fredmiranda.com Login

Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review

  
 
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.24 #1Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
Steve Spencer wrote:
highdesertmesa wroteFor others with this lens: do you think he got a bad copy or is the midzone sharpness really weak enough as to be discouraging?

See Fred's review. The mid zone weakness is there but I don't think it is that bad, which is of course a subjective viewpoint with which other might not agree.


I don't remember seeing a mid-zone test at closer distances, I'll run back through the thread.
Jan 30, 2023 at 05:18 PM
bjhurley
Offline
Details
p.24 #2Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
highdesertmesa wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
highdesertmesa wroteFor others with this lens: do you think he got a bad copy or is the midzone sharpness really weak enough as to be discouraging?

See Fred's review. The mid zone weakness is there but I don't think it is that bad, which is of course a subjective viewpoint with which other might not agree.
I don't remember seeing a mid-zone test at closer distances, I'll run back through the thread.


The mid-zone softness was also brought up in this review: https://jacktaka.com/voigtlander-35mm-f15
Jan 30, 2023 at 05:25 PM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.24 #3Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
bjhurley wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
highdesertmesa wroteFor others with this lens: do you think he got a bad copy or is the midzone sharpness really weak enough as to be discouraging?

See Fred's review. The mid zone weakness is there but I don't think it is that bad, which is of course a subjective viewpoint with which other might not agree.
I don't remember seeing a mid-zone test at closer distances, I'll run back through the thread.
The mid-zone softness was also brought up in this review: https://jacktaka.com/voigtlander-35mm-f15


Thanks, also seeing that in some of Fred's samples now that I'm going back through. Looks like that trying to get sharp eyes at the midframe while wide open at portrait distances would be frustrating with this lens.
Jan 30, 2023 at 05:27 PM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.24 #4Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
Too bad he doesn't test again the ZM and FLE. And, doesn't the SL sensor stack negatively affect IQ compared to the M-line?

Edit: I just did a quick google, and according to the dpreview thread which gathered info from Kolari, the sensor stack is 1.45, thinner than Sonys but thicker than the Z cameras, and much thicker than 0.9 of M mount. Not a solid review...

https://www.dpreview.com/forums/thread/4521180

Jan 30, 2023 at 07:34 PM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.24 #5Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
nehemiahphoto wrote:
Too bad he doesn't test again the ZM and FLE. And, doesn't the SL sensor stack negatively affect IQ compared to the M-line?

Edit: I just did a quick google, and according to the dpreview thread which gathered info from Kolari, the sensor stack is 1.45, thinner than Sonys but thicker than the Z cameras, and much thicker than 0.9 of M mount. Not a solid review...

https://www.dpreview.com/forums/thread/4521180



IIRC, SL cameras have a different microlens design that helps with M lenses, but it won't equal M sensor performance. And the SL 601 he used would be less capable of matching M sensor performance than the SL2-S BSI sensor.
Jan 30, 2023 at 08:46 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.24 #6Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
highdesertmesa wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
phinix wrote
nehemiahphoto wroteI like when he summarizes the FLE vs 35/1.5 stating he hasn’t shot the FLE (points for honesty!), but people like the 3D and micro-contrast of the FLE but they are similar stopped 2.8. He probably pulled that from this thread lol.
Now I'm depressed... I don't know what to think about this lens - he said he wasn't amazed with it, apart from handling.
Still not pulling a trigger on that lens, waiting to see more photos here from owners to convince me.
In 35mm land in m-mount, no clean cut “winner.” Lots of competing options with contrasting strengths and weaknesses, optically, rendering size and price wise.

I like the ZM 35/1.4 files better, but too big. I like the FLE files better too, but to spendy. This CV is honestly great ergonomically, flare wise and price wise. If you like a modern smooth draw and want in all-arounder, this lens is a real winner.
Agreed. There are few universally-liked 35mm M lenses with f/1.4 apertures. Too big, too small, too much glow, not enough glow, too clinical, too busy, too sharp, not sharp enough...

Everyone is ok with owning multiple 50mm variants but wants a single 35mm to do everything
I think with a Leica M mount 35mm lenses, you have the first issue that the lens ideally is small enough that it doesn't block the viewfinder. That means a 35mm has to be smaller than a 50mm. Then designing a wider angle lens is tougher than designing a normal lens. Then if you want your 35mm to be your main lens you want it to be very fast because the wider lens has to be faster to get more blur. At 35mm you can pick any two of: 1) fast, 2) small enough to have only minor viewfinder blockage, and 3) great optical performance, but your can't have all three. So if you want small enough to have only minor view finder blockage, and great optical performance the CV 35 f/2.5 II is a great option. If you want a fast aperture and small enough to minimize view finder blockage then the Leica M 35 f/1.4 pre-Assph or other lenses based on this design including the CV 35 f/1.4 classic fit the bill. If you want fast aperture and very good performance and can live with a bigger size then the ZM 35 f/1.4 is an option. The new CV 35 f/2 APO is sort of similar with a slower max aperture, almost as big of size, and almost no compromises in IQ.

I see the CV 35 f/1.7, the Leica 35 f/1.4 FLE, as coming closest to meeting all criteria but they still have some compromises. The CV 35 f/1.7 blocks the viewfinder quite a bit, is "just f/1.7", and has less than perfect IQ. I like it because it compromises in every area just enough to make it work without really falling down in any area. If it weren't so terrible ergonomically it would be good enough in all the areas to work for me. As it is, I find the ergonomics bad enough and I find the compromises just enough to keep me from using it.

I see the Leica M 35 f/1.4 FLE as providing a nice fast aperture, but it still blocks the viewfinder more than I would like and at this point long after it was introduced the IQ compromises are notable as well (although the lens is sharp, it does have quite a bit of axial CA more than I would like). If I shot 35mm as my primary focal length, however, this would probably be my choice.

I see the Leica M 35 f/2 APO as having only the f/2 aperture as a compromise, but it costs so much I could never consider it. Looks like a lovely lens, however, and not much to complain about other than the obvious--the price and the slightly slower aperture.

Personally, I am going to go with a small lense with great IQ without as fast of an aperture, which means the CV 35 f/2.5 II and it has the benefit of being quite inexpensive too. It will work for me and provide an ultra small kit too. I just may pick up a Leica M 35 f/1.4 FLE sometime too but the fairly high price combined with the slight compromises in size and IQ means it won't be a lens I get anytime soon,
I've landed on the LLL 35mm 8-Element. I played the LLL lotto and got two good ones out of three, one of them being the collapsable version that does 0.5m MFD. It has character wide open, is fairly fast, is reasonably-sharp in the center wide open and across the frame stopped down, is super small, and has insane build quality.

I'm on the preorder list for the Steel Rim reissue, and that plus the 8E will probably be the perfect two 35s for me.


As I understand it that is a remake of one of the Leica M 35 f/1.4 pre-Ash versions. I would classify that as small, fast, but not that strong on IQ. Of course that last part is sort of subjective as many people like the character of that sort of lens. It just isn't my cup of tea, but of course YMMV.
Jan 30, 2023 at 09:12 PM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.24 #7Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
Steve Spencer wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
nehemiahphoto wrote
phinix wroteNow I'm depressed... I don't know what to think about this lens - he said he wasn't amazed with it, apart from handling.
Still not pulling a trigger on that lens, waiting to see more photos here from owners to convince me.
In 35mm land in m-mount, no clean cut “winner.” Lots of competing options with contrasting strengths and weaknesses, optically, rendering size and price wise.

I like the ZM 35/1.4 files better, but too big. I like the FLE files better too, but to spendy. This CV is honestly great ergonomically, flare wise and price wise. If you like a modern smooth draw and want in all-arounder, this lens is a real winner.
Agreed. There are few universally-liked 35mm M lenses with f/1.4 apertures. Too big, too small, too much glow, not enough glow, too clinical, too busy, too sharp, not sharp enough...

Everyone is ok with owning multiple 50mm variants but wants a single 35mm to do everything
I think with a Leica M mount 35mm lenses, you have the first issue that the lens ideally is small enough that it doesn't block the viewfinder. That means a 35mm has to be smaller than a 50mm. Then designing a wider angle lens is tougher than designing a normal lens. Then if you want your 35mm to be your main lens you want it to be very fast because the wider lens has to be faster to get more blur. At 35mm you can pick any two of: 1) fast, 2) small enough to have only minor viewfinder blockage, and 3) great optical performance, but your can't have all three. So if you want small enough to have only minor view finder blockage, and great optical performance the CV 35 f/2.5 II is a great option. If you want a fast aperture and small enough to minimize view finder blockage then the Leica M 35 f/1.4 pre-Assph or other lenses based on this design including the CV 35 f/1.4 classic fit the bill. If you want fast aperture and very good performance and can live with a bigger size then the ZM 35 f/1.4 is an option. The new CV 35 f/2 APO is sort of similar with a slower max aperture, almost as big of size, and almost no compromises in IQ.

I see the CV 35 f/1.7, the Leica 35 f/1.4 FLE, as coming closest to meeting all criteria but they still have some compromises. The CV 35 f/1.7 blocks the viewfinder quite a bit, is "just f/1.7", and has less than perfect IQ. I like it because it compromises in every area just enough to make it work without really falling down in any area. If it weren't so terrible ergonomically it would be good enough in all the areas to work for me. As it is, I find the ergonomics bad enough and I find the compromises just enough to keep me from using it.

I see the Leica M 35 f/1.4 FLE as providing a nice fast aperture, but it still blocks the viewfinder more than I would like and at this point long after it was introduced the IQ compromises are notable as well (although the lens is sharp, it does have quite a bit of axial CA more than I would like). If I shot 35mm as my primary focal length, however, this would probably be my choice.

I see the Leica M 35 f/2 APO as having only the f/2 aperture as a compromise, but it costs so much I could never consider it. Looks like a lovely lens, however, and not much to complain about other than the obvious--the price and the slightly slower aperture.

Personally, I am going to go with a small lense with great IQ without as fast of an aperture, which means the CV 35 f/2.5 II and it has the benefit of being quite inexpensive too. It will work for me and provide an ultra small kit too. I just may pick up a Leica M 35 f/1.4 FLE sometime too but the fairly high price combined with the slight compromises in size and IQ means it won't be a lens I get anytime soon,
I've landed on the LLL 35mm 8-Element. I played the LLL lotto and got two good ones out of three, one of them being the collapsable version that does 0.5m MFD. It has character wide open, is fairly fast, is reasonably-sharp in the center wide open and across the frame stopped down, is super small, and has insane build quality.

I'm on the preorder list for the Steel Rim reissue, and that plus the 8E will probably be the perfect two 35s for me.
As I understand it that is a remake of one of the Leica M 35 f/1.4 pre-Ash versions. I would classify that as small, fast, but not that strong on IQ. Of course that last part is sort of subjective as many people like the character of that sort of lens. It just isn't my cup of tea, but of course YMMV.


Yes, the Leica Steel Rim reissue is a remake of the original 35 Lux pre-ASPH v1. Glow + sharp subject underneath the glow at f/1.4 but high IQ stopped down. If you need clinical sharp at f/1.4, it wouldn't be what you want.
Jan 30, 2023 at 09:25 PM
peter.d.huang
Offline
Details
p.24 #8Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
phinix wrote:
Mr Leica quickly reviewed this lens lately:



I remember Jack Takahashi also mentioned that "Mid-frame is soft at wide apertures"
https://jacktaka.com/voigtlander-35mm-f15

Its just not as good as VM28 f2 ultron.
Jan 31, 2023 at 01:25 AM
phinix
Offline
Details
p.24 #9Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
Are these all bad copies, or did Cosina release such a crappy lens?
What is the point of lens with soft mid frame?
Is it really that bad that you all would suggest not to buy these?
I'm trying to understand the reason for all these comments - is this lens so bad that even amateur hobbist shouldn't buy it, or is it just pro photographers don't like it cause there is about 1% of image quality harmed by wee flaws of this lens?
Jan 31, 2023 at 04:25 AM
Ianforber
Offline
Details
p.24 #10Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
I’m still playing around with my 35mm f1.5 and it’s my only 35mm lens anyway so my opinion will probably be invalid given it’s a sample size of 1. I’m not a pixel peeper nor a portrait photographer and it must by my eyes but to me several of the shots in the review where he says that the CV is softer than the TTArtisan actually look the opposite to me: the CV being sharper.

I subscribe to his Patreon feed which means we have monthly zoom calls. If anyone has questions they’d like me to ask put them down here. The calls are themed and tomorrow’s is about digital gear.
Jan 31, 2023 at 04:38 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

bjhurley
Offline
Details
p.24 #11Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
phinix wrote:
I'm trying to understand the reason for all these comments - is this lens so bad that even amateur hobbist shouldn't buy it, or is it just pro photographers don't like it cause there is about 1% of image quality harmed by wee flaws of this lens?


If you like to take photos where the subject is not centered in the frame but slightly off to either side, your subject will be relatively soft when shot with this lens. That's why a drop in midfield sharpness is a problem. If you always place your subject in the center, or if you don't care whether your subject appears sharp, no problem.

This isn't really about pixel peeping; it's pretty obvious to even a casual viewer.
Jan 31, 2023 at 04:44 AM
phinix
Offline
Details
p.24 #12Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
Ianforber wrote:
I’m still playing around with my 35mm f1.5 and it’s my only 35mm lens anyway so my opinion will probably be invalid given it’s a sample size of 1. I’m not a pixel peeper nor a portrait photographer and it must by my eyes but to me several of the shots in the review where he says that the CV is softer than the TTArtisan actually look the opposite to me: the CV being sharper.

I subscribe to his Patreon feed which means we have monthly zoom calls. If anyone has questions they’d like me to ask put them down
...Show more →

Am I blind or Nokton is sharper than that TT?
He's talking rubbish, look at that video, specifically at that frame here:
https://youtu.be/gghdB_BfGiM?t=248
Jan 31, 2023 at 05:33 AM
hmzimelka
Offline
Details
p.24 #13Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
phinix wrote:
Ianforber wroteI’m still playing around with my 35mm f1.5 and it’s my only 35mm lens anyway so my opinion will probably be invalid given it’s a sample size of 1. I’m not a pixel peeper nor a portrait photographer and it must by my eyes but to me several of the shots in the review where he says that the CV is softer than the TTArtisan actually look the opposite to me: the CV being sharper.

I subscribe to his Patreon feed which means we have monthly zoom calls. If anyone has questions they’d like me to ask put them down here. The calls are themed and tomorrow’s is about digital gear.
Am I blind or Nokton is sharper than that TT?
He's talking rubbish, look at that video, specifically at that frame here:
https://youtu.be/gghdB_BfGiM?t=248


You're not blind. These tests are really quite terrible coming from a reviewer. I was hoping he would at least show us some of his portraits close up or some tripod based tests. The two videos of his were really frustrating to watch.
Jan 31, 2023 at 05:46 AM
fjablo
Offline
Details
p.24 #14Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
phinix wrote:
Are these all bad copies, or did Cosina release such a crappy lens?
What is the point of lens with soft mid frame?


Maybe ask that question to Leica because their 35mm Summicron also has a pronounced mid-zone dip and is the same size as this CV lens, while being 33% heavier and a stop slower. What a crappy lens!*

*neither lens is actually crappy...
Jan 31, 2023 at 05:52 AM
bjhurley
Offline
Details
p.24 #15Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
fjablo wrote:
Maybe ask that question to Leica because their 35mm Summicron also has a pronounced mid-zone dip and is the same size as this CV lens, 33% heavier and a stop slower. What a crappy lens!*

*neither lens is actually crappy...


I have a few lenses with midfield dips but their images are so compelling that I simply work within their constraints (e.g., the ZM 50/1.5 Sonnar). A midzone dip by itself is no reason to dismiss an otherwise good lens, but it has to have other redeeming qualities to compensate. Not sure that would be the case with the CV 35/1.5 for me (I'm only going by the images I've seen, I haven't tried it myself), but others may feel differently.

Jan 31, 2023 at 05:57 AM
phinix
Offline
Details
p.24 #16Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
fjablo wrote:
phinix wroteAre these all bad copies, or did Cosina release such a crappy lens?
What is the point of lens with soft mid frame?
Maybe ask that question to Leica because their 35mm Summicron also has a pronounced mid-zone dip and is the same size as this CV lens, while being 33% heavier and a stop slower. What a crappy lens!*

*neither lens is actually crappy...


This is why I'm asking - is this mid zone softness a really big issue, that so many would not be interested in it? I'm not an expert in lens, that is why I'm asking. Is this issue a minor problem that we shouldn't be focusing on it when considering this lens? Or is it a big issue and many of people decided not to purchase these because of it?
I know that all lens have specific characteristics, "character" if you prefer to call it. Would this mid-zone softness be something that totally writes it off, or could this lens still be highly scored and could be used in 99% of scenarios? Everyday normal use, not pixel peeping lab tests.

Looking at photo examples here in this thread thatguys posted, it looks great, photos are nice and I cannot tell if this lens have very noticible issue there or not. That is why this kind of reviews, tests and statements can be misleading. I hope you know what I mean.

Edited on Jan 31, 2023 at 06:49 AM · View previous versions
Jan 31, 2023 at 06:46 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.24 #17Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
phinix wrote:
Are these all bad copies, or did Cosina release such a crappy lens?
What is the point of lens with soft mid frame?
Is it really that bad that you all would suggest not to buy these?
I'm trying to understand the reason for all these comments - is this lens so bad that even amateur hobbist shouldn't buy it, or is it just pro photographers don't like it cause there is about 1% of image quality harmed by wee flaws of this lens?


Look at the first few pages of this very thread. Fred and a few others have some nice tests looking at mid-field performance of this lens. Fred tested three copies of the lens and said they all performed similarly. He looks at the performance on the Leica M10R and on the Sony A74. He compares the performance to the Leica M 35 f/1.4 FLE, the CVM 35 f/1.4 classic, and the CVM 35 f/2 ultron. Others chip in with nice tests and comparisons as well. My summary is that the midfield reduction in sharpness is there, but in my view it is not extreme, but that is a subjective judgment. Look at the tests and see what you think of the midfield weakness yourself.

I prefer a lens that gradually weakens from center to corner, but the amount of midfield weakness of this lens would not deter me from buying, but that is a subjective judgment. There are, however, other areas of the lens' performance that would keep me from buying it: mainly what I see as strong axial CA and when I combine the mid zone weakness with very high vignetting, and with less than optimal bokeh (none of which would disqualify the lens on their own) the overall performance has enough problems to make me less than excited about the lens. I love that a lens with such a fast aperture is this small, however.

Despite that judgment in my view each of the other three lenses it was tested against have significant issues/problems as well. The Leica M 35 f/1.4 FLE has even worse axial CA than this new lens and also has less than optimal bokeh. The CVM 35 f/1.4 is softer than the new lens everywhere (center, midfield, and corners which are quite bad a wider apertures), and the lack of sharpness at wider apertures is just too much me (again a personal judgment). The CVM 35 f/2 ultron has very similar performance to the new lens and is only slightly smaller and almost a stop slower. There are tradeoffs with all these lenses.

The only lens among these that I would buy if it weren't so expensive is the Leica M 35 f/1.4 FLE as it has stellar performance in most areas with just two major flaws, IMO (bokeh I don't like, and axial CA). You don't have to worry too much about axial CA if you shoot black and white, and the bokeh can be managed with how you shoot (see examples from airfrogusmc for how that can be done with stunning results). I can see liking this lens a lot for some types of shooting. Personally, there are a lot of flaws that I can manage if they are the only flaw or one of just two, but this new lens has so many things I would have to work around I know from past experience I would find using it a chore with too many things to keep track of while shooting.
Jan 31, 2023 at 06:46 AM
pmeheut
Offline
Details
p.24 #18Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
phinix wrote:
or could this lens still be highly scored and could be used in 99% of scenarios

This is what I do and I'm very happy with it. I like the bokeh a lot and sharpness is much better than the Summarit 2.4 it replaced.

As for the rest, the Internet is full of people complaining mainly about thing they do not own or do not use.
When it comes to digital pictures today, most of what we "test" does not appear on a big print nor on a screen unless you pixel-peep at 100%.
And most of the "flaws" can easily be corrected in post-processing.

So you choose the lens you want based on price, size, aperture, rendering, i.e. bokeh, vignetting, etc and you take pictures.
You'll still have 10 to 100 times more technically than 99% of the greatest pictures ever shot but for some reason, people continue to obsess about some details.
This is like sports car test where the ones with 600hp ones are supposed to make the ones with only 500hp feel slow.

Jan 31, 2023 at 08:46 AM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.24 #19Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
If anyone wants to read strong reactions to loss of sharpness off center at wide apertures, read the threads on Leica Forum about the $7.9K USD Noct 1.2 reissue
Jan 31, 2023 at 09:45 AM
phinix
Offline
Details
p.24 #20Voigtlander 35mm f/1.5 Nokton Review
pmeheut wrote:
phinix wroteor could this lens still be highly scored and could be used in 99% of scenarios
This is what I do and I'm very happy with it. I like the bokeh a lot and sharpness is much better than the Summarit 2.4 it replaced.

As for the rest, the Internet is full of people complaining mainly about thing they do not own or do not use.
When it comes to digital pictures today, most of what we "test" does not appear on a big print nor on a screen unless you pixel-peep at 100%.
And most of the "flaws" can easily be corrected in post-processing.

So you choose the lens you want based on price, size, aperture, rendering, i.e. bokeh,
...Show more →

That's exactly what I feel as well. Thank you for your opinion.
Jan 31, 2023 at 09:56 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister