway for those interested here is another weird focussing anomaly - not sure what was going on here but perhaps handholding at 1200mm just needs faster shutter speed. Definitely needed a burst to get a few sharp ones. I would have thought 1/1600 was more than fast enough given the bird was not moving much.



. Ooh, now the "big boy" monicker. I don't see how *I* could have the chip on my shoulder as it is not I that feels the need to keep trying to prove my camera system is better than another camera system by going to another camera forum to make sure everybody is thus informed. Seems quite an insecurity issue. I just do not care as I am not insecure about my camera system but it seems you are.
Oct 05, 2023 at 04:49 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #16Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Eric214 wrote:
RoamingScott wrotePerfect auto area is not, I’ve gone out three times in different light today and gotten strange false positives in all sorts of scenarios. Most usually it’s some high contrast gap in foliage that registers as a bird. That said, it’s a minor quibble in relation to how much better actual bird focus is.

Eric214 wrote
Alistair1 wrote
duncang wroteHappy to say I think Nikon has finally arrived on the scene. In auto area mode it feels just like me A1 ! Brilliant job Nikon. Seems to pick up swallows and terns nearly instantly now.
I am glad you said that because I could not quite believe what I was seeing, I thought it must be some placebo/wishful thinking effect on my part. I took it out to a seabird colony today and a few things I noticed:
1. It holds focus as the bird gets very close, previous firmware always lost focus way before MFD
2. It no longer wants to gab the BG
3. On a clear background it will grab focus a long way out when the subject is just a fuzzy smear in the VF, more like a DSLR in this regard
4. It is MUCH faster to analyse the scene and realise there is a bird in it
5. It's learning set seem to be much deeper in that it knows the various poses a BIF can take. It also knows much better where to look for the eye and if it loses it, it will regain it. For example when shooting gannets, previous firmware versions would be attracted to feet folded under and also to their black wingtips. In 5,000 odd exposures today, only once did it go to the feet as the bird passed by me but even then when the bird reached a different angle, the camera regained the eye.
6. This was all in auto area, I really did not need any other mode

I will post some examples later once I get them off the card.
I agree. I have been seeing no issues whatsoever using Auto Area AF mode. it seems to be a bit more intelligent in recognizing and acquiring/locking/tracking. 3D is lagging a bit but now that I am thinking about it, that sounds about right. 3D defaults to using 3 for the blocked shot setting. I have my blocked shot set to 5 for my Auto Area and Wide Area AF modes and that will use the setting of 5 when using Auto Area or Wide Area AF modes.
Well 2 days, 260 and 592 images and only 3 soft/missed focus frames total. Auto Area is better on my Z9 then 3d currently and virtually instant recognition, Lock on and Tracking including Snowy Egrets and sandpipers, American Avocets flying right at me.


Shoot some more and you'll see what I'm talking about. I took about 1200 images today and by the end I started knowing what would register as a false positive...saw a particular cloud formation that I figured would trip it and lo and behold, instantly thought it was a bird
Oct 05, 2023 at 05:06 PM
1bwana1
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Overall this looks like a solid update from Nikon. It is being well received from what I can tell. Most reports I am seeing from people I trust are saying that they are seeing noticeable improvements in certain circumstances.

This looks like a great thing for my Nikon shooting friends, which I am always happy to see. I believe it is always the case that advancements are a good thing for all photography enthusiasts. In the end we all benefit from the performance competition between companies.

Now, let's get an update that helps our friend Robert deal with Daltonism. Other companies have fixed this through firmware updates. Why not Nikon.
Oct 05, 2023 at 05:19 PM
Jack Flesher
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Agree - 4.1 seems a definite improvement, but not yet an end-all perfect solution.
Oct 05, 2023 at 05:22 PM
Eric214
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
RoamingScott wrote:
Eric214 wrote
RoamingScott wrotePerfect auto area is not, I’ve gone out three times in different light today and gotten strange false positives in all sorts of scenarios. Most usually it’s some high contrast gap in foliage that registers as a bird. That said, it’s a minor quibble in relation to how much better actual bird focus is.

Eric214 wrote
Alistair1 wrote
duncang wroteHappy to say I think Nikon has finally arrived on the scene. In auto area mode it feels just like me A1 ! Brilliant job Nikon. Seems to pick up swallows and terns nearly instantly now.
I am glad you said that because I could not quite believe what I was seeing, I thought it must be some placebo/wishful thinking effect on my part. I took it out to a seabird colony today and a few things I noticed:
1. It holds focus as the bird gets very close, previous firmware always lost focus way before MFD
2. It no longer wants to gab the BG
3. On a clear background it will grab focus a long way out when the subject is just a fuzzy smear in the VF, more like a DSLR in this regard
4. It is MUCH faster to analyse the scene and realise there is a bird in it
5. It's learning set seem to be much deeper in that it knows the various poses a BIF can take. It also knows much better where to look for the eye and if it loses it, it will regain it. For example when shooting gannets, previous firmware versions would be attracted to feet folded under and also to their black wingtips. In 5,000 odd exposures today, only once did it go to the feet as the bird passed by me but even then when the bird reached a different angle, the camera regained the eye.
6. This was all in auto area, I really did not need any other mode

I will post some examples later once I get them off the card.
I agree. I have been seeing no issues whatsoever using Auto Area AF mode. it seems to be a bit more intelligent in recognizing and acquiring/locking/tracking. 3D is lagging a bit but now that I am thinking about it, that sounds about right. 3D defaults to using 3 for the blocked shot setting. I have my blocked shot set to 5 for my Auto Area and Wide Area AF modes and that will use the setting of 5 when using Auto Area or Wide Area AF modes.
Well 2 days, 260 and 592 images and only 3 soft/missed focus frames total. Auto Area is better on my Z9 then 3d currently and virtually instant recognition, Lock on and Tracking including Snowy Egrets and sandpipers, American Avocets flying right at me.
Shoot some more and you'll see what I'm talking about. I took about 1200 images today and by the end I started knowing what would register as a false positive...saw a particular cloud formation that I figured would trip it and lo and behold, instantly thought it was a bird



I shoot plenty. I have been teaching people Z9 setups and techniques since February of 2022 in person and over video chat. I'm near 400k image count on my Z9.

There is nothing wrong with Auto Area AF mode since the launch of the Z9. 3D on the other hand had been ok, then good, then bad over the few updates and then good again since FW 3.0. But I'm seeing 3D slightly behind Auto Area AF with the new Bird SD mode. I'm not alone as a friend with me today was witnessing the same thing.

I'm not sure what your seeing or why in regards to false positives. I'm getting week over 90% and the new FW about 95% in focus shots with Auto Area AF mode. I know dozens of people with the Z9 and have no issues with Auto Area giving "false positives" to date
Oct 05, 2023 at 05:34 PM
RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.4 #20Z9 Firmware Update 4.10
Eric214 wrote:
RoamingScott wrote
Eric214 wrote
RoamingScott wrotePerfect auto area is not, I’ve gone out three times in different light today and gotten strange false positives in all sorts of scenarios. Most usually it’s some high contrast gap in foliage that registers as a bird. That said, it’s a minor quibble in relation to how much better actual bird focus is.

Eric214 wrote
Alistair1 wroteI am glad you said that because I could not quite believe what I was seeing, I thought it must be some placebo/wishful thinking effect on my part. I took it out to a seabird colony today and a few things I noticed:
1. It holds focus as the bird gets very close, previous firmware always lost focus way before MFD
2. It no longer wants to gab the BG
3. On a clear background it will grab focus a long way out when the subject is just a fuzzy smear in the VF, more like a DSLR in this regard
4. It is MUCH faster to analyse the scene and realise there is a bird in it
5. It's learning set seem to be much deeper in that it knows the various poses a BIF can take. It also knows much better where to look for the eye and if it loses it, it will regain it. For example when shooting gannets, previous firmware versions would be attracted to feet folded under and also to their black wingtips. In 5,000 odd exposures today, only once did it go to the feet as the bird passed by me but even then when the bird reached a different angle, the camera regained the eye.
6. This was all in auto area, I really did not need any other mode

I will post some examples later once I get them off the card.
I agree. I have been seeing no issues whatsoever using Auto Area AF mode. it seems to be a bit more intelligent in recognizing and acquiring/locking/tracking. 3D is lagging a bit but now that I am thinking about it, that sounds about right. 3D defaults to using 3 for the blocked shot setting. I have my blocked shot set to 5 for my Auto Area and Wide Area AF modes and that will use the setting of 5 when using Auto Area or Wide Area AF modes.
Well 2 days, 260 and 592 images and only 3 soft/missed focus frames total. Auto Area is better on my Z9 then 3d currently and virtually instant recognition, Lock on and Tracking including Snowy Egrets and sandpipers, American Avocets flying right at me.
Shoot some more and you'll see what I'm talking about. I took about 1200 images today and by the end I started knowing what would register as a false positive...saw a particular cloud formation that I figured would trip it and lo and behold, instantly thought it was a bird
I shoot plenty. I have been teaching people Z9 setups and techniques since February of 2022 in person and over video chat. I'm near 400k image count on my Z9.

There is nothing wrong with Auto Area AF mode since the launch of the Z9. 3D on the other hand had been ok, then good, then bad over the few updates and then good again since FW 3.0. But I'm seeing 3D slightly behind Auto Area AF with the new Bird SD mode. I'm not alone as a friend with me today was witnessing the same thing.


There has been plenty wrong with Area compared specifically compared to Sony since the Z9 launch, and lucky for us, it's gotten better and better with every X.0 firmware. It was so bad on 1.0 that most other modes were more reliable.

My comments today refer SPECIFICALLY to Area with Bird AF applied at the same time. No clue how Area is working on 4.1 away from Bird AF because I haven't had a reason to test it yet.

Anyone who says unequivocally "there is nothing wrong with X" over and over is the last person to be listened to when it comes to observations about performance. Nothing is perfect, no brand does everything right. My impressions were echoed by at least several Youtubers who reported on the false positives with Bird AF.

Edited on Oct 05, 2023 at 05:40 PM · View previous versions
Oct 05, 2023 at 05:40 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister