fredmiranda.com Login

Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review

  
 
josh-himes
Offline
Details
p.26 #1Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
highdesertmesa wrote:
josh-himes wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
josh-himes wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
josh-himes wroteHDM - I'm curious. It sounds like you now have a 2nd copy of the 50 F1. Does it behave just like the first copy wrt focusing at infinity? Also, was that first copy perfectly calibrated with the M body you were using at the time? Mine is front focusing by a very small (but noticeable) amount wide open on my M11. It also focuses past infinity in the center by a noticeable amount at the hard stop, through at least F4. By about F5.6, the hard stop finally matches up with the increased depth of field and everything looks good across the frame. If I focus selectively nearer the edge at infinity, everything looks pretty good across the frame by about F2.8. That mid-zone dip is definitely noticeable though.

For anyone else who is using the 50 F1 with an M body, what are your experiences with rangefinder calibration wide open at or near mfd?

I just received the lens a few days ago and am trying to decide whether to send it back. I'm more concerned with the poorly calibrated rangefinder focusing than the infinity focus.
The lens arrives tomorrow (Sat 1/28), so I'll test it out then.

On the M11 with my previous copy of the CV 50 f/1:

f/1-2.8: Infinity via the rangefinder patch lined up perfectly at the hard stop. At f/1-2.8, the hard stop provided perfect infinity focus in the center of the frame. The area of perfect focus at infinity at f/1-2.8 is very small in the center, and it quickly fades off to soft and softer as you move toward the edges and corners.

From f/4 and smaller, field curvature takes over, and the center is now soft while the edges of the frame are sharp. From f/4 and smaller, you have to use the EVF or LCD to attain focus in the center of the frame at the taking aperture. Using that method with f/8, you should have a fairly sharp image across the frame except for the midfield, which may be a tiny bit less sharp than the rest when viewing at high magnification later on in C1/LR. f/11 can improve the entire frame a small bit. f/16 will soften the entire frame due to diffraction, so I would avoid it.

I'll test my second copy tomorrow and report back.
Thanks in advance. You have an excellent feel for the behavior of your first lens, so I'll be very curious to know if you see any differences with the new one. Thanks for the detailed explanation of your experience focusing at infinity. I wasn't fully appreciating the impact of field curvature at infinity and it was likely throwing off my results. I will test again tomorrow to see if I can replicate your findings.

My concern with the rangefinder focusing is wide open at MFD, not infinity. Mine is front focusing by a small amount, but there is no margin for error wide open. I can make it work by compensating a little as I focus, but it's a hassle. Every other lens I've used with the M11 is spot on at all distances with the rangefinder. Even my 135 APO. What was your experience with the first lens and rangefinder calibration? Weren't you using with an M11 for a while?
Yes, I used it with the M11 for a while. Focus at f/1 with the rangefinder was perfect at ~1.5m and beyond, but the big "if" is I couldn't focus and recompose very far away from center without loosing some sharpness because of field curvature at MFD. I didn't use the rangefinder much with it at MFD because it's way too easy for my body to drift forward a bit and be too close for the lens to be in focus at all. I recommend always focusing no closer than 1.5m without using the EVF – it's just too tricky that close up at f/1.

What you might try is at around 1.5m, focus using the rangefinder with a subject in the center of the frame. Then take shots at f/1 through f/2 using half stops, and see which aperture is sharpest. Of course, increasing the DOF may cover up a mis-calibrated lens, but it could be your lens is calibrated for an aperture other than f/1 (which it probably shouldn't be). I had a CV 35 1.4 Nokton Classic II that was perfect with the rangefinder at f/2 but was 6-10" off at f/1.4. Returned it.
Thanks for the additional info. Definitely a good data point to know that your first one was spot on with the M11 RF. I will try to work through a few different apertures at 1.5-2 meters and see if I notice anything that stands out.

I have only been noticing the rangefinder focusing issues wide open from 1-2 meters. It appears to settle in past 2 meters, or the increased distance is masking the error. I evaluated carefully on a tripod after I failed to nail perfect focus in my first tests and that's how I discovered it was front-focusing. I will concede that it is tough to focus & recompose wide open, so I may just be chasing my tail worrying about the rangefinder inaccuracy. As you mentioned, the EVF is definitely a huge help in nailing focus wide open at MFD, but I would still prefer that the lens were calibrated correctly.

If your new copy hits infinity at the hard stop, then that will be another strike against the lens I'm testing and it may end up going back, with the hope of getting one that is calibrated correctly to the rangefinder and doesn't focus past infinity.
If the focus patch doesn't align at the hard stop, it would be an instant return for me, especially at this price point.


Yep, that's the way I'm leaning. Just trying to gather all the info I can. I'm actually more concerned that it focuses well past infinity at the hard stop, because it will be really tough to find exact infinity focus without an EVF, unless I stop down.
Jan 27, 2023 at 11:05 PM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.26 #3Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
josh-himes wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
josh-himes wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
josh-himes wrote
highdesertmesa wroteThe lens arrives tomorrow (Sat 1/28), so I'll test it out then.

On the M11 with my previous copy of the CV 50 f/1:

f/1-2.8: Infinity via the rangefinder patch lined up perfectly at the hard stop. At f/1-2.8, the hard stop provided perfect infinity focus in the center of the frame. The area of perfect focus at infinity at f/1-2.8 is very small in the center, and it quickly fades off to soft and softer as you move toward the edges and corners.

From f/4 and smaller, field curvature takes over, and the center is now soft while the edges of the frame are sharp. From f/4 and smaller, you have to use the EVF or LCD to attain focus in the center of the frame at the taking aperture. Using that method with f/8, you should have a fairly sharp image across the frame except for the midfield, which may be a tiny bit less sharp than the rest when viewing at high magnification later on in C1/LR. f/11 can improve the entire frame a small bit. f/16 will soften the entire frame due to diffraction, so I would avoid it.

I'll test my second copy tomorrow and report back.
Thanks in advance. You have an excellent feel for the behavior of your first lens, so I'll be very curious to know if you see any differences with the new one. Thanks for the detailed explanation of your experience focusing at infinity. I wasn't fully appreciating the impact of field curvature at infinity and it was likely throwing off my results. I will test again tomorrow to see if I can replicate your findings.

My concern with the rangefinder focusing is wide open at MFD, not infinity. Mine is front focusing by a small amount, but there is no margin for error wide open. I can make it work by compensating a little as I focus, but it's a hassle. Every other lens I've used with the M11 is spot on at all distances with the rangefinder. Even my 135 APO. What was your experience with the first lens and rangefinder calibration? Weren't you using with an M11 for a while?
Yes, I used it with the M11 for a while. Focus at f/1 with the rangefinder was perfect at ~1.5m and beyond, but the big "if" is I couldn't focus and recompose very far away from center without loosing some sharpness because of field curvature at MFD. I didn't use the rangefinder much with it at MFD because it's way too easy for my body to drift forward a bit and be too close for the lens to be in focus at all. I recommend always focusing no closer than 1.5m without using the EVF – it's just too tricky that close up at f/1.

What you might try is at around 1.5m, focus using the rangefinder with a subject in the center of the frame. Then take shots at f/1 through f/2 using half stops, and see which aperture is sharpest. Of course, increasing the DOF may cover up a mis-calibrated lens, but it could be your lens is calibrated for an aperture other than f/1 (which it probably shouldn't be). I had a CV 35 1.4 Nokton Classic II that was perfect with the rangefinder at f/2 but was 6-10" off at f/1.4. Returned it.
Thanks for the additional info. Definitely a good data point to know that your first one was spot on with the M11 RF. I will try to work through a few different apertures at 1.5-2 meters and see if I notice anything that stands out.

I have only been noticing the rangefinder focusing issues wide open from 1-2 meters. It appears to settle in past 2 meters, or the increased distance is masking the error. I evaluated carefully on a tripod after I failed to nail perfect focus in my first tests and that's how I discovered it was front-focusing. I will concede that it is tough to focus & recompose wide open, so I may just be chasing my tail worrying about the rangefinder inaccuracy. As you mentioned, the EVF is definitely a huge help in nailing focus wide open at MFD, but I would still prefer that the lens were calibrated correctly.

If your new copy hits infinity at the hard stop, then that will be another strike against the lens I'm testing and it may end up going back, with the hope of getting one that is calibrated correctly to the rangefinder and doesn't focus past infinity.
If the focus patch doesn't align at the hard stop, it would be an instant return for me, especially at this price point.
Yep, that's the way I'm leaning. Just trying to gather all the info I can. I'm actually more concerned that it focuses well past infinity at the hard stop, because it will be really tough to find exact infinity focus without an EVF, unless I stop down.


My second copy of the CV 50 f/1 lens arrived this morning, and I've done a few quick tests, at least what I can given I'm adapting it to the SL2-S and not using it on the M11.

Lens is perfectly centered – check.

Infinity focus is at hard stop wide open at f/1 – seems to be. It just dawned on my that I'd messed around with adjusting the hard stop on my M adapter when I recently got my LLL 35 8E, so I simply re-adjusted the macro adapter's hard stop to match this copy of the CV 50 f/1 at infinity and f/1. Surprisingly, or maybe not surprisingly, my LLL 8E is now better focused at the hard stop wide open at f/2. I know this doesn't help you much, but I can at least report that its infinity hard stop matches my two other M lenses, which are two copies of the 8E. If I end up getting another M body someday and there's an issue with the lens being calibrated correctly with the rangefinder patch at infinity, I'll just sent it to DAG for adjustment rather than have to try another copy that might not be centered or sent it back to Voigtlander only to have it returned with nothing done to it.

Infinity focus in general: this copy is nothing like my last copy with regard to infinity focus. Focus does NOT get softer in the center when stopping down from f/1 to f/8, and the corners fall in line slightly behind the center for sharpness at every aperture, even f/1. Midfield sharpness is not weak at f/8. This copy is so much more flat field at infinity than my last copy, it makes me wonder: Did I get a copy with poor focus calibration the first time and this one is simply better assembled? – Or did they make a change on the production line recently?

The conclusion for me for now is, assume nothing with this lens unless you're like Fred and have tested several copies. But do know that you can get one that doesn't have wild field curvature at infinity like my first copy.







Perfect-sized for the SL2-S

Jan 28, 2023 at 02:15 PM
ftllens
Offline
Details
p.26 #4Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
nice youre back in the 501 family, i need to test the hard stop on inf as well

it's still my favorite lens to date, i uploaded some more mono samples on my flickr
Jan 28, 2023 at 02:36 PM
josh-himes
Offline
Details
p.26 #5Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
highdesertmesa wrote:
josh-himes wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
josh-himes wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
josh-himes wroteThanks in advance. You have an excellent feel for the behavior of your first lens, so I'll be very curious to know if you see any differences with the new one. Thanks for the detailed explanation of your experience focusing at infinity. I wasn't fully appreciating the impact of field curvature at infinity and it was likely throwing off my results. I will test again tomorrow to see if I can replicate your findings.

My concern with the rangefinder focusing is wide open at MFD, not infinity. Mine is front focusing by a small amount, but there is no margin for error wide open. I can make it work by compensating a little as I focus, but it's a hassle. Every other lens I've used with the M11 is spot on at all distances with the rangefinder. Even my 135 APO. What was your experience with the first lens and rangefinder calibration? Weren't you using with an M11 for a while?
Yes, I used it with the M11 for a while. Focus at f/1 with the rangefinder was perfect at ~1.5m and beyond, but the big "if" is I couldn't focus and recompose very far away from center without loosing some sharpness because of field curvature at MFD. I didn't use the rangefinder much with it at MFD because it's way too easy for my body to drift forward a bit and be too close for the lens to be in focus at all. I recommend always focusing no closer than 1.5m without using the EVF – it's just too tricky that close up at f/1.

What you might try is at around 1.5m, focus using the rangefinder with a subject in the center of the frame. Then take shots at f/1 through f/2 using half stops, and see which aperture is sharpest. Of course, increasing the DOF may cover up a mis-calibrated lens, but it could be your lens is calibrated for an aperture other than f/1 (which it probably shouldn't be). I had a CV 35 1.4 Nokton Classic II that was perfect with the rangefinder at f/2 but was 6-10" off at f/1.4. Returned it.
Thanks for the additional info. Definitely a good data point to know that your first one was spot on with the M11 RF. I will try to work through a few different apertures at 1.5-2 meters and see if I notice anything that stands out.

I have only been noticing the rangefinder focusing issues wide open from 1-2 meters. It appears to settle in past 2 meters, or the increased distance is masking the error. I evaluated carefully on a tripod after I failed to nail perfect focus in my first tests and that's how I discovered it was front-focusing. I will concede that it is tough to focus & recompose wide open, so I may just be chasing my tail worrying about the rangefinder inaccuracy. As you mentioned, the EVF is definitely a huge help in nailing focus wide open at MFD, but I would still prefer that the lens were calibrated correctly.

If your new copy hits infinity at the hard stop, then that will be another strike against the lens I'm testing and it may end up going back, with the hope of getting one that is calibrated correctly to the rangefinder and doesn't focus past infinity.
If the focus patch doesn't align at the hard stop, it would be an instant return for me, especially at this price point.
Yep, that's the way I'm leaning. Just trying to gather all the info I can. I'm actually more concerned that it focuses well past infinity at the hard stop, because it will be really tough to find exact infinity focus without an EVF, unless I stop down.
My second copy of the CV 50 f/1 lens arrived this morning, and I've done a few quick tests, at least what I can given I'm adapting it to the SL2-S and not using it on the M11.

Lens is perfectly centered – check.

Infinity focus is at hard stop wide open at f/1 – seems to be. It just dawned on my that I'd messed around with adjusting the hard stop on my M adapter when I recently got my LLL 35 8E, so I simply re-adjusted the macro adapter's hard stop to match this copy of the CV 50 f/1
...Show more →

Cool. Thanks for the info. I think you got a good copy this time! Do you still see the mid-zone drop at wider apertures that clears up around F8? At what aperture would you say this copy hits acceptable sharpness edge to edge?

It's snowing here, so waiting on some decent conditions to resume my infinity tests.
Jan 28, 2023 at 02:45 PM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.26 #6Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
ftllens wrote:
nice youre back in the 501 family, i need to test the hard stop on inf as well

it's still my favorite lens to date, i uploaded some more mono samples on my flickr


Looks great. You should add your Flickr URL to your profile here so it shows up on the left side of your posts under your username. I found one of your old posts and got to your Flickr via one of the links below one of your posted images

Focus at infinity and f/1 is such a razor-thin variable, the slightest change, and it's way out of focus. I have to wonder if CV designed this lens to hit infinity just a hair before the hard stop in case of variables like temperature, minor differences in flange distance, etc.
Jan 28, 2023 at 02:53 PM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.26 #7Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
josh-himes wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
josh-himes wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
josh-himes wrote
highdesertmesa wroteYes, I used it with the M11 for a while. Focus at f/1 with the rangefinder was perfect at ~1.5m and beyond, but the big "if" is I couldn't focus and recompose very far away from center without loosing some sharpness because of field curvature at MFD. I didn't use the rangefinder much with it at MFD because it's way too easy for my body to drift forward a bit and be too close for the lens to be in focus at all. I recommend always focusing no closer than 1.5m without using the EVF – it's just too tricky that close up at f/1.

What you might try is at around 1.5m, focus using the rangefinder with a subject in the center of the frame. Then take shots at f/1 through f/2 using half stops, and see which aperture is sharpest. Of course, increasing the DOF may cover up a mis-calibrated lens, but it could be your lens is calibrated for an aperture other than f/1 (which it probably shouldn't be). I had a CV 35 1.4 Nokton Classic II that was perfect with the rangefinder at f/2 but was 6-10" off at f/1.4. Returned it.
Thanks for the additional info. Definitely a good data point to know that your first one was spot on with the M11 RF. I will try to work through a few different apertures at 1.5-2 meters and see if I notice anything that stands out.

I have only been noticing the rangefinder focusing issues wide open from 1-2 meters. It appears to settle in past 2 meters, or the increased distance is masking the error. I evaluated carefully on a tripod after I failed to nail perfect focus in my first tests and that's how I discovered it was front-focusing. I will concede that it is tough to focus & recompose wide open, so I may just be chasing my tail worrying about the rangefinder inaccuracy. As you mentioned, the EVF is definitely a huge help in nailing focus wide open at MFD, but I would still prefer that the lens were calibrated correctly.

If your new copy hits infinity at the hard stop, then that will be another strike against the lens I'm testing and it may end up going back, with the hope of getting one that is calibrated correctly to the rangefinder and doesn't focus past infinity.
If the focus patch doesn't align at the hard stop, it would be an instant return for me, especially at this price point.
Yep, that's the way I'm leaning. Just trying to gather all the info I can. I'm actually more concerned that it focuses well past infinity at the hard stop, because it will be really tough to find exact infinity focus without an EVF, unless I stop down.
My second copy of the CV 50 f/1 lens arrived this morning, and I've done a few quick tests, at least what I can given I'm adapting it to the SL2-S and not using it on the M11.

Lens is perfectly centered – check.

Infinity focus is at hard stop wide open at f/1 – seems to be. It just dawned on my that I'd messed around with adjusting the hard stop on my M adapter when I recently got my LLL 35 8E, so I simply re-adjusted the macro adapter's hard stop to match this copy of the CV 50 f/1 at infinity and f/1. Surprisingly, or maybe not surprisingly, my LLL 8E is now better focused at the hard stop wide open at f/2. I know this doesn't help you much, but I can at least report that its infinity hard stop matches my two other M lenses, which are two copies of the 8E. If I end up getting another M body someday and there's an issue with the lens being calibrated correctly with the rangefinder patch at infinity, I'll just sent it to DAG for adjustment rather than have to try another copy that might not be centered or sent it back to Voigtlander only to have it returned with nothing done to it.

Infinity focus in general: this copy is nothing like my last copy with regard to infinity focus. Focus does NOT get softer in the center when stopping down from f/1 to f/8, and the corners fall in line slightly behind the center for sharpness at every aperture, even f/1. Midfield sharpness is not weak at f/8. This copy is so much more flat field at infinity than my last copy, it makes me wonder: Did I get a copy with poor focus calibration the first time and this one is simply better assembled? – Or did they make a change on the production line recently?

The conclusion for me for now is, assume nothing with this lens unless you're like Fred and have tested several copies. But do know that you can get one that doesn't have wild field curvature at infinity like my first copy.
Cool. Thanks for the info. I think you got a good copy this time! Do you still see the mid-zone drop at wider apertures that clears up around F8? At what aperture would you say this copy hits acceptable sharpness edge to edge?

It's snowing here, so waiting on some decent conditions to resume my infinity tests.


I need to test for midzone at more apertures and will report back. So far it looks good at f/8, but maybe it clears up before that now.
Jan 28, 2023 at 02:55 PM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.26 #8Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
ftllens wrote:
nice youre back in the 501 family, i need to test the hard stop on inf as well

it's still my favorite lens to date, i uploaded some more mono samples on my flickr


I just looked at all your mono 501 shots full screen. Damn, this lens really shines on that sensor, plus your shots are incredible. You should use them to make a YouTube video talking about the lens.
Jan 28, 2023 at 03:12 PM
ftllens
Offline
Details
p.26 #9Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
oh just took your advice and added the link to profile, and thanks for the kind words!

i'm gonna use it on a cine cam too, so maybe i'll make a video about it then. the focus breathing on it is actually not horrible
Jan 28, 2023 at 03:27 PM
lifeandmylens
Offline
Details
p.26 #10Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
highdesertmesa wrote:
The conclusion for me for now is, assume nothing with this lens unless you're like Fred and have tested several copies. But do know that you can get one that doesn't have wild field curvature at infinity like my first copy.


Looks great on your SL2-S! Glad you got a good one.

I've been eyeing this lens and would use it mostly on my SL601, but also on my m11. That said, I've had some bad luck with CV lenses. Half or so were either not calibrated for the rangefinder, were decentered, didn't stop at infinity etc. What's the best way to get an optimal copy? Order 3 and keep the best?
Jan 28, 2023 at 04:12 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.26 #11Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
lifeandmylens wrote:
highdesertmesa wroteThe conclusion for me for now is, assume nothing with this lens unless you're like Fred and have tested several copies. But do know that you can get one that doesn't have wild field curvature at infinity like my first copy.
Looks great on your SL2-S! Glad you got a good one.

I've been eyeing this lens and would use it mostly on my SL601, but also on my m11. That said, I've had some bad luck with CV lenses. Half or so were either not calibrated for the rangefinder, were decentered, didn't stop at infinity etc. What's the best way to get an optimal copy? Order 3 and keep the best?


Pretty much, or just do the merry-go-round of exchanges. I've had better luck with Leica lenses, but I've gotten duds from them, too. Voigtlander quality control seems to get worse as the price of the lens gets lower. The 50 f/1 is probably just very difficult to get perfect, so I'd consider it an outlier.
Jan 28, 2023 at 04:26 PM
lifeandmylens
Offline
Details
p.26 #12Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
highdesertmesa wrote:
lifeandmylens wrote
highdesertmesa wroteThe conclusion for me for now is, assume nothing with this lens unless you're like Fred and have tested several copies. But do know that you can get one that doesn't have wild field curvature at infinity like my first copy.
Looks great on your SL2-S! Glad you got a good one.

I've been eyeing this lens and would use it mostly on my SL601, but also on my m11. That said, I've had some bad luck with CV lenses. Half or so were either not calibrated for the rangefinder, were decentered, didn't stop at infinity etc. What's the best way to get an optimal copy? Order 3 and keep the best?
Pretty much, or just do the merry-go-round of exchanges. I've had better luck with Leica lenses, but I've gotten duds from them, too. Voigtlander quality control seems to get worse as the price of the lens gets lower. The 50 f/1 is probably just very difficult to get perfect, so I'd consider it an outlier.


Makes sense thanks.
Jan 28, 2023 at 07:00 PM
josh-himes
Offline
Details
p.26 #13Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
highdesertmesa wrote:
ftllens wrotenice youre back in the 501 family, i need to test the hard stop on inf as well

it's still my favorite lens to date, i uploaded some more mono samples on my flickr
Looks great. You should add your Flickr URL to your profile here so it shows up on the left side of your posts under your username. I found one of your old posts and got to your Flickr via one of the links below one of your posted images

Focus at infinity and f/1 is such a razor-thin variable, the slightest change, and it's way out of focus. I have to wonder if CV designed this lens to hit infinity just a hair before the hard stop in case of variables like temperature, minor differences in flange distance, etc.


I'm beginning to believe that's the case and that if you are trying to nail infinity at F1, it will require careful focusing. In my case, that is just short of the hard stop on the M11. Infinity at F1 is likely a pretty rare use case though.

I was able to test mine further at infinity and it really is pretty good. I tested against the Elmar-M f2.8, the 50 1.2 VM and also the 55 Otus, to provide a few reference points.

The Leica gets left in the dust quickly and never catches up (but it is acceptable at f8-11 and the small size is beneficial). The Otus is amazingly good at f1.4 compared to the VM lenses, but is obviously huge and not a great fit for an M body. At 5.6 both VM lenses pretty much catch up to the Otus, with the f1 ahead of the f1.2. At f8, the 50 f1 looks best across the frame. To my eye, it is slightly better than both the Otus and 50 1.2 VM. My lens does have the small rangefinder calibration error near MFD, so still trying to decide whether to exchange. Its appears to be very well centered, so may just keep it and depend on the EVF for wide open use.
Jan 29, 2023 at 10:12 AM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.26 #14Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
josh-himes wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
ftllens wrotenice youre back in the 501 family, i need to test the hard stop on inf as well

it's still my favorite lens to date, i uploaded some more mono samples on my flickr
Looks great. You should add your Flickr URL to your profile here so it shows up on the left side of your posts under your username. I found one of your old posts and got to your Flickr via one of the links below one of your posted images

Focus at infinity and f/1 is such a razor-thin variable, the slightest change, and it's way out of focus. I have to wonder if CV designed this lens to hit infinity just a hair before the hard stop in case of variables like temperature, minor differences in flange distance, etc.
I'm beginning to believe that's the case and that if you are trying to nail infinity at F1, it will require careful focusing. In my case, that is just short of the hard stop on the M11. Infinity at F1 is likely a pretty rare use case though.

I was able to test mine further at infinity and it really is pretty good. I tested against the Elmar-M f2.8, the 50 1.2 VM and also the 55 Otus, to provide a few reference points.

The Leica gets left in the dust quickly and never catches up (but it is acceptable
...Show more →

It's also possible your rangefinder is off just a little, made noticeable by the f/1 DOF.
Jan 29, 2023 at 11:12 AM
josh-himes
Offline
Details
p.26 #15Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
highdesertmesa wrote:
josh-himes wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
ftllens wrotenice youre back in the 501 family, i need to test the hard stop on inf as well

it's still my favorite lens to date, i uploaded some more mono samples on my flickr
Looks great. You should add your Flickr URL to your profile here so it shows up on the left side of your posts under your username. I found one of your old posts and got to your Flickr via one of the links below one of your posted images

Focus at infinity and f/1 is such a razor-thin variable, the slightest change, and it's way out of focus. I have to wonder if CV designed this lens to hit infinity just a hair before the hard stop in case of variables like temperature, minor differences in flange distance, etc.
I'm beginning to believe that's the case and that if you are trying to nail infinity at F1, it will require careful focusing. In my case, that is just short of the hard stop on the M11. Infinity at F1 is likely a pretty rare use case though.

I was able to test mine further at infinity and it really is pretty good. I tested against the Elmar-M f2.8, the 50 1.2 VM and also the 55 Otus, to provide a few reference points.

The Leica gets left in the dust quickly and never catches up (but it is acceptable at f8-11 and the small size is beneficial). The Otus is amazingly good at f1.4 compared to the VM lenses, but is obviously huge and not a great fit for an M body. At 5.6 both VM lenses pretty much catch up to the Otus, with the f1 ahead of the f1.2. At f8, the 50 f1 looks best across the frame. To my eye, it is slightly better than both the Otus and 50 1.2 VM. My lens does have the small rangefinder calibration error near MFD, so still trying to decide whether to exchange. Its appears to be very well centered, so may just keep it and depend on the EVF for wide open use.
It's also possible your rangefinder is off just a little, made noticeable by the f/1 DOF.


That could definitely be the case. It seem spot on with all my other lenses, but F1 is pretty demanding.
Jan 29, 2023 at 11:42 AM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.26 #16Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
josh-himes wrote:
highdesertmesa wrote
josh-himes wrote
highdesertmesa wrote
ftllens wrotenice youre back in the 501 family, i need to test the hard stop on inf as well

it's still my favorite lens to date, i uploaded some more mono samples on my flickr
Looks great. You should add your Flickr URL to your profile here so it shows up on the left side of your posts under your username. I found one of your old posts and got to your Flickr via one of the links below one of your posted images

Focus at infinity and f/1 is such a razor-thin variable, the slightest change, and it's way out of focus. I have to wonder if CV designed this lens to hit infinity just a hair before the hard stop in case of variables like temperature, minor differences in flange distance, etc.
I'm beginning to believe that's the case and that if you are trying to nail infinity at F1, it will require careful focusing. In my case, that is just short of the hard stop on the M11. Infinity at F1 is likely a pretty rare use case though.

I was able to test mine further at infinity and it really is pretty good. I tested against the Elmar-M f2.8, the 50 1.2 VM and also the 55 Otus, to provide a few reference points.

The Leica gets left in the dust quickly and never catches up (but it is acceptable at f8-11 and the small size is beneficial). The Otus is amazingly good at f1.4 compared to the VM lenses, but is obviously huge and not a great fit for an M body. At 5.6 both VM lenses pretty much catch up to the Otus, with the f1 ahead of the f1.2. At f8, the 50 f1 looks best across the frame. To my eye, it is slightly better than both the Otus and 50 1.2 VM. My lens does have the small rangefinder calibration error near MFD, so still trying to decide whether to exchange. Its appears to be very well centered, so may just keep it and depend on the EVF for wide open use.
It's also possible your rangefinder is off just a little, made noticeable by the f/1 DOF.
That could definitely be the case. It seem spot on with all my other lenses, but F1 is pretty demanding.


Tough call then. I would lean toward exchanging it for another copy. Up close and wide open is the main use case for this lens.
Jan 29, 2023 at 02:33 PM
HelenaN
Offline
Details
p.26 #17Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
highdesertmesa glad to hear that you are happy with your new lens. Looking forward to see more photos from you and others.
ftllens, had a look at your Flickr and your photos are really good and inspirational! Please post some in this thread too.

Snowy horses.
A7II and CV 50mm/1 VM

















Jan 30, 2023 at 06:11 AM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.26 #18Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
HelenaN wrote:
highdesertmesa glad to hear that you are happy with your new lens. Looking forward to see more photos from you and others.
ftllens, had a look at your Flickr and your photos are really good and inspirational! Please post some in this thread too.

Snowy horses.
A7II and CV 50mm/1 VM

https://helenasphotography.com/keep/2023/20230126_010_a7ll-cv50f1b.jpg

https://helenasphotography.com/keep/2023/20230126_004_a7ll-cv50f1b.jpg

https://helenasphotography.com/keep/2023/20230126_005_a7ll-cv50f1b.jpg


Thanks Helena. ^ Beautiful shots as always.

Your samples in the CV 40mm f/1.2 thread have put that lens on my list of potential next purchases
Jan 30, 2023 at 09:36 AM
HelenaN
Offline
Details
p.26 #19Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
highdesertmesa wrote:
Thanks Helena. ^ Beautiful shots as always.

Your samples in the CV 40mm f/1.2 thread have put that lens on my list of potential next purchases


Thank you very much! Yes, CV 40/1.2 is also a good lens, but I prefer CV 50/1. I find the field curvature on the 40mm too annoying (the 50mm has it too, but not as bad, even though it's VM and the 40mm is E mount and I use both on Sony) and CV40 has deeper DoF at the same apertures. And even though I'm not very picky about such things the onion ring bokeh does bother me sometimes.

The main reasons though are that my CV40 has issues. The aperture blades sometimes get stuck and it also has electronic issues. Also, I have found that I prefer 50mm focal length.
Jan 30, 2023 at 10:37 AM
highdesertmesa
Offline
Details
p.26 #20Voigtlander 50mm f/1 Nokton Review
HelenaN wrote:
highdesertmesa wroteThanks Helena. ^ Beautiful shots as always.

Your samples in the CV 40mm f/1.2 thread have put that lens on my list of potential next purchases
Thank you very much! Yes, CV 40/1.2 is also a good lens, but I prefer CV 50/1. I find the field curvature on the 40mm too annoying (the 50mm has it too, but not as bad, even though it's VM and the 40mm is E mount and I use both on Sony) and CV40 has deeper DoF at the same apertures. And even though I'm not very picky about such things the onion ring bokeh does bother me sometimes.

The main reasons though are that my CV40 has issues. The aperture blades sometimes get stuck and it also has electronic
...Show more →

Thanks, that's very helpful info – it will really help with the decision-making.
Jan 30, 2023 at 10:45 AM


FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister